News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable by InclinedPlane on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @06:49AM (#2275017)
As I've pointed out before piracy is a misnomer. Sharing has always been an integral part of the way people are exposed to and consume art. There are even institutions that have been built up to support such things for older media: libraries, used book stores, radio stations, museums. We treasure and value such institutions because they help to preserve and to spread our art and our culture.

However, when you take this incredibly vital and ingrained mechanism for spreading appreciation and knowledge of various works of art and you translate it to the limits (or lack thereof) and character of modern communications and storage technologies you get a phenomena which externally is nearly indistinguishable from piracy (at least without further context of individual behavior).

To put it lightly this is a very serious problem. Imagine if libraries and museums were as much legal pariahs as speakeasies during prohibition, how would the world be different? And yet increasingly the collision of outmoded legal frameworks (already bent beyond reasonable measure by the corrupting influence of large "intellectual property" institutions such as Disney and Sony) with technological advancement is leading to conflict and strife between ordinary people engaging in traditionally ordinary behavior and governing institutions who see that behavior as a dangerous threat.

P.S. Whether sharing in the digital realm is compatible with profit is an equally important question, but the onus is on producers to figure that out (current evidence seems to indicate that it's not such a big problem, given record box office revenue in 2010, for example). It's quite simply infeasible (technologically, legally, socially, and culturally) to demand that people stop sharing because the power of sharing and of stealing are too closely related.

Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable by bad_user on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @09:17AM (#2275411)
Selling used books is not comparable with putting an ebook on PirateBay. Lending books and returning them when you're done reading is also not comparable to putting an ebook on PirateBay. You also can't display the same painting in 2 museums unless one of them is just a cheap copy and people don't appreciate copies in museums.

All cases of "sharing" the "older media" you describe are subject to the laws of scarcity. Even xeroxing a book is subject to it, as the cost of that can be even higher than just buying the book; and is mostly done for technical references for which you can't find the original.

"people sharing" is a romantic notion; in a perfect world there would be no problem with it, but writing a book / creating a game / composing a song / creating a movie - takes time, lots of effort and monetary cost that can be quite substantial.

Would people create movies such as Avatar (in the interest of sharing) if the movie industry would go bankrupted? I doubt it. Would people donate money if movies were released for free? Sharing is all fine for people, as long as it doesn't cost them too much. But few people give away their work for free and even fewer do it for altruistic reasons (it's like "spending other people's money" - how can you not be fine with that?)

      the onus is on producers to figure that out
And they have, with DRM and all that. Only problem with it is that it's a PITA for honest customers, but technology evolves and people always find ways to build better mouse-traps.

So the onus really is on all of us - if you don't like the current legal frameworks, think of something to reward the original authors; otherwise the situation is only going to get worse.

Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable by joebadmo on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @12:59PM (#2276429)
Ugh. I know I'm probably in the minority, but, to me Avatar is a perfect counter-example. Because so much money was involved in its production, to make it a safe bet for a good return on investment, it had to necessarily appeal to the lowest common denominator. Hence the emphasis the flashy technology of production and presentation and basic complete neglect of everything that makes a film _art_.

If the movie industry went bankrupt, people would still create cultural artifacts, and (though I have no evidence for this) I would imagine they would create more meaningful ones. I don't think any of our neolithic ancestors made any money on the paintings at Lasceaux.

Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable by muhfuhkuh on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @02:52PM (#2276931)
"If the movie industry went bankrupt, people would still create cultural artifacts"

But they won't have much "entertainment value" and therefore be disregarded as narcissistic ramblings or self-indulgent drivel. Or, just a hobby.

To have a "value" in a society or to have a cultural impact, one must create compelling works that appeal to a wide swath of the population to which the piece of creative expression is communicating. Perhaps that may take more than one person to accomplish. How do you get a group of people together to perform such a task without a motivational lubricant like money?

"I don't think any of our neolithic ancestors made any money on the paintings at Lasceaux."

There was no money in cave art because, well, there was no money at all. As soon as money was created, so was the minstrel, the portraitist, and the professional writer.

Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable by joebadmo on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @04:01PM (#2277176)
Thanks, those are great points! I have to admit at this point to be forming some of these thoughts as I type. (Also, I should admit replying to the GP mostly because I wanted to complain about the popularity of Avatar.)

But they won't have much "entertainment value" and therefore be disregarded as narcissistic ramblings or self-indulgent drivel. Or, just a hobby.

I disagree. History is littered with profound cultural artifacts that had plenty of "entertainment value" (weird term if you ask me) that did not have a monetary motivation. One might argue that these are in fact the best ones. You point out yourself that cave art preceeded money. Yet, it existed.

To have a "value" in a society or to have a cultural impact, one must create compelling works that appeal to a wide swath of the population to which the piece of creative expression is communicating.

True enough. But I would argue that in general the breadth of that impact is inversely proportional to it's weight. The Pixies (as the first example that comes to mind) influenced a pretty small number of mostly musicians, but that influence was profound enough to inspire bands that would later go on to have a much wider (and more commercial) impact.

I'm sure neither of us believe that money doesn't change the way art is produced. My point is that if you look at the correlation between production cost and final quality (of say, Avatar), if anything (maybe after a certain point), things get worse, not better.

Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable by InclinedPlane on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @06:50PM (#2277811)
It's worth remembering that Hollywood was created (as a movie making center) to escape the suffocating regulatory environment created by Edison on the East coast (specifically the Motion Picture Patents Company).

This debate isn't helped by demagogues on either side pedaling excluded middle fallacies. The future lies somewhere in the middle, not in either extreme.

Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable by chopsueyar on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @10:04AM (#2275621)
But few people give away their work for free and even fewer do it for altruistic reasons (it's like "spending other people's money" - how can you not be fine with that?)

Are you saying the main motivation to create art is profit and/or recognition?

Human history has many examples of altruistic behaviors for art's sake.

You argue people will stop creating because there will be no profit for them to do so (or "lots of effort and monetary cost that can be quite substantial").

I argue if someone is motivated enough and creative enough, that person will find a way to manifest their vision into physical reality.

James Cameron's life during the creation of the movie "Titanic" was not one motivated by profit for profit's sake...

http://www.ew.com/ew/article/0,,290182,00.html

Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable by bad_user on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @10:23AM (#2275695)

       Are you saying the main motivation to create 
       art is profit and/or recognition?
No, stop twisting my words.

BTW, that article about the Titanic is in total favor of what I said. To break even, the Titanic needed ~ $400 million dollars.

I would totally love to see someone sharing that for free, for art's sake ;-)

      You argue people will stop creating because there will 
      be no profit for them to do so
I'm not talking about profits; I'm talking about revenu. I'm talking about a book author that works on a book for an entire year, during which he has to put food on the table, pay the rent, pay for his son's tuition and live in a decent environment. In my country, the best poet we've had, a pure genius, lived in inhuman conditions and died at 39 years old because of syphilis.

Are you by any chance suggesting that they are paid too much?

Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable by chopsueyar on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @10:36AM (#2275758)
Do you think the genius poet would have been inspired living in a mansion, every need catered to by servants?

You validated my point. The best poet was not motivated by revenue, and althought I do not know, was probably not worried of others disseminating their work.

Creating art for art's sake, not to pay for the offspring's tuition bills.

Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable by muhfuhkuh on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @02:31PM (#2276851)
Some of the greatest pieces of expression that have endured the test of time and taste (from the ceiling of the Sistine Chapel to Norman Rockwell's most iconic American slices of life to Hemingway's "The Sun Also Rises") were almost resoundingly commissioned works, the artist working full time on their craft and getting paid to do so. Most artists are career changers, going from a "normal" job to one of creativity and artistry.

Even John Keats, the "poster boy" for poetic works of unending beauty and pure inspiration, quit his job as a surgeon-in-training to become a full-time published-and-paid poet. He could've easily worked his day job as a surgeon and moonlighted as a for-free poet by night. His primary goal was to be a poet, and he found the only way to do so was by making it his career.

Even Vincent Van Gogh, the more modern keeper of raw artistic expression, pined for more people to buy his work, not the least of reasons being to fend off abject poverty, but also as a validation of the style he admittedly created. He was resigned in his later years to live off his brother as he painted prodigiously, but by that point he was in the throes of psychosis. Is that what you meant by "art for art's sake"?

It's surely a romantic notion that artists draw forth passionate forms of expression from fending off psychological defect, hungry bellies, and harsh surroundings. But the truth is, every one of those artists to a person wanted to get paid doing what they do. Perhaps the money is a validation, or incidental being a published or culturally accepted artist, or simply a means to an end. Doesn't matter a whit. They want to do what they want to do full-time.

In other words, "Shakespeare got to get paid, son"[1]

[1] http://i.imgur.com/cyIGF.jpg

Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable by Nobido on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @11:30AM (#2276031)
In the arts, like in any field, you only get better by immersing yourself in it and it's hard to do that when you have to treat it like a hobby rather than a job.

Ask yourself what level of talent you would have right now if there was zero money in coding or designing software, and you just did it on evenings and weekends, when you were not working your full time job in retail or food services to scrape by?

There is just something disturbing to me about this idea that people should be suffering so that others can read better poetry on their comfy 100k tech salaries.

Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable by muhfuhkuh on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @03:00PM (#2276952)
"Ask yourself what level of talent you would have right now if there was zero money in coding or designing software"

That's actually part of the reason why I find it so delicious that there are people outside of Computer Science that are hitting it big in Web and mobile apps; it's a validation that anyone can do the work of a CS grad just as anyone can write a novel or paint a picture; it just takes time and effort and acquiring skills.

Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable by ffumarola on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @10:25AM (#2275707)
I'll go along with bad_user's example of Avatar.

From Wiki: "Avatar was officially budgeted at $237 million.[3] Other estimates put the cost between $280 million and $310 million for production and at $150 million for promotion."

So, I'd have to agree. At those costs, I don't think any amount of creativity or motivation could get that creator over the hump if all they had to look forward to was a bunch of people torrenting their creation.

I view the choice as simple. If you don't want to pay, in some regard, then don't watch the movie. Everyone has a choice. And nowadays the choice is easy... wait a few months and pay a $1 from Redbox if that's all its worth. Or get it through Netflix. At least the team gets SOMETHING for it.

Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable by chopsueyar on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @11:12AM (#2275941)
If you don't want to pay, you don't have to pay. Ever snuck into an extra movie in the theatre when you were a kid, or had a friend who worked at the theatre get you in to a free show?

In your Avator example, had their been a group of motivated people willing to pursue the creative goal of James Cameron's vision in spite of monetary compensation, $237 million would not be required. Some sort of 501c3 action movie production company.

Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable by jamesgeck0 on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @11:26AM (#2276013)
There have been no instances of altruistic people creating a movie valued at over two hundred million dollars, nor would piracy be justified if such an instance existed.
Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable by ffumarola on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @11:32AM (#2276037)
I actually haven't snuck into an extra movie. But, to be fair, I have downloaded movies and music.

I just grew up and don't find the need to do that anymore. With services like Pandora and Slacker Radio, and a ton of pay per song models, I don't need to steal music anymore.

With Netflix and Redbox, it is worth a few bucks to keep the artists creating so that I can keep enjoying their work.

People who justify piracy either A) Haven't grown up, B) Don't work for a living so they don't understand how important it is to get paid for their work, or C) Are selfish and feel the world owes them something.

Maybe a mixture of the above.

Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable by neutronicus on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @12:30PM (#2276309)
And they have, with DRM and all that. Only problem with it is that it's a PITA for honest customers, but technology evolves and people always find ways to build better mouse-traps.

i.e. publish serially and demand advances, like authors used to do.

Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable by yxhuvud on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @01:59PM (#2276692)
Avatar is an interesting choice to make an example of, since copying it degrades a lot more information than copying normal, non3d movies. That is, by whatching it in a cinema, you get a better experience than if you download it (since you lose the 3d effects).
Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable by InclinedPlane on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @04:06PM (#2277202)
Selling used books is not comparable with putting an ebook on PirateBay. Lending books and returning them when you're done reading is also not comparable to putting an ebook on PirateBay. You also can't display the same painting in 2 museums unless one of them is just a cheap copy and people don't appreciate copies in museums.

All cases of "sharing" the "older media" you describe are subject to the laws of scarcity. Even xeroxing a book is subject to it, as the cost of that can be even higher than just buying the book; and is mostly done for technical references for which you can't find the original.

I think you might be missing my point. My point isn't that piracy doesn't exist, it does, my point is that sharing also exists and in the digital realm it is easily confused with piracy. A library allows a great number of people to read a book without any of them paying a dime to the author. In many ways it's fundamentally comparable to piracy, potentially hundreds of people a year can read a book while the author is only compensated for the purchase of a single book. However, we tolerate and indeed celebrate such things because we recognize that there is a tradeoff between the necessity of financial reward for creating art and the necessity of spreading the consumption of art by lowering the financial barriers to access.

However, while scarcity is intrinsic with physical goods it is not so with digital goods. Thus, when you translate an ordinary library into the digital realm without imposing artificial scarcity you get something that is fundamentally indistinguishable from pirate bay.

"people sharing" is a romantic notion; in a perfect world there would be no problem with it, but writing a book / creating a game / composing a song / creating a movie - takes time, lots of effort and monetary cost that can be quite substantial.

Would people create movies such as Avatar (in the interest of sharing) if the movie industry would go bankrupted? I doubt it. Would people donate money if movies were released for free? Sharing is all fine for people, as long as it doesn't cost them too much. But few people give away their work for free and even fewer do it for altruistic reasons (it's like "spending other people's money" - how can you not be fine with that?)

This is a false dichotomy. If all unregulated digital distribution were piracy then you would be correct, people would stop paying for goods that were available digitally and it would become difficult for more such things to be created, as creators would no longer be supported financially in doing so. However, that's not how things have played out. Avatar is a good example. It was almost certainly available online in clean, high-def versions while it was still in theaters and long before it was available on DVD. With just a few clicks and some waiting anyone of hundreds of millions of people could have downloaded and watched it, without paying James Cameron anything. And indeed many did. But none of this forestalled the massive financial success of the movie, both at the box office and in later DVD, blu-ray, and streaming sales.

This is not an isolated phenomenon. The ability to "pirate" digital media has been widely available and widely known for many years. And yet the music, movie, television, and book industries have not collapsed. Indeed, in the case of the movie industry it had a banner year in 2010. How can this be? There is no possible interpretation of the data which is compatible with the notion that huge numbers of people who engage in "piracy" are not also spending lots of money on media. Under the "all unregulated digital distribution is piracy" model this doesn't make sense. However, under the piracy + sharing model it not only makes perfect sense but is a predicted phenomenon of that model.

Despite this evidence that there is more to media "piracy" than just piracy many people refuse to accept it. But in order to proceed to a sane enforcement of laws and a healthy industry where content creators are rewarded for their creations we must see and acknowledge what is actually going on.

_the onus is on producers to figure that out_

And they have, with DRM and all that. Only problem with it is that it's a PITA for honest customers, but technology evolves and people always find ways to build better mouse-traps.

DRM very rarely works. DRM on movies, tv, and music does not work. Every example of DRM trying to impose artificial scarcity on these media has been utterly broken. It takes only a matter of seconds to begin downloading blu-ray rips. And yet despite this, as I've said, the industry still makes tons of money. Indeed, even when digital media is distributed without DRM (as is increasingly the case for music through Amazon MP3, iTunes, and other distributors) the world doesn't end, and artists still make money.

So the onus really is on all of us - if you don't like the current legal frameworks, think of something to reward the original authors; otherwise the situation is only going to get worse.

You seem to think that the situation has been getting worse, but it hasn't. In fact, the situation has been getting better. The lower costs and barriers of digital distribution, with or without DRM, has enabled artists to gain a higher share of the revenues of their work. And has enabled more artists to get into business who would otherwise have been too marginal to have been accepted into the industry. There are many examples now of artists giving away their work in exchange for variable donations (down to none), many of these have been hugely successful in generating revenue.

The problem we face today is not to find some desperate measure to divert us from the inevitable desolate wasteland of rampant piracy and starving artists. Rather, the problem we face is to acknowledge and accept the reality of digital goods and to come up with legal frameworks and business models which embrace the natural strengths of digital goods rather than denying them and pretending we can model this new media landscape by pasting a map of old media on top of it and changing a few of the labels.

Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable by bad_user on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @04:30PM (#2277272)

      If all unregulated digital distribution were piracy then 
      you would be correct
I was thinking about trends.

Selling digital goods is obviously flawed right now; as you said, and you are right - because copying and sharing is so damn easy to do (and human nature too).

Heck, I "share" lots of stuff myself; then I start feeling guilty and purchase some of that stuff.

It's a trend that I worry about; because I'm also in the business of selling digital goods; but I also feel that the legal frameworks have been stretched too far and that DRM is really all about artificial restrictions, not "rights", which is just wrong.

I guess on the Internet the long tail works and some authors are doing quite well because of it. But technology is so disruptive in this case that it will shake a lot of bones :) - and this situation might be comparable to the end of The Renaissance period.

Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable by rick888 on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @04:37PM (#2277297)
"DRM very rarely works. DRM on movies, tv, and music does not work. Every example of DRM trying to impose artificial scarcity on these media has been utterly broken."

Since you say there is no scarcity, create Photoshop for me without making a copy. How about a Metallica album? Oh? you can't?...that means that not everybody can create it..and there is scarcity. You (and every other person that tries to make the case for piracy) claim that the scarcity is in the copy..when it's actually in the creation.

"Indeed, even when digital media is distributed without DRM (as is increasingly the case for music through Amazon MP3, iTunes, and other distributors) the world doesn't end, and artists still make money."

You need to look at the big picture. Movies (and anything digital) are only about what people are willing to pay. Right now, piracy still has some stigma attached to it and most people will pay rather than pirate. If everyone knew they could get something for free, the value would eventually be $0, which will make it impossible for anyone to make money (or even recoup the initial costs). Since software isn't worth $0, I would say DRM has done a pretty good job.

A good example of this is iPhone apps. For the most part, you can't charge more than a few dollars, because that's what people are willing to pay.

"There are many examples now of artists giving away their work in exchange for variable donations (down to none), many of these have been hugely successful in generating revenue."

This isn't a viable business model. Donations only work so far. There are also many examples of people that asked for donations, had thousands of downloads, and got very little in revenue.

It's funny there aren't more people that have your views on things such as the GNU/GPL licenses. Since there is no scarcity with digital goods, am I really hurting anyone when I use GNU licensed code in my proprietary app (the original code is still 'free')? But, whenever there is a discussion on copyright infringement, people talk it's not theft yet when the guy from thesis used GNU code and didn't release it under the GNU license, it was called 'theft' by many people here on HN. It's because of this that I can't take the movement seriously.

Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable by InclinedPlane on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @04:49PM (#2277348)
I'm not making a case for piracy. I'm making a case that there's more to unregulated digital distribution than just piracy. The mistaken belief that there is only piracy is fundamentally incompatible with developing healthy and profitable legal frameworks and business models for digital goods.
Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable by rick888 on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @05:04PM (#2277404)
no, you are trying to make the case that piracy is merely sharing, which is wrong.
Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable by dablya on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @06:39PM (#2277773)
He seems to be making the case that a business model that insists that there is no difference between sharing and piracy is not likely to succeed long term.
Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable by humblest_ever on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @09:53AM (#2275569)
Unless I am misremembering, decriminalizing drugs in Portugal led to less people using them. Going from this, criminalizing libraries might be the best thing that could ever happen to education.
Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable by xpaulbettsx on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @02:30PM (#2276849)
I love the irony of large corporations trying to lecture me on ethics and morality. Totally agreed, if someone invented the Library today they would be sued out of existence, and look at all the good that public libraries have done to our culture.
Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable by tzs on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @11:29AM (#2276026)
Libraries buy copies, and then lend out those copies. Pirates make an arbitrary number of copies and give those out. These are not comparable.
Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable by __david__ on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @03:42PM (#2277106)
That's just a function of the different technologies, not the attitudes.
Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable by Silhouette on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @10:41PM (#2278356)
No, it's not. There is a practical limit -- and it's a low one -- on how many people can borrow and benefit from a single copy of a book, even if a library buys that copy and then lends it out freely to the public. If everyone wanted to rely on a library model instead of buying their own copies, libraries would have to buy many more copies. Thus the people behind the book would still get compensated, and thus the loop would be closed and there would be a meaningful incentive to create and share books in the first place. This isn't a matter of attitude, it's a matter of practical economics.
Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable by __david__ on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @11:37PM (#2278466)
> There is a practical limit -- and it's a low one -- on how many people can borrow and benefit from a single copy of a book.

That's what I mean by technology. Book technology is expensive to copy compared to a digital file.

Looking at the big picture of libraries, I can go get a book and read it for free, just the same as downloading a text file. The attitude of libraries is that books should be available to read for free. Libraries are not for profit.

Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable by Silhouette on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @03:24AM (#2278859)
But it's not the same, is it? With a library, you have to wait until the book is in stock, which it won't be if their copy/copies are all on loan to other people. Whatever you consider their attitude to be, the bottom line is that they are still paying the people who make the books for those books, and the more people are going to benefit from the books, the more the people behind the books are going to get paid. The economic incentive to produce the book in the first place is still there, it's just a different guy settling the bill.

With digital files, that isn't the case. The technology doesn't have just a simple, quantitative effect, such as halving the money going to those who make the books for each copy. The change is qualitative, undermining the entire economic model that physical books allowed.

Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable by A1kmm on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @04:26AM (#2278973)
Authors do benefit from libraries; not as much as if everyone bought every book they ever read, but enough.

Public libraries actually have efficient economic properties from a macroeconomic perspective that governments should try to replicate and extend: * Authors are paid by the government on behalf of the public in proportion to the demand for their work (libraries buy more copies of popular books to meet demand from patrons). * The public pay the same amount no matter how much information they consume (via their taxes).

From a macroeconomic perspective, information has different properties to physical goods: * Information has high fixed costs, and low variable costs. * Variable costs of disseminating information can be spread to individuals other than the original creator. * Once the fixed cost of information that improves productivity is met, the most efficient outcome is to distribute the information as widely as possible.

Therefore, there should be a way to compensate information creators in proportion to value to society, without imposing a price disincentive to consume information.

One way to do this would be to have an alternative economic system for digital works where there is no limit on how much digital information an individual or company can consume after they have paid a fixed amount in the main system, with allocation of the individual's total in proportion to some metric - such systems are tricky to get right while not incentivising dividing up one invention / work into small pieces or creating complex entity structures to game the system.

Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable by Silhouette on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @12:07PM (#2276208)
> Whether sharing in the digital realm is compatible with profit is an equally important question, but the onus is on producers to figure that out (current evidence seems to indicate that it's not such a big problem, given record box office revenue in 2010, for example).

Part of the problem with the piracy debate is that advocates of unrestricted personal use copying tend to pitch it as sticking it to The Man, where the man in question is a big name movie studio that puts annoying unskippable messages on the front of every DVD or a record label that charged absurd prices for CD singles for a few years.

This is a problem because (a) many smaller companies and individuals rely on copyright protection just to make a living, and (b) many copyright-protected works are developed because they are useful rather than because they are inherently fun to work on, artistic, or otherwise worthy of volunteer effort. In their haste to show that Big Media "can afford it", critics of copyright seem amazingly willing to overlook the number of small businesses from inde games developers to niche publishing houses that have been going to the wall in recent years as the Internet has made copying quick, easy, and practically free.

There is a valid argument when assessing damages from copyright infringement that not every copy made necessarily represents a lost sale. You can't know for sure either whether everyone would have bought the product at its legal asking price or whether the free but illegal distribution channels have positive effects on legal sales because of secondary effects like advertising.

However, there is also a valid argument that we don't really know how much work would be created in a world where copyright was fully respected or could be strictly enforced, but never gets made because the current illegal activity makes it too risky to get a project off the ground in the first place.

> It's quite simply infeasible (technologically, legally, socially, and culturally) to demand that people stop sharing because the power of sharing and of stealing are too closely related.

People used to make that sort of argument about driving after a couple of pints at lunch time and about driving while using a phone. They were always better than everyone else, and what harm did it really do?

And yet, today there is no doubt in the mind of anyone who has seen the real evidence, or worse, the result of a driver who overestimated their competence and caused a crash, that we should not condone bad driving just because it means some people will have to suffer some minor inconvenience.

The trouble with the copyright debate is that while we have ample empirical data to support policy on driving law at this point, we simply don't know exactly the effects of different models for promoting content distibution to consumers while still incentivising the original creation and sharing by artists.

Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable by InclinedPlane on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @04:44PM (#2277325)
Re: the problem of indie developers dying due to copying being quick and easy.

The appropriate response is to embrace it as Valve has with Steam. The low incremental costs of distribution allow new business models such as "steam sales". This model has generated literally billions of dollars for Valve and other game makers. And in several instances small game companies have come back from the brink of death.

You can fight against the grain or you can work with it (steam, amazon mp3, humble indie bundle, etc.) The idea that taking advantage of the characteristics of digital goods is akin to surrendering to piracy and thus an end to all revenue for creators is profoundly mistaken. Above all else that's the point I'm trying to make.

Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable by Silhouette on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @04:59PM (#2277386)
Sorry, but I don't understand how your argument works. Steam is one of the businesses with a smart business model, sure, but it still basically relies on copyright to keep the hordes in order.

Take copyright away so everyone, including those who currently follow the law, is free to copy as much as they want from wherever they want, and channels like BitTorrent rapidly become more viable. For one thing, more people would soon learn to use them, and their effectiveness increases with the networking effect. For another thing, you don't have to hide your identity if you're sharing ripped stuff any more so the "poisoning the well" tactic by copyright holders becomes almost worthless.

I suspect the optimum model in the absence of any copyright at all may be as simple as free distribution and inviting donations, but given that people have tried this and a tiny fraction of users ever donate anything at all, that's a pretty unappealing prospect if you're the guy looking at investing years and millions in building good software for others to enjoy. I have seen a few other funding/incentive models advocated in similar debates in the past, but usually the administrative burden and risks when you think them through in detail make today's copyright mess look the epitome of elegance.

Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable by InclinedPlane on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @08:02PM (#2278036)
With Steam Valve understands the problems of DRM and the disruptive nature of digital distribution. They appreciate that you can't just slap DRM on digital goods and pretend that they are now effectively identical to physical goods (where scarcity can be controlled more easily). Thus they make sure to offer many inducements to sweeten the pot after souring it with DRM. They make distribution easy rather than a chore, they add new features (like "steam cloud" configuration management, multiplayer conveniences and social software functionality), and they leverage the digital nature of goods to put on incredible sales (where sometimes you can buy a fairly recent game for as little as a few dollars, right now you can buy Braid, an award winning game released just a little over 2 years ago for $3).

There is nothing fundamentally uncrackable about the DRM of any games available through Steam. Indeed, many games on Steam are available in cracked versions. Nevertheless, this doesn't change the value of Steam or the ability of Steam to do amazing business. Often times it's just plain easier and better to buy a game through Steam than to go to the trouble of pirating it. That's very much a part of Steam's business model. Embracing digital distribution and adding value to digital ownership, in contrast to the typical approach which is to poison digital ownership in the hopes of crippling it enough to make it conform to the characteristics of physical ownership (i.e. constrained scarcity).

As to open donation models, I think you have a misconception about the idea. It is utterly irrelevant if the number of people who donate anything is vastly exceeded by the number of people who play a game (or listen to music, or watch a movie) without paying anything. What matters is the total revenue. If you can make more revenue by having 2,5, or 10 times as many people donate money even though 100x as many people donate nothing. This situation may tickle your "unfairness" sense (but to that I'd ask, do lending libraries do so as well?) but at the end of the day the artist still nevertheless has paid the rent and put food on the table, and that's what's important.

Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable by Silhouette on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @10:37PM (#2278351)
I understand what you're saying, but I still don't see how your argument is convincing. Almost everything you said about Steam there might be true today, but if everyone was legally allowed to openly redistribute content, most of the potential advantages Steam offers by not sucking as much as the other approaches today still disappear. It all comes down to convenience and reliability, and I see no reason to believe that social networking tools wouldn't quickly evolve at least as much of both as any centralised, controlled service. After all, this has been happening within the modding community for years.

As far as donations, I do understand that the point isn't whether everyone pays. However, you still need whatever total you raise from whoever does donate to be worthwhile. Given that (a) there is nothing in today's law stopping someone from adopting that approach if it truly provides a better incentive to share their work, (b) various people have tried, and (c) I'm still waiting to hear about the market-changing success stories, I think a major cultural shift would be required before a purely donation-based model could provide incentives as effective as even the broken copyright mechanisms we have today.

Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable by GrandMasterBirt on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @09:17AM (#2275404)
Well said.

However another argument: If 99% of the people thought that every 18 year old female must be raped repeatedly until shes 19, will that make it right? A lesser example. If every man believed that a woman must be whipped in public for not wearing the appropriate clothing, is it right? If every man believed that a woman cheating on her husband is grounds for execution, while a husband cheating on his wife is completely acceptable. Is all that moral or right? Consensus does not mean morality.

I feel that InclinedPlane's points raise the correct questions: What part of "piracy" is what people feel is sharing/socially acceptable behaviors taken from the physical to the digital world, and what part is really theft. Intent is important. And how do we separate the theft intent from the sharing intent.

Also another point: Perceived value. If by now people perceive music as worthless commodities, to them downloading it illegally is moral BECAUSE they feel that buying it is a rip off. They are buying something of no value. This could be a side-effect of theft they committed in the past. The content industry must change from "steal and we'll fucking sue" to "steal and you will miss out on big values of the product"