News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Oil is selling for less than $10 across key North America... by symplee on Tuesday March 31, 2020 @11:42PM (#22745419)
This is the time to fill every strategic petroleum reserve in the world [0] to the top. And then double capacity and fill again. I'm sure there are some unintended consequences to doing this, anyone care to weigh in on pros and cons?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_strategic_petroleum_res...

Re:Oil is selling for less than $10 across key North America... by agrajag on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @12:26AM (#22745679)
I’m not sure it would be practicing good social distancing to do a ton of construction work to double capacity, but yes, now would be a good time to fill existing reserves. Even oil tankers are getting reserved to store oil for later.
Re:Oil is selling for less than $10 across key North America... by apexalpha on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @04:12AM (#22746712)
I don't know. Since the entire country is in lockdown the infrastructure arm of the Dutch government has been fast-tracking all kinds of infrastructure maintenance and upgrades that would usually disrupt traffic.
Re:Oil is selling for less than $10 across key North America... by nazgulnarsil on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @04:24AM (#22746761)
And road crews generally don't need to be super close to work effectively. Brilliant.
Re:Oil is selling for less than $10 across key North America... by credit_guy on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @08:24AM (#22747892)
Not to mention that often times construction workers use respirators as part of their job.
Re:Oil is selling for less than $10 across key North America... by totalZero on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @12:34AM (#22745722)
The petroleum industry is much lighter on manpower-per-unit-profit than most other industries, and the job sites involved tend to allow workers to stay away from society for extended periods of time.

Oil tankers that are converted to FPSOs and FSOs are among the most expensive storage available for crude.

Re:Oil is selling for less than $10 across key North America... by credit_guy on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @08:30AM (#22747920)
It looks like the current US administration agrees with this line of thinking [1].

[1] https://www.worldoil.com/news/2020/3/13/trump-to-fill-us-str...

Re:Oil is selling for less than $10 across key North America... by siruncledrew on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @12:19AM (#22745640)
What is the shelf life of oil?

Is there a point where not using the stored reserves by a certain year would make it unusable if bought today?

Re:Oil is selling for less than $10 across key North America... by kleton on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @12:23AM (#22745662)
Crude's been sitting in those formations since the dinos. It's not going bad in a couple years. Petrol expires because it is heavily refined, cracked etc for higher octane rating at the cost of shelf-life.
Re:Oil is selling for less than $10 across key North America... by adrianN on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @12:30AM (#22745697)
To be fair, the conditions under ground are very different from the conditions in a tanker.
Re:Oil is selling for less than $10 across key North America... by SomewhatLikely on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @12:57AM (#22745848)
The u.s. strategic reserve is stored in salt mines.
Re:Oil is selling for less than $10 across key North America... by AngryData on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @12:42AM (#22745764)
Unrefined it is basically infinite. If it is refined it varies from months to years, to potentially decades depending on exactly what it is. But worst case, you can always refine it again if it goes bad.
Re:Oil is selling for less than $10 across key North America... by MR4D on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @12:36AM (#22745730)
Trump wanted that in the stimulus package, but it got tossed out somewhere along the way (I.e. it wasn’t funded).

Not sure who took it out, but it seemed like a great opportunity.

Re:Oil is selling for less than $10 across key North America... by x__x on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @12:29AM (#22745691)
What could this mean on a local/consumer level? Is there the potential to have a manufactured shortage?
Re:Oil is selling for less than $10 across key North America... by totalZero on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @12:47AM (#22745797)
No, you wouldn't have a manufactured shortage, because any one of the several entities with a strategic reserve could defect from the others and sell its product when the price increases. Not to mention that investment in production activity would sharply increase if spot price were to rally significantly.

On a consumer level, it would just delay the inevitable price decline of oil, heating fuel, diesel, gasoline, resid, and jet fuel, and that delay would be harmful to alternative energy investment and electric car sales. Not to mention it would benefit China, a place where industrial activity has already been rebooted.

The economy isn't down because oil prices are down. It's quite the opposite; the oil market is reflecting the economic reality. Prices were declining even prior to the OPEC+ meeting. If it were not for the market already softening, nobody would have been discussing additional production curbs at all. We had a mild winter, so heating fuel demand was low. Industrial production was interrupted, so that hurt demand for residual fuels that give energy to factories and power generation plants, as well as the ships that carry goods across oceans. Diesel was affected for the same reason. Jet fuel demand is down due to the complete standstill of the travel industry. Even bitumen and carbon black should see decreased demand because when people stop commuting and traveling, there is less need to resurface roads and replace tires. Plus, if you're not driving your car, you're not buying much gasoline.

Those are massive, natural reasons why demand is down for gasoline, middle distillates, and heavy residues. You can't bring that demand back by simply pumping a few-hundred-million barrels of oil into the ground for storage.

The way to induce a manufactured shortage would be by imposing import restrictions or tariffs.

Re:Oil is selling for less than $10 across key North America... by totalZero on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @12:31AM (#22745711)
1. The price of oil won't necessarily go up from here. If it goes to $5/bbl, that will make governments look a bit stupid when they filled every storage space available at $15/bbl in the open market. One scenario where price doesn't increase would be if there is destruction of demand for commuting, as people realize they can work from home just fine in the long term. Another would be if auto prices increase due to automakers shutting down production lines. A third would be if vacation travelers are still spooked by residual outbreaks after travel restrictions are lifted. On the production side, we haven't seen the kind of capitulation that would be required to change the who's-who of the market; the fracking industry has yet to go over the precipice and there's no sign of renewed OPEC+ cooperation, so there's no organic reason yet for prices to increase.

2. Strategic reserves are generally in salt domes and other accessible underground formations, so there is actually a cost to filling them and also to pumping them empty. And you can't exactly "double capacity" without buying old wells from corporations. So what you are proposing would actually be a bailout for oil producers.

3. Petroleum reserves are not terribly useful to the economy, aside from two particular cases: war and natural disaster. In war, supply chains get interrupted and fuel demand goes up. In natural disasters, production and storage can be interrupted. Outside of those two things, the ability for frackers and other high-cost producers to come online and sell oil will naturally act as a resistance to skyrocketing fuel prices in times of supply shock.

4. This could be a massive moment for renewable energy; goods transportation costs are very low and many people will be seeking work once the pandemic abates, so the government could establish WPA-style programs to build wind farms, electrical grid improvements, and solar farms -- instead of spending that money on buying fossil fuels in order to pump them back into the ground. Instead of spending money in an attempt to cling to fossil fuels, we could use this moment as an opportunity to pivot.

5. The sooner the price of oil bottoms and a few overextended frackers devalue themselves by selling at a loss in order to generate cash flow, the more likely it is that Saudi Arabia will be satisfied with the results of its price war and will return to the negotiating table to re-establish output curbs. If you try to artificially boost the price by buying crude, all you will end up doing is delaying the natural solution. Low prices solve the problem of low prices, by pushing many market participants out of the supply side and allowing the survivors to push up prices again in an attempt to capture their larger market share at a price point with a favorable profit margin.

6. Strategic petroleum reserves aren't that big, and many of them were already quite full prior to the selloff. Even the US SPR had only enough capacity to absorb all Saudi production for less than two weeks.

Re:Oil is selling for less than $10 across key North America... by _delirium on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @01:27AM (#22745983)
> Petroleum reserves are not terribly useful to the economy, aside from two particular cases: war and natural disaster.

It's not even clear that the US one is useful for war anymore. At the time it was built, the US was a net importer of about 5 million barrels/day of oil, so it made sense to have a buffer allowing the country to weather a few months of an embargo. But now the US is a net exporter. The strategic petroleum reserve can handle withdrawal of about 4 million barrels/day, compared to about 11 million barrels/day of regular US production, which is more than enough for total domestic demand. And the regular production is more geographically distributed and redundant. If anything, just leaving the oil in the ground in its original locations is a better strategic reserve nowadays, compared to pumping it out of one part of the US, only to pump it back into the ground in a different part of the US, into a facility that forms more of a single point of failure, and doesn't even have a faster withdrawal rate. That's just shuffling oil around between different holes in the ground as a kind of make-work job.

Re:Oil is selling for less than $10 across key North America... by kube-system on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @10:58AM (#22749280)
Part of the strategy is that you don't know if those other wells are going to exist decades from now. The US was a net exporter in the early 1900s as well, but things changed.
Re:Oil is selling for less than $10 across key North America... by nesyt on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @12:42AM (#22745762)
The thought of humanity destroying the environment to get the oil and then, in a fit of panic and at great expense, pumping it back into the ground, caused me to erupt in laughter.
Re:Oil is selling for less than $10 across key North America... by hackeraccount on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @07:29AM (#22747610)
5. I'm genuinely confused about this. Is the price war a war between Russia and S.A. about market share or is it a war on U.S. frackers about the prices in general? I'd take some combination of the two as a reasonable answer.
Re:Oil is selling for less than $10 across key North America... by Bendingo on Thursday April 02, 2020 @12:05AM (#22756097)
I guess it's probably the latter: RF wants to kill US fracking industry. Maybe even payback for US trying to derail Nord Stream 2, or sanctions, or just all the anti-Russia bullshit in general.
Re:Oil is selling for less than $10 across key North America... by lozaning on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @12:37AM (#22745732)
> So what you are proposing would actually be a bailout for oil producers

In my mind a bailout is cash in exchange for nothing. If you're paying someone for the usage of something they own, isn't that just commerce?

Re:Oil is selling for less than $10 across key North America... by zipwitch on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @12:44AM (#22745774)
Only if there's a real demand for it.
Re:Oil is selling for less than $10 across key North America... by kube-system on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @11:00AM (#22749303)
Current or future or both?
Re:Oil is selling for less than $10 across key North America... by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @02:54AM (#22746355)
> The price of oil won't necessarily go up from here. If it goes to $5/bbl, that will make governments look a bit stupid when they filled every storage space available at $15/bbl in the open market.

Companies can't actually produce oil for $5/bbl. In the long term that price would drive some of the producers out of the market and then the price would increase. It might go lower than it is right now before it goes back up, but it won't stay at $5/bbl in the long-term. They might give up the chance to pay $5/bbl instead, but it's unlikely they'd be losing money on the deal. Assuming they actually resell the oil when the price rebounds.

> This could be a massive moment for renewable energy; goods transportation costs are very low and many people will be seeking work once the pandemic abates, so the government could establish WPA-style programs to build wind farms, electrical grid improvements, and solar farms -- instead of spending that money on buying fossil fuels in order to pump them back into the ground. Instead of spending money in an attempt to cling to fossil fuels, we could use this moment as an opportunity to pivot.

WPA-style programs were never really efficient. They came out of the Keynesian argument that it's better to pay someone to dig holes and fill them back in than have them unemployed, because they're still not doing anything useful but at least then they have money to spend in the economy, and if you can get them to work doing anything even marginally useful then even better.

The biggest problem with it is that you're better off to just give them the money unconditionally (so they have it to spend) and then let them find a normal job with a normal level of productivity while still receiving the extra money, because there would be plenty of normal jobs now that everyone has some money to spend again and normal jobs are more productive than makework.

But that brings us back to the low oil prices. If you're going to stimulate employment by handing out cash, where does it come from? A carbon tax is a damn fine source, but even better when you have low oil prices, because then consumers don't feel it as much. And then you get your green jobs, automatically, because the carbon tax keeps oil and coal more expensive than electric cars and solar panels, and then there's a lot of demand for building electric cars and solar panels from all the people with money to spend because they're receiving the dividend from the carbon tax.

> The sooner the price of oil bottoms and a few overextended frackers devalue themselves by selling at a loss in order to generate cash flow, the more likely it is that Saudi Arabia will be satisfied with the results of its price war and will return to the negotiating table to re-establish output curbs.

I don't know about that. I think everybody sees the writing on the wall here -- we can't burn the known reserves we have in the ground or the world is totally screwed, so somebody is going to end up sitting on a whole lot of oil and coal that doesn't get sold before the world switches away from it. Nobody wants to be the ones holding the bag so everybody is now trying to sell their reserves for whatever they can get before one solution or another shuts down the demand permanently. That's not likely to change even if some of the producers go bust.

What gets price back up (some, maybe never fully to where they were) isn't the Saudis cutting production after the frackers go bust, it's just the frackers going bust. Which they'd still do even if we topped up the reserves, because that by itself wouldn't get the price up to where they'd need it to stay in business.

The real question is, if we top up the reserves, what are we supposed to do with them then? Do we want to be the ones holding the bag?

Re:Oil is selling for less than $10 across key North America... by iamthemonster on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @03:57AM (#22746654)
Surprisingly, we can produce oil for even less than $5/bbl out of existing reservoirs. I can't imagine any new project every going ahead at a $5/bbl price, but the facility I work at could go for years and years at a lifting cost of $5/bbl. And if demand is in enough decline, then you don't even need any new projects. I'm not saying that $5/bbl is credible, but there is absolutely nothing to guarantee that prices will increase from here.

On another topic, unfortunately this is a 'massive moment for renewable energy' but not in a good way. Their great competitor, fossil fuels, have now just tripled their cost-effectiveness. And government subsidies for renewables are also being pinched to balance budgets.

In an interesting twist, the fossil fuel company I work at are now on the hunt for 'distressed assets' in the renewables industry.

I have no idea what our current situation means long term for climate change, but cheap oil is going to be with us for some time now.

Re:Oil is selling for less than $10 across key North America... by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @12:33PM (#22750566)
I didn't mean to suggest that nobody can extract oil at $5/bbl but rather that not everybody can. When the people who can't do that go bust, supply goes down, price goes up. Also, $5/bbl would generally tend to stimulate demand -- not in the midst of this coronavirus obviously, but eventually that will pass.

Oil was above $60/bbl three months ago. A rebound wouldn't have to be $60, it could just be $20 or $30.

It would only stay around $5/bbl if we actually do the carbon tax or something of a similar nature. That could suppress demand to an arbitrary degree indefinitely and then wholesale prices might never rebound.

Re:Oil is selling for less than $10 across key North America... by mushamalizat on Tuesday March 31, 2020 @11:48PM (#22745451)
Yes, you may have heard before but global warming is something to think long term about it
Re:Oil is selling for less than $10 across key North America... by texasbigdata on Tuesday March 31, 2020 @11:50PM (#22745459)
The strategic reserves are one time and not immense.
Re:Oil is selling for less than $10 across key North America... by kube-system on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @12:04AM (#22745538)
And that oil isn't necessarily burnt.
Re:Oil is selling for less than $10 across key North America... by colechristensen on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @12:08AM (#22745565)
Oil is dying. Fossil fuels are dying. Not in a hopeful environmental sense, but in an economic sense.

Electric cars are here, not in some far off hopeful environment with a few for rich people and nerds but here. Countries have mandated electric only in the near future. Coal mines are going broke. Renewable energy is often cheaper than fossil fuel energy.

This whole price crash is because two countries whose economies rely very heavily on oil profits can't really survive on $50 once they got used to $100 oil. Oil is $22 today because the monopoly was broken with North American oilsands kinds of production and enormous in ground capacity puts a price cap on oil.

We're watching two countries fight over the scraps of the oil market. Now this is on the scale of decades, but it's not just far off thinking but near-term risk of oil demand plummeting ... the current world economic shutdown is just a little extra nudge.

If we filled and doubled all of those strategic petroleum reserves, there would be serious doubt if they would ever – ever be used.

We are in the early stages of exponential growth of batteries replacing fossil fuels. After a generation, internal combustion will seem quaint.

Re:Oil is selling for less than $10 across key North America... by JohnJamesRambo on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @12:11AM (#22745584)
I like your optimism but I’d still like those reserves filled up for cargo planes, fighter jets, helicopters, tanks, big trucks, etc. that, due to energy density, I’m not sure will run on batteries for quite some time, if ever.

https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=9991

Re:Oil is selling for less than $10 across key North America... by icelancer on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @12:12AM (#22745588)
Cars are hardly the only driver for fossil fuels.

Why oil price is crashing is simply variance in the greater scheme of things. Not some death knell to it, not in 2020. Industry will take far far longer to convert to electrical/alternative methods of energy.

Though I'll concede that oilsands/hydraulic fracking dealt a serious blow to oil prices worldwide.

Re:Oil is selling for less than $10 across key North America... by colechristensen on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @01:07AM (#22745887)
Industry is electric by wide margins.

Batteries are cheaper than electric peak plants. Solar and wind are cheaper than coal and still benefiting from economies of scale and technology development.

Getting energy from the sun and wind is already cheaper than some fossil fuel sources. Conversion will accelerate as that gap widens.

Re:Oil is selling for less than $10 across key North America... by ppf on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @03:09AM (#22746430)
>Coal mines are going broke.

Maybe some are, but world coal consumption is actually increasing. Imho the bigger effect here is developed countries externalizing pollution and manufacturing costs (electric cars take a lot more energy to make) to countries that don't mind burning whatever they can find. China has enormous reserves of brown coal - they'll happily burn it to make our solar panels and wind turbines.

http://theconversation.com/explaining-the-increase-in-coal-c...

Re:Oil is selling for less than $10 across key North America... by kube-system on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @11:05AM (#22749377)
Even if 100% of the fuel used in the US were renewables, we'd still need oil. Petrochemicals are a foundation of modern industry.
Re:Oil is selling for less than $10 across key North America... by modriano on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @12:11AM (#22745582)
How fast do you think America or the world will transition away from gas cars? Be realistic. Is there any way you see that happening in less than 25 years?
Re:Oil is selling for less than $10 across key North America... by colechristensen on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @12:59AM (#22745856)
Yes, people get new cars rather frequently. 50% of new cars by 2030 easily.

With the upcoming generation, driving an ICE car will be a social stigma, and electric a status symbol.

Re:Oil is selling for less than $10 across key North America... by RandomBacon on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @01:19AM (#22745932)
For many people, a new-to-them car, is a used car. As long as used ICE vehicles are cheaper than Elec vehicles, there will be a significant demand.
Re:Oil is selling for less than $10 across key North America... by colechristensen on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @04:14PM (#22753076)
Median age of cars on the road today is a little under 11 years.

Growing global warming problems and anti-environmenalist population aging means there will be growing support for taxing ICE and incentivizing electric vehicles.

The used market will begin to include more and more electrics.

Electrics are far cheaper to operate, competition and economies of scale will make electrics cheaper because they are far mechanically simpler.

Some places already have plans for banning ICE vehicles, cost be damned.

Re:Oil is selling for less than $10 across key North America... by mandelbrotwurst on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @01:03AM (#22745873)
Maybe in San Francisco.
Re:Oil is selling for less than $10 across key North America... by tamersalama on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @12:13AM (#22745596)
With oil so abundant and cheap - there's a renewed appeal in gas-operated cars.