News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Merkel bans meetings of more than two people to slow coro... by RalfWausE on Sunday March 22, 2020 @01:55PM (#22656949)
I think this is fair. The problem in most western democracies is, that it is nearly impossible to enforce a law that is not accepted by the people, at least not for a long time. A complete shutdown in Wuhan-style may be more effective, but in any western country the people would, after two or three weeks, start to find loopholes. So i think its better to make a law that is a bit less effective but accepted by the people instead of a law that invites people to get "creative"
Re:Merkel bans meetings of more than two people to slow coro... by hutzlibu on Sunday March 22, 2020 @02:01PM (#22657006)
" The problem in most western democracies is, that it is nearly impossible to enforce a law that is not accepted by the people"

It's not a bug, its a feature.

Seriously, the very idea of democracy is to only have laws accepted by the people.

So if there is no acceptance, there should be no law. Unless it is accepted to have emergency authorian rule, like in this case.

Re:Merkel bans meetings of more than two people to slow coro... by tpetry on Sunday March 22, 2020 @02:37PM (#22657369)
Would be nice if democracy would really work like that. In reality the ruling parties can make the laws how they like no matter if people will like it or not. Think for example on the current plan in the US to break all end-to-end encryption: people will not like it but it does not matter
Re:Merkel bans meetings of more than two people to slow coro... by hutzlibu on Sunday March 22, 2020 @03:20PM (#22657730)
"people will not like it but it does not matter"

It does matter what the people like and not. The problem in this case is just, that most people do not at all understand the implications of breaking encryption. Actually most barley know what encryption is at all. Thats why there is no outrage.

Re:Merkel bans meetings of more than two people to slow coro... by DangitBobby on Sunday March 22, 2020 @03:55PM (#22658037)
There was this analysis of bills passed and who supported them a while back by someone at Princeton. Turns out public opinion has a near negligible impact. https://act.represent.us/sign/the-problem/
Re:Merkel bans meetings of more than two people to slow coro... by vinay427 on Sunday March 22, 2020 @02:44PM (#22657422)
That's not a counterexample. The claim was about enforcement of a law, not proposed legislation. It hasn't worked very well for other governments that have tried a similar approach, so I have little reason to believe people would just stop using E2E encryption. For a more apt example, consider digital piracy laws which are IIRC in the US explicitly ignored up to a certain number of counted (far from actual!) abuses.
Re:Merkel bans meetings of more than two people to slow coro... by polk on Monday March 23, 2020 @11:40AM (#22665086)
I feel like this is ignoring how self-centered most people are.

There's plenty of laws that your average person agrees with because they want everyone else to follow them: pay your taxes, follow the speed limit, don't be loud after 10 PM, and clean up your dogs poop. But at the same time, they have no problem making exceptions for themselves.

So whether or not any individual follows a certain rule is not indicative of their support of the rule, and a lot of people breaking a certain rule doesn't make it nondemocratic.

Re:Merkel bans meetings of more than two people to slow coro... by pmlnr on Sunday March 22, 2020 @03:19PM (#22657720)
> Unless it is accepted to have emergency authorian rule, like in this case.

Post socialist seem to understand what a national emergency is and when it's on, you shut up and do as told. I'm a Hungarian, living in England; the brits have no grasp on this scenario. Somewhere deep down it feels like we needed this pandemic to:

a, undestand one's "rights" doesn't always apply

b, to realize we're living in the golden years* - it's cushioned, comfortable, wonderful, and that we should cherish it and value it.

* Iron Maiden - Wasted Years https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=mmszv0jpvSY

Re:Merkel bans meetings of more than two people to slow coro... by mattmanser on Sunday March 22, 2020 @03:57PM (#22658057)
All countries have had challenges like this before, be it world war 1/2, conscription, etc.

It's not an excuse to lose rights outside the confines of the emergency.

It might be true post-Russian dominated states might still have recent memories on how to obey a central authority (mainly on pain of 'disappearing' into something like a gulag or being executed), it's not a lesson we need to learn thanks.

It's still hard for many of us to take the threat seriously, but that'll change.

Re:Merkel bans meetings of more than two people to slow coro... by grawprog on Sunday March 22, 2020 @03:43PM (#22657930)
>undestand one's "rights" doesn't always apply

It's funny, movies got it wrong, you don't need mass deaths, zombies or giant deadly global disasters to have people accept their rights being suspended and acquiesce to being herded like sheep under strict authoritarian rules under threat of monetary punishment or even incarnation....you just need to make them scared of being sick...

Re:Merkel bans meetings of more than two people to slow coro... by pizza234 on Sunday March 22, 2020 @02:22PM (#22657213)
Speaking about social behavior, I'm in contact with Italian people; they're pretty scared and they're respecting the rules (that is, staying home).

I can definitely tell you that up to around a week ago, there was a certain anarchy, that is people carelessly meeting in crowded places (Italy has a mix of both strongly social behavior, and cultural aversion to rules), but things changed drastically.

Until people is scared, they'll honor the rules (of course, one will always find exceptions); I think that it's not about acceptance, but fear.

If this is true, then while the epidemic is (sadly) going strong, people will do what's necessary in an acceptable manner.

Re:Merkel bans meetings of more than two people to slow coro... by lbeltrame on Sunday March 22, 2020 @06:38PM (#22659429)
> I can definitely tell you that up to around a week ago, there was a certain anarchy

As one of the locked up people in Italy, I don't think it is completely true. The media did quite a nice job at cherry picking the bad apples. But if we go by the number of fines levied for breaking the rules, it's around 45K (figure taken from a day). A drop in the bucket compared to the population that's staying at home.

And it's still not clear why the people were fined: were they breaking intentionally the rules, or were they not in possession of the required documents? (You have to go around with a piece of paper stating wh you're out of your house, and if not found truthful you risk a fine and an arrest).

Re:Merkel bans meetings of more than two people to slow coro... by pizza234 on Monday March 23, 2020 @08:09AM (#22663220)
I've checked the chat logs with my Italian friends, and the discussion about people still carelessly gathering in social places (and in fact, photos were being posted on forums) was referring to March 9th.

Therefore, the reference "around a week" that I've made is wrong, considering that March 9th was the lockdown date.

My experience with another country with lockdown is still different - people started to be wary of social gatherings/interactions earlier, however, at this point, the anarchy argument is weaker :-)

Re:Merkel bans meetings of more than two people to slow coro... by lbeltrame on Tuesday March 24, 2020 @12:18PM (#22675871)
> I've checked the chat logs with my Italian friends, and the discussion about people still carelessly gathering in social places (and in fact, photos were being posted on forums) was referring to March 9th.

That's what I meant by cherry picking. Some were ignoring the requests, but a lot of others did respect them. I was already working from home from a few days before.

Re:Merkel bans meetings of more than two people to slow coro... by haggy on Sunday March 22, 2020 @02:30PM (#22657289)
I agree with you here. Fear is a core, primitive driver for human behavior.
Re:Merkel bans meetings of more than two people to slow coro... by oaiey on Sunday March 22, 2020 @02:01PM (#22657004)
In Bavaria we have these rules already a few days. They are quite acceptable. It leaves options to go jogging alone, to go out with the kids and have a chat with the neighbors over the street. 1.5m is IMHO a bit too close, but it seems the recommendation.

However, I live a villagers life. Wuhan is a huge city with much less public space. So I argue, it is not only democratic vs. Non democratic society but also depends on the location dramatically.

Re:Merkel bans meetings of more than two people to slow coro... by RalfWausE on Sunday March 22, 2020 @02:08PM (#22657096)
I know people who would argue if Bavaria really counts as a western democracy ;-)

But i think you are right: The infection risk out in the countryside must be magnitudes smaller than in any major city (so long as mass-events are banned).

Re:Merkel bans meetings of more than two people to slow coro... by pachico on Sunday March 22, 2020 @02:07PM (#22657079)
In general, I think it also depends on society maturity (given there are many ways to get to that state). In Spain and Italy, the countries I know best, thousands of citizens are trying to cut corners and bypass any quarantine obligation.
Re:Merkel bans meetings of more than two people to slow coro... by oaiey on Sunday March 22, 2020 @02:51PM (#22657479)
I would be very careful with the wording maturity in context of society. Italy and Spain have a society which is far more family friendly, elder friendly and outgoing culture than Germany. That is usually much better. Just not now.
Re:Merkel bans meetings of more than two people to slow coro... by pachico on Sunday March 22, 2020 @02:54PM (#22657508)
By maturity, in this case, I mean to really understand the thread, act upon it and have the society backing up measures taken, even if they personally affect you. In Mediterranean countries this usually doesn't happen.
Re:Merkel bans meetings of more than two people to slow coro... by ceejayoz on Sunday March 22, 2020 @02:20PM (#22657208)
It's quite acceptable for a while.

Non-compliance will increase the longer it goes on, I suspect. There's a reason isolation is used as punishment/torture in prisons.

Re:Merkel bans meetings of more than two people to slow coro... by seppel on Sunday March 22, 2020 @03:32PM (#22657840)
That should have started in winter, when the weather was crap anyway.

As soon as it will start getting nice outside, I don't believe you will be able to detain people for long.

Re:Merkel bans meetings of more than two people to slow coro... by Bombthecat on Sunday March 22, 2020 @02:32PM (#22657311)
Absolutely. I suspect that 8 months or so we just accept dead people.
Re:Merkel bans meetings of more than two people to slow coro... by dathinab on Sunday March 22, 2020 @02:58PM (#22657534)
Believe me this won't take 8 month. Especially given that in many areas the live of "old" people and "mid/young" people got sadly somewhat decoupled in the recent 30 or so years.
Re:Merkel bans meetings of more than two people to slow coro... by airstrike on Sunday March 22, 2020 @04:19PM (#22658256)
The young which require hospitalization have a real chance to die if left untreated. There aren't enough beds to treat everyone if 80% of people get sick.
Re:Merkel bans meetings of more than two people to slow coro... by Bombthecat on Monday March 23, 2020 @02:52AM (#22661797)
Downvotes wont change the fact that mass psychology is at play. Not invidual psychology, like people in jail.

Those are two different things! Most people think they are the same, but they are not.

Nonetheless,thats why i wrote, soon or later we accept the dead people as part of doing "business"

Re:Merkel bans meetings of more than two people to slow coro... by airstrike on Monday March 23, 2020 @08:58AM (#22663636)
You're way off base. We're not going to "accept" the risk of dying tomorrow any more than we do today. This isn't about old people dying. It's about 40-80% getting infected, 17-20% needing hospitalization and there not being enough beds. Simple as that.
Re:Merkel bans meetings of more than two people to slow coro... by rootusrootus on Sunday March 22, 2020 @05:53PM (#22659074)
I'm betting it will happen far sooner than 8 months. Just watching the public polls, there is already plenty of evidence to suggest people are making that calculation already.

The cold truth -- if the bodies that keep stacking up are nearly all 80+ years old, as it seems to be now, then people of working age aren't going to tolerate a forced quarantine all that long. If gov't tries to force the issue, they may only succeed in demonstrating the limits of gov't power.

Re:Merkel bans meetings of more than two people to slow coro... by gindely on Sunday March 22, 2020 @02:36PM (#22657351)
Try looking at traffic rules. No-one likes rules against speeding. But in places where there are hidden road safety cameras and significant fines that quickly arrive in the post, people speed much less.

Rules can be enforced even in western democracies.

Re:Merkel bans meetings of more than two people to slow coro... by dathinab on Sunday March 22, 2020 @02:50PM (#22657469)
This is not quite true I believe, it's more like no one like to be found out when overstepping regulations. But that doesn't mean they don't like the regulation in general.

Most people would agree that most traffic regulations makes sense in general. Not just necessary in that specific situation. Like "yes speed limits make sense but in this street it should be 20km/h higher then it is". "Yes speeding cameras make sense when used at places where speeding is quite dangerous. But do they need to use them here where it's not really dangerous just to earn more money with fines" etc.

Still you can enforce regulations the _population_ doesn't like, but it's really hard to do so effectively for more then just a short amount of time.

Re:Merkel bans meetings of more than two people to slow coro... by vinay427 on Sunday March 22, 2020 @02:42PM (#22657409)
> No-one likes rules against speeding.

I can't imagine this is true. Not many drivers overtly claim to support rules against speeding, but I expect most people would not campaign to remove them because it's not hard to imagine potential problems in their absence.

Re:Merkel bans meetings of more than two people to slow coro... by praeconium on Sunday March 22, 2020 @09:11PM (#22660377)
Germans would not agree and neither would their road accident statistics.
Re:Merkel bans meetings of more than two people to slow coro... by odessacubbage on Sunday March 22, 2020 @04:29PM (#22658339)
about that, >http://www.hwysafety.com/hwy_montana.htm common sense keeps people safe, over aggressive legalism creates learned helplessness at scale and reduces common sense.
Re:Merkel bans meetings of more than two people to slow coro... by bobjob on Sunday March 22, 2020 @02:01PM (#22656999)
I think that this and our lack in 'hands on' experience with pandemics play a role in how western governments act. It is sad that the population has to learn via a death toll that certain things have to be done. I wish I could say it wetter, but I'm lacking the right words/phrases.
Re:Merkel bans meetings of more than two people to slow coro... by pb060 on Sunday March 22, 2020 @03:18PM (#22657705)
It is still possible to declare martial law in case of disaster, which I would welcome looking at how many "creative" people are there (at least here in Italy).
Re:Merkel bans meetings of more than two people to slow coro... by rootusrootus on Sunday March 22, 2020 @05:56PM (#22659095)
If you are right, then I forsee that some countries are going to have significant changes of government in the coming months and years.