News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Venezuela to Close Pumps as Gas Runs Short, Viral Outbrea... by nostromo on Sunday March 22, 2020 @03:40AM (#22653367)
Quarantine, and the economic meltdown, will end up being worse than the disease.
Re:Venezuela to Close Pumps as Gas Runs Short, Viral Outbrea... by PeterStuer on Sunday March 22, 2020 @03:55AM (#22653437)
Thing is we can change 'the economy', as in the way we choose to support or hamper people's living conditions, at will, not without huge efforts, but it is under our control.

We can not change the spread of the virus or how our bodies respond to it at will.

Re:Venezuela to Close Pumps as Gas Runs Short, Viral Outbrea... by PeterStuer on Thursday March 26, 2020 @03:04AM (#22691251)
Re:Venezuela to Close Pumps as Gas Runs Short, Viral Outbrea... by xiler on Sunday March 22, 2020 @05:42AM (#22653826)
I'd say that's a bit of a false dilemma. Countries like South Korea and Taiwan have dealt with this problem far better than other countries despite having very few lockdowns [1,2]. Instead they have made use of government funded distribution of free masks and testing and now have a low or declining number of active cases [3,4,5].

[1] https://www.scmp.com/week-asia/health-environment/article/30...

[2] https://chinapost.nownews.com/20200317-1094238

[3] https://www.taiwannews.com.tw/en/news/3869320

[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2020_coronavirus_pandemic_in_T...

[5] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2020_coronavirus_pandemic_in_S...

Re:Venezuela to Close Pumps as Gas Runs Short, Viral Outbrea... by unishark on Sunday March 22, 2020 @06:08AM (#22653914)
South Korea passed new laws after MERS which allowed them to publicize personal health information. People get alerts telling them someone of a certain gender and age was tested positive and gives their prior activities. I suspect a lockdown would be easier to pull off in the US.

Taiwan has been passing new laws since SARS that allowed them to quarantine people. They also track people on quarantine via their phones.

If anything, I'd say the common denominator in handling this outbreak well is having experienced a similar outbreak recently and adapting to it, at least in part by swinging the pendulum further away from civil rights towards protecting the populace. Both SK and Taiwan's govts were also embarrassed and criticized after those respective previous outbreaks, prompting quicker action next time around.

https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-51733145

Re:Venezuela to Close Pumps as Gas Runs Short, Viral Outbrea... by __Joker on Sunday March 22, 2020 @05:53AM (#22653871)
Yeah, people in SK and Taiwan seems to be more sensible than the people who are partying like there is no tomorrow.

On the other note I am kind of bit understanding how climate change can be tough sell. Here the effect of COVID is almost visible and people are/were in denial. Think about the effects of climate change which is into future.

Re:Venezuela to Close Pumps as Gas Runs Short, Viral Outbrea... by adrianN on Sunday March 22, 2020 @04:14AM (#22653492)
How many people do you think that quarantine and economic trouble will kill? Because if 20% of the population gets Covid19 and 1% dies that's 15 million people. More realistically if we don't quarantine 60% will get it and 4% will die. That's 180 million people. That's more than twice as many people as died in WW2.
Re:Venezuela to Close Pumps as Gas Runs Short, Viral Outbrea... by nostromo on Sunday March 22, 2020 @04:22AM (#22653528)
I’ll be very direct because of the dire situation at hand.

If you die of Covid-19 you were already dying. This illness was simply the straw that broke the camel’s back.

99% of fatalities in Italy are among people with a prior illness. About 50% of the deaths were people suffering from at least three other illnesses.

The average age of fatalities in Italy is over the median life expectancy of an Italian man.

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-03-18/99-of-tho...

We may have a wave of elders die this year if we don’t quarantine them immediately. (And the next year or two we’ll have fewer elders die than ever.) But there is no need to quarantine the whole world. The young and healthy need to start building up antibodies.

Re:Venezuela to Close Pumps as Gas Runs Short, Viral Outbrea... by adrianN on Sunday March 22, 2020 @04:28AM (#22653549)
Yeah, a prior illnesses like high blood pressure or diabetes with which you can live many more years and which are very prevalent in the 50+ age bracket.

We're still very early in the epidemic. The people dying now are naturally the weakest. Even among young people a percent or two needs hospitalization. If you cumulate up to 50 years, 10% or so need hospitalization and 2% need critical care. Good luck providing for them when millions are infected.

You're also discounting all the additional deaths caused by a healthcare system that runs way over capacity.

Re:Venezuela to Close Pumps as Gas Runs Short, Viral Outbrea... by nostromo on Sunday March 22, 2020 @04:35AM (#22653580)
> You're also discounting all the additional deaths caused by a healthcare system that runs way over capacity.

This hypothetical situation people keep referring to hasn’t happened in Wuhan or Italy.

Young people didn’t die there in large numbers, despite a strained healthcare system.

Re:Venezuela to Close Pumps as Gas Runs Short, Viral Outbrea... by adrianN on Sunday March 22, 2020 @04:38AM (#22653591)
The situation in Wuhan or Italy is not over yet and they did implement the harsh measures that you criticize.
Re:Venezuela to Close Pumps as Gas Runs Short, Viral Outbrea... by DanBC on Sunday March 22, 2020 @05:22AM (#22653758)
> This hypothetical situation people keep referring to hasn’t happened in Wuhan or Italy.

China built sixteen new hospitals in Wuhan in two weeks.

Italy is overwhelmed. Listen to any Italian doctor. https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/coronavirus-...

Re:Venezuela to Close Pumps as Gas Runs Short, Viral Outbrea... by travisoneill1 on Sunday March 22, 2020 @05:30AM (#22653789)
It has happened in Wuhan. Mortality was 0.7% outside the quarantine zone and 5.8% inside.
Re:Venezuela to Close Pumps as Gas Runs Short, Viral Outbrea... by jylam on Sunday March 22, 2020 @04:54AM (#22653642)
If you don't quarantine everyone, you spread the disease. Hospitals are already crowded, look at Europe. If you, 30's something, have severe a health issue for some reason, you won't be treated properly. You'll die or crowd the hospitals more. As will hundreds of thousands. Your antibodies are useless against an heart disease or an accident. Don't spread the disease, don't be a selfish idiot.
Re:Venezuela to Close Pumps as Gas Runs Short, Viral Outbrea... by m4rtink on Sunday March 22, 2020 @10:32AM (#22655166)
Here in Czech Republic hospitals are not overwhelmed yet and all is done to keep it that way - all elective surgeries have been cancelled, same for regular medical checkups and non critical medical consultations.

Also 3 hospitals have been selected as main treatment centers for coronavirus patiens & capacity in them cleared as much as possible. Also in paralle ventilators have been ordered, about 500 so far with first 50 hopefully ariving early newt week.

BTW, for the current numbers here in Czech Republic: 15584 tested, 1047 infected, 6 recovered and 11 vonnected to ventilators. And so far no one died.

Re:Venezuela to Close Pumps as Gas Runs Short, Viral Outbrea... by baddox on Sunday March 22, 2020 @04:35AM (#22653576)
But how much earlier are they dying than they otherwise would have? After all, anything that kills you is just killing you before something else would have killed you. It’s not very satisfying to say “they would have died anyway” without giving some time frame on that, since that’s literally always true.
Re:Venezuela to Close Pumps as Gas Runs Short, Viral Outbrea... by 0xfaded on Sunday March 22, 2020 @05:23AM (#22653761)
You basically present the herd immunity argument with the caveat that it's okay for people older than the median life expectancy to die if they become infected.

I agree this would be a solution, with the huge caveat, that it becomes socially acceptable to euthanize the old instead of dedicating medical resources trying to save them. As others point out, those resources will be needed to maintain normal healthcare operations and treat younger Covid-19 victims who require it.

With the current "save everyone" strategy, I think it should be a fairly easy argument that the older generation, for whom you convincingly argue benefit most from the measures, pays for it. You do this by printing a huge amount of money (diluting those who hold savings) and transferring to the workers whose livelihoods are being destroyed. Increasing public debt should be seen as unacceptable, no bank would ever make a loan for end of life care.

Edit: PS, in Europe printing money will require Germany to allow the ECB to fire up the printing press, which would be fascinating to see.

Re:Venezuela to Close Pumps as Gas Runs Short, Viral Outbrea... by DanBC on Sunday March 22, 2020 @08:54AM (#22654607)
> If you die of Covid-19 you were already dying. This illness was simply the straw that broke the camel’s back.

People with covid-19 need ventilators and intensive care. This isn't just old people with severe comorbid illness, it's younger relatively healthy people too.

If we ignore for a moment the old people who were going to die this year with or without covid-19 we're still left with huge numbers of younger people needing intensive care and ventilation. This has knock-on effects: many healthcare systems have cancelled almost all elective healthcare. You might say that a cancelling a knee replacement doesn't matter, but these kinds of surgeries transform life and allow people to live independently for longer.

Covid-19 is flooding our hospitals with very ill people, and some of them are going to be pretty poorly when they're ready to be discharged, and some community care or care homes are going to have to deal with a larger number of ill people.

The jargon word for this is "acuity". Increased patient acuity increases costs of healthcare, increases risks of harm, increases rates of HCP burnout, decreases access to health care etc etc.

Covid-19 is going to have long lasting effects on healthcare systems even though it's mostly killing people who would have died anyway.

Re:Venezuela to Close Pumps as Gas Runs Short, Viral Outbrea... by woofie11 on Sunday March 22, 2020 @05:14AM (#22653707)
Younger people have lung damage. Read the reports of MERS and SARS survivors to see how that goes.

Also, we don't need to kill our economy:

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1YbtJGn7ida2IYNgwCFk3Sjhs...

Re:Venezuela to Close Pumps as Gas Runs Short, Viral Outbrea... by im3w1l on Sunday March 22, 2020 @05:19AM (#22653742)
SARS was much more dangerous than Covid19 is, so you can't really generalize like that.
Re:Venezuela to Close Pumps as Gas Runs Short, Viral Outbrea... by woofie11 on Sunday March 22, 2020 @07:44AM (#22654276)
Not without CT scans of COVID-19 patients and doctors' reports, I couldn't. We do have those, however.

We can't know what percentage end up with lung scarring. With CT scans, we need to wait to see how lungs recover with time. With doctor's reports, it's anecdotal; we have no statistics.

It might be 1%, or it might be 20%. I'm betting on the 5-6% range. That's an educated guess, based on hospitalization and ICU rates and how the disease progresses.

Re:Venezuela to Close Pumps as Gas Runs Short, Viral Outbrea... by DanBC on Sunday March 22, 2020 @05:16AM (#22653724)
> If you die of Covid-19 you were already dying.

No, this is simply untrue. For some patients the comorbities were things like diabetes.

Also, death is only one outcome. We know covid-19 can affect the lungs, fertility, and can cause neurological damage.

Re:Venezuela to Close Pumps as Gas Runs Short, Viral Outbrea... by m0zg on Sunday March 22, 2020 @05:07AM (#22653686)
>> The average age of fatalities in Italy is over the median life expectancy of an Italian man

And that is probably because they give preference to younger people. If they did not, they'd likely have fewer fatalities overall, but slightly more fatalities in the lower age ranges. Someone made the tough call that if you're 80+ you are "already dying".

Re:Venezuela to Close Pumps as Gas Runs Short, Viral Outbrea... by ChrisClark on Sunday March 22, 2020 @09:10AM (#22654693)
But half the US is obese, that's one of the biggest health issues in the ones dying from SARS 2.

Technically, half the US is already dying from obesity, but I don't think that means they should be all killed off at once.

Re:Venezuela to Close Pumps as Gas Runs Short, Viral Outbrea... by jacobush on Sunday March 22, 2020 @05:21AM (#22653747)
The cases in critical care in Sweden are younger. This indicates spread in Italy has been different due to social differences in contacts between age groups.
[dead]
Re:Venezuela to Close Pumps as Gas Runs Short, Viral Outbrea... by dang on Sunday March 22, 2020 @03:13PM (#22657668)
If you continue to break the site guidelines like this, we will have to ban you. Please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to the rules. We've had to ask you about this before.
Re:Venezuela to Close Pumps as Gas Runs Short, Viral Outbrea... by lawn on Sunday March 22, 2020 @04:20AM (#22653522)
Yes... As long as you deem all the people that will die irrelevant.
Re:Venezuela to Close Pumps as Gas Runs Short, Viral Outbrea... by nostromo on Sunday March 22, 2020 @04:29AM (#22653558)
We could all stop driving tomorrow and save millions of lives over an extended time.

We could ban alcohol and save more.

Banning sex could surely prevent the spread of HIV which has killed tens of millions.

My point is that we are always balancing risk of injury and fatality with costs, and this should be no different.

HN, I suspect, may start to feel differently when they start getting laid off. Google and Facebook ads will decline; Apple stores are closed; venture rounds will dry up. You’re not immune.

Re:Venezuela to Close Pumps as Gas Runs Short, Viral Outbrea... by dang on Sunday March 22, 2020 @03:17PM (#22657701)
I understand it's frustrating to be representing a minority view, but please stick to not being inflammatory. That's critical, given the levels of stress, fear, and anger right now. And you've mostly been doing a good job of it.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Venezuela to Close Pumps as Gas Runs Short, Viral Outbrea... by nostromo on Sunday March 22, 2020 @06:40PM (#22659445)
Thank you, I'll do better.
Re:Venezuela to Close Pumps as Gas Runs Short, Viral Outbrea... by Kiro on Sunday March 22, 2020 @05:11AM (#22653699)
800 people died in Italy just yesterday. Stop downplaying.
Re:Venezuela to Close Pumps as Gas Runs Short, Viral Outbrea... by dang on Sunday March 22, 2020 @03:14PM (#22657680)
No one knows what's happening right now, so it's natural and inevitable that are different views. As long as people express their views thoughtfully and respectfully, that's within the site guidelines.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Venezuela to Close Pumps as Gas Runs Short, Viral Outbrea... by ddxxdd on Sunday March 22, 2020 @05:43AM (#22653835)
I'm not the OP, but the world just lost hundreds of trillions of dollars of wealth over the past month. When people start going hungry because of a lack of income, then we can really start comparing the harm of containment to the harm of the pandemic itself.
Re:Venezuela to Close Pumps as Gas Runs Short, Viral Outbrea... by inferiorhuman on Sunday March 22, 2020 @06:15AM (#22653940)
I'm not the OP, but the world just lost hundreds of trillions of dollars of wealth over the past month

Folks wealthy enough to own equity lost wealth, that's a pretty small minority though. That it's a eye popping amount of money just goes to show how unequally wealth is distributed.

When people start going hungry because of a lack of income, then we can really start comparing the harm of containment to the harm of the pandemic itself.

Dead people don't eat. People too sick to work in America won't have any income. With enough incapacitated and dead you'll still have your economic harm, only this time with a lot more dead bodies. If your customers are incapacitated / sick, dead, or too destitute (as a result of expensive medical care) they're not going to provide you any income either.

Folks in the UK/EU will have some safety net, what happens if/when this explodes in India? Iran has a rather large middle class (especially considering the region). With the mass graves that they're building, how much economic productivity do you think's been sucked out of Iran? Do you think the CCP quarantined 100 million people on a whim without a care in the world for their economy?

In the immediate term there's also a price war going on between Russia and Saudi Arabia. That is a much bigger deal right now.

Longer term we've already got a number of high profile politicians (and immediate family) with the virus (e.g. wives of the Spanish and Canadian PMs, various American congress critters, UK MPs, etc., etc.). What's a power vacuum going to do to the economy? My guess is: nothing good.

Re:Venezuela to Close Pumps as Gas Runs Short, Viral Outbrea... by op03 on Sunday March 22, 2020 @06:30AM (#22653996)
Nothing good is not something new to humanity.

Ask the German and Japanese survivors of WW2. India has gone through its own share of unimaginable trauma such as Partition. Travel around the Balkans today or Russia and talk to people about their memories of War and Collapse.

Its hard to imagine how society recovers from such events, while in the midst of one.

But we do.

[dead]
Re:Venezuela to Close Pumps as Gas Runs Short, Viral Outbrea... by dang on Sunday March 22, 2020 @06:03PM (#22659159)
We've banned this account for repeatedly posting personal attacks and flamewar comments. That's not cool on HN at any time, and certainly not now.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html