News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by jagger27 on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:00PM (#22612067)
$11,000 for a plastic valve. Unreal. No wonder hospitals are always stretched to the limit when they're being gouged like this.

Think of it this way, a hospital could buy 10 valves or hire a physician for a year. Are these valves typically re-used? Are they going through them faster because they don't want to risk infecting other people?

Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by Ididntdothis on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:20PM (#22612250)
I wouldn’t feel too bad for the hospitals. They are happy to mark up prices by an outrageous amount. My company does medical devices. One device goes for around 20k to the hospital. I have heard that the hospital often charges 80-100k for the device plus the cost for doctors and facility which is often another 50k or more.
Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by jagger27 on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:26PM (#22612287)
I don't feel bad for hospitals, I feel bad for the patients in hospitals who suffer because of the greed of private companies.
Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by ma2rten on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:22PM (#22612265)
I doubt that's the case in Italy.
Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by negrit on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:39PM (#22612382)
In the US yes, thanks god not every country has 3rd world healthcare.
Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by rbanffy on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @02:58PM (#22620052)
The third world finds this comparison rather offensive.
Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by oliwarner on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @05:52PM (#22621627)
This was an Italian hospital, not an American one. Devices and drugs are dispensed at cost, or lower, and that number often comes out considerably less than the public list price.

Either which way, typical healthcare profiteering is not going to end well here. There is simply too much on the line to allow people to block or threaten progress.

Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by cosmiccatnap on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @09:15PM (#22612606)
Considering your company probably makes them for <5k I'd say it's sad all around
Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by Narkov on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:07PM (#22612121)
It's not $11,000 for a plastic valve. It's $11,000 for a plastic valve and the many thousands of hours of R&D, testing, validation, certification and risk.
Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by caymanjim on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:20PM (#22612248)
> It's not $11,000 for a plastic valve. It's $11,000 for a plastic valve and the many thousands of hours of R&D, testing, validation, certification and risk.

Nope. Sorry. Not buying that argument this time. I accept that argument for patent exclusion periods and high prices on medication, because the R&D has enormous risk costs when medications don't work or don't get approval. Allowing pharmaceutical companies to recoup those costs is vital to innovation and public health. This is a piece of plastic that's part of a larger machine. There was no enormous R&D budget required to develop the replaceable component. By all means let them make money on the machine, but the argument doesn't hold up for this simple maintenance component.

Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by OnlineCourage on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:40PM (#22612386)
You don't get to, "not buy the argument," because R&D costs are constrained by layers of unimaginably complex legislation and compliance. The company had to jump through ridiculous hoops for every component of said machine. Until you pull out the book and say, "Nope, see here Section 93...they did not have to do X, it's needless," you don't really have a good counterpoint because this is the case for all medical equipment. You can't just out of the blue say, "Yeah but not this one!" The entire medical regulatory and compliance system is overly complex. You're making the $10000 toilet seat argument...yeah, well the toilet seat needed to be delivered to a highly regulated aircraft. Ironically those $10,000 toilet seats are now $300 because they are 3d printed.
Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by joshvm on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @12:29AM (#22613637)
Nobody has mentioned how much an entire ventilator costs. Best I can find is between $5-50k usd. For example a Puritan Bennett 980 quoted as around $50k (by the manufacturer) with a $2k a year service contract.

https://www.medtronic.com/covidien/en-gb/products/mechanical...

So why is a valve $10k? Note that a replacement battery for the above ventilator costs < $1k.

Is the valve a disposable part (at 20% cost of the whole unit?) Is it some special valve that is the core IP (that other medical valves can't replace?) Is it made from some special material? Do they have to make each one from scratch? Does individual certification cost a fortune (and maybe this is a fixed cost regardless of what you're testing)? How much does a similar replacement valve cost for a similar ventilator?

Bear in mind that $10k implies a $3k cost to the company, at a typical hardware engineering markup.

I don't think we can handwave "Rnd" or some mystical "compliance" cost without knowing more details.

Seems like a valve for anaesthesiology is a Class II medical device, which may be a start?

https://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/cdrh/cfdocs/cfcfr/CFR...

Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by caymanjim on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:18AM (#22616278)
> So why is a valve $10k? Note that a replacement battery for the above ventilator costs < $1k.

I'm guessing the valves are single-use (due to contamination), so the cost is passed along to the customer. They can't charge every customer for a battery (I mean, they could prorate it, but that's not how medical billing works). The hospital doesn't care what a valve costs if they're passing-along 100% of the cost to you.

Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by teilo on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @10:47AM (#22617210)
If that is the case, then I have even less sympathy for the manufacturer.
Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by jagger27 on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @09:14PM (#22612605)
> The entire medical regulatory and compliance system is overly complex.

And big companies take advantage of their position as the only ones who can navigate such a system to justify their sky high prices, and then they lobby to maintain that position.

The valve in question looks to be for IV drug delivery, which is not a new technology. It's probably just a simple check valve.

Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @09:29PM (#22612694)
> And big companies take advantage of their position as the only ones who can navigate such a system to justify their sky high prices, and then they lobby to maintain that position.

This is something most people don't comprehend. People tend to think that it's the government putting in place these regulations and the companies are against them, but more often than not the regulations exist at the behest of the incumbents to constrain competition.

Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by ASalazarMX on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @10:09PM (#22612897)
It's hard to climb up, but it's harder to stay at the top, so they put barriers behind once they have reached high enough.
Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by rbanffy on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @03:02PM (#22620091)
In a sense, it's the government. It's just that, thanks to massive donations, committee stuffing and other shenanigans, they got to write the regulations themselves.
Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by Narkov on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:23PM (#22612271)
> There was no enormous R&D budget required to develop the replaceable component.

Are you sure about this? Just because it is one small part of a complex device doesn't make it low cost.

> By all means let them make money on the machine

Ok...so the machine becomes (for example) $1m instead of $10k. The financial cost to use the machine remains the same.

Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by jagger27 on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:14PM (#22612194)
Let's say the regulatory costs add up to $100,000,000 and the valve has a marginal cost of $1.00 to make and distribute. They would have to sell just 10,000 units to more than offset their investment. I think I'd wager the world needs more than 10,000 air valves.

How can one justify this kind of vicious exploitation of publicly funded healthcare?

Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by asdfadsfgfdda on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:36PM (#22612348)
I seriously doubt any critical medical part can be made for $1. If that part fails, there are likely serious consequences for the patient. Sure the plastic is cheap, but the manufacturer will likely do several expensive steps to reduce the failure rate:

Each part is traceable from all raw materials to finished product

Each part is manually tested/calibrated

Each part may be tested with non-destructive testing (x-ray, ultrasound, dye crack inspection etc)

For every lot of parts, several parts will be tested destructively

Each part comes with liability, so the manufacturer will likely purchase liability insurance

Also, the regulatory costs are paid years in advance of a single unit being sold. Once the device is approved (that is, if it's approved at all), the units are sold slowly over years. So the regulatory costs must be financed.

Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by jagger27 on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @09:05PM (#22612534)
> So the regulatory costs must be financed.

Absolutely. Why does the "financing" in this case have to go through a hospital's purchasing department? The obvious reason for why they charge such incredible amounts per unit is because they can. If there was any amount of competition or marketplace for it, it would be cheaper. There clearly isn't.

Explain to me how this way of doing things is not holding the public hostage.

Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by tomrod on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @09:14PM (#22612598)
> I seriously doubt any critical medical part can be made for $1.

Seems like these things that were 3D printed could be. At least at a marginal cost.

Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by gentleman11 on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @09:42PM (#22612755)
A few failures is a lot less deadly than what is happening in Italy right now
Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by kube-system on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @12:38AM (#22613679)
What specifically is this valve for? A lot of medical equipment is surprisingly low volume. The UK for instance has 5000 ventilators in the entire country. Ventec was interviewed on NBC News this evening, they said they normally produce 150 ventilators per month.

There are tons of medical devices that are low enough volume that most hospitals don't even have a single unit. There's a reason why we have hospitals with varying levels of status, capabilities, and specialties. There are fairly common surgeries that require equipment that only exists in 2 or 3 digit quantities in the entire world.

Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by manicdee on Thursday March 19, 2020 @08:06PM (#22633142)
So few are available because they are hideously expensive.

They are hideously expensive because so few are bought.

Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by Narkov on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:16PM (#22612215)
All three of your numbers are purely hypothetical and are likely out by one or two orders of magnitude.

My point is that people saying that it is overpriced don't understand the input costs of medical devices.

Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by gerdesj on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:36PM (#22612354)
"Let's say the regulatory costs add up to $100,000,000 and the valve has a marginal cost of $1.00 to make and distribute."

That's two numbers relating to the cost of production. The second is the cost that a 3D printer doing one off prints actually costs (it's in the article, as a rough estimate.) The first number is a deliberately chosen "insane" example figure to show the absurdity of an $11,000 part. A medical test n license for a single part of a device does not cost anything like $100M.

Now as to the market for these things - the third number. Nearly 8,000 people have died so far. I can't be arsed to extrapolate further but I recall reading that these are single use devices.

Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by negrit on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:38PM (#22612372)
The very likely overpriced. The healthcare industry made over $100 billion in the US only in 2018. I've experienced it first hand, UCSF tried to force me into buying a ($174) kneebrace for over $2400...

And the fact that they are threatening to sue for something they couldn't sell is disgusting.

Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by jagger27 on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:20PM (#22612244)
You're right, it's probably closer to a billion dollars to develop and $0.10 to produce. Doesn't change my argument very much.
Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by johnwheeler on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:12PM (#22612180)
A hell of a lot of advertising, r&d etc goes into a can of Coke too. It doesn't cost 11,000 dollars
Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by throwaway894345 on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:25PM (#22612283)
Coke cans don’t have the same regulatory hurdles and moreover there your coke can R&D is amortized over something like a trillion units. There’s a real argument for why this lawsuit is dumb, but this ain’t it.
Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by Narkov on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:17PM (#22612228)
Are you comparing a can of Coke to a medical device? It's surprising that I need to say this but the economies of scale are completely different.
Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by jacquesm on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @08:32AM (#22615845)
I've seen up close how medical devices are made. I've also been in a softdrink bottling plant. Based on those experiences I think your chances of acquiring some disease from a softdrink vs acquiring one from a medical device are about equal.
Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by tomrod on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:11PM (#22612166)
Lovely. Duplication of fixed costs lead to natural monopolies. Sounds like there is room for intervention.
Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by scotty79 on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:16PM (#22612212)
If your plan is to finance yourself by charging $11k for a piece of plastic maybe you need another plan because people will rightfully crucify you.
Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by notRobot on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:08PM (#22612126)
Still too much.
Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by Turing_Machine on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:10PM (#22612146)
Maybe you (or someone) should go into the respirator business and undersell them on price?
Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by jagger27 on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:16PM (#22612213)
And risk getting sued by extremely well funded corporations protected by broad scope patents. It may well be the case that it is prohibitive to get proper regulatory approval to sell such a device.
Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by Turing_Machine on Sunday March 22, 2020 @03:37PM (#22657874)
Ventilators are early 1900s technology. You're not *going to "get sued" for a basic unit.

And yeah, it costs a ton of money to get regulatory approval.

So where do you think all that money comes from? Think maybe they have to build that into the price of the ventilator, so maybe it's not so "overpriced" at all? Maybe?

Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by sharemywin on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:58PM (#22612488)
you forgot all the medical savings groups(cartels) that won't buy from you because they're paid commission that the hospitals have contracts with so they can't buy from you.
Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by chance_state on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:12PM (#22612173)
Sounds like that's already happening with a new price of "free" and they're not happy about it.
Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by gameswithgo on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:15PM (#22612202)
someone just did and they are getting sued
Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by Narkov on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:09PM (#22612136)
What are you basing that on? How much was spent on development that $11,000 is too much? $100k, $1m, $1b ?
Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by e40 on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @11:48PM (#22613441)
Seriously, unless the inside of that value is really, really, really complex, I can't imagine it would take that much R&D, relative to the rest of the machine. I would think relative to that, this value was dead trivial.
Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by indymike on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:16PM (#22612211)
Um, $11k for your life is not a legal contract.
Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by inetknght on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:23PM (#22612276)
...yet.
Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by tathougies on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:04PM (#22612093)
Part of the cost is certainly regulatory / insurance underwriting approval, isn't it?
Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by TheOtherHobbes on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:06PM (#22612116)
And the rest is pure profit.
Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by thrill on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:08PM (#22612131)
If it was that profitable there'd be dozens of competitors.
Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by al3xandre on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:10PM (#22612154)
... or there was and they consolidated to increase profits since antitrust is rarely enforced these days
Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by betaby on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:12PM (#22612177)
Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by awb on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:10PM (#22612149)
Unless there are patents involved.
Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by 0_gravitas on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:11PM (#22612164)
Not if the barrier to entry is high enough (and then also assuming there is zero collusion)
Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by HeWhoLurksLate on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:09PM (#22612141)
It's also that entrenched, as well.
Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by rbanffy on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @03:03PM (#22620097)
Let's say it did cost a million to certify the valve. That's covered in the first 100 valves sold.

From then on, which should be like after a week, every single dollar is profit.

Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by Turing_Machine on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:08PM (#22612134)
Yes, it is. Medical devices have to be FDA approved (or the equivalent in other countries) and that costs LOTS of money.

On top of that, you have to account for the potential lawsuit if your 3D-printed knockoff respirator valve fails and someone dies.

Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by nexuist on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:18PM (#22612237)
As opposed to not having a valve at all? The hospital wouldn't need knockoff valves if they had the real thing. In such dire circumstances I don't think any judge would fault you for going the unconventional route to deliver results. It's similar to how captains on boats and airplanes are allowed to break almost any regulation in the book to ensure the safety of their passengers.
Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by sokoloff on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:24PM (#22612277)
This. I have set this policy as the first rule of our SRE response teams to make it clear the broad extent of their power. Because it’s our written policy, it’s incorporated into our PCI and SOX compliance programs as well. The auditors don’t always love it, but we’ve always gotten them to understand.

The aviation law: https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/14/91.3

Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by enriquto on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:15PM (#22612204)
> On top of that, you have to account for the potential lawsuit if your 3D-printed knockoff respirator valve fails and someone dies.

In that case, the alternative was a few people over there going to die by slow asphyxiation, so the 3D-printed knockoffs were a really good thing, even if some of them failed.

Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by UnpossibleJim on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:28PM (#22612305)
Except, that the 3D printer plastic might not hold up to the medical grade plastic and might cause system wide infections that hadn't been accounted for culminating in a brain or spinal infection that leaves a person in a coma for the rest of their painful life while the family watches. The family then Sue's malpractice, doctor's lose their medical license and hospitals lose millions which could go to treat patients. Hypotheticals can go both ways.
Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by enriquto on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @03:22AM (#22614382)
Yes, this is a difficult decision. If you were a doctor what would you do? Let the patient die today, or try the newly 3D printed valve that looks and feels like the real one but may have unintended side effects?
Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by unionpivo on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @03:22AM (#22614379)
Thats why they printed so many, that they can change them for each patient.
Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:56PM (#22612473)
> On top of that, you have to account for the potential lawsuit if your 3D-printed knockoff respirator valve fails and someone dies.

Where does this meme that companies get sued for parts made by completely independent third parties come from?

The most obvious reason that wouldn't be true is that without a patent on the part or similar, companies generally have no right to prevent third parties from making replacement parts for their equipment. It would be pretty silly to impose liability for something they have no control over.

Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by Turing_Machine on Sunday March 22, 2020 @03:38PM (#22657891)
> Where does this meme that companies get sued for parts made by completely independent third parties come from?

"Meme"?

Where does your your that malpractice lawsuits are just "memes" come from? Because I can assure you that they exist in the real world. As do massive fines for using equipment that hasn't been FDA approved.

Re:Company threatens to sue volunteers who 3D-printed valves... by zokula on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:25PM (#22612282)
Late stage capitalism