https://www.medtronic.com/covidien/en-gb/products/mechanical...
So why is a valve $10k? Note that a replacement battery for the above ventilator costs < $1k.
Is the valve a disposable part (at 20% cost of the whole unit?) Is it some special valve that is the core IP (that other medical valves can't replace?) Is it made from some special material? Do they have to make each one from scratch? Does individual certification cost a fortune (and maybe this is a fixed cost regardless of what you're testing)? How much does a similar replacement valve cost for a similar ventilator?
Bear in mind that $10k implies a $3k cost to the company, at a typical hardware engineering markup.
I don't think we can handwave "Rnd" or some mystical "compliance" cost without knowing more details.
Seems like a valve for anaesthesiology is a Class II medical device, which may be a start?
https://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/cdrh/cfdocs/cfcfr/CFR...
I'm guessing the valves are single-use (due to contamination), so the cost is passed along to the customer. They can't charge every customer for a battery (I mean, they could prorate it, but that's not how medical billing works). The hospital doesn't care what a valve costs if they're passing-along 100% of the cost to you.
And big companies take advantage of their position as the only ones who can navigate such a system to justify their sky high prices, and then they lobby to maintain that position.
The valve in question looks to be for IV drug delivery, which is not a new technology. It's probably just a simple check valve.
This is something most people don't comprehend. People tend to think that it's the government putting in place these regulations and the companies are against them, but more often than not the regulations exist at the behest of the incumbents to constrain competition.
Are you sure about this? Just because it is one small part of a complex device doesn't make it low cost.
> By all means let them make money on the machine
Ok...so the machine becomes (for example) $1m instead of $10k. The financial cost to use the machine remains the same.
Nope. Sorry. Not buying that argument this time. I accept that argument for patent exclusion periods and high prices on medication, because the R&D has enormous risk costs when medications don't work or don't get approval. Allowing pharmaceutical companies to recoup those costs is vital to innovation and public health. This is a piece of plastic that's part of a larger machine. There was no enormous R&D budget required to develop the replaceable component. By all means let them make money on the machine, but the argument doesn't hold up for this simple maintenance component.