News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Biggest U.S. airlines spent bulk of free cash flow on sto... by roenxi on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @07:42AM (#22603876)
Wiki says:

> free cash flow to firm (FCFF) is a way of looking at a business's cash flow to see what is available for distribution among all the securities holders of a corporate entity. [0]

What do people expect them to do with free cash flow? The point of free cash flow is to get the money back to shareholders. These aren't high-growth industries.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_cash_flow

Re:Biggest U.S. airlines spent bulk of free cash flow on sto... by Dobbs on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @07:43AM (#22603883)
Pay employees more, increase benefits, better service for customers, put money away for a rainy day? There are lots of ways to spend money that are good for the long term rather than making the rich richer.
Re:Biggest U.S. airlines spent bulk of free cash flow on sto... by wil421 on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:40AM (#22604301)
Delta just paid every employee 14% of their pay earlier this year after a blockbuster 2019. I bet they are rethinking that decision.
Re:Biggest U.S. airlines spent bulk of free cash flow on sto... by yyy888sss on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:44AM (#22604332)
Public companies aim to maximise shareholder value, however in competitive markets that usually involves improving service, having a happy workforce (higher benefits) so it all works. And putting money away for a rainy day will never be as beneficial for companies as for individuals.
Re:Biggest U.S. airlines spent bulk of free cash flow on sto... by aNoob7000 on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:51AM (#22604389)
If saving money for a rainy day is never going to be a top priority, then going bankrupt should be an option.

I think what's frustrating for me is that under these circumstances, there will be a lot of individuals and small businesses that will go under because they didn't save enough for a rainy day, but if your big enough, we have to save you.

Re:Biggest U.S. airlines spent bulk of free cash flow on sto... by Justsignedup on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @09:13AM (#22604550)
This is exactly the point.

There is never a reason to save if the government will always bail you out.

If you are forced to save because not saving could mean certain company death, you will save. And make sure you have a two year runway if zero business is happening.

But with the bailouts the companies are rightfully maximizing shareholder value.

The bailout should directly go to displaced workers and supporting them. It'll directly stimulate the economy and correctly punish the company got fucking itself.

Re:Biggest U.S. airlines spent bulk of free cash flow on sto... by ses1984 on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:57AM (#22604425)
If you think your stock is going to beat the market then share buybacks are similar to putting money away for a rainy fay. If you don't think your stock is going to beat the market then close the business.
Re:Biggest U.S. airlines spent bulk of free cash flow on sto... by Donald on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @07:48AM (#22603934)
These companies have gutted their research and development costs to increase free cash flow. For example, Boeing’s share repurchase program also accelerated as BA reached all time highs and became an extremely risky asset after the second MAX crash and endless FAA investigations. That’s a senseless use of capital yet they’re asking tax payers for bailouts.
Re:Biggest U.S. airlines spent bulk of free cash flow on sto... by senordevnyc on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @07:50AM (#22603946)
We’re talking about airlines, not Boeing. How much R&D should they be doing?
Re:Biggest U.S. airlines spent bulk of free cash flow on sto... by whb07 on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:40AM (#22604289)
You mean they couldn’t be doing R&D into better flight paths for fuel economy or risk? What about finding ways to better transact with the end client? Or a better way to deal with cargo? How’s about research into a machine to better load cargo into the plane?

What type of question is this?

Re:Biggest U.S. airlines spent bulk of free cash flow on sto... by yyy888sss on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:50AM (#22604375)
They already do this, in fact it's critical to optimise things like this in a low margin industry like airlines. Any airline that doesn't calculate the best flight paths for fuel economy will quickly go out of business.
Re:Biggest U.S. airlines spent bulk of free cash flow on sto... by whb07 on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:59AM (#22604444)
Because they couldn’t spend more money to improve things, yep, you’re right.
[dead]
Re:Biggest U.S. airlines spent bulk of free cash flow on sto... by dboreham on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:18AM (#22604144)
That problem can probably be solved with a small dose of common sense.
Re:Biggest U.S. airlines spent bulk of free cash flow on sto... by lordnacho on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @07:45AM (#22603897)
They could hold on to some, just in case there was a disturbance that caused cashflow to stop for a while.
Re:Biggest U.S. airlines spent bulk of free cash flow on sto... by dforrestwilson on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @07:47AM (#22603918)
For example paying down debt instead of loading up like American Airlines did.
Re:Biggest U.S. airlines spent bulk of free cash flow on sto... by roenxi on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @07:47AM (#22603920)
Then the money would probably not be free cash. It would be held under some sort of actuarial title for dealing with risk. Maybe amortization? I'm not an accountant.

If the business needs it to sustain operations then it probably isn't free cash flow.

Re:Biggest U.S. airlines spent bulk of free cash flow on sto... by frgtpsswrdlame on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @07:56AM (#22603992)
The argument here is that they actually did need it to sustain operations since there's a significant chance they'll now receive a bailout. The whole point is they took cash they should have kept as a backup and then used it to boost share price instead.
Re:Biggest U.S. airlines spent bulk of free cash flow on sto... by IkmoIkmo on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @10:09PM (#22623696)
Do we really want businesses to hold onto cash, sitting idle, just in case a once in a century pandemic like this hits your industry particularly hard?

I don't think that makes sense. People talk about 'socialised losses' as if it's the devil's work. I think socialised losses aren't that bad when talking about such unique events. Should companies really be holding on to cash for once in a century events? Imagine a 1950s CEO had been hoarding cash for 70 years. Now imagine how much wealth has been generated, by putting that cash to use, including by paying it out as cash to investors who'll go on to finance new businesses, new jobs, new research etc.

That having been said, while I'm not opposed to socialised losses / bailouts per se, I don't really quite see yet why airlines need bailouts. Their stock valuations rose due to bailouts. Now they drop some due to the crisis. They should be high enough to sell more stock it once bought and raise new capital. In good years you buy the stock back. In bad years you sell stock. What's the problem? Yes investors take losses, it's part of the game. That's why you diversify. If you don't, that's on you.

Not sure how far the US goes, but in the Netherlands all employees have unemployment insurance if they get laid off. And those who don't, get a little over $1k in social security, plus various subsidies on rent, healthcare etc. Companies in trouble can layoff people, and they're taken care of with the insurance premiums paid out in the good years. The company sells off stock and hunkers down. The government offers cheap lines of credit. Good businesses survive, a few bad ones die off. I don't see why a big bailout is necessary.

Re:Biggest U.S. airlines spent bulk of free cash flow on sto... by roenxi on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:01AM (#22604030)
Which is a fair point but ... and I'm going to stop after this because I've made my point to the best of my ability ... but if they did that then the money wouldn't be called free cash flow because they've decided they need it for emergencies. They could be extremely risk tolerant and they'd still be sending all their FCF to shareholders. The amount would simply be smaller.

I'm totally on board that bailouts are the worst and are inappropriate; but the statistic in the article is an accounting identity. They call the money they send to shareholders FCF, so obviously around 100% of FCF is going to be going to shareholders. If they think there is a potentially better use for the money than going to shareholders it isn't classed as FCF.

Re:Biggest U.S. airlines spent bulk of free cash flow on sto... by luckylion on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:26AM (#22604190)
RE "wouldn't be called free cash flow": it still would, because it'd be their own personal decision to save it for a rainy day. When they'd have to save some amount for a rainy day due to regulations, that money wouldn't be considered free cash flow. FCF is, from what I understand, not automatically equal to what you send to shareholders, but sending it to shareholders is an option. Another option would be investing it, or putting it in your bank accounts, as Apple, Google, Microsoft etc are doing.

The airlines simply made a business decision and bet their company on never needing to sustain a drop in traffic, and they've lost the bet.

If you take whatever you have left after paying for rent, food and insurance, that's your FCF. You can now decide whether you want to save some or all of that, spend it on a new bed, or blow it on coke. The airlines chose what made them/their shareholders happy in the short term and potentially very sad in the long term.

Re:Biggest U.S. airlines spent bulk of free cash flow on sto... by QuesnayJr on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:36AM (#22604255)
That's not true. The definition of free cash flow includes cash the firm keeps on hand. Any positive change in Apple's "cash and cash equivalents" counts as free cash flow, for example.
Re:Biggest U.S. airlines spent bulk of free cash flow on sto... by lordnacho on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:14AM (#22604112)
No, there's no actuarial or accountancy reason they'd have to do that. It's no different from someone running a restaurant business saving some in the bank instead of taking it all out.

The cash flow is "free" in the sense that you don't owe it to someone else, eg salaries, suppliers, etc. You can save it in a pot if you feel like it.

Re:Biggest U.S. airlines spent bulk of free cash flow on sto... by hef19898 on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @07:58AM (#22604004)
I read it that airlines could have simply put the cash in a bank account. Pretty mch what Apple does. becasue that amount of free cash would sure be handy right now.
Re:Biggest U.S. airlines spent bulk of free cash flow on sto... by zaroth on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:28AM (#22604205)
Apple has a lot of cash, but they also do more stock buybacks than anyone. ~$20 billion just last quarter!

https://ycharts.com/companies/AAPL/stock_buyback

Re:Biggest U.S. airlines spent bulk of free cash flow on sto... by aNoob7000 on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @09:54AM (#22604860)
And if they run into any issues because of this outbreak, they are out of luck in my book.
Re:Biggest U.S. airlines spent bulk of free cash flow on sto... by swarnie_ on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @07:46AM (#22603914)
This would result in the board being sacked for sitting on spare cash and not maximising shareholder return.
Re:Biggest U.S. airlines spent bulk of free cash flow on sto... by chewz on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @07:48AM (#22603932)
Did Apple board got sacked?
Re:Biggest U.S. airlines spent bulk of free cash flow on sto... by zaroth on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:25AM (#22604183)
Apple has done more buybacks than anyone! And pays a dividend.

> Since 2012, Apple has been buying back shares at the extraordinary rate of around $10 billion per quarter.

Shareholders demanded it.

Re:Biggest U.S. airlines spent bulk of free cash flow on sto... by QuesnayJr on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:39AM (#22604283)
Apple has gigantic amounts of free cash flow, which is why they have $100 billion of cash on their balance sheet, despite their buybacks.
Re:Biggest U.S. airlines spent bulk of free cash flow on sto... by zaroth on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:50AM (#22604370)
Just back of the envelope, if every Fortune 100 had $100 billion in cash, that would be $10 trillion sitting in accounts as, what, a rainy day fund?

Apple keeps a massive cash hoard in case they want to do a very large strategic acquisition. Airlines would be doing mergers not acquisitions.

IMO it’s entirely appropriate that if a black swan even cripples an industry like air travel for a government to offer low-interest loans until they can start generating cash again.

This is actually significantly more efficient than each company having to put billions of capital on the sidelines “just in case” their entire multi-billion dollar revenue stream goes to $0 for a few months. Capital efficiency is very important to overall economic growth.

Re:Biggest U.S. airlines spent bulk of free cash flow on sto... by QuesnayJr on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @10:07AM (#22604954)
It's not on the sidelines. Like 0.001% of "cash" is actually cash. Apple holds like a third of its "cash" in equities. Airlines could do the same, or hold short-term debt, or pay down their own debt (which would free up capital for other uses). (They could also hold long-term debt in other companies, but I'm not sure where that shows up in the balance sheet.)
Re:Biggest U.S. airlines spent bulk of free cash flow on sto... by chewz on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:56AM (#22604422)
Money is returned to shareholders as buyback or dividend and shareholders can capitalize company in times of need (or when they see an opportunity for expansion or market takeover).

This is more effective, quicker and cheaper way of capital alocation. It also eliminates political agenda.

Re:Biggest U.S. airlines spent bulk of free cash flow on sto... by willsr on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @07:53AM (#22603977)
What about some equity in return for a bail out..
Re:Biggest U.S. airlines spent bulk of free cash flow on sto... by QuesnayJr on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:31AM (#22604220)
A firm who returns free cash flow to shareholders and then defaults on debt is transferring money from bondholders to shareholders.
Re:Biggest U.S. airlines spent bulk of free cash flow on sto... by asplake on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @07:46AM (#22603901)
Save it as a buffer against changes in conditions?
Re:Biggest U.S. airlines spent bulk of free cash flow on sto... by boh on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @09:49AM (#22604825)
From an economics perspective FCF is a company's failure to make efficient use of capital. They can just as easily pay more taxes. Individual shareholders have a limited capacity to efficiently allocate capital when compared to larger enterprises (that's pretty much the point of having corporations).
Re:Biggest U.S. airlines spent bulk of free cash flow on sto... by supdatecron on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @07:50AM (#22603949)
[0] Save cash for a rainy day