News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by topkai22 on Monday March 16, 2020 @12:02AM (#22589801)
When talking about economic damage it is also worth thinking about what we are trying to avoid in the US- if SARS-Cov2 gets to 60% of the population, then at a 2% case fatality rate we are looking at 4 million excess deaths. Most importantly, that is a humanitarian tragedy that we must avoid. However, having numbers also let’s us put an economic value out there for what we are trying to save.

A 1% reduction in the case fatality rate saves roughly 2M people. Let’s assume that each would live another 10 years and that each person year is worth $100k. That means a 1% reduction in the case fatality rate is worth 2 trillion dollars. That’s roughly 10% of GDP. You can play with the numbers a bit, it’s hard not to end up in the “taking a multi year recession might be worth it” territory. Obviously, there are decreasing marginal returns to various actions, but the it’s important to keep in mind the scale of what we are trying to avoid.

Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by pombrand on Monday March 16, 2020 @02:30PM (#22595757)
Who cares about Case Fatality Rate (the % diagnosed that die), it depends on how many cases are measured. What you need to base yourself on is estimated Infected Fatality Rate (the % infected that die) which is what the CDC states is about 0.1% for the seasonal flu in the US. In Korea the CFR is closing on the IFR as they're testing thousands of asymptomatic people, currently at 0.6% AFAIK.

Infected Fatality Rate will likely end up at 0.3% taking the diamond princess cruise ship as a model (this assumes access to quality care and a PCR false negative rate of 29% adjusted for the higher average age on the cruise).

Worst case: 327 million people * 0.6 (a worst case nr) * 0.005 = 981 000 dead.

More likely 30% gets infected, we figure out what treatment options are optimal and we end up with something like 30% infected and a 0.2% IFR = 196 000 dead.

Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by cutemonster on Monday March 16, 2020 @10:28PM (#22600911)
When running out of hospital beds the fatality rate increases a lot though.
Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by dillondoyle on Monday March 16, 2020 @02:46AM (#22590570)
I hate myself for saying this but if one wants a cold calculous thought experiment, what about thinking about the mortality age? mostly older people, not only don't work but are also often a net burden to society.
Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by SkyPuncher on Monday March 16, 2020 @09:33AM (#22592489)
This is a misguided thought.

Older people are more affected by SARS-2, but they are also more affected by nearly every disease. It comes with age.

Another huge factor is we're very, very early in this crisis. On average, it takes longer for younger, stronger people to succumb to their symptoms. Even if death is not a common outcome for young people, there are concerns of long term lung and organ damage. Not to mention if you have a bad case, it literally feels like you're suffocating.

Data I've seen from Italy and China showed two important factors:

* 41% of people in China's ICU's were under 50 * Italy's average death age from COVID-19 has been dropping. I'd expected this trend until we're about 4 to 6 weeks into this being widespread in Italy (currently 2 or 3 at the moment).

Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by topkai22 on Monday March 16, 2020 @09:38AM (#22592525)
Its already in the model- 10 quality adjusted years of life. You could reasonable drive that down, but not to less than 3 I'm pretty sure.

I don't think it's appropriate to model current output though. This is a social / political question as much as a economic one. I mostly view retirees as "paid up" members of society and, since I'd like my kids and grandkids to think this way when I'm old be not feeble, believe they should be treated as full members of society.

Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by dillondoyle on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @02:24AM (#22602281)
Does the model include costs too - not just earnings potential? like social security?

To be clear I am 100% with your priorities just think it's an interesting - albeit totally inhumane - thought experiment.

Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by llampx on Monday March 16, 2020 @07:06AM (#22591666)
Yes we've already extracted all the value we could extract from them. Better get rid of the useless husks asap.

Do you realize how that sounds?

Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by bobbylarrybobby on Monday March 16, 2020 @11:09AM (#22593357)
If we’re gonna talk about the economic value of individuals to society, it makes sense to evaluate that value correctly. The premise of the discussion was that a life has finite value to society.
Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by thrownaway954 on Monday March 16, 2020 @08:23AM (#22592038)
don't hate yourself. china is facing a huge economic epidemic from the elderly and although noone wants to be "that guy" this virus outbreak could actually be a good thing for them and the rest of the world to curb the elderly population.

https://time.com/5523805/china-aging-population-working-age/

Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by anewguy9000 on Monday March 16, 2020 @08:47AM (#22592197)
its a hard but fair and valid moral question
Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by hartator on Monday March 16, 2020 @12:43AM (#22590032)
Current total deaths are 6,000 with China already saying the worst is behind them. Why the US would have 4M deaths?
Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by rocha on Monday March 16, 2020 @12:53AM (#22590105)
Probably means 4M assuming that no containment measures are taken.

Like someone said on twitter, “In the end, it will be impossible to know if we overreacted or did too much, but it will be QUITE apparent if we under reacted or did too little.”

Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by Data_Junkie on Monday March 16, 2020 @01:13AM (#22590209)
Right, the rich have nothing to lose, the poorer capitalists pay for the over reaction. That's why we see an over reacting, panicking society, because the rich benefit from it. It is the only reason they do anything, I hate to break it to you.
Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by rocha on Monday March 16, 2020 @01:33AM (#22590289)
If nothing is done, the least privileged will suffer the most due lack of access to health services and a financial safety net.
Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by Data_Junkie on Monday March 16, 2020 @02:27AM (#22590503)
But what is most assuredly going to happen is what benefits rich people. The rest is collateral damage or pure luck. Is what it is, nothing new under the sun.
Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by joshstrange on Monday March 16, 2020 @01:03AM (#22590165)
The number coming out of China do not seem... completely above board and have been questioned by many people. Also as other have said, China, being an authoritarian country, had the power to lock down in ways that the US simply is not ready for or willing to put up with. Already in KY we've had a man who refused to self isolate after testing positive so now we have to station someone outside his house. We have 21 cases total.
Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by llampx on Monday March 16, 2020 @07:08AM (#22591670)
We need a couple more cases like that for people to be out baying for blood and for pandemic-level laws that allow people to be jailed/isolated forcibly.
Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by pinot on Monday March 16, 2020 @12:54AM (#22590112)
China nipped this before they spent much time in the exponential phase:

http://nrg.cs.ucl.ac.uk/mjh/covid19/#g8

US is tracking highly with Italy, but 12 days behind.

Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by briandear on Monday March 16, 2020 @01:40AM (#22590320)
How is the US 12 days behind? Where does that number come from? The first Italian case was a month after the first US case.
Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by foota on Monday March 16, 2020 @03:45AM (#22590830)
Iirc the first us case was isolated, what really matters is the first community spread. The 12 days comes from lining up the curves. Our current # of cases is where Italy was 12 days ago.
Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by naiveprogrammer on Monday March 16, 2020 @10:45AM (#22593147)
Seems like cherry-picking to me.

Italy has an older population to start with. I don't think the US will remotely reach the chaos we are seeing in Italy.

Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by mdorazio on Monday March 16, 2020 @02:42AM (#22590557)
Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by cooljacob204 on Monday March 16, 2020 @09:48AM (#22592598)
Population of Italy is 60m and the US is 327m.

Land size if Italy is 116,347 mi², land size of US is 3.797 million mi²

I don't think it's fair to make any assumptions from those infection numbers when the two countries are vastly different.

Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by trent09 on Monday March 16, 2020 @03:36AM (#22590784)
Interesting, but to truly track similar to Italy wouldn't we need higher numbers being we're a much larger populous? Just curious.
Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by jobigoud on Monday March 16, 2020 @04:59AM (#22591117)
Each outbreak is regional, having the numbers normalised to the total country population doesn't really give interesting information. It is the medical system of that specific region that is at risk of saturation.
Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by llampx on Monday March 16, 2020 @07:09AM (#22591673)
The US isn't doing anywhere near as much testing as Italy.
Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by remarkEon on Monday March 16, 2020 @12:56AM (#22590122)
China shut down their entire economy for about 6 weeks. That's what we're debating here, whether we should do that in the US.
Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by iso947 on Monday March 16, 2020 @03:51AM (#22590852)
China is still locked down. It can’t unlockdown until they have a way to stop it, they’ve basically managed to reset the clock to early January.
Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by PeterisP on Monday March 16, 2020 @08:03AM (#22591955)
Wuhan is still locked down, but most of China seems somewhat "restarted" by now.
Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by alexchantavy on Monday March 16, 2020 @11:07AM (#22593344)
Yeah, most if not all of the larger cities are back to work now.
Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by nneonneo on Monday March 16, 2020 @01:00AM (#22590148)
The worst is behind China because they've instituted heavy lockdown measures beyond what would be acceptable in the US, and enacted emergency measures like constructing temporary hospitals and isolation centres. They're still under lockdown - Beijing for instance is mulling a mandatory 14-day quarantine for anyone entering the city. So far, only a handful of other countries, mostly Asian ones, have had success slowing down this virus.

Most of Europe and North America is on a steady exponential curve upwards with no sign of slowing down yet. Germany has already clearly said that they expect 70-80% of the population to be infected eventually - 60M people, of whom ~2% or 1.2M will likely die. Scale that up to the USA.

Without a vaccine, the only way this virus peters out is through eventual herd immunity, which will require a sizeable fraction of the population to catch it.

Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by ardy42 on Monday March 16, 2020 @11:18AM (#22593421)
> Current total deaths are 6,000 with China already saying the worst is behind them. Why the US would have 4M deaths?

The official Chinese death statistics are probably severely under-counting deaths, in Wuhan at least. IIRC, they only counted deaths of confirmed cases, but the medical system was so overwhelmed that many, many cases weren't getting confirmed, and people were dying at home.

Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by m0zg on Monday March 16, 2020 @01:14AM (#22590211)
I agree that "millions will die" is just pure panic. But I'd like to point out that China is most definitely _not_ out of the woods yet. And won't be until there's a cure. This merry-go-round could start again there at a moment's notice.
Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by saiya-jin on Monday March 16, 2020 @06:12AM (#22591397)
I don't get this sentiment, I mean numbers are pretty clear at this point. We have +-2% mortality rate, and that when system is not utterly overloaded and those critical patients (15-20%) are getting artificial ventilation and very personalized treatment. Without it, most if not all would die.

So real mortality, once health systems will crumble from the load (we will see in 1 week here in Europe), might be more around 10%. Not many seem to like to accept this simple fact, happy to hear where my conclusion is wrong. I mean if you have water/mucus in your lungs, that's it, very little can be done.

If we take >50% of earth population would eventually take it (which seems more realistic, since we have no vaccine, and no effective treatment and those won't work very well in many places like India or most of Africa), we're talking about 80 million - 400 million of dead (2-10% of 4 billions). I don't see how we can avoid this - we can't shutdown whole global economy for even 6 months, whole system didn't evolve with this safeguard in mind. People will have to start working again. Producing food, goods, services etc.

Now lets be skeptical and have only 10% of those horrible numbers coming true - still talking about 8-40 millions of dead.

Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by m0zg on Monday March 16, 2020 @06:41AM (#22591532)
You're confusing things. Not everyone who has the disease is diagnosed or treated in a hospital. In fact the majority of people are probably not. As the healthcare system is stressed, you will see higher "mortality" in the hospital cases because only the extremely severe patients will seek treatment and the rest will try to get by on their own. None of this is _population_ mortality. Meaning, these numbers cannot be extrapolated to the population as a whole, due to the selection bias inherent in them, and the lack of accurate infection rate estimates.
Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by saiya-jin on Monday March 16, 2020 @06:47AM (#22591571)
That would cover the sceptical 10%. But OK, lets be really sceptical and have only 1% - still 800k - 4 millions. Sounds a bit like millions to me
Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by m0zg on Monday March 16, 2020 @06:54AM (#22591602)
This ignores several things. For one thing we might get a reprieve due to seasonality. For another, better treatments will almost certainly be found in the near future. Some are undergoing trials as we speak. Then there's the issue of people who will acquire immunity and therefore cease to be transmission vectors. And then there's the most glaring issue: less than 6K people are likely to die in the _very epicenter_ of the epidemic: in China. Out of 55M people in that region. People are returning to work there now. So this can be contained, with drastic measures. And you can bet drastic measures will be taken if we even begin to approach seven figure casualty counts. Extrapolated from 55M Hubei population to 331M of US population, this would be less than 40K dead: on the order of a severe flu season, but compressed into 3 months. That's in the absence of any advanced treatments, and with a healthcare system arguably inferior to what you'd find in the West.
Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by cmendel on Monday March 16, 2020 @09:00AM (#22592273)
Sure, though that number that you have memorized for the world population is wrong. We're at approx 7.8 billion rather than 4 billion.
Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by Mountain_Skies on Monday March 16, 2020 @10:53AM (#22593223)
Perhaps an unknowable ahead of time, but if we go into recession due to shutting everything down rather than due to poor market fundamentals, the recovery from the recession could be fairly rapid by historical standards.
Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by acangiano on Monday March 16, 2020 @12:47AM (#22590061)
Also, 2% is very dubious. Italy is at 7%. The Philippines at 8%. I mean, sure these figures are out of people who were tested, but 2% is looking awfully optimistic at this point. So the potential for death reduction is even greater than the intentionally unassailable 1% figure you picked.
Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by michaelt on Monday March 16, 2020 @09:26AM (#22592439)
In terms of fatality, the Diamond Princess cruise ship [1] has the helpful property that everyone on board was tested. Nobody recovering/asymptomatic not getting tested, nobody being refused a test.

The wikipedia page lists 700 infections and 7 deaths.

Of course there are still certain biases: on one hand it happened early, when hospitals weren't overloaded; on the other, cruise ships tend to have more older people. And as I don't speak Japanese I haven't traced those numbers to primary sources.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2020_coronavirus_outbreak_on_c...

Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by djsumdog on Monday March 16, 2020 @12:11PM (#22593850)
..and they were trapped on that ship for days. Amesh Adalja (infectious disease MD at John Hopkins) has been in a few interviews where he commented, SARS-Cov2 is similar to other viruses where the initial dosage does impact the severity of the infection.
Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by altoidaltoid on Monday March 16, 2020 @11:56AM (#22593722)
Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by irq-1 on Monday March 16, 2020 @01:45PM (#22595191)
From: Situation report - 55, 15 March 2020

3.5% mortality worldwide (there are totals at the end of country listings)

Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by rocha on Monday March 16, 2020 @12:59AM (#22590141)
Note that in both cases there is a selection bias, due poor testing, and having the majority of initial reported cases being severe enough to reach hospitals. In my opinion, South Korea has better data, due to massive testing, and not having a completely overwhelmed health system. The rate there is 0.6%, which is still significant.
Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by JamesBarney on Monday March 16, 2020 @03:06AM (#22590661)
0.6%-1% is what we would be looking at when everyone gets the medical care they need. But many people are suggesting that instead of shutting down a large portion of the economy we let this thing rip through our population. And if we do that, a very small percentage of the population will get the healthcare they need. So the rate we should use when considering the "rip the bandaid" off approach should be closer to 6% than 0.6%.
Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by ardy42 on Monday March 16, 2020 @11:16AM (#22593409)
> And if we do that, a very small percentage of the population will get the healthcare they need. So the rate we should use when considering the "rip the bandaid" off approach should be closer to 6% than 0.6%.

And if you take the "rip the bandaid off" approach, you can't restrict your analysis to just CoVID-19 deaths. The strain on the medical system will mean there will be an increase in deaths from other causes that didn't get the treatment they need.

Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by easytiger on Monday March 16, 2020 @03:34AM (#22590772)
Those tested represent a tiny fraction of those likely infected.
Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by marvin on Monday March 16, 2020 @04:50AM (#22591068)
Yes. But South Korea is still at 0.6%, and they've tested everyone and their dog, and provided top care to everyone.
Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by easytiger on Monday March 16, 2020 @05:34AM (#22591245)
This is incorrect. As of the weekend gone past South Korea had tested 248,000 people out of a population of 50,000,000, with 8,086 +ve cases and 72 deaths.

<300k is not "and they've tested everyone and their dog"

There is a lot of memetic nonsense flying around about this online and this is part of it

Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by marvin on Monday March 16, 2020 @07:13AM (#22591690)
Hm, ok. That would make it in the region of 1%. Thought my numbers were out of date since I heard 0.6% somewhere else.
Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by easytiger on Monday March 16, 2020 @07:17AM (#22591715)
1% of what?
Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by marvin on Monday March 16, 2020 @07:53AM (#22591901)
8000-ish cases. 70-ish deaths => ~0.9% fatality rate. Very thorough testing, so 0.9% is likely to be a reasonable estimate of the real fatality rate.

Granted, 250k-ish of 50 million is a small sample, but you've got to assume that they haven't tested randomly but tested people who have been in touch with known cases.

Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by easytiger on Monday March 16, 2020 @08:09AM (#22591982)
You are almost there.

> but you've got to assume that they haven't tested randomly but tested people who have been in touch with known cases

Yes. Well with symptoms etc. So of the people who got tested they are much more likely to test +ve. I agree. Which means real cases are massively more widespread than those tested.

It is believed here in the UK that this has been fairly rife for a while now, but those who got it are not statistically counted anywhere. The real fatality rate is way less than 0.9

Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by marvin on Monday March 16, 2020 @02:32PM (#22595783)
I don't follow your reasoning. South Korea has tested 35 times the number of positive cases. That's a lot. Presumably, it's not a random sample, but people who have been in touch with people who have had obvious symptoms. Maybe some random sampling in outbreak areas, I don't know their methodology.

Certainly there's a number of people that are not picked up throughout that process. This means that the real death rate is not ~70/8000. The real denominator is bigger.

But it wouldn't be on the order of 10 times bigger. In most of the groups of sick people, there's likely to be some that show enough symptoms to prompt a test, with a positive test leading most of that group to be tracked down. The exception would be tiny groups that somehow did not spread the disease further, or untracably spread it to similar tiny groups.

I don't buy that there's a massive amount of such lonely cases out there. Twice as many as detected? Sure. But not a dramatically bigger number than that.

Maybe there's a way to show mathematically that this reasoning is wrong, if so, please feel free.

Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by easytiger on Monday March 16, 2020 @04:30PM (#22597319)
I'll use London for an example. I personally know many people who believe they have this, and, I believe I and 3 friends picked it up from each other after one visited Milan in Feb. Loads of people have this and are not counted.

> But it wouldn't be on the order of 10 times bigger.

I believe it is of that order.

> In most of the groups of sick people, there's likely to be some that show enough symptoms to prompt a test, with a positive test leading most of that group to be tracked down

Literally not because most people won't be tested unless they are in need of hospitalisation

Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by djsumdog on Monday March 16, 2020 @12:12PM (#22593866)
248k out of 50M is still a very impressive sample size; especially compared to most scientific papers coming out these days.
Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by easytiger on Monday March 16, 2020 @04:12PM (#22597077)
There is a persistent assertion that "everyone" in SK is being tested. It's not true. There is a pretty high chance that a high % of the infected are almost asymptomatic. Fatigue might be the only thing some get. Others nothing. The problem is people asserting without statistical extrapolation a base fatality rate predicated on a division of [+ve tests/deaths]. It is exactly what WHO have done before in other epidemic like situations and it doesn't make sense.

Previous epidemics have seen these massive similar ratios promoted only to later be revised aggressively. I can offer examples if required

Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by djsumdog on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @12:53PM (#22606968)
I am curious of those examples. The big outbreaks in the past the WHO has focused on include MERS, Ebola and H1N1. There's a really good Wendover video on the WHO Ebola response and it's pretty impressive.

That said, Ebola got people sick quickly (compared to SARS-cov2) and it started in areas that weren't as globally connected, limiting the spread.

Still, there was a lot of hype of H1N1 that never really panned out. Still this is a totally new virus, from a family of viruses that has historically never been bad (a quarter of colds are caused coronaviruses).

If it's May 1st and there are <50k dead in the US with the patient rates going down, I think people are going to start to seriously question anything the WHO says going into the future. The alternative is that by May we'll be hearing news reports of how 90% of hospital in <insert big city .. London, Brussels, Atlanta> are at capacity with people being shipped to suburbs and individual 3D printing ventilator parts.

Honestly, I will be surprised either way.

Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by easytiger on Monday March 16, 2020 @03:32AM (#22590764)
And if the mortality rates (from Italy) are fundamentally wrong/misleading?
Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by ryanobjc on Monday March 16, 2020 @12:15AM (#22589888)
Actually then CFR would probably be like 5% if medical services would be overcome.

So more like 11m excess deaths.

Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by topkai22 on Monday March 16, 2020 @12:23AM (#22589935)
I picked a lower number to get less quibbles from any doubters. But yeah, bringing CFR from 5% to 2% at 60% infection you can justify actions that otherwise seem nuts.
Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by willis936 on Monday March 16, 2020 @12:49AM (#22590080)
Honestly, the number I take issue with is the $100k. In terms of household income, this is far above the median.
Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by topkai22 on Monday March 16, 2020 @01:05AM (#22590170)
The actuarial value of a human life is difficult to calculate, but it is definitely above the economic output. There are large 2nd order effects- the pain of those left behind. I picked $100k because it made the math easy, but it's also between the $50k and $129k numbers i grabbed off Wikipedia.

Also, this is one of the rare times it does makes sense to go with mean as the measure of center.

Re:Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars by naiveprogrammer on Monday March 16, 2020 @10:40AM (#22593107)
When it is all said and done, we will find out that the mortality rate is very close to regular flu (around 0.1%). Italy, China and other countries with high mortality rate are not a great model because they were caught unprepared and their health system cannot sustain a moderate peak in hospitalizations. Also keep in mind that a large segment of the infected people go untested in most places which affects the denominator. I see many epidemiologists estimating that the number of true infected is 5 or even 10 fold of what we are seeing being reported. If that is the case, then we can assume the mortality rate certainly drops to less than 1% and most likely ranges in the 0.5% to 0.1%.