You are living in some pleasant fantasy!
Back in reality, the UK wants to infect about a cool 40M people (for the herd immunity!). Last I heard they expect 50% (20M) to get it in a 3 week interval. Meanwhile they have about 4k ICU beds, which are at close to capacity already. Assuming cocooning works so great that only 3% of people need urgent care (rather than a more likely 5-10%) and only for one week on average (again, unlikely!), that's 200k people for 4k beds for a period of 3 weeks. Surely the fatality rate for those 3% is going to be way over 60%. At which point you have close to half a million dead in those 3 weeks alone.
I'd like to see numbers for a realistic scenario where this strategy does not result in something in the millions of deaths.
I know that extreme measures were taken to stop the spread (and such actions are infeasible in the West), but they did contain it: there are very few new cases or deaths.
So no, there won't be "millions of deaths" or anything close to that, especially if older people are isolated.
> So no, there won't be "millions of deaths" or anything close to that
I showed you some simple arithmetic, based on official figures from the UK government. Can you come up with better numbers or point out an obvious flaw in my calculation?
So the argument that follows from that is, "these are the measures required to achieve fewer than 3200 deaths."
Germany and France are at 4000 cases, so even draconian lock-down of the entire country might end up with 32.000 deaths each.
When people start to say "all this panic for that..." it means that the measures taken have worked, not that they were unnecessary.
The best case scenario is that restrictions are introduced, and they work so well that people complain that they were unnecessary.
And remember folks, when it comes to exponential growth, the best time to act was yesterday.
Perhaps it could be effective enough to have multiple 2-week lockdown periods (eg. separated by 2 or 4 weeks non-locked-down periods), just to slow down the spread so health care systems can keep up?
There is so many variables at play, and no simple model could come up with "the best" solution, if there ever is one.
Look at taiwan , singapore, hong kong, macau. You can totally slow it down to a reasonable number of new cases daily such that the hospitals can handle. Just don't start like wuhan, iran, italy...
Well, they could do what every other developed country is doing: implement social distancing measures. Social distancing can't stop the spread of the virus, but it can slow the spread down.
People seem to have an impression that the case fatality rate (CFR) has some fixed value somewhere between 0.1% and 4%, and that the CFR is set in stone; but obviously there are many confounding factors, such as access to ventilators. If a sizable portion of the UK population contracts the virus all at once, the NHS will be overwhelmed and many otherwise preventable deaths will occur (see the graph near the end of this BBC article [1]). In contrast, social distancing would "flatten the curve", reducing the burden on the NHS (eg, see this interactive Washington Post article [2]).
~~~
[1] https://www.bbc.com/news/explainers-51632801
[2] https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/2020/world/corona-si...
And so begins the Great Reaping. Get rid of the old and the sick, so the nation can move on, freed of the burden of caring for an elderly population that consumes but does not produce.
Also, what are the chances nearly all of the recovered infected are in near mint condition post-recovery? If it turns out non-trivial numbers now have permanently reduced lung capacity or pregnant women produce a lot of wonky babies, what then?
We've just had years and years of austerity in the UK, imposing a huge toll on the most vulnerable in society. The government repeatedly said there was no money. Then they turn the taps on when it effects them. They clearly do not care about the bulk of people.
Put those two together and you have the ingredients for a big uproar.
when did that happen?
More like a million deaths assuming 50% UK infected and 2% death rate.
Both the 50% and the 2% are very conservative.
The numbers we're seeing from The Netherlands, Italy and France show that over half the people in the ICU are between 30 - 60 years old. I'm not convinced the 0,2 % is accurate anymore.
Lockdowns are to buy time for vaccination. That will be the optimal solution. Unfortunately, the time when the vaccination will arrive is unclear, at the earliest time expected is 6 months, but it will more likely to take more than a year. New treatment method are also being tested, like make use of blood from those who have recovered (Apparently I do not mean to drink those like vampires do). The UK government may think it will take much longer fo find effective treatment or vaccination.
Under that assumption you presumably have no choice? The question is whether that is a good assumption
The uncomfortable truth is, the British government have weighted cost and benefit, and they have decided, the death of thousands or more is not worth the cost of near-absolute lockdown of a country, It might lead to total breakdown of the economy, full-recession, and that may cost more lives anyway. These elder people are old enough anyway, and the death rate for young is just 0.2%. (which rise to 1.3% for people elder than 50, and 6% for elder than 60 according to data from China)
What does those number mean? If you and your partner's parents are elder than 60 years old, there is 25% chance, at least one of them will die. That is, very likely, you're going to hear it from your best friends that one of their parents died from COVID-19. Are you okay with that? (Under the assumption everyone will get infected anyway). And beware, these statistics are not final, and mostly from patients who received some level of medical care, although we do not yet know how many of those heavily-ill patients received intense care. Without medical care, the number could easily double, after all, it takes time to die, that's just how lung disease works.