News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by leto_ii on Saturday March 14, 2020 @04:17AM (#22573924)
> I’m stunned by the absolute absence of global dialogue for what is a global event. In Europe right now, you would never believe that there was a European Union.

This is my key takeaway. A lot of the damage is in the end self-inflicted. People seem not to be able to act cohesively at an inter-national scale, not even within a country group that is supposedly designed for that.

Whether it's pandemics, global warming or nuclear weapons this lack of cooperation shows up again and again.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by kjakm on Saturday March 14, 2020 @09:07AM (#22574998)
This is happening on the individual level too. The panic buying of items like toilet roll + pasta in places the virus hasn't even taken hold yet is a stark reminder of how utterly selfish some people can be. Sadly the people that will end up with difficulties are the less selfish people who now can't get essential items even when there is zero need for them to be scarce.

Edit: As an example: I would like one bottle of hand sanitiser. That should last quite a while (nobody needs boxes and boxes of the stuff) and it would be very useful. I cannot buy it anywhere either IRL or online. As a last resort I just checked eBay. I found a 500ml approx bottle of Purrell for £17. Insane but given it would be very useful to have I almost bought it. Then I noticed the postage price was £100. The crazy part is that this person has sold quite a few of these according to eBay. You can claim this is the free market and supply/demand etc.etc. all you want but that doesn't make it ok. It's still incredibly selfish behaviour.

Edit 2: Any explanation for the downvotes? I almost self-censored my comment on the free market as I thought it might lead to downvotes - decided to go ahead with it anyway. If you disagree with anything I've said starting a discussion is much more productive than hiding something you don't like.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by scrollaway on Saturday March 14, 2020 @09:56AM (#22575281)
> The panic buying of items like toilet roll + pasta in places the virus hasn't even taken hold yet is a stark reminder of how utterly selfish some people can be.

I disagree… "before the virus has even taken hold" is the perfect time to do long-term shopping. Avoiding crowded areas (read: THE MALL and the public transports to get to the mall) is key to reducing infection.

Yes, hand sanitizer/face mask markets are ridiculous right now, but that's to be expected. It's not people being selfish, there's clearly genuine needs for it. When there's a fuckton of needs and not enough being produced… how is it people being selfish that you can't find hand sanitizer at a decent price? All those have been bought.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by goblin89 on Saturday March 14, 2020 @11:03AM (#22575767)
If everyone buys only what they need (e.g., if it’s a small personal sanitizer bottle, keep 1 in use and 1 in inventory), demand could be spread out and crowds avoided.

The problem appears to combine habitual shopping for long term (not many have a 24/7 convenience store within 3 minutes of walking), panicked distrust in infrastructure reliability, and good old tragedy of the commons.

Some countries fare better on first two, but still have the last one (e.g., Hong Kong).

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by cortesoft on Saturday March 14, 2020 @12:44PM (#22576621)
The thing is, normally most people done have ANY hand sanitizer, let alone two, as you describe.... so when suddenly everyone wants to buy them, there isn't enough for everyone to have even two. That doesn't make the people buying them selfish.
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by sjtindell on Saturday March 14, 2020 @02:28PM (#22577430)
But that’s not what they do, try to buy two or whatever reasonable number. A few people literally fill a shopping cart with toilet paper, water bottles, and hand sanitizer, and it’s gone. The problem is one of capacity to match demand within such short time frames.
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by beatgammit on Saturday March 14, 2020 @06:35PM (#22579263)
I went to Costco and saw people buying up to the limit on random stuff, and they end up with 6 months of toilet paper, 1 year worth of pasta, etc. I wanted one box of diapers (one lasts over a month), and there were only 4-5 boxes left when there's normally 20+, even when there's a good sale. I have never seen them be out of baby wipes, but they were out when I went (which is a shame because we just ran out). In fact, they had to shut down a local Costco because people are fighting over toilet paper.

COVID-19 isn't going to be some world ending thing, it's just going to put some supply pressure in the short term until production and distribution can ramp back up, but people are treating it like it will be. It's really frustrating.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by ethbro on Friday March 20, 2020 @04:55AM (#22636092)
The base problem is that it's Prisoner's Dilemma.

If nobody hoards, everyone is fine.

If a small number of people hoard, there are stock-outs, and everyone else has no access to the thing.

Ergo, the strictly dominant individual move is to hoard ASAP. As it provides coverage against all scenarios.

Limiting quantities is the obvious equitable response to this, so it's been good seeing retailers step up and do so.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by goblin89 on Friday March 20, 2020 @08:38PM (#22643207)
I believe the implicit assumption here is distrust in reliability of supply, other people’s behavior and infrastructure in general. Some cultures are more resistant to this kind of stuff.
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by kjakm on Saturday March 14, 2020 @10:07AM (#22575352)
>> I disagree… "before the virus has even taken hold" is the perfect time to do long-term shopping. Avoiding crowded areas (read: THE MALL and the public transports to get to the mall) is key to reducing infection.

While I agree that being prepared is important people are stocking up for much longer than necessary + not considering other people. This all depends on your ethical/world view I suppose but we don't have enough of certain items yet. The options are to think of only yourself and buy as much as you can as quickly as you can (while leaving other people with no options at all) or buy what you need now so that everyone has what they need and hopefully production can increase of the in demand items so we can all stock up before (worst case scenario) production has to cease entirely for a period of time. It's interesting to see how quickly our progressive societies can become every person for their self (to an extent).

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by pbhjpbhj on Saturday March 14, 2020 @01:43PM (#22577038)
To my recollection (corrections welcome), the covid19 virus has been reported to live on hard surfaces for 8 weeks, have an incubation period of up to 4 weeks, and live 5 weeks in vitro after confirmed infection ... if you're sanitising several times a day then that's a need for quite a long stretch of sanitiser.
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by kd0amg on Saturday March 14, 2020 @04:39PM (#22578496)
Do you have sources for those figures? The ones I find are suggesting up to 2 weeks incubation (but more typically about 5 days) and surviving on some surfaces for 3 days (less for others).

https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/sars-cov-2-study-c...

https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2020/03/14/8116090...

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by pbhjpbhj on Saturday March 14, 2020 @05:01PM (#22578660)
I'll have a look at the sources I've been watching and post back.
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by hef19898 on Saturday March 14, 2020 @12:00PM (#22576232)
You might read up on the Bullwhip Effect. these demand fluctuations can have very disruptive effects on supply chains and availability of things, even if nothing else happens.

Doig the kind of shopping right now is extremely disruptive if happening at scale. Which it does. Long-term availability of all kind necessities will suffer from it, for you, for everyone. It is the opposite of reasonable right now.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullwhip_effect

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by 0xffff2 on Saturday March 14, 2020 @01:37PM (#22576992)
So... what exactly are we all supposed to do? Taking reasonable precautions is extremely disruptive. Not taking reasonable precautions is extremely disruptive (when everyone gets sick and overwhelms the medical system). It seems like pretty much any reaction is going to result in extreme disruption. Which really isn't even that surprising given the extremely disruptive nature of a global pandemic.
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by hef19898 on Saturday March 14, 2020 @02:11PM (#22577295)
First thing would be to mentally disconnect the supply of people in quarantine from the spread of the virus. Even under lockdown, quarantined people will be supplied and grocery stores open and supplied.

Then, follow the guidelines (washing hands, ....). Avoid big groups, keep a certain distance. Regarding shopping, buy normal volumes of stuff. That always works, the system is used to this. If there are things missing, buy small volumes. Spread shopping over multiple shops of multiple chains. Ideally over multiple days. This keeps peak small, reducing the risk of supply disruption.

And keep away from things medical professionals would need as well.

If push comes to shove, accept shortages of luxury stuff and certain products. But we are very far from that.

All that is a European perspective, so.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by 0xffff2 on Saturday March 14, 2020 @03:02PM (#22577751)
>Even under lockdown, quarantined people will be supplied and grocery stores open and supplied.

From an American perspective, that is not immediately clear to me.

>Avoid big groups, keep a certain distance.

...

> buy normal volumes of stuff ... Spread shopping over multiple shops of multiple chains

These two things are not compatible in my view.

>If push comes to shove, accept shortages of luxury stuff and certain products. But we are very far from that.

Maybe where you are. My grocery shopping trip this morning ended with me re-planning meals for the week in the supermarket based on what was available. A wide range of staple ingredients were completely out of stock.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by hef19898 on Saturday March 14, 2020 @03:53PM (#22578154)
As I said, no such problems over here so far.

We might see shortages for stuff coming from China, inventoires will slowely be depleted and the replenishment from China severly hampered by the situation in Europe and the US. Stuff sourced / produced on the same continent won't hit nearly as hard. As long the production doesn't break down there shouldn't be to hard impacts. And since quarantine measures only started a couple of days ago, we can rule out those impacts as causes for the shortages you saw. Leaves short term and mid term disruptions caused by, what I might call, panic shopping, which outpaced replenishment.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by coding123 on Saturday March 14, 2020 @10:07AM (#22575353)
The downvotes is for calling panic buying selfish. You can't simultaneously tell people to stay at home for long periods of time and tell them to not stock up for that.
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by hef19898 on Saturday March 14, 2020 @12:09PM (#22576331)
Google the "Bullwhip Effect" to get an idea of how disruptive this bahiour can be, for everyone. And if individual behaviour has negative impacts on others, yes it's selfish.

Supply will be kept open, quarantine or not. Italy and China are the best examples, groccery stoes and pharmacies remained open. It is much harder to do that, so, if everybody goes panic shopping before. So please, don't do that.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by kjakm on Saturday March 14, 2020 @11:30AM (#22575960)
>> You can't simultaneously tell people to stay at home for long periods of time and tell them to not stock up for that.

Nobody is telling people to stay at home for long periods of time. If you think you have the disease you need to quarantine for a couple of weeks. That doesn't require a lot of stocking up. In Italy, where they are in 'lockdown', grocery stores remain open along with other essential services. So panic buying is unnecessary, causing shortages that are unnecessary and causing problems for people who aren't panic buying.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by mlthoughts2018 on Saturday March 14, 2020 @11:51AM (#22576154)
Companies are _requiring_ people to work from home, childcare options are closing, schools are closing, businesses are cutting staff and hours, and there are public bans on large gatherings and urgings to stay home so that even if you are asymptomatic or healthy, you don’t risk accidentally contributing the spread to immunocompromised or elderly people.

If you think you only need to budget supplies for two weeks, you’re just wrong. You need to budget for _months_, and likely need to budget many supplies you otherwise wouldn’t have needed, like increased food for daily breakfasts and lunches for a whole family who otherwise would have been at school / work drawing those supplies from elsewhere.

While I agree the panic buying is harmful & we could ration and space it out with less shock to supply chains, I also think the behavior of everyday people facing the sudden prospect of a large family consuming toilet paper, 3 full meals, soap, medicine, etc., for an indefinite number of weeks ahead, it’s totally understandable and not even remotely “selfish.”

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by kjakm on Saturday March 14, 2020 @12:34PM (#22576536)
>> If you think you only need to budget supplies for two weeks, you’re just wrong. You need to budget for _months_

Can you back this up at all? As I explained in my comment, Italy, one of the worst hit countries globally (and on 'lockdown') has grocery stores still functioning. The idea that people will be required to not leave their homes for months is fear mongering , impossible to enforce, and even in the worst case scenario people simply won't do it - they'll go stir crazy and give up a lot quicker than they think.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by mlthoughts2018 on Saturday March 14, 2020 @01:12PM (#22576818)
Saying “can you back this up at all” in response to this is just glib rhetoric. There’s no published standard of evidence for this, by very definition of the type of event (panic).

When you buy a stockpile of supplies, it is for contingency, not immediate threat. You are not accounting for this.

If the probability of being home quarantined is, say, 1%-5%, that’s huge and requires stockpiling at least some supplies. The grocery stores functioning today has literally nothing to do with it. That’s not fear mongering.

In the absence of hard data on the probability of home quarantine, then what do you recommend people do? Prepare for a worst case scenario? Act like nothing will happen? Somewhere in between (but where exactly, and why?)

I’ll reiterate, your responses so far are just glib rhetoric. Unless you can provide a reason why people shouldn’t prepare for a worst case scenario (knowing it’s unlikely to get that bad, but better to have the supplies if it does), it’s extremely disingenuous of you to brandish such moralistic grandstanding judgment towards people trying to prepare for an emergency.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by nitrogen on Saturday March 14, 2020 @04:10PM (#22578254)
Ideally we would all have our own stocks of essentials that we build up gradually over time during normal circumstances. Unfortunately this is both difficult for some people, and antithetical to the modern trend of urban minimalism.
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by luckylion on Saturday March 14, 2020 @10:01AM (#22575316)
I believe that the panic buying is primarily a leadership problem. Especially in Europe, the governments have, for the past decades but even more so in the past 5 years, retreated and said "we can't do anything anyhow, so you'll just have to deal with it". People have learned and do whatever they have to to protect themselves, because the society at large is falling apart and losing cohesion. If you have no leadership, you can't expect people to behave orderly.

The US population is historically suspicious of the government and it's ability to get things done, so individuality is much more pronounced there.

Secondly, I think the government, media and experts just haven't thought their communication strategy through. They've told people "you might need to get isolated in your home for a few weeks, and remember to wash your hands a lot". What, besides stocking up on food, soap/sanitizer and toilet paper, would you expect them to do in response?

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by kjakm on Saturday March 14, 2020 @10:11AM (#22575389)
>> What, besides stocking up on food, soap/sanitizer and toilet paper, would you expect them to do in response?

I would have hoped people would keep in mind that staying home for a few weeks doesn't necessitate buying all that much more than a lot of families do in a "big shop". Take toilet paper as an example. The amount of it that's being bought by most people will last them 6-12 months. I know there's a lot of factors pushing people to make these decisions but it's certainly altered my generally optimistic/positive view of people as a whole.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by luckylion on Saturday March 14, 2020 @10:44AM (#22575638)
I've seen some pictures of people walking out with mountains of toilet paper as well, but I don't think that was the norm. It's not three guys making off with a truckload, it's a lot of people buying and extra package or two, enough for the next six weeks which will quickly deplete the aisles, since stores are operating without storage space (because storage is expensive, and stored goods are dead capital), so they have no reserves.

Also, from my personal experience, it's a distribution problem. There is enough toilet paper, but it's sold out at some stores while others have more than enough. Can't level that out though, because margins are thin and the companies would lose money.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by 0xffff2 on Saturday March 14, 2020 @01:55PM (#22577136)
It necessitates that all of those families buy twice as much this month so that they're prepared to spend a few weeks staying home starting the day before they would have gone shopping again. It also necessitates that I (a single person living alone who normally goes grocery shopping every other day or so) buy way more than I ordinarily would. Most people are not out there buying truckloads of TP. Everyone buying twice as much TP (and everything else) as usual is more than enough to create shortages.
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by DonaldFisk on Saturday March 14, 2020 @10:21AM (#22575457)
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by hordeallergy on Saturday March 14, 2020 @10:54AM (#22575702)
I agree. These people are not just selfish, they're idiots - I've seen purchases of years worth of toilet paper. My local shop had empty shelves for about a week but now has stacks on the floor as well as full shelves. The sanitiser stocks will soon arrive too - cash in on the nutters.
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by achillesheels on Saturday March 14, 2020 @12:41PM (#22576596)
Free markets do not promote ideal behavior. Morals do!
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by quattrofan on Saturday March 14, 2020 @11:00AM (#22575738)
Just soap and water far more effective due to fatty structure of viruses. Not an expert I'm sure someone else can provide more detail.
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by kjakm on Saturday March 14, 2020 @12:30PM (#22576505)
Agreed, the only reason I was after the hand sanitiser was that it would be useful the use when I get off public transport + am not going somewhere I can easily wash my hands with soap and water.
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by IanDrake on Saturday March 14, 2020 @09:47AM (#22575230)
Re: down votes. HN isn't a forum for people to disagree and discuss.

It's a hive mind where dissenters are punished via down votes for hurt feelings.

Regarding people being selfish... There is nothing selfish about self preservation. The problem is we have a negative view on "price gouging" which is just economic triage.

There wouldn't be a run on toilet paper if it cost 10x the normal price. It costs you nothing to stock up, so people do.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by kjakm on Saturday March 14, 2020 @10:16AM (#22575418)
>> Regarding people being selfish... There is nothing selfish about self preservation.

No, but purchasing much more of an item that you are ever likely going to need (at the cost of everyone who isn't doing that) is selfish. Stock up on enough essentials to get you through a self-quarantine period (2-3 weeks). Don't buy enough to last the next 12 months because a) it's completely unnecessary and b) you're preventing other people stocking up enough to cover a self-quarantine period.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by IanDrake on Saturday March 14, 2020 @04:17PM (#22578309)
And you are the arbitor of how much of something a person needs?

Two people at a grocery store, both with an entire shopping cart full of dried pasta. One has twelve mouths to feed at home, the other lives alone.

How do you police that or distinguish who is selfish?

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by bamboozled on Saturday March 14, 2020 @04:50AM (#22574031)
Not looking forward to watching these “leaders” panic once the real existential threat really gets into the final stages. The climate emergency.

This dress rehearsal hasn’t gone well.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by avip on Saturday March 14, 2020 @06:48AM (#22574405)
You are using past tense to describe an emerging event. I agree, very few nations took the required decisive actions.

We've wasted all the time China gave us.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by ekianjo on Saturday March 14, 2020 @07:06AM (#22574450)
> We've wasted all the time China gave us.

China did it to themselves in the first place. They silenced the early warnings about the epidemic, and did not acknowledge anything until it was already too late in Wuhan. It could have ended right there had they been more serious to begin with.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by llampx on Saturday March 14, 2020 @01:12PM (#22576819)
Weeks after the total shutdown in Wuhan, the President of the United States went on TV to say that it was little more than a flu. Same with the leaders in Europe. I'd say they absolutely dropped the ball.
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by makomk on Saturday March 14, 2020 @07:12AM (#22574481)
As far as I can tell, the only way to contain this would've been if every county on the planet had cut off travellers from China in January and tracked down and quarantined those already in the country - something China actively campaigned against with the support of the WHO. All of the countries that have contained this relied on that combined with contact tracing and testing once one became available, even China itself. Just testing and tracing alone hasn't worked anywhere. So it's less "wasted all the time China gave us" and more "trusted what China was saying, not what they were doing".
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by KaoruAoiShiho on Saturday March 14, 2020 @08:08AM (#22574681)
Except the country that handled it best (South Korea) didn't ban travel from China and the president even publicly declared it won't ban travel from China saying things like "If Korea bans China then other countries may ban Korea" despite mass protests.
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by makomk on Saturday March 14, 2020 @08:32AM (#22574789)
South Korea hasn't contained the virus yet. They've done a good job at squashing the big cluster in Daegu, partly due to luck (the index patient didn't meet the criteria for testing but got tested anyway), and their numbers look promising. However, Italy's numbers looked good right up until they didn't. The fear is that there are a bunch of other clusters spread throughout the country that are slowly bubbling away, too many to apply contact tracing to, and it looks like there's evidence that is becoming the case: https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2020/03/10/8128651...
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by KaoruAoiShiho on Saturday March 14, 2020 @08:54AM (#22574928)
Korea is doing really well. Here's an article from today: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-health-coronavirus-southk...

There's a huge difference between looking good with small numbers because you haven't done testing like in much of Europe or NA vs looking good because you've blanketed the country in tests and are seeing recoveries outstrip infections.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by treis on Saturday March 14, 2020 @10:32AM (#22575551)
Italy also wasn't testing. Their signal was hospitals overflowing with dying patients. So it's unlikely that SK is missing significant numbers of cases. If they were their hospitals would be overflowing.
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by stevenwoo on Saturday March 14, 2020 @01:00PM (#22576728)
A Stanford health expert was planning on traveling to Taiwan when the outbreak news first came out and published a JAMA article on a study on their approach which so far has contained the outbreak. https://healthpolicy.fsi.stanford.edu/news/how-taiwan-used-b... https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/2762689
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by corpMaverick on Saturday March 14, 2020 @04:25AM (#22573945)
Lack of leadership. That happens when the most powerful man in the world is an idiot that doesn't believe in multilateral cooperation.
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by atoav on Saturday March 14, 2020 @05:25AM (#22574148)
Living in Germany I don't really feel there is a lack of leadership. So far the politicians listened to expert advice which is precisely what I expect from them. And to oir luck the testing infrastructure in Germany is much better than in nearly every other nation (which also means the numbers are closer to reality than e.g. in Italy or the US). On top of that we have paid leave, so people who are showing symptoms can stay at home without worrying about money.

This is a very different story in the US of course — but is it really only a leadership problem? Isn't it more of a systemic issue in the sense that now the weaknesses of e.g. certain centralized testing structures, not having universal healthcare etc come to light.

Trump might be the worst president the US could have at that point in time, because he acts actively destructive on top of a system that hasn't that much ressilience anyways.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by Mirioron on Saturday March 14, 2020 @09:08AM (#22575002)
>So far the politicians listened to expert advice which is precisely what I expect from them. And to oir luck the testing infrastructure in Germany is much better than in nearly every other nation (which also means the numbers are closer to reality than e.g. in Italy or the US).

And with all of that Merkel still said that 60% to 70% of the population will end up infected with the virus. It doesn't sound like Germany's going to be much better off than most other European countries.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by bigfudge on Saturday March 14, 2020 @11:04AM (#22575771)
The point is that they won’t all hit the ICU athe same time. See flattenthecurve.com
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by tsimionescu on Saturday March 14, 2020 @11:22AM (#22575919)
Isn't Germany one of the slowest countries to respond to the epidemic? Aren't schools still open in Germany, with thousands of cases and quite a few deaths already?

In my country (Romania), our normally horribly inefficient government has closed schools the moment our 25th confirmed case was announced, it has banned events of more than 100 people, has encouraged people to work from home, and encouraged those who can't to change their work schedule so that people come in at different times to avoid mass transit overcrowding (and enforced this in public institutions). Many large shops have started limiting the number of people allowed in at once, preferring to firm queues outside. Flights to several countries have been canceled. And all of this in addition to screening travelers, putting everyone coming in from Italy/China/France/Germany/Spain in isolation for 14 days, as well as anyone who came into contact with a confirmed case, and of course tracking everyone who came into contact recently with an identified patient.

And all this is before we saw our 100th confirmed case, with 0 deaths so far. How can you say that the German response was efficient?

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by high_derivative on Saturday March 14, 2020 @07:34AM (#22574557)
>And to oir luck the testing infrastructure in Germany is much better than in nearly every other nation (which also means the numbers are closer to reality than e.g. in Italy or the US)

I am baffled as to why you would think this?

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by jsnell on Saturday March 14, 2020 @08:27AM (#22574762)
I don't know what's actually happening in Germany, but here's one reason one might think that:

You can use the number of deaths to reason about the true infection rate, independent of the testing strategy. (Until something happens that changes the death rate, like the health system getting overwhelmed.)

For example, Germany and France started seeing cases at about the same time and have found about the same number of cases. But France has 10x the deaths. This suggests that Germany has found a larger proportion of their cases, i.e. they've got better test coverage.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by mbeex on Saturday March 14, 2020 @06:44AM (#22574396)
> So far the politicians listened to expert advice which is precisely what I expect from them.

This is simply not true. The response of the Merkel administration is one of the slowest and inconsequential in whole Europe. Very probably accompanied by deliberately playing down death cases and infection numbers in general if anectotical information and comparison with the numbers of surrounding countries has any value.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by kriro on Saturday March 14, 2020 @07:33AM (#22574553)
I think they have handled it pretty well. I'm pretty sure they spent some time talking to experts. I've worked in a research project on crisis management before and have a very high opinion of the Robert Koch Institute which was one of the partners (and am generally quite critical of government organizations). Given the political infrastructure (states can make the decisions in many areas), I think the reaction was pretty good so far. One of the major concerns is always avoiding panics. I'm pretty sure they are balancing all official statements against that.

Tbh. the most important thing for me is that you listen to experts and don't overreact.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by wirrbel on Saturday March 14, 2020 @09:57AM (#22575290)
In retrospect I think three things could have been handled better. Screening for fever at airports and clearer rules for self quarantining of people after traveling. Third point is control of medical and hygienic supply chains.

Otherwise okish response I would say. Also no indication for dow playing. Maybe a bit reluctant with shut downs of Carnevale, clubs and ski vacationing

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by mbeex on Saturday March 14, 2020 @02:31PM (#22577459)
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by leto_ii on Saturday March 14, 2020 @04:49AM (#22574026)
Trump is part of the problem, for sure, but it seems to me that a world that is strongly divided into nation-states is just not able to effectively tackle pan-national threats.

Even at an individual level we're so used to thinking in terms of 'our country vs. the rest' that our ability to empathize with people from 'far-away' is impeded.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by Mirioron on Saturday March 14, 2020 @09:13AM (#22575033)
But it makes sense to think that way. The ones who know the local situation best are the locals, not bureaucrats thousands of miles away. And when it comes to empathy, then those bureaucrats tend to have little of it towards the people affected by essentially any problem that doesn't affect where they are.
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by leto_ii on Saturday March 14, 2020 @11:41AM (#22576041)
I don't get why coordination is equated by many people with centralization. You can agree on a set of measures that should be taken by everybody under certain circumstances and then let individual countries apply those measures.
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by bamboozled on Saturday March 14, 2020 @04:52AM (#22574034)
I’ve literally heard this virus be called “foreign”, like it identifies with a nationality etc.
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by sorokod on Saturday March 14, 2020 @05:09AM (#22574092)
Quote: "This is the most aggressive and comprehensive effort to confront a foreign virus in modern history"
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by buboard on Saturday March 14, 2020 @05:36AM (#22574184)
OTOH it s increased international travel that causes the acuteness of these pandemics
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by natmaka on Saturday March 14, 2020 @06:38AM (#22574376)
Any "pan-national" effort implies massive transportation of goods/specialists.

All this will let the virus thrive.

Moreover such pan-national tackling will let the apparently most adequate response be adopted, therefore if it fails too badly we may be all wiped out because it will fail everywhere.

Such a major pandemic is only possible thanks to our current population densities, massive transportation of persons/goods. Our central administrations were, as usual, patently totally unable to cope and even in some cases their very actions amplify the threat (cops in Wuhan silencing the local doc who early understood the threat, grotesque CDC actions in the US...), and are always pushing towards more densely populated huge territories for them to 'administer'.

... and further transportation of persons/goods and centralization of control should be in order?

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by TheOtherHobbes on Saturday March 14, 2020 @06:52AM (#22574410)
In developed countries, I see no reason why there would be any need for "massive transportation" of either goods or specialists at a scale that would make a significant difference to viral spread.

Even if it were necessary, mitigation measures are neither difficult nor expensive.

Perhaps we could just leave it to the markets. They've done such a good job of providing robust and affordable healthcare in the US, markets can surely handle an international viral outbreak simply by maximising efficiency and ROI.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by natmaka on Saturday March 14, 2020 @11:08PM (#22580886)
> In developed countries, I see no reason why there would be any need for "massive transportation"

Mirioron answered.

> Even if it were necessary, mitigation measures are neither difficult nor expensive

The very reason why the virus spreads like it does February is because it is difficult and expensive.

> Perhaps we could just leave it to the markets.

The current state of affairs in the US, as in most countries, is crony capitalism, which has nothing to do with 'leaving it to the markets'.

Isn't 'maximising efficiency' the very raison d'être of the 'pan-national effort' you proposed?

Isn't it also the reason why huge amounts of humans live in giant and dense cities, with strong central government powers? From an organizational standpoint those are the main causes of the present crisis: total failure at detecting it early (the Chinese doc was censored), then at devising and implementing adequate measures (the faulty CDC coronavirus test is a prominent case, there are many others), and now at managing a major crisis (in most European countries the reality is that nearly no new potential case can be tested). And just wait for such a Supa Dupa Central Mega Pan-National Gov decision, applied everywhere, which will prove to be an error...

Centralization and transport are sure ways to enforce the pandemics. We may be reckoning that high population density and centralized power not only aren't usefully efficient because the efficiency gain they induce is mainly used to produce nearly-useless (at best) products, and that they are extremely dangerous. We may, instead, appeal to moar of all this.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by Mirioron on Saturday March 14, 2020 @09:17AM (#22575056)
>In developed countries, I see no reason why there would be any need for "massive transportation" of either goods or specialists at a scale that would make a significant difference to viral spread.

Because of economies of scale and specialization? It's often cheaper for one place to produce a lot of a narrow list of goods and trade that for the goods they're lacking rather than every place making everything they use. This means that a lot of goods need to be moved around and a lot of people too.

>Even if it were necessary, mitigation measures are neither difficult nor expensive.

Like what? Shut down international travel? Test every person coming into a country for a new disease? Both of these are very expensive, especially the former.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by 101404 on Saturday March 14, 2020 @05:21AM (#22574134)
Because the US is the only country in the world and Trump the only political leader in the world?
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by robk on Saturday March 14, 2020 @05:12AM (#22574101)
Please check your trump derangement syndrome. He's not the cause of all the world problems.
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by te_chris on Saturday March 14, 2020 @10:51AM (#22575684)
The man leading the richest and most powerful country on earth is a unilateralist and a physical embodiment of the Peter Principle. He’s doing an awful job and not reaching out globally to solve a global problem. How is this derangement syndrome? If anything it seems your inability to see criticism of him beyond shallow catch phrases exhibits a form of “derangement syndrome”
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by atoav on Saturday March 14, 2020 @05:33AM (#22574168)
Although this wasn't exclusively about the US: Most issues the US now has, indeed existed before Trump became president — so much is true. Yet Trump still is the worst president you could have at that point in time. Nearly a month into the whole thing he decides it would be a good thing to call the virus a hoax, disregard expert advice and ultimately acts (as he usually does) purely on symbolical plane by blaming it on foreigners and closing the border. Closing the dissease control unit Obama built in the white house is only the cherry on top. Nothing to adress the issue of not beeing able to test people, there is no real oversight what is going on in the US.

And quite frankly: if your leader's decisions are worse than throwing a dice, why even bother having him? Because it is more entertaining?

In times of a pandemic you want to have something in leadership who does the unpopular thing, that ultimately stops the spread and saves the lives. Not someone who only thinks about themselves and changes their stance on the topic with every turn of the wind. But feel free to argue otherwise, if you know how the poststructuralist ways of trumpian confusion somehow help in times of a pandemic.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by sojournerc on Saturday March 14, 2020 @09:08AM (#22575006)
We have leadership in the state governments. Colorado and even health officials in my county are taking this seriously, have closed schools, all big events canceled etc.

Often I feel that Europeans forget wet have state governments that have more local authority than the federal Gov.

Trump isn't some dictator. I'm perfectly happy with how my state officials are dealing with this virus.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by tres on Saturday March 14, 2020 @12:16PM (#22576395)
The U.S. federal government had a significant amount of control and formerly had the sole resources to deal with issues like this. Ironic that the sole raison d'être one of those resources was in mitigating and coordinating responses to events just like the one we find ourselves in.

Destroying that resource is squarely on turmp.

We've been watching the tearing down of the federal government since the Reagan years. We've witnessed the slow evisceration of everything outside of the department of defense.

The federal government could have and should have led a coordinated response to this. But now that the conservative dream of having a federal government big enough that it could be drowned in a bathtub is in reach, it's nearly impossible to.

This is the consequence of forty years of coordinated effort to hollow out the federal government from within.

States have very limited resources at their disposal. There's simply no way that they can coordinate the kind of response needed for an epidemic that knows no borders.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by roenxi on Saturday March 14, 2020 @06:37AM (#22574374)
He didn't call the virus a hoax ( https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/trump-coronavirus-rally-re... ) and he's happy to have people on his task force who will publicly contradict him so he isn't flooding the response with compliant yes men ( https://edition.cnn.com/2020/03/02/politics/donald-trump-cor... ).

The US is probably doing terribly because of the CDCs absolute fumble of the test kit debacle; but assessing Trump's response as good or bad will take a lot of time. His border closures, believe what you will, were totally in character and probably good ideas for this specific crisis.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by throwaway_pdp09 on Saturday March 14, 2020 @07:45AM (#22574600)
From the link you gave,

"During a Feb. 28, 2020, campaign rally in South Carolina, President Donald Trump likened the Democrats' criticism of his administration's response to the new coronavirus outbreak to their efforts to impeach him, saying "this is their new hoax." "

So while he didn't exactly, it doesn't show a person who cares for reality. Snopes says "mixture" on it's veracity.

> he's happy to have people on his task force who will publicly contradict him

You mean he doesn't care enough to put out the right information in the first place, and relies on being 'cleaned up afterwards' by his staff (who he keeps sacking)? He's made a mess of this primarily. The buck stops with him. The CDC does seemed to have fouled up badly but that doesn't exempt Trump's bizarre and dangerous response to a real crisis.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by roenxi on Saturday March 14, 2020 @08:17AM (#22574716)
The Snopes article is perfectly clear; the answer to the question "Did Trump call the coronavirus a hoax?" is no and atoav was precisely wrong on that point. There is a Hoax hoax afoot here.

Trump banned travel from China in early February, and the hoax comment is late February. It is pretty obvious from his actions that he takes Coronavirus much more seriously than the flu whatever his public message.

> He's made a mess of this primarily. The buck stops with him.

Yeah, but we don't know how this plays out. There are a bunch of drugs against Coronavirus starting to complete clinical trials, so this may actually get nipped in the bud as far as the US is concerned. It is a real test of the Trump administration though, no argument there.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by cglace on Saturday March 14, 2020 @08:38AM (#22574823)
You seriously think a new drug will be ready to treat this within a few months?
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by roenxi on Saturday March 14, 2020 @09:45AM (#22575220)
Depends what standard you hold 'ready' to. There are a bunch of things that by rights should help treat COVID-19, the clinical trials are due to start finishing in late March through to May and - depending on the drug - production might be fast or slow.

I've read patchy reports (eg, https://www.hngn.com/articles/228138/20200223/coronavirus-cu...) that the Chinese have started marking out specific drugs as effective for treatment. And of course Remdesivir is getting positive sounding press although I havn't seen any actual data.

It isn't really a question of whether we have something that works against COVID-19 because we surely do. The tricky part is figuring out what so it can be systematically delivered, and working out manufacturing. With a bit of luck (eg, chloroquine working out) the risk profile of the pandemic looks very different.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by thu2111 on Saturday March 14, 2020 @09:11AM (#22575021)
It could be. I did my own research on that a couple of weeks ago. If you look at the latencies involved with developing antibodies they're not that high, especially if you get lucky and are willing to throw money around. Humanity is right at the start of the whole protein design revolution - I don't think our regulatory infrastructure is set up for it yet. But where there's a will ...
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by sonotathrowaway on Saturday March 14, 2020 @09:58AM (#22575300)
Trump deliberately sabotaged efforts to protect the American public at almost every step along the way. He fired the team tracking pandemics and tried to gut their budget, and when the virus broke out he stopped the implementation of large scale testing in order to reduce the numbers of people who tested positive, and forbade use of the UN tests. This past week his CDC has completed 77 tests, as compared to Obama, who had completed one million tests in the month after H1N1. He’s also classified information regarding the disease in order to hamper the spread of vital information, and has actively lied and shifted blame regarding the availability of testing, the timeline to a vaccine, and even the efforts of private companies. Acknowledging that he is the single worst person to lead America through the crisis isn’t partisan, it’s objectively considering reality.
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by passer_byer on Saturday March 14, 2020 @10:30AM (#22575537)
This administration's handling of this pandemic is absolutely atrocious as you point out, perhaps that is where we have a silver lining. Coming close to a US presidential election perhaps Americans will consider their penny-wise, pound foolish healthcare policies.

The fact that the richest nation on earth permits about 10% of its population no access to decent healthcare is morally repugnant. But even if one is not persuaded by the moral argument, perhaps the economic impacts can change views.

With no national sick leave policy, potentially infected uninsured citizens will have the incentive to go to work, raising the risk for all. Children of uninsured whose parents are unable to take sick or medical care leave may be shunted to older care givers who are most at risk. Uninsured families are acting rationally for their own economic circumstances, but creating a larger risk profile for all.

Let's hope Americans are sobered by this experience and consider a more sensible healthcare policy.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by mistermann on Saturday March 14, 2020 @10:21AM (#22575453)
Do you believe most of the issues at the CDC are due to Trump? The development of their own kit, refusal to allow independent testing, a lack of any stockpiles (is this their job? Well, whoever), etc. Did someone from the administration throw out all the stockpiled masks in medical institutions across the country for example?

Also, we have similar issues with testing and shortages of obviously critical supplies here in Canada, as do many other countries. Can one man do that much damage?

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by sonotathrowaway on Saturday March 14, 2020 @10:52AM (#22575690)
I don’t really care to debate strawman arguments- I never blamed him for lack of masks, so we can summarily move past that. Acknowledging that he is the cause of many actual issues is not fantasy. In reality, the United States has the worst testing capacity and infrastructure of any developed nation - this fact has to be specifically trumps fault. Obama was not caught unprepared during H1N1, and it’s impossible to imagine that the CDC is the most powerless among every major nation to secure critical supplies.

Yes, I believe most of the issues at cdc are due to trump - so far he has fired the experts who can best work with the CDC to implement policies needed, and has censored and classified their attempts to spread critical information. He rolled back Obama’s executive directives regarding pandemic response simply to spite democrats, and now is rushing to reimplement those same directives, with much less effectiveness. It’s literally a government agency under his sole control - by definition the failures of the cdc are his failures. That’s how accountability works.

I know that he specifically said that it’s not his fault and that he doesn’t stand for anything, regardless it’s still his fault. This crisis is the most current proof that he is utterly incapable of being an effective leader.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by mistermann on Thursday March 19, 2020 @12:39AM (#22624532)
Houston, we have a problem:

https://www.washingtonpost.com/investigations/face-masks-in-...

Does skeleton in closet beat imaginary strawman?

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by mistermann on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @11:19PM (#22613288)
> I don’t really care to debate strawman arguments

Straight to rhetoric. One can characterise this as a strawman argument I suppose, but is it true?

I asked very specific questions, that can be answered. If you accuse me of framing, well...guilty as charged. In fact, I'm the one bringing this up.

> I never blamed him for lack of masks, so we can summarily move past that.

I never said you did, so we can summarily move past any insuation that I in any way made that assertion.

Please, argue against my words, not a distortion of them. And especially not while accusing me of using a strawman argument.

> Acknowledging that he is the cause of many actual issues is not fantasy.

I am not disputing that. Again, please argue against my words.

> In reality, the United States has the worst testing capacity and infrastructure of any developed nation - this fact has to be specifically trumps fault.

For you to know that is true would require some specific evidence, much of it quantitative. I've seen absolutely nothing even remotely resembling this, have you? Please note: the current lack of this data in no way proves anything one way or the other, and me asking such questions in no way requires that I believe it is false, or am making a suggestion - had I not written this disclaimer, that would have been a common rhetorical escape route. It is now closed.

> Obama was not caught unprepared during H1N1

Can you define "not caught unprepared" in more explicit detail? Specifically, can you provide a reference to inventory levels of critical care supplies over the last 20 years?

I have seen no such data, therefore I will continue to classify this as ~"Inconclusive - significant non-evidence based news that is highly narrative-based; numerous stories across independent media outlets all point back to the same 2 or 3 "fundamental" media stories (also narrative based). Biased reporting highly likely, even though their hearts are probably in the right place."

And again, none of this is to say I'm suggesting Trump has handled this well. He's handled it atrociously. I have zero doubt Obama would have handled it way better. But I suspect what really has gone on, is no one was prepared, not really. Beyond doing the standard "fund this 2500th "obviously a good idea" bill", I doubt anyone did too terribly good of a job.

If they did, but then this finely tuned, incredibly robust system fell apart in the span of 3 years under one rogue leader, with hardly anyone noticing....may it not be fruitful to investigate and discuss the actual events that occurred here? Is looking at reality, to the best of our ability to discern it, a bad idea?

I would support a full investigation into this. I welcome the full exposure of Trump's sins with open arms. Do you feel similarly unattached about Obama, or other parts of "the system" as it is? Are you willing at all times to reconsider everything you hold to be true?

And as for investigations, I think random members of the public need to start being on these investigations, like a variation of jury duty. I can pick out obviously misleading stories in the media as easily as finding cigarette butts on the ground. There is ample evidence that many fishy things are going on (think: reefer madness, racism, sexism, war propaganda & rationing), and the public's trust of media, government, and experts is unsurprisingly low as a result.

It doesn't have to be this way.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by mter on Saturday March 14, 2020 @11:46AM (#22576084)
> Obama was not caught unprepared during H1N1

Did the US actually do widespread testing for H1N1? Or do anything at all?

My memory of the H1N1 outbreaks are that it was downplayed heavily in the media, and doing nothing was our response. It's pretty easy to do nothing. The way I remember it is that Asia did all of the heavy lifting by quarantining anyone with a fever.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by sonotathrowaway on Saturday March 14, 2020 @12:57PM (#22576710)
Obama tested 1 million Americans the month after h1n1 broke out in America. Your memory seems to be quite selective.
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by mter on Saturday March 14, 2020 @01:18PM (#22576855)
> Obama tested 1 million Americans the month after h1n1 broke out in America.

Where is this number from? You aren't the only person that I've seen use it.

https://www.cdc.gov/flu/pandemic-resources/2009-pandemic-tim...

I see 1 million estimated in June 25, then by september we had done 1,000 test kits (which I assume have many samples).

> Your memory seems to be quite selective.

It was 11 years ago. Most of us don't remember what actually happened.

Edit to add: The biggest original difference in testing seems to be that the existing influenza tests worked for H1N1, then were easily modified for H1N1, while producing the corona virus test and running it appears to take far more time + we have shortages in sourcing chemicals because everyone is trying to get those chemicals atm. That 1 million number may be correct since existing tests that everyone can perform may have worked. That doesn't seem to have anything to do with who the president at the time was, or their actions though. I don't see any regulations being lifted/waived to make that happen. Do you remember that being a big deal at the time?

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by tjpnz on Saturday March 14, 2020 @07:48AM (#22574614)
Trump didn't create this but all signs indicate that he and his merry band of luddites will continue to exasperate the situation.

Where's the international cooperation? As the article mentions Bush and Obama were regularly on the phone with world leaders to coordinate their responses to the Avian Flu and Ebola outbreaks. This administration has done none of that and has effectively taken it's hand off the wheel.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by Mountain_Skies on Saturday March 14, 2020 @08:34AM (#22574803)
Believing that all international communication must be routed through the United States government is a very U.S. centric way of looking at things. Other nations are free to cooperate with each other without first checking in with the U.S. president for his blessing.
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by Goronmon on Saturday March 14, 2020 @12:30PM (#22576502)
Believing that the US somehow isn't a part of the international community is definitely a strange take that I haven't heard before. I don't really see the advantage to the US taking action completely separate from the rest of the world.
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by bobwaycott on Saturday March 14, 2020 @08:34AM (#22574800)
I think you mean exacerbate. :)
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by tjpnz on Saturday March 14, 2020 @09:49AM (#22575240)
Thank you.
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by throwanem on Saturday March 14, 2020 @10:03AM (#22575325)
Being fair, "exasperate" (= "make hopeless") works too...
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by ekianjo on Saturday March 14, 2020 @07:08AM (#22574461)
> Lack of leadership

Really? The US was the first country to stop flights from China, as far as I recall. Were there other leaders anywhere who did the same?

https://www.nytimes.com/2020/01/31/business/china-travel-cor...

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by dannyr on Saturday March 14, 2020 @07:40AM (#22574580)
No US airports until a few days ago screened arriving passengers. They were not asked if they came from regions with large outbreaks.

After a month from 1st infection, less than 2000 tests was conducted in the US. Right now, it's 12,000+ tests which is the lowest tests per million in the world.

Schools, theaters, theme parks are closed. Sports events are suspended.

What other evidence do you need that there is lack of leadership?

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by tsbinz on Saturday March 14, 2020 @07:34AM (#22574563)
Italy stopped flights from china before the US, it didn't work so well for them. https://www.forbes.com/sites/davekeating/2020/03/12/italy-ba...
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by tomp on Saturday March 14, 2020 @11:45AM (#22576075)
US has much better control of its borders than Italy (being part of Schengen zone).
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by petre on Saturday March 14, 2020 @09:03AM (#22574982)
They've got it via Germany apparently. The decision to suspend all flights from China should have been taken earlier at EU level. Either that or we go back to border controls, which is what has actually happened at least in countries that still have operational checkpoints.

https://www.reuters.com/article/us-health-coronavirus-italy-...

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by FlorianRappl on Saturday March 14, 2020 @08:43AM (#22574859)
My key takeaway, too. I am not worried we will pass NCov19 - we surely will. I am afraid we won't learn anything from it.

We surely need to invest more into health policies and reaction to pandemics. We need to be more conservative about spending resources. We should communicate and coordinate better.

Right now I feel like a lot of actions just prevent the spread (good), but not so many measures for the long-term play are being instantiated. Let's hope I am wrong.

Personally, I think the current situation could be the beginning of a new and better era. It could strengthen remote work, less travel, less global dependencies, digitalization, local economies, and the environment. The next virus could be a lot more harmful ...

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by AlexandrB on Saturday March 14, 2020 @11:47AM (#22576106)
Let me put your mind at ease: we will learn nothing.

I’m sure epidemiologists and other scientists will learn a lot about the spread of pandemics and coronavirus. As a society though...

For an institution to learn there have to be consequences for failure. The US is so hyper-polarized that these won’t materialize for anyone involved. You can already see the circling of wagons and history being re-written in real time (on this site even). Investment in healthcare (including pandemics) will continue to follow party lines.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by throw_m239339 on Saturday March 14, 2020 @07:21AM (#22574506)
> Whether it's pandemics, global warming or nuclear weapons this lack of cooperation shows up again and again.

Because it's everybody for themselves. What do you want, a world government? Of course there is no coordinated answer.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by phs318u on Saturday March 14, 2020 @07:31AM (#22574545)
> What do you want, a world government?

Well, if it were reasonably run, why not? Imagine a world where the trillions going into the military were spent in other ways? Where people weren’t arbitraged across artificial boundaries? Would that be so horrible? So much more terrible than what we have now?

Of course, it will never happen. See earlier poster’s point about people not being able to cooperate.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by miscPerson on Saturday March 14, 2020 @08:20AM (#22574725)
> Where people weren’t arbitraged across artificial boundaries?

The boundaries aren’t arbitrary; they reflect ethnic differences between groups.

Homogenizing people is an abhorrent suggestion — and without that, large governments don’t really work.

> Well, if it were reasonably run, why not?

This is extremely unlikely, because history has shown us that remote, centralized governments are generally both arbitrary towards citizens and ineffective at addressing regional needs.

Big, centralized government has killed 100M people in the past century.

> Imagine a world where the trillions going into the military were spent in other ways?

There’s basically zero chance that would happen, as a central world government would need a lot of force to keep regions following their edicts.

That you even suggest it shows that this isn’t a serious proposal.

> Would that be so horrible? So much more terrible than what we have now?

Yes, absolutely.

You seem to have a fantasy, not a serious view of how that would operate or the consequences to human well-being based on historic precedent.

It’s not that people don’t cooperate, it’s that what you’re proposing is dangerous and harmful, so people cooperate to oppose it.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by nico_h on Saturday March 14, 2020 @01:49PM (#22577086)
> The boundaries aren’t arbitrary; they reflect ethnic differences between groups.

no they don’t. they’re the result of a lot of wars and invasions. just look at a map of the middle east or Africa. or of china for example. low correlation between border and ethnies.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by leto_ii on Saturday March 14, 2020 @12:29PM (#22576498)
> The boundaries aren’t arbitrary; they reflect ethnic differences between groups.

> Homogenizing people is an abhorrent suggestion

Ok, just for the sake of throwing gasoline onto the fire, why do you think that boundaries are a natural thing, and why do you find the mixing of ethnic groups abhorrent?

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by miscPerson on Saturday March 14, 2020 @12:44PM (#22576617)
Boundaries are an expression of each tribe exerting an area of influence. A boundary forms where two areas of tribal dominance collide. You can watch animals pee and poop on things to mark theirs, among other signals.

I didn’t say boundaries should be completely non-porous (as your comment implies), but rather that we don’t want to eliminate human ethnic/cultural diversity and that requires boundaries which enforce rate limited exchange. To borrow an analogy, there’s a reason cells have membranes.

Intermingling at a rate which allows each tribe to maintain its integrity is natural, and has evidence going back longer than writing. As does outbreaks of violence at exceeding that rate.

For example, Brexit was an act of political violence because the UK immigration exceeded the rate at which the society could naturalize immigrants leading to horrific events like “grooming gangs” of immigrants raping native children. Typically at the point gangs of migrants are raping natives, we drop the word “immigration” and talk about “invasion” or “colonization”.

Similarly, other lurches towards nationalism in Europe and the US.

Homogenizing everyone into a single global culture, which would be required to have a single government without boundaries that rate limit migration, would be verging on genocide.

Your comment assumes a very negative interpretation of what I said.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by leto_ii on Saturday March 14, 2020 @01:40PM (#22577013)
> leading to horrific events like “grooming gangs” of immigrants raping native children. Typically at the point gangs of migrants are raping natives, we drop the word “immigration” and talk about “invasion” or “colonization”.

I didn't notice this sentence before. Did you edit your comment to add in this part? If so you should mention it.

In any case, given the tone of this particular statement as well as that of your previous comments I really don't think we can have a productive conversation, so I'm gonna stop replying.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by miscPerson on Sunday March 15, 2020 @11:28PM (#22589547)
How would you describe it if gangs of people from the UK went to Pakistan and raped children there?

Would it be by the term “immigration”?

I’m genuinely curious.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by leto_ii on Saturday March 14, 2020 @01:13PM (#22576825)
> Your comment assumes a very negative interpretation of what I said.

Not sure that it does :D

I'll address your points one by one:

> Boundaries are an expression of each tribe exerting an area of influence.

Modern boundaries, like modern nation-states, don't really work like tribes did. Prehistoric tribes tended to move around, didn't build fences or patrol them with armed guards and usually had a relatively vague concept of ownership.

In many places around the world boundaries were drawn by colonial powers according to their own interests and not by natives themselves. For that reason borders very often actually split cultures and lead to ethnic tensions (e.g. in the Middle East).

> we don’t want to eliminate human ethnic/cultural diversity ...

Fully agree.

> ... and that requires boundaries which enforce rate limited exchange

I really don't understand why you think this is the case. It seems to me you're operating with a mechanistic/thermodynamic model about how cultures work. It's simply not true that you need borders to allow diversity to survive.

Take for example the concept of linguistic continuum: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dialect_continuum. This actually ante-dates modern borders and shows how you can have cultural diversity and cultural mixture at the same time.

> Intermingling at a natural rate which allows each tribe to maintain its integrity is natural, and has evidence going back longer than writing.

Again, tribes and cultures used to mix all the time and modern states are not like tribes (or ancient kingdoms or empires for that matter).

> Brexit was an act of political violence because the UK immigration exceeded the rate at which the society could naturalize immigrants.

While I agree that Brexit was caused by a perceived flood of immigrants, the act of violence is mostly self-harm. The public's belief that immigration is excessive and harmful was encouraged by certain political and economic interests and is not an objective fact.

> Homogenizing everyone into a single global culture, which would be required to have a single government without boundaries that rate limit migration

I wasn't arguing for a global government to begin with. However, again, I don't see why you think administrative unity requires cultural uniformity. We can, and do, have institutions that oversee multiple diverse cultures, both across nation-states (e.g. UN, EU, NATO etc.) as well as inside them (many countries are federations that oversee ethnically diverse populations).

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by throw_m239339 on Saturday March 14, 2020 @07:36AM (#22574566)
> Well, if it were reasonably run, why not? Imagine a world where the trillions going into the military were spent in other ways? Where people weren’t arbitraged across artificial boundaries? Would that be so horrible? So much more terrible than what we have now?

These trillions would be spent oppressing you for a change. A "world government" cannot be anything but a complete bloody dictatorship.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by Retric on Saturday March 14, 2020 @08:01AM (#22574662)
Rejecting the premise does not invalidate the argument. It’s at least possible for a world government to be reasonably run.
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by thu2111 on Saturday March 14, 2020 @09:13AM (#22575035)
Where's the evidence? This thread is decrying the response of one of the world's largest governments. Good thing the rest of the world doesn't depend on the US CDC or we'd all have a big problem.

One world government doesn't look like some utopian committee of experts making perfect decisions each time. It looks like Trump and Xi but multiplied by a million.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by Retric on Saturday March 14, 2020 @09:41AM (#22575206)
I am not saying it would generally be a good idea. Obviously it could be a terrible thing. However, considering the best possible option out of all possible futures as a theoretical exercise it would look like something else.
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by neuro_image3 on Saturday March 14, 2020 @08:00AM (#22574660)
The libertarian propaganda runs deep in the west.
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by Mirioron on Saturday March 14, 2020 @09:23AM (#22575095)
Yeah, you wouldn't spend that on the military. It would be spent on "the world police" that require rifles, APCs, tanks, jet fighters, and carriers to "enforce the law". The larger you make your administration the greater the chance of corruption and the less individual people matter to the leaders.
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by int_19h on Saturday March 14, 2020 @06:27PM (#22579209)
How would you make a government of 8 billion people reasonably run? I mean the mechanics of it - if your definition of "reasonably run" includes being democratic, and the arrangement is the usual representative democracy, it's not going to be very representative in practice, because a single person can't meaningfully represent millions.
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by leto_ii on Saturday March 14, 2020 @08:16AM (#22574708)
> Because it's everybody for themselves.

That definitely shouldn't be the case. Epidemics/pandemics are a situation of "we either make it together or we don't make it at all".

In a sense you're merely arguing for a collapse of civilization.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by AndrewKemendo on Saturday March 14, 2020 @01:00PM (#22576733)
This shouldn't be a surprise really, the human brain does not have the capability to coherently reason and act consistently over long time and distance horizons.

We're just not designed to be able to take third and fourth order effects into consideration in our day to day decisions at scale.

Just look at the current pandemic and this toilet paper stuff. We smoke, we drink alcohol, we don't count externalities in our consumption etc... The best thing we can do is build systems that nudge us to making better decisions in the longer term.

Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by chongli on Saturday March 14, 2020 @10:53AM (#22575697)
All problems of this scale are coordination problems. Inability to coordinate effectively on a large scale is the fundamental problem of humanity. If we could coordinate then there’d be no poverty, war, or famine. Disease outbreaks like this one would be slowed dramatically as well.
Re:A Man Who Saw the Pandemic Coming by dustingetz on Saturday March 14, 2020 @09:42AM (#22575208)
Tragedy of the Commons

Prisoners Dilemma

Game of Chicken

However lack of cooperation has been solved in the past. We are not killing each other anymore (a backstab/backstab outcome of prisoner's dilemma). We coordinated cooperation here for shared values. It's time for better values. A good, simple set of values that everyone recognizes could spread very quickly in today's era of global light-speed communication networks.