In some countries ISP's have moved from data caps to 'unlimited' offers over a decade ago. 'Unlimited' always comes with an asterix, where you will find the 'good house-father' clause, meaning that they can decide to throttle your connection based on some vaguely or unspecified condition completely under their discretion.
In practice network usage is unsurprisingly following a Pareto distribution. Every ISP wants to get the top 10% of bandwidth users off their network and dump them onto their competitors. So they use the 'good house-father' clause to try to do just that.
At least with data caps you had a clear and verifiable criterium. The 'unlimited' plans just give the ISP carte-blanche in actively selecting and culling their users.
If ISPs are suffering congestion, that's because they did a bad job designing their network for the amount of demand they have. Throttling is just a way for them to cheap out on their network, but sell "gigabit" internet to everybody. If they can't serve me 1 gigabit, they are selling shitty service.
If they want to charge for X amount of bits per month, that should be the up front pricing scheme. I should not be paying for a "1 gigabit" plan, but have the amount of bits that I can use be buried in the fine print. Especially when bits per month is the REAL indicator of what they are selling.
www.t-mobile.com/support/plans-features/data-passes
Some network architectures involve fragmenting and reassembling packets, and there it can become nearly impossible to implement 'priority' correctly.
"We limit you to 10Mbps at just one bottleneck location if you use more than 50 gigs" is far far easier to implement, not to mention easier for the business managers, and customers, to understand.
Interestingly, my ISP gave me a breakdown of my data usage, and I was under a meager 30gb/mo ever since my contact started. That surprised me as I watch a fair bit of YouTube etc, however, I guess it just doesn't add up to all that much.
My hypothesis (could be wrong, very anecdotal, no evidence):
1. YouTube does some pretty heavy compression to begin with (as several popular YouTubers have complained over the years) 2. YouTube in its default settings switches to the lower resolution when it detects you are not actively watching the video
I think this one two punch means that you sip on data even when you think you use YouTube a lot.
How? By its very nature, watching video is passive. Unless they watch you through the camera.
It actually infuriates me when YouTube auto-lowers the resolution (usually because I have slow Internet). I almost always set it to 720p or 1080p, but I have to do it every time because it doesn't remember my setting.
I hope the trend worldwide would be Speed based Price Plan with Fair Use policy and throttling. I hate the idea of Data Caps, especially when Apple is sending hundreds of MB of Data every month for whatever reason. ( Calander, Syncing etc.. )
Do you know how many 'broadband' customers you can get out of a 1000/1000 strand of fiber? Way more than you'd guess. And at our monopoly rates, you could pay off everything you needed to serve it to them in less time than Comcast's and AT&T's CEOs will spend caring about actually providing service that meets the definition of broadband.
Yes I do know a bit about GPON, but my comment was referring to wireless. Where Data Cap is common, I see no reason why wired internet on fibre should have Data Cap, when terabytes is referred to was not that much at all.
My school did this when I was an undergrad. The top 100 users on campus often used more than half the bandwidth. That was fine and the school was more than happy for them to use the internet heavily - the connection had already been paid for, might as well have it used. However, the school did put them at a lower priority when there was congestion. Most of the heavy users didn't even notice.
I'm really hopeful that wireless technologies will improve competition over the next decade. If three wireless companies can provide home broadband competition in the future, we won't be beholden to the single provider that most of us deal with now. AT&T, Verizon, and T-Mobile all bought a bunch of millimeter wave spectrum in the latest auction (in addition to their current holdings). T-Mobile is gearing up for a big home broadband push. They're hoping to have 9.5M home broadband customers in the next three years which would probably make them the third largest after Comcast and Charter who have around 26-27M I believe (and around double Fios' customer base). Having even a little competition would mean that they'd have to compete for my business rather than being able to hike prices every year.