Re:Coronavirus could force ISPs to abandon data caps forever
by lonelappde on Friday March 13, 2020 @05:14PM
(#22570939)
What's wrong with charging more for people who use more?
Re:Coronavirus could force ISPs to abandon data caps forever
by olyjohn on Friday March 13, 2020 @05:59PM
(#22571240)
When I pay for bandwidth to my house, I should get that bandwidth, and be able to use it for whatever I want. I don't care if they oversold their network. It's not my problem. I should not get punished for using the bandwidth I paid for. If people who barely use the internet are paying the same as me, that's not my problem either.
If ISPs are suffering congestion, that's because they did a bad job designing their network for the amount of demand they have. Throttling is just a way for them to cheap out on their network, but sell "gigabit" internet to everybody. If they can't serve me 1 gigabit, they are selling shitty service.
If they want to charge for X amount of bits per month, that should be the up front pricing scheme. I should not be paying for a "1 gigabit" plan, but have the amount of bits that I can use be buried in the fine print. Especially when bits per month is the REAL indicator of what they are selling.
Re:Coronavirus could force ISPs to abandon data caps forever
by PeterStuer on Friday March 13, 2020 @05:26PM
(#22571008)
That is not the point. Consumption based charging would be fine and which is exactly what we had before. These 'unlimited' plans are not that. These are a free pass to ditch your more 'undesirable' customers onto your competition. Yes, that can be because they use more, but also because they use less of your 'value-added' high margin services, because they use 'non-mainstream' data (less edge-cached), less data for which you receive kickbacks, consume not more but at peak times, or simply because you do not like them for whatever.
In some countries ISP's have moved from data caps to 'unlimited' offers over a decade ago. 'Unlimited' always comes with an asterix, where you will find the 'good house-father' clause, meaning that they can decide to throttle your connection based on some vaguely or unspecified condition completely under their discretion.
In practice network usage is unsurprisingly following a Pareto distribution. Every ISP wants to get the top 10% of bandwidth users off their network and dump them onto their competitors. So they use the 'good house-father' clause to try to do just that.
At least with data caps you had a clear and verifiable criterium. The 'unlimited' plans just give the ISP carte-blanche in actively selecting and culling their users.