News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by asickness231 on Thursday March 12, 2020 @02:27PM (#22560023)
"inject 1.5t" by that do they mean a 1.5t panic bailout for wall street? how can we find 1.5t in the budget but no money for universal healthcare, student loan forgiveness, ubi etc.

The markets wouldn't be so important if there were a safety net.

</soapbox>

Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by ipnon on Thursday March 12, 2020 @02:36PM (#22560144)
The Fed isn't printing 1.5 trillion greenbacks and handing out fat sacks on Wall St. They are providing short-term loans to increase the amount of money in circulation (liquidity). The intent is to increase the total amount of trading occurring so that the market can return to equilibrium sooner than later. The Fed wants to prevent firms from not making trades solely for lack of liquidity in the market.

edit: "from making profitable trades" -> "from not making trades"

Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by JumpCrisscross on Thursday March 12, 2020 @03:07PM (#22560536)
> They are providing short-term loans

They're also buying assets, e.g. Treasuries. This is about increasing liquidity, not printing money.

Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by krtong on Thursday March 12, 2020 @03:10PM (#22560572)
It's the closest to printing money as the real world gets. "Hey here's an insane amount of money at 0% interest rate so you could literally invest in ANYTHING and make free money. Go ham."

Lets remember what causes slowdowns in productivity, panics, the great depression, the recession etc: people being slammed with too high interest rates for what's feasible for them to repay when times are tough. If the fed offered low interest rates directly it would be a different world. Remember also, the world is an auction house, so when people get these kinds of perks and you don't, your money doesnt go as far.

Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by sytelus on Thursday March 12, 2020 @05:09PM (#22561765)
There is huge amount of cash sloshing around as it is. Folks like Mark Cuban have already been mostly cash. Big tech have $100B cash lying around. I think it would be disgenuous to say there is no cash available for trading but perhaps right thing to say that I rather not trad with my own cash. I presume if you trad with fed money and go on loss over long term then you can simply declare bankrupcy of your shell company and start a new one.
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by Waterluvian on Thursday March 12, 2020 @08:52PM (#22563677)
Literally printing money and pushing up inflation would effectively claw back these dollars, yeah? So long as you send rebates to everyone else.
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by mamon on Thursday March 12, 2020 @03:37PM (#22560862)
>> They are providing short-term loans

If I want to give my friend a loan, I need to earn that money first by working hard. FED does not conduct any profitable activity that would earn them any money, they DO PRINT that money from thin air.

Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by kylebenzle on Thursday March 12, 2020 @03:43PM (#22560939)
Why do people keep telling the lie that the FED "does not print money"? As you say, these "loans" are the FED printing $1.5t, no other way to look at it.
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by 34679 on Thursday March 12, 2020 @03:52PM (#22561023)
There is at least one other way to look at it. These loans will primarily, if not exclusively, go to large financial institutions. Due to the wonders of fractional reserve lending, those institutions will get to loan out several multiples of the original $1.5T. Another way to look at it is that they've probably "printed" closer to $15T.
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by kamaal on Friday March 13, 2020 @12:16AM (#22564658)
How does this work? Like any government can just print their way to prosperity?

I mean you just magically put $15T into circulation?

Won't this lead to inflation?

Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by 34679 on Friday March 13, 2020 @07:22AM (#22566387)
Yes it will absolutely lead to inflation. But for the well connected banks who are first to benefit, and coincidentally, I'm sure, the ones who run the Federal Reserve, the money will get to be spent/loaned before it causes much or any inflation. For the rest of us with value stored as US currency, we get fucked.
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by imtringued on Friday March 13, 2020 @10:25AM (#22567467)
It depends on what it is used for. If banks have enough deposits to lend out $15T they might not find enough borrowers and therefore only a partial sum will reach the economy. Why do banks have so much trouble getting borrowers if the interest rates are negative? Because banks add additional fees on top. The fee must high enough to cover defaulting loans and the bank's expenses.

If you have ever taken a loan from a bank you are aware that you must prove to the bank that you are able to repay the sum. Based on the information they receive they will calculate the default risk and increase the interest rate accordingly.

Warning. Extremely simplified for ease of demonstration.

If you have a 50% default risk then someone else has to cover your missed payments. For every $10k you want to borrow the bank has to ask for another $10k in additional interest to cover the default risk. If your loan lasts 8 years that means $833 additional interest per year or around 8%.

Now, if you are a young poor person with a bad credit score then you might end up paying 5% on top of the actual interest rate. Negative interest: 5% - 0.1% = 4.9%. Positive interest: 5% + 1% = 6%. I'm glossing over compounding interest but the picture is clear. Negative interest rates are not going to meaningfully change the cost of borrowing money for the average person unless they get a mortgage that is backed by the value of the house. Meanwhile for rich people and companies who can get rates as low as 1% lowering the interest rate to -0.1% is almost like a cheat code. At those rates the money might as well be free.

Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by dchyrdvh on Friday March 13, 2020 @02:35AM (#22565248)
As long as other countries use dollars, it's the US that's got 15T worth of goods more. These 15T buy entire tankers of oil, metals, minerals and goods from other countries and this is what matters.
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by ipnon on Thursday March 12, 2020 @04:10PM (#22561211)
The key distinction is that the Fed is trading the new money for high-quality collateral. The original owners of the collateral will return the Fed's money within weeks of months in exchange for the return of the collateral.
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by cryptica on Thursday March 12, 2020 @04:38PM (#22561474)
No matter how you look at it, somebody who is not the Fed benefits from this. If market participants didn't think that they will benefit financially from this, they would not participate. This kind of "zero-sum temporary money" theory doesn't add up.

The situation is exactly as kylebenzle inferred; the Fed is injecting new fiat money into the economy and it's going straight into the pockets of rich financial institutions which add no value whatsoever to the economy or society.

Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by tomp on Thursday March 12, 2020 @05:38PM (#22562064)
No, the way this works is this (as I understand it): I'm a bank, I need some cash to operate (people withdrawing money, trading, making payments, etc.), but I have no cash. I have $10B in US Treasury bonds, but - well, they're notionally worth $10B, but nobody want to exchange them for money, because noone else has money to spare (i.e. liquidity crisis). So here comes the Fed, takes my $10B in bonds, gives me $10B of cash so that I can run my business... In a week or so, I need to return $10B in cash, I get my $10B in bonds back ("collateral") and the cycle continues again.

The alternative is, the bank collapsing, taking some part of the economy with it.

Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by gumbo on Thursday March 12, 2020 @08:55PM (#22563714)
Genuine question here. Any data on the typical duration of these loans? How long typically the Fed holds collateral?

I remember 2 years ago the market throwing a tantrum because of the fed unwinding it balance sheet. Doesn’t that mean that typical loans are never repaid and the Fed just let the bonds mature?

Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by tomp on Thursday March 12, 2020 @09:46PM (#22563992)
I think the "unwinding" was Fed stopping QE, which is slightly different - they were buying bonds on the market (not as emergency liquidity) to prop up asset prices (buy bonds -> reduce interest rate -> investors seek other sources of returns -> buy stocks -> stock prices go up... same with real estate). Bonds mature (literally disappear), so if you want to keep propping up asset prices, you must keep buying new bonds as the ones you own mature. The Fed was doing that for a while, then tried to slowly stop, ween the market off the cheap money (because if the patient is supposed to be healthy, s/he should be able to survive and thrive without drugs). Trump threw a tantrum (I guess he knew/suspected that Fed was the only/main thing propping up asset prices, without Fed the market would crash/stop increasing, which isn't good for elections because politicians always get the blame), the markets weren't happy either (basically NIMBY - you're invested so you want to keep the value of your assets as high as possible).
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by gumbo on Friday March 13, 2020 @12:32AM (#22564737)
Got it thanks. Still, any data on how long a typical repo loans is?
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by lbotos on Thursday March 12, 2020 @04:54PM (#22561618)
> the Fed is injecting new fiat money into the economy and it's going straight into the pockets of rich financial institutions which add no value whatsoever to the economy or society.

Financial institutions control who gets levered money (loans). They provide a huge value to an economy and society in a fractional reserve banking system.

You are upset about the Fed, when you should be upset about the government who controls fiscal policy. The government can provide tax holidays and other benefits more directly to people, as is their role, not the Fed.

Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by cryptica on Thursday March 12, 2020 @06:54PM (#22562841)
I don't agree that bank loans add any value to our modern fiat-based economy. It's possible that loans may have added economic value when money was based on a limited resource such as gold, but that economy was an entirely different beast from what we have today. Fiat is not simply a switch that one can flick off and on without anticipating negative flow-on effects; and yet that's exactly how governments have treated it when they abolished the gold standard whilst continuing to support an archaic system of debt and credit. Since the fiat system was introduced, house prices have skyrocketed (relative to average salaries) and corporations have gained monopoly positions in the market whilst using lobyists to take control of our governments. Our fiat-based, debt-oriented system has some obvious drawbacks.

Both the government and the Fed are to blame; one for designing the whole scheme and the other for implementing it. I'm upset about the idea that the Fed can inject money into the economy based on obscure criteria. From the perspective of an average citizen, who is legally obliged to accept Fed money in exchange for their labor, whatever set of criteria the Fed chooses is going to be inherently inadequate; the mere lack of transparency behind the Fed's operation is by itself sufficient to discredit the validity of the entire operation.

Money backed by gold was good money precisely and fundamentally because everyone understood what gold was and where it came from. Now, essentially nobody knows what fiat money is or where it comes from and yet everyone is legally obliged to accept it.

Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by jonahbenton on Thursday March 12, 2020 @10:35PM (#22564216)
No. There are all kinds of discontinuities in money but this narrative is just an exhibition of ignorance.

Even when "money backed by gold" was a slightly less completely inaccurate fiction than it is now, what people "knew" to be money was many, many, many different things, depending on where they were and what they did for work.

Stories like this are like religious narratives, and "money backed by gold" is like the story of the angry god allegedly giving tablets to some dude. It is at BEST an allegory but yall go and read it like it happened.

Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by OGWhales on Friday March 13, 2020 @11:54AM (#22568250)
What are you talking about? I’d love to see you actually expand on this and explain what you mean instead of just pooping on it and saying people believe in fairy tails.
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by jonahbenton on Saturday March 14, 2020 @04:05PM (#22578230)
I'm sorry- I am happy to respond to specific questions from the above but nearly every single sentence is a factual/historical misrepresentation, and the language/terminology ("fiat-based", "backed by gold", "yet everyone legally obliged to accept it") is that of someone who has a particular religious view of money (maybe a "goldbug") that may have its own philosophical consistency but...is...just...completely...ahistorical.

Money is a much more interesting topic that goldbugs give it...um...credit for.

There is another recent discussion on HN:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22573204

that has a lot of pointers to good resources from which to begin the discovery process.

Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by kirykl on Thursday March 12, 2020 @04:52PM (#22561593)
Essentially its countering threat of massive deflation with some inflation
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by ipnon on Thursday March 12, 2020 @03:59PM (#22561106)
If you want to compare apple to oranges, then you would need to be able to print money from thin air in order to be consistent in your metaphor where you are the Federal Reserve and your friend is a cohort of "financial institutions providing high-quality collateral" in exchange.

Personal finance and monetary policy are not similar even though they both involve money. Money in your bank account is not the same as money in the Federal Reserve or even money printed at a mint.

Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by mamon on Thursday March 12, 2020 @05:23PM (#22561908)
>> Personal finance and monetary policy are not similar even though they both involve money.

That's what central banks want you to believe: that what they are doing is something special, "God's work" - as some drunk Goldman Sachs executive put it. Truth is: law of economics are pretty much like laws of physics - they work the same in small and large scale. It is no coincidence that Great Depression happened in 1929, mere 16 years after FED was created - that was just a first of many consequences of central bank's irresponsible actions.

Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by 6gvONxR4sf7o on Thursday March 12, 2020 @04:42PM (#22561508)
How short term are these loans?
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by tandr on Thursday March 12, 2020 @10:40PM (#22564233)
Overnight, I think
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by gowld on Friday March 13, 2020 @12:57PM (#22568880)
Why do banks get these sweetheart loans instead of civilians?
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by MrMember on Friday March 13, 2020 @02:08PM (#22569479)
What is the average person going to do with an overnight loan?
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by SilasX on Thursday March 12, 2020 @02:35PM (#22560131)
I 100% agree that the Fed's actions are troubling and it's boxed itself into a corner, and has very ineffective tools for what it's trying to do, but ...

This injection isn't really comparable because those other things are expenditures, while the 1.5t refers to short-term loans to very creditworthy borrowers. It really doesn't come at the cost of providing universal healthcare.

Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by ahi on Thursday March 12, 2020 @03:29PM (#22560777)
The very creditworthy borrowers are very creditworthy because they receive 1.5t in short term loans from the Fed.
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by SilasX on Thursday March 12, 2020 @03:49PM (#22560991)
Not really, the assessment is made before extending the credit.
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by strbean on Thursday March 12, 2020 @05:19PM (#22561855)
Like they were "very creditworthy" in 2008.
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by ryandvm on Thursday March 12, 2020 @02:56PM (#22560397)
Because the people that pay for campaigns already have healthcare. The more money you allow into politics, the more politics is about money.
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by 34679 on Thursday March 12, 2020 @02:30PM (#22560057)
The Federal Reserve is not a government entity and has nothing to do with the budget, which is set by the US congress.
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by Frondo on Thursday March 12, 2020 @02:39PM (#22560176)
The Fed does not set the budget, and is independent of the three branches of government, that's true, but...

> The Federal Reserve System is an independent government institution that has private aspects. The System is not a private organization and does not operate for the purpose of making a profit.

From https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Structure_of_the_Federal_Reser...

Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by 34679 on Thursday March 12, 2020 @03:00PM (#22560454)
Two sentences later in the paragraph your quote came from:

>As an independent institution, the Federal Reserve System has the authority to act on its own without prior approval from Congress or the President.

And later:

>The twelve Federal Reserve banks provide the financial means to operate the Federal Reserve System. Each reserve bank is organized much like a private corporation so that it can provide the necessary revenue to cover operational expenses and implement the demands of the board. A member bank is a privately owned bank that must buy an amount equal to 3% of its combined capital and surplus of stock in the Reserve Bank within its region of the Federal Reserve System.

*edit - Also, the source for your quote is cited as "BoG 2005", with a dead/nonexistent URL

Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by lbotos on Thursday March 12, 2020 @02:47PM (#22560287)
Uh what?

Fed = Monetary policy == Make sure money can flow "appropriately"

Government = Fiscal Policy == "Who gets money"

I don't know how your quote is relevant at all.

Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by glitcher on Thursday March 12, 2020 @09:09PM (#22563791)
You seem to be assigning the values of boolean comparison results with that syntax. So Fed and Government are both false in this example.
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by scrumbledober on Thursday March 12, 2020 @02:49PM (#22560320)
the part where it says the fed is a government institution...
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by Frondo on Thursday March 12, 2020 @02:59PM (#22560424)
Specifically, "the fed is a private bank" is a common refrain among goldbugs and currency conspiracy theorists, and it's not true, no matter how often it's repeated.

Not saying the OP is a goldbug or currency conspiracy theorist, but they're the only people I ever see tossing that out so quickly and without any elaboration on what they mean.

Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by exclusiv on Thursday March 12, 2020 @03:32PM (#22560807)
> The System is not a private organization and does not operate for the purpose of making a profit.

> Specifically, "the fed is a private bank" is a common refrain among goldbugs and currency conspiracy theorists, and it's not true, no matter how often it's repeated.

I'd recommend reading The Creature from Jekyll Island. Once you understand the origins of the Fed you will understand that it's an institution founded by public and private individuals and entities to drive profit and leverage the system and taxpayers where it can. It's a creature with public/private/independent parts. It requires no conspiracy because much is known about it, although most people are unaware. JP Morgan, Wells Fargo, Citibank, the government and others founded it together!

"At the end of November 1910, Senator Nelson W. Aldrich and Assistant Secretary of the U.S. Treasury Department A. Piatt Andrew, and five of the country's leading financiers (Frank Vanderlip, Henry P. Davison, Benjamin Strong, and Paul Warburg) arrived at the Jekyll Island Club to conduct a secret meeting to plan the country's monetary policy and banking system, formulating during the meeting the Federal Reserve as America's next central bank.[14] [15] According to the Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta, the 1910 Jekyll Island meeting resulted in draft legislation for the creation of a U.S. central bank. Parts of this draft (the Aldrich plan) were incorporated into the 1913 Federal Reserve Act." [1]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jekyll_Island#Planning_of_the_...

Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by partiallypro on Thursday March 12, 2020 @03:00PM (#22560443)
$1.5 Trillion goes into a certain aspect of the money supply to help maintain credit spreads, etc. This is completely different than your agenda list expenses. If you flooded the entire US economy with $1.5 trillion in straight cash it would likely cause inflation, but the Fed isn't injecting it into that level of the money supply.
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by strstr on Thursday March 12, 2020 @02:30PM (#22560048)
Often this type of action is not the government spending that level of money with nothing in return. Generally it is buying an asset it intends to sell later (often at a profit).
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by rcar on Thursday March 12, 2020 @02:34PM (#22560115)
For sure. People still get up in arms about the 2008 bank bailout without realizing that it ended up resulting in a $121B profit to the government: https://projects.propublica.org/bailout/
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by spaced-out on Thursday March 12, 2020 @02:46PM (#22560277)
I tried to click your Propublica link because I want to see their numbers, since the wiki article on TARP points out that the "profit" the government made comes out to a 0.6% annualized interest rate, so once you take inflation into account the government actually lost money.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Troubled_Asset_Relief_Program

Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by rcar on Thursday March 12, 2020 @03:52PM (#22561028)
The Propublica link includes both TARP and the government's investments in Fannie/Freddie, which provided heavy dividends and is where a large portion of the profits have come from.

That aside, the common misperception of TARP is that the government gave away $400+B of taxpayer money, which is a very, very far cry from a small inflation-adjusted loss.

Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by spaced-out on Thursday March 12, 2020 @06:17PM (#22562499)
>the common misperception of TARP is that the government gave away $400+B of taxpayer money

I don't think this is a common misconception, I think it's a strawman argument to deflect criticism of the bailouts.

Regardless of whether or not the government made money, we created a massive moral hazard by allowing banks to engage in shady behavior, avoid any criminal prosecution, get below-rate loans to avoid the market consequences of their actions, and left the common people out in the cold.

On top of that, we supposedly fixed the problem by expanding banks' reserve requirements, but when they got into trouble in the repo market, the FED runs to their rescue with even more below-market-rate loans, which seem to get larger and larger by the week.

Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by vkou on Thursday March 12, 2020 @02:53PM (#22560364)
When taking inflation and the time value of money into account, it was a loss.
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by oxymoran on Thursday March 12, 2020 @02:44PM (#22560253)
This isn’t a bailout for wall street, it’s an attempt to bailout the economy as a whole because there isn’t enough money in the banking system to cover the institutional sell off. In other words, they had to do this to prevent a run on the banks which would royally fuck everyone.
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by sg47 on Thursday March 12, 2020 @06:10PM (#22562420)
Yes, because banks are over-leveraged. Regulations that kept leverage in check have been overturned by the GOP.
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by missedthecue on Thursday March 12, 2020 @07:54PM (#22563322)
Completely and utterly false. Banks are at their lowest leverage of the last 40 years. This is verifiable hard data.
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by OGWhales on Friday March 13, 2020 @12:05PM (#22568377)
Can you help me find this data?
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by stevetodd on Thursday March 12, 2020 @02:38PM (#22560172)
When you hear the Fed, it is referring to the Federal Reserve. The Federal Reserve is independent of the federal government. Essentially, it's the entity that can print money. When it does, it doesn't just give the money away, but it injects the cash by purchasing assets and making loans. It also does the reverse by selling assets. So this money doesn't come out of the Federal budget.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Reserve#Tools

Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by stevenwoo on Friday March 13, 2020 @02:32PM (#22569699)
Yes. The 500 million they injected yesterday stopped the freefall for 30 minutes. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-03-12/n-y-fed-t...
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by aguyfromnb on Thursday March 12, 2020 @04:09PM (#22561199)
>inject 1.5t" by that do they mean a 1.5t panic bailout for wall street?

Banking clients are demanding more liquid assets (ie cash) than banks have access to, so they are swapping treasuries for cash from the Fed.

It's not like this is banking profits; would you rather the bank fail and you or your business or your employer lose everything you had there? Because that is also an option.

Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by imtringued on Friday March 13, 2020 @10:48AM (#22567649)
People always forget that the bank bailout is ultimately about people protecting their own bank accounts. If you dislike the incompetent banks then take your business to a bank you trust.
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by OGWhales on Friday March 13, 2020 @12:14PM (#22568469)
There aren’t any
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by FlyMoreRockets on Saturday March 14, 2020 @08:07PM (#22579804)
Credit unions are generally trustworthy.
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by chonitoe on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @12:43AM (#22601743)
I trust my BTC wallet.
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by 99052882514569 on Thursday March 12, 2020 @03:08PM (#22560545)
>how can we find 1.5t in the budget

Central bank ≠ treasury.

Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by anonu on Thursday March 12, 2020 @02:29PM (#22560043)
Not all dollars are created equally
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by munk-a on Thursday March 12, 2020 @02:30PM (#22560061)
Yea, dollars put into student loan forgiveness actually pay themselves off many times over due to the high velocity of cash in the hands in young people - money injected into the market has a comparatively low velocity and tends to just get exported overseas.
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by tomp on Thursday March 12, 2020 @05:42PM (#22562122)
Why would you forgive student loans? That way you reward incompetence. Instead, you should give each young person $300k - some would repay their student loans, others (who were more prudent with their choice of education) would have down-payment for a house or something... Forgiving just the student loans would create massive perverse incentives.
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by spopejoy on Thursday March 12, 2020 @07:46PM (#22563263)
> Why would you forgive student loans? That way you reward incompetence

It's the opposite: it's a step toward removing the moral hazard that allowed predatory loans to be offered to students in the first place. The logical end-point is to get back to free or affordable tuition.

> Instead, you should give each young person $300k

Admirable suggestion, but how does that _not_ create perverse incentives to e.g. blow it all speculating on Hearthstone cards?

Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by imtringued on Friday March 13, 2020 @10:38AM (#22567569)
They could also decide to buy stocks and then the entire idea becomes meaningless.
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by munk-a on Thursday March 12, 2020 @06:17PM (#22562504)
Because those student loans were made in bad faith to people who were too young to realize how badly they were being exploited and how meaningless their education was - for clarification I've paid off all of mine, and I'm still happy to see zero benefit out of this expenditure because it'll be just and help the economy.
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by imtringued on Friday March 13, 2020 @10:36AM (#22567561)
You didn't meaningfully address the parent which was talking about rewarding this exploitation. Imagine you are a college and instead of investing into high quality education you try to get as many students to enroll through concessions even if it means that they cannot repay their loans because of bad job prospects. If students know that their loans will be forgiven then they might go for the "expensive vacation" college instead of the "boring nerd" college with those super strict professors.
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by sg47 on Thursday March 12, 2020 @06:12PM (#22562441)
Just like the bank bailout?
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by bscphil on Thursday March 12, 2020 @07:25PM (#22563122)
Not taking a stance here either way, but surely it's possible to oppose both the bank bailout and forgiving student loans on the grounds that they both create perverse incentives?
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by imtringued on Friday March 13, 2020 @10:42AM (#22567611)
The bank bailout was purely about liquidity. Over the long term the banks are going to repay the loans. Student loans are a long term problem. The only way you could fix it is by sending students back to college and force them to get a profitable STEM degree.
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by jvanderbot on Thursday March 12, 2020 @02:36PM (#22560152)
I tend to agree philosophically, but is there data to support this? I'd like to upgrade to informed agreement.
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by munk-a on Thursday March 12, 2020 @02:44PM (#22560246)
Here is one source based on income bracket[1] which I think is a pretty strong corollary. Here is a nice visualization of spending by age group[2] and the original source for that data[3].

1. https://www.pewtrusts.org/en/research-and-analysis/issue-bri...

2. https://engaging-data.com/household-spending-age/

3. https://www.bls.gov/cex/home.htm

Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by paulmd on Thursday March 12, 2020 @04:05PM (#22561162)
these are overnight loans that are intended to allow normal overnight financing to continue even if the markets siezed up because everybody is so panicked nobody wants to let loose of their cash.

Yes, this means the Fed is very very worried about the state of the market, it means they think it's at risk of stopping normal operation. Maybe not ongoing crisis but they're worried about crisis in the near future.

The fact that the stock market circuit breaker has been hit a grand total of once before, back when it used a different set of rules and was easier to hit, and then we've hit it twice in a week is pretty fucking bad news, if that sets the backstory for you at all.

Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by gentleman11 on Thursday March 12, 2020 @02:44PM (#22560255)
By contrast, the Hong Kong plan is to mail a grand to every citizen (iirc)
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by aantix on Thursday March 12, 2020 @03:59PM (#22561105)
While good long term health is nice, no one wants to be on the receiving end of mass hysteria when individuals find out they can't withdraw their money.
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by malandrew on Thursday March 12, 2020 @05:18PM (#22561846)
> The markets wouldn't be so important if there were a safety net.

The markets literally pay for the entirety of any safety net. Without the markets there are no jobs, so no payroll or income tax revenue. Without tax revenue, there are no safety nets.

Without the markets, there are no investments, so no capital gains tax revenue.

Without the markets, there is nothing to sell, so no sales tax revenue.

Without the markets, there is capacity for charity.

If you don't understand how critical the markets are to the functioning of the country, you don't understand how countries function.

Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by adaisadais on Thursday March 12, 2020 @02:34PM (#22560119)
We have a fiat currency. The Government creates “money” whenever it pleases. The money is “Backed by the full faith and credit of the United States”.

I completely agree that in the long term this is completely faulty and just helps to exacerbate the underlying causes of economic crisis. But our government (typically) does not act in long-term interests. We as a people do not hold our politicians accountable.

Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by TheSoftwareGuy on Thursday March 12, 2020 @02:40PM (#22560197)
>The money is “Backed by the full faith and credit of the United States”.

I'm pretty sure its treasury bonds that are "Backed by the full faith and credit of the United States". Dollars are backed essentially by what you can buy with them.

Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by gen3 on Thursday March 12, 2020 @06:28PM (#22562598)
The US dollar was at one point backed by a gold and silver standard, meaning that you could always go redeem the cash for a specific amount of the metal. After the Great Depression the US moved away from the standard, backing the money with the faith in the US government.

This is why each note has “Backed by the full faith and credit of the United States” printed on it.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_United_States...

https://www.reference.com/business-finance/backs-up-currency...

Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by TheSoftwareGuy on Friday March 13, 2020 @09:24AM (#22567040)
>This is why each note has “Backed by the full faith and credit of the United States” printed on it.

No they don't. I just checked three different bills in my pocket (a $1, a $10 and a $100) and none of them say this. They say "This note is legal tender for all debts public and private" but there is absolutely no reference to "the full faith and credit of the united states"

Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by jonahbenton on Thursday March 12, 2020 @10:22PM (#22564158)
This is debt, not equity.

The "budget" is equity.

Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by golergka on Thursday March 12, 2020 @03:34PM (#22560826)
Just a reminder, "bailout" is loans, not gifts. US government got it's 2008 bailout money back with interest.
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by nathancahill on Thursday March 12, 2020 @04:04PM (#22561158)
If we're getting in to the weeds on the ebb and flow of money to and from the government, universal healthcare saves the government money rather than costing it money.
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by rlt on Friday March 13, 2020 @12:44AM (#22564806)
I'm genuinely curious what evidence there is for this?
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by nathancahill on Friday March 13, 2020 @12:34PM (#22568656)
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by taiwanboy on Thursday March 12, 2020 @02:42PM (#22560226)
Folks. Companies listed on the stock market hire average folks who need the money to provide for their spouses and kids. Companies that provide staples to you like food and gas and transportation and medical supplies.

These are the companies you are actively shorting. Think about that. This isn’t the same as 2008.

Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by munk-a on Thursday March 12, 2020 @02:47PM (#22560294)
Company's welfare is somewhat connected to their stock price, but it's a really weak relation. The stock market is mostly a gambling simulator that runs beside the economy as it's own little micro-economy - this doesn't make it worthless but it does make this sort of a statement ring really hollow.
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by jacquesm on Thursday March 12, 2020 @03:01PM (#22560465)
The connection with the real world is made whenever a company floats some of their stock.
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by whateveracct on Thursday March 12, 2020 @02:58PM (#22560419)
It's like fantasy basketball vs real basketball
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by taiwanboy on Thursday March 12, 2020 @02:57PM (#22560408)
These days companies are VERY tied to quarterly EPS guidance and stock prices. Layoffs and adjustments closely follows that as well.
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m... by jacquesm on Thursday March 12, 2020 @03:01PM (#22560457)
Only when those companies are trying to raise money. In the meantime, it is the speculators and the institutionals that hold a large chunk of what has been floated.