Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m...
by tomp on Thursday March 12, 2020 @05:42PM
(#22562122)
Why would you forgive student loans? That way you reward incompetence. Instead, you should give each young person $300k - some would repay their student loans, others (who were more prudent with their choice of education) would have down-payment for a house or something... Forgiving just the student loans would create massive perverse incentives.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m...
by spopejoy on Thursday March 12, 2020 @07:46PM
(#22563263)
> Why would you forgive student loans? That way you reward incompetence
It's the opposite: it's a step toward removing the moral hazard that allowed predatory loans to be offered to students in the first place. The logical end-point is to get back to free or affordable tuition.
> Instead, you should give each young person $300k
Admirable suggestion, but how does that _not_ create perverse incentives to e.g. blow it all speculating on Hearthstone cards?
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m...
by imtringued on Friday March 13, 2020 @10:38AM
(#22567569)
They could also decide to buy stocks and then the entire idea becomes meaningless.
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m...
by munk-a on Thursday March 12, 2020 @06:17PM
(#22562504)
Because those student loans were made in bad faith to people who were too young to realize how badly they were being exploited and how meaningless their education was - for clarification I've paid off all of mine, and I'm still happy to see zero benefit out of this expenditure because it'll be just and help the economy.
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m...
by imtringued on Friday March 13, 2020 @10:36AM
(#22567561)
You didn't meaningfully address the parent which was talking about rewarding this exploitation. Imagine you are a college and instead of investing into high quality education you try to get as many students to enroll through concessions even if it means that they cannot repay their loans because of bad job prospects. If students know that their loans will be forgiven then they might go for the "expensive vacation" college instead of the "boring nerd" college with those super strict professors.
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m...
by sg47 on Thursday March 12, 2020 @06:12PM
(#22562441)
Just like the bank bailout?
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m...
by bscphil on Thursday March 12, 2020 @07:25PM
(#22563122)
Not taking a stance here either way, but surely it's possible to oppose both the bank bailout and forgiving student loans on the grounds that they both create perverse incentives?
Re:Fed to inject $1.5T to prevent ‘unusual disruptions’ in m...
by imtringued on Friday March 13, 2020 @10:42AM
(#22567611)
The bank bailout was purely about liquidity. Over the long term the banks are going to repay the loans. Student loans are a long term problem. The only way you could fix it is by sending students back to college and force them to get a profitable STEM degree.