News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Young and unafraid of the pandemic? Good for you. Now sto... by keeganjw on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @04:57PM (#22550492)
They make a good point in this article, I just wish Newsweek and other media outlets would get this pissed off about climate change. "Old and unafraid of the climate crisis? Good for you. Now stop killing future generations." If we're mobilizing to stop a pandemic, why the hell aren't we mobilizing to stop climate change?

I know this is going to get downvoted into oblivion, I just wanted to say it.

Re:Young and unafraid of the pandemic? Good for you. Now sto... by geerlingguy on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @05:04PM (#22550587)
Not to excuse anything, but the main difference is the time scale—within days/weeks we saw differences, and death counts... with climate change it's not only difficult to measure easy-to-understand direct correlation sometimes, it also is at minimum on time scales of months to years.

Most news cycles are hours or days, not months or years.

Re:Young and unafraid of the pandemic? Good for you. Now sto... by godelski on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @05:23PM (#22550864)
This is exactly right. As young people we are afraid of climate because we know it will affect us in the future. That's not true for older people (well, we can quite easily argue that it is __currently__ affecting people).

I think another good example is nuclear. It may have low deaths per terrawatt of energy, but the deaths it causes are localized, physically and temporally. It doesn't matter that each year more people die in the US from coal ash than all those that ever have (or will) from (current) nuclear disasters.

These kinds of things are well known in psychology (including the simplest: marshmallow experiment). Humans are bad at risk estimation and even worse when it comes to time scales. If it isn't happening before our eyes then chances are we're pretty bad at estimating risk.

Re:Young and unafraid of the pandemic? Good for you. Now sto... by csomar on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @05:19PM (#22550797)
> with climate change it's not only difficult to measure easy-to-understand direct correlation sometimes, it also is at minimum on time scales of months to years.

Isn't this, exactly, why we are in trouble with the coronavirus. Our inability to see a disaster looming ahead?

Re:Young and unafraid of the pandemic? Good for you. Now sto... by chrisco255 on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @05:06PM (#22550626)
Nobody is dying from global warming. It's a sea level rise of 2-3mm a year. Less than 11,000 people a year die from natural disasters, which is near all-time lows despite a rising population. 100 years ago, it was common for at least 1,000,000 people a year to die from natural disasters. Thanks to technology, including internal combustion vehicles and electricity, that number has dropped dramatically. Crop yields are up almost 100% since the 80s for many crops, including staples like corn, wheat, and soybeans. We're able to feed more people than ever before. Also, winters are far more deadly than summers.

Source for the data: https://ourworldindata.org/natural-disasters Zoom out back to 1900 and see how much the world has improved.

Re:Young and unafraid of the pandemic? Good for you. Now sto... by atoav on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @05:17PM (#22550773)
> Nobody is dying from global warming.

Citation needed. Many (also old) people died in the European heat waves of the last summer. And every year these summers are getting hotter.

Once crops closer to the already dry and hot areas of the globe stop to yield, and people migrate away from those areas — how many people die in the resulting conflicts, how much human suffering will be produced there?

What impact will the usage of resources we use to safeguard costal cities against rising waters have on other areas that prevent human suffering?

Answering the possible fallout from even a moderate change in global climate is nowhere near as clear cut as you make it out to be.

On top of that: the ddcisions we take now could potentially be multiplied by the next 1000 human generations, only idiots would take that risk lightly.

Re:Young and unafraid of the pandemic? Good for you. Now sto... by chrisco255 on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @07:26PM (#22551899)
I did include a citation with a chart for deaths from natural disasters worldwide for the last 120 years. Meanwhile you mention heat wave deaths in Europe (with no citations) and conveniently exclude deaths from winter-based natural conditions.

Here's the CDC analysis on deaths from temps, showing that among weather related causes of death (which are not even in the top 50 ways to die, by the way), 31% were due to excessive heat and 63% were due to excessive cold: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25073563-deaths-attributed-t...

There is no evidence of precipitation decline across the planet. Some drought-prone areas, that have been drought prone for thousands of years, have gotten some drought conditions. There's nothing new about that. In California there's fossil evidence of 200 year megadroughts that pre-date industrialization. So mother nature is gonna throw us curve balls no matter what we do. We have to adapt when that occurs, see links below for studies on historical megadroughts not caused by man:

https://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/geology/article-abstrac...

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2730237/

https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10933-012-9590-9

Re:Young and unafraid of the pandemic? Good for you. Now sto... by Nuzzerino on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @05:34PM (#22551001)
Good points, but:

> On top of that: the ddcisions we take now could potentially be multiplied by the next 1000 human generations, only idiots would take that risk lightly.

The problem with this is that the decisions we take now could potentially mean anything. The butterfly effect effectively makes it meaningless to measure what we do now, so many years into the future. There's a lot of sentiment against climate change "denial", but the real denial is not about the presence of climate change but rather whether it is wise to make changes that we cannot measure the impact of.

Re:Young and unafraid of the pandemic? Good for you. Now sto... by atoav on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @06:12PM (#22551379)
If you argue like that nothing counts anymore and everything can be justified – maybe it turns out the puppy you shot would have mauled the kid that would have invented the cure to cancer – who knows. If you warm a perfectly inhabitable planet up very quickly, there will be friction.

What too little people really grasp is the fact that global warming is a highly non-linear process. It takes the same energy to melt 1kg of ice (at 0°C) to 1kg of water (at 0°C) as it takes to heat water from 0°C to 80°C. Currently we are melting ice – once that is gone things will go at a very different pace and this will be practically irreversible.

I don't think I am clever enough to judge alone if this is really a safe route to go, which is why I trust the experts on this one. And they all say: get your fuckign shit together and do something drastic right now.

Re:Young and unafraid of the pandemic? Good for you. Now sto... by shawnb576 on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @05:37PM (#22551034)
> Nobody is dying from global warming.

This is definitely not true now and will be less true in future. And its a very narrow view - climate change is spreading misery and destruction at massive scales.

- More powerful hurricanes and cyclones kill people directly then many more through disease, starvation, homelessness, etc.

- The Australian fires killed 1 BILLION animals. [1]

- India is running out of water [3]

- Ocean fish stocks are collapsing - leading to malnutrition and starvation of many who depend on them

- Global heating is driving conflicts and migration from places like central america, middle east, etc.

- While not climate change, the cause of it (fossil fuels) causes 10K deaths EVERY DAY [2]

[1] https://www.cbsnews.com/news/australia-fires-over-1-billion-... [2] https://www.forbes.com/sites/rogerpielke/2020/03/10/every-da... [3] https://www.nytimes.com/2019/07/15/opinion/india-water-crisi...

Re:Young and unafraid of the pandemic? Good for you. Now sto... by chrisco255 on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @07:40PM (#22551991)
Deaths are down 99% over the last 100 years. From 1,000,000+ a year in (as many as 3,000,000 people a year died from natural disasters in the 30s!) This despite a population increase of almost 5x in that time frame. Follow my link in the parent comment and zoom out to 1900 on natural disaster deaths. It's not even close to what our ancestors were dealing with. We're at near all time lows.

That is thanks to tech. Less people are dying from all natural disasters than they were 100 years ago. We have emergency response vehicles, we have satellite communication and early warning signs for impending disasters, we have better response systems that while imperfect far exceed what were available 100 years ago. We have worldwide wireless phone coverage and many countries that didn't even have phones 100 years ago can now dial for help in an emergency.

The Aussie fires are nothing new. This happens every couple of decades in Australia and has occurred for thousands of years. The whole history of weather in Australia is drought, flood, drought, flood, rinse, repeat.

https://www.australiangeographic.com.au/topics/science-envir...

Stop blaming EVERY occurrence of weather on elevated CO2 levels. It makes zero sense from a thermodynamic perspective. There are systems in the climate that are completely outside of our control, and they cause weather and climate to change. Some small fraction of that is due to CO2.

Re:Young and unafraid of the pandemic? Good for you. Now sto... by squarefoot on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @05:15PM (#22550744)
"If we're mobilizing to stop a pandemic, why the hell aren't we mobilizing to stop climate change?"

Because a frog boiled very slowly usually doesn't complain until it's too late. Had this pandemic infections happen two orders of magnitude slower, nobody would give a damn.

Re:Young and unafraid of the pandemic? Good for you. Now sto... by headcanon on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @05:03PM (#22550581)
We're just not wired to think about things at that scale and over long periods of time. IMO the reason we're taking climate change as seriously as we are now is because of the visceral evidence provided by the hurricanes of the last couple of years.

We collectively need things to be observably happening right now in order to believe they are true.

Re:Young and unafraid of the pandemic? Good for you. Now sto... by 3fe9a03ccd14ca5 on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @05:04PM (#22550597)
Plus, climate models and predictions just don’t resonate with people.
Re:Young and unafraid of the pandemic? Good for you. Now sto... by Melting_Harps on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @05:21PM (#22550824)
> They make a good point in this article, I just wish Newsweek and other media outlets would get this pissed off about climate change. "Old and unafraid of the climate crisis? Good for you. Now stop killing future generations." If we're mobilizing to stop a pandemic, why the hell aren't we mobilizing to stop climate change?

> Help to fight climate change. Kill old people with the corona virus.

I knew someone was going to take it to this level after I read your initial post an upvoted it, a part of me laughed, another part made me wonder if that's what it would take...

Re:Young and unafraid of the pandemic? Good for you. Now sto... by shakezula on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @04:58PM (#22550507)
I can't agree with this enough. The media seems willing to be alarmist about everything _but_ the most important crisis my generation will ever face.
Re:Young and unafraid of the pandemic? Good for you. Now sto... by jshevek on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @05:07PM (#22550642)
Part of the problem here is that extremists have subjected us to at least three decades of climate alarmism poisoned by bad science and failed predictions. People who lack the scientific background to properly understand specific claims and the basis for them rely on ignorant heuristics, such as "the boy who cried wolf". They wrongly conclude that the current round of climate concern is no different than the rounds they've previously experienced.
Re:Young and unafraid of the pandemic? Good for you. Now sto... by ajross on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @05:20PM (#22550807)
> extremists have subjected us to at least three decades of climate alarmism poisoned by bad science and failed predictions.

I'm sure someone said something dumb. But straightforward models of long term climate change and CO2 output going back to the 70's have all been largely proven out. Which "extremists" are you trying to point the finger at, specifically?

Re:Young and unafraid of the pandemic? Good for you. Now sto... by jshevek on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @05:32PM (#22550993)
> I'm sure someone said something dumb

Yes, just one person.

Edit: I try not to engage with people who use this kind of rhetorical technique. If anyone else is honestly ignorant of and curious about the damaging effects that decades of climate alarmism has had on some people's trust, you need only Google. For example: "bad climate change predictions"

In my opinion, the problem still exists and it is important to be honest about the elements (activists, journalists, politicians) who are on the 'right side' of the discussion but do a poor job of representing the data.

Re:Young and unafraid of the pandemic? Good for you. Now sto... by gbrown on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @05:14PM (#22550729)
Is that true? I feel like the mainstream scientific picture has been alarming (correctly) for that whole period, and people (using ignorant heuristics) have incorrectly discounted the warnings since they don't feel the pain right now.
Re:Young and unafraid of the pandemic? Good for you. Now sto... by jshevek on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @05:16PM (#22550762)
Both [your observation and mine] are true. I am not talking about mainstream scientists. Sadly, they don't control the larger conversations.
Re:Young and unafraid of the pandemic? Good for you. Now sto... by ajross on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @05:20PM (#22550813)
> I am not talking about mainstream scientists.

Then who are you talking about?

Re:Young and unafraid of the pandemic? Good for you. Now sto... by jshevek on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @05:31PM (#22550961)
> Then who are you talking about?

This question is so strange I don't know where to begin. Should I look up the percentage of the population that are scientists? Should I pull up an Amazon list of books popular in the 70s and 80s dealing with climate change? Should I start listing various forms of dysfunction in the 4th estate? Should we talk about the culture of activists?

Disseminating scientific knowledge correctly is a challenge in our society.

Re:Young and unafraid of the pandemic? Good for you. Now sto... by ajross on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @08:22PM (#22552258)
OK, start with those. I mean, your point upthread is that you didn't personally believe all the good science of the last 30 years because of some "extremists", which now apparently includes the entirety of the media and political left. I think that's a pretty ridiculous argument, and am challenging you to give me some specifics to focus the discussion.

You don't get to wave this away. Let's see who you're talking about.

Re:Young and unafraid of the pandemic? Good for you. Now sto... by jshevek on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @09:24PM (#22552570)
Please try not to misrepresent other people's claims nor presume their experiences.

>I mean, your point upthread is that you didn't personally believe all the good science of the last 30 years because of some "extremists"

Re:Young and unafraid of the pandemic? Good for you. Now sto... by pc86 on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @06:02PM (#22551282)
> Please don't comment about the voting on comments. It never does any good, and it makes boring reading.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Young and unafraid of the pandemic? Good for you. Now sto... by bumby on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @05:12PM (#22550708)
There’s numerous cognitive biases in play that cause people to disproportionately weigh near-term risks/rewards (hyperbolic discounting). Not to mention one is a direct threat while one is more abstract
Re:Young and unafraid of the pandemic? Good for you. Now sto... by opwieurposiu on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @05:32PM (#22550983)
Fewer people means less carbon emissions. More people means more carbon emissions.

On the other hand, fewer people means lower oil prices, which increases carbon emissions.

Hard to say what the net effect will be.

Re:Young and unafraid of the pandemic? Good for you. Now sto... by chadlavi on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @05:00PM (#22550522)
Newsweek's main audience is older folks. I think they wouldn't necessarily like to bite the hand that feeds them.

But I agree, and I hope you don't get downvoted to oblivion.

Re:Young and unafraid of the pandemic? Good for you. Now sto... by Nuzzerino on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @05:05PM (#22550606)
But we aren't mobilizing to stop the pandemic (or at least, not enough), and the WHO even cited that as a reason for declaring COVID-19 as a pandemic today.

Many of these media outlets still publish their Coronavirus content behind paywalls, or plastered with advertisements everywhere. That isn't mobilizing, that's capitalizing.

Re:Young and unafraid of the pandemic? Good for you. Now sto... by Grue3 on Thursday March 12, 2020 @05:55AM (#22555208)
Ironically making people more aware of climate change causes people to vote for candidates who are objectively terrible for climate change (see: anti-nuclear Green party in Germany, Bernie Sanders etc.)
Re:Young and unafraid of the pandemic? Good for you. Now sto... by rvz on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @05:17PM (#22550775)
Perhaps its because we already have technological solutions put in place or still actively developed to actually reduce climate change ahead of time even when eventually we'll see the real devastation in action in 10 - 20 years time.

Compared to this, the virus spreads extremely fast and healthcare systems across the world are being stretched and tested since there aren't any vaccines or solutions yet to tackle COVID-19 except for reminding everyone to wash their hands regularly.

So the world now has to focus on battling a pandemic now rather than improving on the technologies already put in place to save us from climate catastrophe. At least taking a flight should now be seen as a double negative at this time for the kids of today.

[dead]
Re:Young and unafraid of the pandemic? Good for you. Now sto... by dang on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @07:33PM (#22551948)
Please stop posting flamebait to HN. We don't want generational flamewars here, in addition to the other kinds of flamewar we don't want here.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Young and unafraid of the pandemic? Good for you. Now sto... by cmrdporcupine on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @05:01PM (#22550542)
I was making a related comment to my coworkers earlier this week: if the stock market is this freaked about covid19, just wait til investors realize climate change is real and it will be hard to make money while NYC is flooded and nobody wants to buy oil anymore.
Re:Young and unafraid of the pandemic? Good for you. Now sto... by travisoneill1 on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @05:16PM (#22550760)
At this point we have had 1C of warming, and the economic effects have been minimal. The most aggressive IPCC model shows another 1C by 2050. So that's double the warming. What will the economic damage be? Probably more than 2x, but almost certainly not 100x, which is what it would take to have a meaningful impact on the economy. This is why the market isn't worried about it.
Re:Young and unafraid of the pandemic? Good for you. Now sto... by btilly on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @05:31PM (#22550969)
When you say things like this, you come across as uninformed. Not smart.

Seriously, https://riskfinder.climatecentral.org/place/new-york.ny.us?c... shows you the worst projected flood in the next 30 years. As you can see, there is substantial damage, but the vast majority of New York will be fine.

And mitigation of that particular risk is available at a relatively cheap price of building dykes. Which is well-understood technology. In fact there is a country (the Netherlands) that in large part consists of reclaimed seabed kept dry through dykes.

About oil, oil isn't most of our economy. Believe it or not, people realize this and it won't actually change our economic system as much as you seem to think it will.

So yes, climate change is a real problem. But "OMG, NEW YORK IS ABOUT TO BE FLOODED AND OUR ECONOMY WILL END WITH OIL" is not supported by the evidence.

Re:Young and unafraid of the pandemic? Good for you. Now sto... by jshevek on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @05:14PM (#22550737)
Do you mean flooded from some specific storm, or from rising sea levels? When do you think NYC will become flooded? I've heard predictions of a sea level rise of 50 inches by 2100, but I don't know how much the levels need to rise to flood NYC.
Re:Young and unafraid of the pandemic? Good for you. Now sto... by mattnewton on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @05:07PM (#22550633)
I think people know and just believe there will either be a magical human engineered solution that solves the problem or lots of time to find a greater fool before it gets that bad.
Re:Young and unafraid of the pandemic? Good for you. Now sto... by datashow on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @05:12PM (#22550712)
Climate change is real doesn't mean NYC will be flooded.