I understand HN skews more toward extremely expensive CoL areas of California, so I grant that there may be many people here who legitimately could not although I don’t think SDI should be expected to cover 100% of living expenses for extremely highly compensated individuals in the most expensive area to live in the state.
That aside, SDI is one of the best public goods California has. I had surgery this past year and was able to take 3 months off work with no impact to my financial situation. The benefit almost replaced my take home pay (since, again, it was not taxed) and then my company topped it off. It was sort of surreal to be paid equivalently for not working. Unaccustomed to that as an American.
Does Aflac cover time away for work due to COVID-19?
Paying the country to take a week off would cost something on the order of $125 billion, to say nothing of the knock-on effects.
In any case, there is a minuscule number people who are unable to work because of COVID-19 relative to the total number of people unable to work on a short-term basis for all other reasons.
If I am healthy enough (imho) to go to work because a sneeze and a runny nose never killed anyone (until now) is something that people were/are/will do. If someone prohibits me to go to work and it is THEIR choice, then it would be only fair to support me so I can continue living. Not buying Prada shoes, but the "Essentials" (as defined by Dave Ramsey and/or the Minimalists). From my travels in the USA I remember that Silicon Valley and SF are crazy expensive (and people, I live in London).
So back to the point. You want me to keep away? Can I WFH? Then thank you I can continue WFH to support my family. If not, don't destroy me and my family financially, help me help the society. I know that USA has a small allergy on social provisions but this is literally "do or die".
Disability insurance might pay $50 a week for many, more for some. It's not enough. So the isolated break quarantine and roam, or go insane. Both are understandable given the horrific mismanagement of the crisis.
Based on my analysis of widespread stock market anomalies, the secretive quasi-executive branch's Plummet Protection Team has been spending dozens or even hundreds of billions of federal reserve creation bucks per day for almost two weeks now attempted to counter market slides. This is going to cause massive inflation, possibly hyperinflation if not stopped, and will not stop anything regarding the virus spread because it's not addressing market fundamentals. The same amounts spent on assisting with quarantined people, plus manufacturing masks and Chloroquine for mass distribution would have a chance of stopping this. There is absolutely no interest whatsoever in that approach, I presume because it is not profitable to certain parties or otherwise coalesce with their trajectories.
Since it’s not taxed, that’s 90-100% of your salary.
Should help most people stay afloat.
$1000 a month property taxes.
$2000 a month health insurance premiums.
$1000 a month car payments.
$1000 a month food bill.
That's not uncommon in the bay area for a developer with two or three kids. $132k without even getting started.
Suddenly his $150k developer income is cut to 60% of what it was before, $90k. Except wait it's not there's a "cap" so he's pulling in a massive $62k. With $132 in basic expenses.
This is no problem and terribly generous as you see it.
And is he paying $24,000 per year in premiums?
This example is someone obviously living beyond their means, so of course they're going to get into trouble.
This is recipe for disaster. I do understand that CA is expensive, but "living paycheck to paycheck" is an accident waiting to happen. This time it is CV. Next time it could be something else. Unless a family has enough on the side to live off no (new) income for 6 months, then sweat and stress sets in.
I hope everyone, everywhere will ride this CV out as unscathed as possible. But with budget like that, it's very "challenging".
Of course the payout is capped, so anyone earning more than maybe $30k is subsidizing the insurance pool, but anyone who qualifies for SDI should absolutely claim it, because it's a benefit they have been paying for.
Supporting a family on that if you're the single household income might be a bit tight. Paying rent on a nice house could easily swallow it (though a nice house isn't a basic necessity) - but 67.6k really is a fair amount of money. It's more than the median income in Oakland. 2x that (i.e. both parents working) is more than the median income in SF.
Edit: also, keep in mind that if there’s a second working adult in the household, both are likely to be impacted.
I was keeping in mind that both adults would be effected... that's why I was using the disability pay rates for both adults in the above.
I'm sure you're familiar with the study that says 4 in 10 Americans can't cover a $400 unexpected expense? Well, it doesn't quite say that [0], but it does cite a study that says only 24% of households have $400 in liquid assets. And, it also says that 14% of households would not be able to pay some bills if such an expense arose, and 12% could not cover the expense at all (I'm unclear if the 12% overlaps with the 14% though).
Are you saying you're okay with those people taking the first step into total financial ruin, just because of something they have little or no control over (becoming temporarily unable to work due to disability)? And, I'll ask again: why should one's bank balance affect one's ability to claim benefits when one paid into the system in order to fund those very benefits?
---
[0]: https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2019-06-04/the-40...
I have never said I wanted to punish anyone.
I have never suggested looking at bank balances - in fact I explicitly argued against this the only time I mentioned it.
You are arguing against a straw man.
That said - I have no interest in replying to the content of the argument - I stay away from arguing about things on the internet where there is no right side. The general question of what to do is too political for me to approach here. All I am willing to do, and have done in my comments, is respond to clearly incorrect statements.
Which seems far more reasonable to me than actually measuring savings. We don't want to punish people for creating emergency funds.
Critically deprived people reasonably go insane, escape isolation, and become spreaders. Thus it is a matter of public health not to deprive people.
> Disability Insurance provides short-term benefit payments to eligible workers who have full or partial loss of wages due to a non-work-related illness, injury, or pregnancy. Benefit amounts are approximately 60-70 percent of wages (depending on income) and range from $50 - $1,300 a week.
This isn't going to be enough to cover a lot of peoples' monthly expenses. After taxes, $1300/week barely covers my rent, much less food and other necessities.
Edit: does anyone downvoting care to actually explain why they disagree? Or, are y'all just offended by the statement?