News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sonos is getting rid of its controversial “recycle mode” by fierarul on Friday March 06, 2020 @05:17AM (#22502421)
I think Sonos did the right thing by creating Recycle Mode and the over-reaction to this was amazing.

Telling customers to just send the bricked device to the local recycling centre in exchange for a discount seems fair.

Apple also has a trade-in program except they expect you to send them the device. Sonos took the cheaper approach by offloading the actual recycling to a local centre. But people want to have it both/all three ways: feel good about recycling, get a discount on a future new gadget and sell/give the functioning old device to somebody. Amazing.

Re:Sonos is getting rid of its controversial “recycle mode” by gambiting on Friday March 06, 2020 @05:40AM (#22502537)
>>Telling customers to just send the bricked device to the local recycling centre in exchange for a discount seems fair.

No, that's literally insane by every definition of the word. They took perfectly fine, working products, and destroyed them in order to give their customers a discount. Which part of that seems "fair" to you? Imagine if a car manufacturer would give you a discount on a new car, if you took your old one to the scrapyard first - everyone would immediately how this is a huge waste of resources if the car was still working. How is this acceptable with speakers??

Other companies somehow manage without this madness fine - if you are verified as an actual customer, they give you a discount for more stuff. What usually happens then is that you either sell or give away the old device, and someone else might get into the brand and potentially purchase more devices from it as well. It's a win win for everyone. This stupid recycling thing serves no one, except like you said - people feeling "good" about recycling, which is nonsense, a fully working device should be reused first.

Re:Sonos is getting rid of its controversial “recycle mode” by derekp7 on Friday March 06, 2020 @05:53AM (#22502596)
That was almost exactly what the Cash for Clunkers program was doing. Under the Gov. contact, the dealer had to pour an engine seizing compound through the caurborator to get the discount reimbursement. Kept functional vehicles from ending up in the hands of the poor.
Re:Sonos is getting rid of its controversial “recycle mode” by Angostura on Friday March 06, 2020 @06:54AM (#22502887)
That's because it was designed specifically to remove more environmentally damaging vehicles from being used. It's purpose was to give people incentives to get them destroyed.

There is no similar environmental incentive here.

Re:Sonos is getting rid of its controversial “recycle mode” by sitkack on Friday March 06, 2020 @11:15AM (#22504728)
The purpose was to prop up the auto industry while having an eco cover story.
Re:Sonos is getting rid of its controversial “recycle mode” by CPLX on Friday March 06, 2020 @05:57AM (#22502618)
Yes but that was the stated goal of the policy. If this speaker program was designed to remove unsafe or environmentally unsound speakers from circulation we’d be having a different conversation.
Re:Sonos is getting rid of its controversial “recycle mode” by fierarul on Friday March 06, 2020 @06:39AM (#22502813)
+1

Clunkers are generally functional machines. At least here they don't accept the clunker if you can't drive it in there.

Re:Sonos is getting rid of its controversial “recycle mode” by alien1993 on Friday March 06, 2020 @05:48AM (#22502571)
>> Imagine if a car manufacturer would give you a discount on a new car, if you took your old one to the scrapyard first - everyone would immediately how this is a huge waste of resources if the car was still working. How is this acceptable with speakers??

This is pretty standard in Italy, nevertheless bricking devices is shit.

Re:Sonos is getting rid of its controversial “recycle mode” by wirrbel on Friday March 06, 2020 @06:00AM (#22502634)
I think what Sonos did there was fairly ok from a customer-interaction point of view, but bad from the environmental perspective.

There is a difference between bricking a device and offering a trade-in program, or offering a trade-in programm. The former does not allow you to continue using a PURCHASED device (your property), the latter allows you to continue using your property or OPTING for the trade-in programm. Sonos didn't kill the devices without the customer OPTING for the purchase of a new one. I guess it's kind of bad UX, but an offer to the customer.

From an environmental perspective its obviously bad. Bricking kills reuse in a second hand market and is an insentive to take working devices out of operation.

Yet, its not the first sketchy thing I remember hering about Sonos and I am glad I bought Teufel multimedia systems https://www.teufel.de who I have no recollection of pulling any of these moves.

Re:Sonos is getting rid of its controversial “recycle mode” by mkj on Friday March 06, 2020 @07:19AM (#22503000)
Even from a customer interaction point of view it's dubious. Sonos gear benefits from a network effect, so giving someone a hand-me-down speaker has potential for future sales there.
Re:Sonos is getting rid of its controversial “recycle mode” by duxup on Friday March 06, 2020 @06:47AM (#22502847)
How does that work in Italy exactly?
Re:Sonos is getting rid of its controversial “recycle mode” by fierarul on Friday March 06, 2020 @06:47AM (#22502846)
You are assuming there is a market for used Sonos gear. I pretty much assume it is not. Dismantling and recycling used electronics is what actually happens. Even Apple boasts about their Liam robot to dismantle iPhones... what percentage do they fix and resell and what percentage they dismantle? Who knows?

Note that the didn't take anything. It was an offer between two parties.

Since they were going to dismantle the obsolete tech anyhow, they just allowed consumers to send them to the local recycling centre (it's debatable if this part was fair). But since they wanted to make sure these things actually do get recycled, they bricked the devices that the consumer said not to need anymore and agreed to recycle.

What people wanted was a 30% discount for existing users. They got this, in the name of being green. A true win-win-win.

This move just teached other companies not to try similar stunts. Just let the devices die of old age, sit for a while in a drawer and let the consumer figure out what to do with the e-trash... using the local recycling centre or worse.

Re:Sonos is getting rid of its controversial “recycle mode” by zwily on Friday March 06, 2020 @08:52AM (#22503493)
Actually there’s a strong market for used Sonos gear. It generally holds value better than other consumer electronics.
Re:Sonos is getting rid of its controversial “recycle mode” by duxup on Friday March 06, 2020 @06:49AM (#22502858)
Why wouldn't there be a market for used Sono equipment?

Wouldn't even that existing owners use them?

Re:Sonos is getting rid of its controversial “recycle mode” by fierarul on Friday March 06, 2020 @07:07AM (#22502947)
Since the existing owner just 'sold' them to Sonos for a 30% coupon and the promise of actually recycling the gear, I'd say no.
Re:Sonos is getting rid of its controversial “recycle mode” by normalnorm on Friday March 06, 2020 @07:02AM (#22502926)
> But people want to have it both/all three ways: feel good about recycling, get a discount on a future new gadget and sell/give the functioning old device to somebody. Amazing.

The discount in this case is an incentive against the best possible type of recycling, which is precisely to let someone else reuse it as is. Of course, companies tend to hate the good kind of recycling because it limits their profits. Companies are not entitled to infinite growth, nor should we facilitate that sort of expectation, least we end up destroying our own habitat. Well, we probably will, considering the way things are going...

What is actually amazing is that a company would create such an incentive and then pretend to be the good guys, caring about recycling and so on. Even more amazing is that some people are convinced by such low-effort bullshit.

Re:Sonos is getting rid of its controversial “recycle mode” by fierarul on Friday March 06, 2020 @07:10AM (#22502960)
I'm convinced both the company wrapping this as an eco-friendly move and the eco blow-back from some consumers to be morally equivalent.

I didn't see a mob asking for 30% higher prices so Sonos could actually do proper recycling.

Re:Sonos is getting rid of its controversial “recycle mode” by Nasrudith on Friday March 06, 2020 @08:00AM (#22503206)
That is a complete nonsequitior - 30% isn't what they need for proper recycling but what they believe they can afford to give as a sale to promote conversion from those who already sold it.

The two offenses are very non-equal and not remotely equatable. One is claiming to help the environment while doing something actively detrimental to it, the other is at most not going for a non-existant hypothetical option which resembled someone trying to sell them the Brooklyn bridge and added sales sleeze. If that caught on without some through and validated accreditation method would rapidly see fly by night "recycling surplus" operations that ran off with the money without any actual recycling.

Re:Sonos is getting rid of its controversial “recycle mode” by fierarul on Friday March 06, 2020 @08:28AM (#22503347)
Point is, nobody wants to pay.

> The two offenses are very non-equal and not remotely equatable.

Both sides are pretending to want to be eco-conscious while buying/selling more hardware.

> One is claiming to help the environment while doing something actively detrimental to it

I'd say something neutral to it as they are promoting recycling. Maybe detrimental as encouraging e-waste but all hardware sellers want you to upgrade so e-waste is part of the modern tech industry. How long does a modern smart phone last?

> the other is at most not going for a non-existant hypothetical option which resembled someone trying to sell them the Brooklyn bridge and added sales sleeze.

No, the other is wanting to have their cake and eat it too. Which after much scandal, they did!

> If that caught on without some through and validated accreditation method would rapidly see fly by night "recycling surplus" operations that ran off with the money without any actual recycling.

In the end it was Sonos that did offer a discount, so they couldn't run with any money. It's actually the consumers that decided the deal was not good enough so now they keep the old device and get the money.

Re:Sonos is getting rid of its controversial “recycle mode” by debian3 on Friday March 06, 2020 @05:22AM (#22502442)
Reduce, Reuse, Recycle. There is a reason why it’s in that order.
Re:Sonos is getting rid of its controversial “recycle mode” by fierarul on Friday March 06, 2020 @06:38AM (#22502805)
None of these really require the manufacturer to step in and give you any money or discounts.
Re:Sonos is getting rid of its controversial “recycle mode” by speedgoose on Friday March 06, 2020 @05:20AM (#22502435)
Why sending to the recycling centre perfectly fine products ?
Re:Sonos is getting rid of its controversial “recycle mode” by yardstick on Friday March 06, 2020 @05:51AM (#22502587)
Exactly this. Answer: they were too lazy to collect the returned units and clean/prep/rebox them for resale. The whole discount for recycling offer was just designed to encourage more sales, they didn’t care about the recycling bit. Maybe they should just... reduce their prices by 30%?

Side note: will there now be a market for buying used Sonos devices dirt cheap just for the discount in buying new devices? Or will Sonos only offer this on the first sale.

Re:Sonos is getting rid of its controversial “recycle mode” by zwily on Friday March 06, 2020 @08:53AM (#22503500)
The discount only works once per device.
Re:Sonos is getting rid of its controversial “recycle mode” by givinguflac on Friday March 06, 2020 @08:03AM (#22503222)
This is wildly wrong. The whole point was that it’s a massive carbon footprint to ship them all back. Local recycling is much more environmentally friendly. Not to mention this is an optional thing regardless. The discount is offered to any owner provided it hasn’t already been claimed by a previous owner.
Re:Sonos is getting rid of its controversial “recycle mode” by fierarul on Friday March 06, 2020 @06:53AM (#22502881)
Because a trade-in program where you sent the device to Sonos wasn't operationally / financially possible.

There are extra costs with doing this in house (or, I guess, by partnering with a recycling centre) which meant the discount would have been much lower, or perhaps close to 0.

But for an existing customer that did want to trade in, 30% was perhaps acceptable.

Re:Sonos is getting rid of its controversial “recycle mode” by Canada on Friday March 06, 2020 @05:23AM (#22502447)
Apple resells the used devices to the public, so they aren't just throwing them in the trash
Re:Sonos is getting rid of its controversial “recycle mode” by fierarul on Friday March 06, 2020 @06:37AM (#22502803)
Apple marketed a lot their Liam iPhone dismantling robot: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AYshVbcEmUc
[dead]
Re:Sonos is getting rid of its controversial “recycle mode” by givinguflac on Friday March 06, 2020 @08:04AM (#22503225)
Clearly, you didn’t read the article. What you’re saying is the equivalent of Tesla offering a 30% discount on a new car, while still letting you resell your old car. There’s nothing good enough for you ever?
Re:Sonos is getting rid of its controversial “recycle mode” by netsharc on Friday March 06, 2020 @09:51AM (#22503971)
I'm replying to a severely downvoted comment who thought the original bricking (so a 30% discount, but no resell because Sonos would turn the old device to a doorstop by a server-side flag) was a fine idea.

Fucking hell, but my -1 shows me Hacker News is full of people -- like you -- who can't even follow threads.

Re:Sonos is getting rid of its controversial “recycle mode” by fierarul on Friday March 06, 2020 @03:33PM (#22507056)
I think he was following the thread just fine. (And I didn't downvote you).