What would happen to the food market were it not for the generally high supply of food? It wouldn't be pretty.
Because of that, some sort of non-market intervention is simply unavoidable. As are the inefficiencies that go along with price controls and other similar endeavors. Ugly stuff, this healthcare business.
Not necessarily. Suppose you have a deadly condition. Your information is extremely limited as non-professional. Would ... you can pay all your money now for the cure your doctor offers or you can wander over to an unknown provider for the best price? The quality of unknown providers is ... unknown and your doctor is known. And he knows he's got by the genitalia and will charge accordingly since with even a thousand unknown providers, your real choices are very limited.
Just as much. Presently, no American hospital publishes its price list. I believe there's no regulation about this. Why hasn't "the market" impelled these providers to publish their prices.
Almost every American hospital publishes its price list to its primary customers: the insurance companies. The problem as I see it is that the insurance companies are the only entities that can get fair prices for health care, and they want to keep it that way. A potential solution would be to ban insurance discounts; a health-care provider could charge any price it wants, but it would be required to charge all customers the same price. Insurance companies would still negotiate for lower prices, so it would benefit all of us.
For instance, a podiatrist I know charges $350 to the insurance company (which shows this as the discounted, negotiated rate) but $150 cash to remove an ingrown toenail.
I'm sure there are exceptions.
This "retail rate" mentioned in the article is crap.
This was in Texas, so maybe someone that understands the laws can chime in and comment on that.
Medicare is the largest payer of insurance claims by far. Medicare also has a lot of rules. One of these rules is that, in order to prevent providers from shortchanging Medicare, they have to charge everyone the same price (otherwise medicare would be overpaying....). Medicare will then pay 80% of the indicated amount and the rest is covered by medigap insurance, Medicaid, or by the patient.
As you might imagine, the lack of ability to price discriminate, even to patients, hugely distorts the market. However, private insurers have gotten around this (how I don't totally understand), by using what is called the contractually "allowed amount". This is an agreement that the provider will write off the variance between the allowed amount and the billed amount. This results in de facto price discrimination for large insurers while getting around the medicare law. Patient's don't have this kind of gig.
Of course, there are tons of other corruptions and inefficiencies in the system. I could tell you a story about a friend who once worked for NY Medicaid who was actively prevented from working to prevent the state from going bankrupt by paying claims.
I don't have the answers, but there is serious distortion of the market ATM.
I hope I never have to use this information, but it's out there.
1. the medical industries/professions work very hard at discouraging price competition.
2. price competition is not sufficient to create a healthcare marketplace that works well for society. I'd like to see people without means have at least some access to medical technology/services, even at the cost of inefficiency. But that's just me.
Like I said - it's a beast.
you don't have time to shop around for services while unconscious in the back of an ambulance.
It is true that some people will choose badly when left to their own devices, but that's better than forcing the same dumb rule on everyone. Each of us is an end in ourselves. So long as we do not violate the negative rights of others, we are responsible only for our own lives, not the lives of our brothers.
No man is an island. Neither you, nor anything you create is created in isolation.
Dependencies are ever-present and failing to understand this leads to failed ideas such as "true free market" not unlike the idea of "true communism".
In reality the very fact that you are alive to write your words is a testament of other peoples effort including your parents to guard you against the many many dangers in this world.
Ultimately you don't own the right to anything, not even yourself.
It's an agreed upon right not a natural law.
I agree that there are some times too many regulations. But claiming what you do here is simply wrong in a very unfortunate Ayn Rand way.
I can forgive Jefferson for living in different times, but Ayn Rand should have known better.
The Founding Fathers declaration doesn't apply to the 5.8 billion people who lives outside the US.
And even if it did it would not by any metrics be a natural law. Property rights is a human construct nothing else.
Elasticity in economics describes the relationship between two variables (normally price and demand which is price elasticity [of demand] but by no means exclusively).
But unless you define your variables (or state what sort of elasticity) it's not a useful term and certainly not something I'd be bandying about while suggesting that someone else didn't have a clue.
Nonsensical. What kind of market theory are you following that doesn't factor in market elasticity? Rush Limbaugh eco 101?
As I said the term elasticity isn't meaningless, but without defining the variables you are defining as elastic (or inelastic) it doesn't make sense, at least not without assumptions which obviously may or may be wrong.
Personally by default I'd assume that you were referring to price elasticity of demand - that is the relationship between changes in price and the resulting change in demand, however there are many other types of elasticity (see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elasticity_(economics)).
So if you want to explain exactly which variables "market elasticity" refers to then that would be great, but as "market" is a very loose term, on it's own it's not very useful.
You pulled someone up for not knowing what they were talking about ("For someone who puts so much faith in free markets you don't appear to understand how they work. In your studies, look up "market elasticity" for a clue."), when it seems the same accusation could be levelled at you.
But, I never really meant it to become a big deal so I apologise for being picky and I'll move on to answering your question.
Broadly I agree with you but I think it's slightly more complex than that a straight forward "it doesn't work" and for me the issue is how you factor in the failures which in healthcare tend to result in injury or death. For instance, would a law covering corporate homicide (that is an organisation causing the death of someone in the course of their work due to incompetence or carelessness) count as market regulation? Or even manslaughter if a doctor acting alone did the same? Would that be regulation?
Because of this I think any civilized society wouldn't accept the possibility of severe injury or death without significant consequence, so even if it might work in theory (more below), we'll never know in practice as it would never be allowed to come about.
More generally though my view is that markets of any sort only work well when you've got a few factors at play:
(1) the deals and decisions are being made directly by those they impact - that is the patients so the deal genuinely reflects the will and interest of the patients (as opposed to them being one step removed as with insurance companies where their interests muddy things)
(2) the system has to be such that there is a financial consequence to the patient of the decision they make (that is they see the benefit of getting a deal which is good value as well as good medicine otherwise why would they look for value)
(3) there has to be as close to perfect information as possible to allow these decisions to be made on a true and fair basis - and when you look at the PR machines we see today exist, you've got to think that's not going to happen without regulation.
My issue is I don't see how you'd consistently get those factors without regulation. I couldn't say it's impossible but it certainly seems highly improbable, certainly in the culture we have now (point 3 being the one I can't ever see coming about without enforcement).
As an aside - I live in the UK where we have nationalised healthcare and it's frankly great. The market reforms over here terrify me because they're ideologically driven by people who seem to want to drive us towards an American system so in theory while I'm not intrinsically against the market playing a greater role in health provision, in practice I'll tend to fight it on the grounds that it looks like they're going to the whole thing up a treat.
Which isn't to say either (1) that they actually do work well in, say, the USA, or (2) that some less free-market-based system mightn't work better. (I'm in the UK; the situation in the US looks absolutely horrifying to me. I don't know what an ideal healthcare system looks like, but it surely can't be that.)
You turned cause and effect upside down. You think the free market for food "works" because food supply is "abundant"? Think again. The supply is high because it's market is "free" (not really but fairly) globally and (sorta) works.
And of course, they will grow better if they eat their carrots ;-)
Healthcare can be broken up into a lot of smaller markets, and for a lot of those the free market works just fine. The market for coffee in the cafeteria of the hospital works fine as a free market. Do you know what percentage of healthcare cost pertain to the cost of the actual treatment itself? (hint: it's a very small part)
Basically everyone has to maintain a fund (the government pay into it for the poorest) for healthcare. This is what they spend when they have healthcare needs.
Because the people are making the purchasing decisions themselves (as opposed to the insurance company doing it) they have a far stronger incentive to demand value and to be informed, and you get genuine competition between providers (as if you don't like them this time you'll go elsewhere next time with no insurance company mandating who you can see).
The government then picks up the few areas that aren't well catered for by this system.
I think it costs about 40% of what the US system costs (possibly even less) and Singapore has a typical life expectancy of 80.
... has a price- and service-controlled market, set not by the healthcare industry but by the Singaporean government (you know, the guys that cane graffiti artists and banned gum-chewing?) They also provide government subsidies to citizens as well as permanent residents (though not as much) for their compulsory Medisave program. So, their invisible hand is very visible and it's called "their government regulates or pays for alot of their care".
And with that, you're no longer in a free market.
The Japanese system is not without its problems. More importantly, the "price fixing" approach to health insurance simply isn't going to happen in the US. What parts of it do you think we really can adopt? Because nobody is going to fix US healthcare by fiat.
Why wouldn't it? Would there be riots in the streets? Roving gangs of healthcare-affiliated hooligans throwing rocks, burning patient effigies? Doctors lining up to leave the country en masse for a freer medical marketplace or just throwing dirt in the eye of medicine to go be a quant trader at a hedge fund?
The more important question is: Why hasn't that happened worldwide, in places where there truly _is_ universal/free/government healthcare?
"What parts of it do you think we really can adopt? Because nobody is going to fix US healthcare by fiat."
And, nobody but the rich and upper-middle class will be able to afford healthcare by Market. We can already see that today, with over 50 million uninsured Americans, up from 37 million just two years ago. How many will it be next year?
My objection to your point is twofold:
(1) It is total wishful thinking.
(2) It's wishful thinking in the face of pragmatic solutions that could resolve the problems we have now without utterly restructuring the market for health care.†
I'd also appreciate it if you wouldn't attempt to frame any critique of your comments in terms of "you're either with me or against health care reform". As you can see from a casual glance at this vast, Reddit-like thread, few opponents of health care reform would dare poke their head up on HN these days. I'm not an opponent of reform.
† Recap of my wish list: mandatory guaranteed-issue private high-deductable health insurance, an exchange-type system that fosters 5+ insurers in every major market (up from the 2 we have today), and broad adoption of cost-cutting services like telemedicine-issued scripts and nurse-practitioner clinics.
Guaranteed-issue meaning "you have to get it, but we [the insurer] can charge whatever the hell we want. So, you, small biz of 10 employees with one person who had cancer, you premium is now more money than the GDP of Haiti, per month. Thanks and come again!"
That kind of practice can be fixed by either 1) price-fixing or 2) subsidies forever, the latter of which is really, REALLY expensive.
"an exchange-type system that fosters 5+ insurers in every major market (up from the 2 we have today)"
The one that the Obama administration just gave $240 million to 7 states (Kansas $31.5 million, Maryland $6.2 million, Massachusetts $35.6 million, New York $27.4 million, Oklahoma $54.6 million, Oregon $48.1 million and Wisconsin $37.8 million) to implement as part of the healthcare overhaul passed last year? I think it'll work, too. Funny how that needs federal dollars, though. Shouldn't the free market sort this stuff out without the magic hand of socialism?
"Broad adoption of cost-cutting services like telemedicine-issued scripts and nurse-practitioner clinics."
That I'll agree with, big time along with EMR mandates. That with HIPAA are a big step toward alleviating alot of the administrative burdens in healthcare management, especially tracking and billing.
I disagreed with you that what we need is the Department of Health and Human Services to set prices for health care by fiat. So, first, you attempt to paint me as against all reform and in favor of people dying instead of companies going into debt. Now, you've tried to reframe the discussion so that you're either in favor of market-based approaches or a "socialist".
And, after you've done your level best to suck all the oxygen out of the conversation, it turns out... you agree with me.
Please stop writing like this on HN.
I didn't say they did. I said 10-person startup. And, regardless of the existence of an "exchange" or not, policies of that size will still be meted out case-by-case, and those little start-ups will get squeezed, especially if they have someone on board with a pre-existing condition.
There's no getting around that problem unless each state acts as a group insurance pool. You will ALWAYS run into the small business, part-timer, or self-employed worker problem. Full stop. No arguments.
"it turns out... you agree with me."
Let's get this out of the way from square one: I don't agree. At all. In principle or in general. I may agree in some finer details, but my ultimate pie-in-the-sky wish for America is for us to implement a mandatory system in which every man, woman, and child, regardless of age or infirmity can get covered for a nominal price, unless they are a religious or conscientious objector and chooses to opt-out, but must themselves still pay, like we do with defense.
"I disagreed with you that what we need is the Department of Health and Human Services to set prices for health care by fiat."
And, I disagreed that the free market cannot correct what is here _in practice_. Not some theoretical America where we didn't have a glacially large government or a sedentary populace with 50 Million uninsured that didn't eat Cheetos and Mountain Dew for dinner. I'm talking about the reality of the situation and how it will take more than EMR and telemedicine changes to close that 50 Million (and counting) gap, though I do agree that technology can play a non-trivial role in cutting administrative costs.
See, I have wiggle room and patience for negotiation.
"Please stop writing like this on HN."
You, I can see, don't.
Government-dictated pricing wouldn't necessarily violate the Constitution, it's been done several times throughout American history.
Funny mental picture though :D In my head they're wearing those stereotypical nurse hats and brought their own stretchers to carry off the wounded / exhausted / weaponry.
I can imagine a scenario where the age for Medicare was lowered slowly over time to cover more and more people. (Unlikely, but not beyond the realm of possibility).
The government is getting a pat on the back for removing essential services because the masses aren't taking notice; we've fanboy-ed our system while ignoring its degradation of the fundamentals. Our current system is not a positive guideline to success.
A Macleans article about the state of our system: http://www2.macleans.ca/2011/01/25/our-health-care-delusion/
Everything has a price, but that seems a little lopsided.
That was happening anyway, if it weren't for Medicaid, that is. There was a definite brain drain of doctors (especially specialists) who choose to go to affluent suburbs and urban areas simply because they get more (and better quality, AKA rich) patients. You think if we _further_ privatized the market, those in rural areas would be _better_ served? Isn't that the opposite of what the free market would actually do? In fact, take a look at this study[1] about physicians in rural America. It's eye opening how they advocate federal and state intervention (read Medicaid and Medicare) as one of the solutions (along with opening training up to more potential candidates, which even I as a liberal elitist supports).
I generally trust a self-correcting free market over a government bureaucracy to solve such problems, but in this case it seems the fundamental problem is that there just isn't enough margin for for-profit insurance companies to prosper without turning the screws on either doctors & staff, patients, and/or taxpayers.
Bulk billing is so much more convenient for everyone that you'll see signs advertising it on the outside of doctors surgeries, thus the cost of care is kept down. On the other hand, the doctors are free to charge what they want. Sounds like a fair way to do it.
And the funny thing is, Singapore and Japan both are rather well-off nations, not much different wage and price wise than the US. Biggest difference is medical cost...
In fact, forcing US hospitals and doctors to publish a price of any kind would be a simple improvement.
It is amazing with all the other twiddling that this approach never appears - at least not much.
The problem with comparing global stats like cancer survival rates is their weak correlation with the health care system. For example, the reason why colon/rectal cancer survival rate is high is because Japan is basically the only rich country where those cancers are the most common one (in other rich countries, prostate, breast, lungs usuallly come first for the concerned sex). There is also the issue of "free-ride", where most western countries benefit from research being done in the US and a couple other countries - which is not so easy to quantify either.
Designing good indicators is incredibly hard, and for that reason alone I think it will always be a political question first, and an economical one second (i.e. economics can help making a decision, but it won't give you the decision).
Hospitals are private, and both they and doctors negotiate every two years to set prices for everything from MRIs to stitches. The insurance industry is also private, but they have a public-run insurer for Japanese poor. AFAIK, taxes are taken just for the public-run insurance, to which only a small percentage of Japanese apply, but for private insurance (which the rest are mandated to have), it's paid through premiums per month, which is on average about $250/mo per family (and employers pay for almost all of that).
Incidentally, as near as I can tell, a hospital in Japan is equivalent to a clinic or doctor's office in the US. They also seem to be open weird hours. (example http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mi31MJrRjhE)
And, if you want to talk care and outcomes, let's pick the most grim of diagnostics: Cancer. Japan's 5-year survival rates are among the highest in the world, and the highest in particular cancers such as colon and rectal cancer. And, FYI, the US isn't #1 in survival rates for all cancers. It's spread evenly through the G8.
And, the most free of supposed free markets and tax-friendly wonderlands, Singapore, also puts price controls on procedures, with similarly successful outcomes. So it isn't a cultural or "economic" thing, it's a government thing. It always will be. An adult just needs to come in, put their foot down similar to what Tommy Douglas did in Canada, and declare either we all buy in to a government-run healthcare system, or we buy in to the government completely regulating the market much like it does the stock market or agricultural industry. States will have no say, no quarter, or feedback. They can choose to secede from the union to opt-out of the program.
And, while I love me some comment karma, I know that my position is tantamount to heresy on this board, so, get your dismissive hand cocked and ready to wave me away :D