News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NASA images show China pollution clear amid slowdown by CountHackulus on Saturday February 29, 2020 @09:18PM (#22454670)
Hmmm, survival of the planet vs progress of the economy.
Re:NASA images show China pollution clear amid slowdown by Melting_Harps on Sunday March 01, 2020 @02:14PM (#22458585)
> progress of the economy.

I take it this means headlong consumerism? If so, I think this is could be a net positive for Humanity, and perhaps a pause in the order of things to re-evaluate one's value system.

I'd prefer to be healthy and of sound mind, which requires the planet no descend into an uninhabitable wasteland, than to continue and have every trinket factory come from China come back online.

Re:NASA images show China pollution clear amid slowdown by pergadad on Sunday March 01, 2020 @05:17PM (#22459755)
I warmly recommend the book Factfulness by Hans Rosling. Stunning revelations that should be obvious but somehow aren't on every page. One of the most striking ones are his points on climate & development - especially that many people aspire to live a decent live and sadly the quickest way to get there is often polluting. This doesn't mean they are bad people, it's just normal humans that want to offer their kids a better future and themselves have a tiny bit of comfort.

The ones wasteful is still mostly us, the rich Western countries (not to mention the Emirates & similar oil countries). Yes we should give up some of our consumerism. You don't need that 2nd TV or new car. But can you tell the Chinese migrant worker that he can't buy a washing machine for his mom? Or the Bangladeshi call centre agent that she can't have a new apartment with warm water and electric sockets?

Re:NASA images show China pollution clear amid slowdown by daxfohl on Sunday March 01, 2020 @07:03PM (#22460346)
To a certain extent I find the parent post somewhat valid. If you think of "economy" as all the crap in my house that I want to get rid of, then sure. But ultimately we got to where we are (7B humans) by being a social species and developing the machinery to feed, clothe, shelter our population en masse. And machinery to make the machinery, and so on.

And much of that machinery may be subsidized by economy of scale that's driven largely by people's fascination with buying unnecessary shiny objects, the same way ads make free search and TV possible. Without that subsidy, the machinery to support life would be more expensive.

Our population may not be sustainable if there's a sudden dramatic and long-lived shutdown of this machinery. Maybe in the short term, sure. But over the long term even a minor shutdown could have big repercussions. Or maybe not. Interesting thing is, this whole covid episode, if it lasts a while, will help shed light on those questions.

Re:NASA images show China pollution clear amid slowdown by NicoJuicy on Sunday March 01, 2020 @10:27AM (#22457220)
The planet will survive
Re:NASA images show China pollution clear amid slowdown by briandear on Saturday February 29, 2020 @09:33PM (#22454737)
That’s a false dichotomy.
Re:NASA images show China pollution clear amid slowdown by FalconSensei on Saturday February 29, 2020 @10:25PM (#22454925)
But that's what Damorian was suggesting
Re:NASA images show China pollution clear amid slowdown by ars on Saturday February 29, 2020 @10:32PM (#22454950)
Killing progress of economy would make the planet much much worse off long term.

Notice how the richest countries have the cleanest environments - that's not by happenstance, it's because with basic needs met, people are willing to spend effort on the environment.

Re:NASA images show China pollution clear amid slowdown by hnews_account_1 on Sunday March 01, 2020 @01:18AM (#22455439)
What is this basic bullshit? Who makes China so polluted? Are the Chinese themselves consuming all the shit they make that makes their cities polluted? Or is it the rest of the world and China grew by being a massive net exporter?

This is like how the British lamented about the abject poverty in India after raping the country for hundreds of years. "willing to spend effort on the environment" my ass. Move the production chains back into those countries. We'll see how long the air remains clear despite temperate latitudes having the benefit of better weather systems.

Re:NASA images show China pollution clear amid slowdown by LessDmesg on Sunday March 01, 2020 @09:39AM (#22456987)
In the long run, economical and industrial progress is still better for the environment. The key is new technologies. There is no pollution that cannot be cleaned up, the question is only in the cost, and that depends directly on the tech.

Ultimately, any piece of trash or a dangerous chemical can be separated into atoms (e.g. with a plasma burner) that can be separated into pure chemical elements that then can be used to create products or chemically neutralized. The problem is only in the cost of energy, and that's, again, a question of tech. With fusion reactors, we'll have a way to solve world's pollution problems easily. So yes, developed countries ARE moving towards a clean environment. The solution is to move faster, not try to slow down the progress in economy, industry and technology with greenie measures that achieve only temporary pollution slow-down while postponing the real future solutions.

Re:NASA images show China pollution clear amid slowdown by xupybd on Sunday March 01, 2020 @01:51AM (#22455549)
As China gets wealth they will reduce their environmental impact. They will have the money to do so. It's not blaming them to state that poorer countries don't have the resources to clean up their production. Progress is required to develop clean energy, that will require economic activity.
Re:NASA images show China pollution clear amid slowdown by yibg on Sunday March 01, 2020 @02:36AM (#22455674)
There is a pretty strong correlation between wealth and environmental impact. Wealthier countries are in general not great for the environment.
Re:NASA images show China pollution clear amid slowdown by hnews_account_1 on Sunday March 01, 2020 @10:48AM (#22457306)
Entirely missing the point. It isn't "poor country has unclean air", it is "mass producer has unclean air". There are no technologies that rich countries are hoarding and using to clean their air that is too costly for poorer nations. If you moved all of this production back to developed countries, their air won't be clean either.

Just because China took the hit of having unclean air in order to manufacture stuff for the world's needs so it could raise its population from poverty, doesn't mean that they don't have enough money to get any rich country tech that can clean the air. No technology can work effective enough at the rate that China manufactures shit that all developed countries use without realising where it's sourced from.

[dead]
Re:NASA images show China pollution clear amid slowdown by boomboomsubban on Sunday March 01, 2020 @02:43AM (#22455708)
Even accepting you're incredibly cynical view of the Chinese state, they would care about nature as it has an influence on their lives.
Re:NASA images show China pollution clear amid slowdown by uk_programmer on Sunday March 01, 2020 @03:44AM (#22455854)
It isn't a cynical view. it is reality. The Chinese state have shown ever since Mao they have little or no regard for Human life. Off the top of my head (I am sure there is much more):

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Leap_Forward#Treatment_o...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1989_Tiananmen_Square_protests

https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-china-45474279

Also their response so far to the current Epidemic i.e. trying to cover it up has cost the lives of people in many countries.

But apparently I am being cynical ...

Re:NASA images show China pollution clear amid slowdown by LessDmesg on Sunday March 01, 2020 @09:46AM (#22457016)
They have even less regard for the environment. China's soil is polluted and eroded with callous farming practices, their animal life has been nearly exterminated thanks to their primitive beliefs in traditional medicine, their air and water are polluted with heavy metals (and whistleblowers are persecuted). This absolute disregard for the environment is one of the reasons China has become the world's industrial powerhouse in the first place: they literally chose to be a toxic wasteland to win the world's investment money.
Re:NASA images show China pollution clear amid slowdown by powerapple on Sunday March 01, 2020 @06:18AM (#22456383)
China reported cases to WHO by the end of December. Maybe they didn't manage it well (i.e. didn't block the whole city when cases were discovered maybe), it is a tough decision. It is so easy to say what to do now when you have seen everything.

How is British care about humans when they started forcing Opium trade to China?

Re:NASA images show China pollution clear amid slowdown by heavenlyblue on Sunday March 01, 2020 @12:04PM (#22457761)
British still lament about that, don’t be mistaken. Not all of them, but many still do.
Re:NASA images show China pollution clear amid slowdown by t-writescode on Saturday February 29, 2020 @11:50PM (#22455195)
It might also be able to be argued that those countries refuse to allow production that includes all those chemicals, so we offload that production to other countries that aren’t so strict, suggesting that we ourselves and our wants are a major source of their production and that all these advanced countries are doing a great job contributing to pollution, just through a middle man.
Re:NASA images show China pollution clear amid slowdown by seanmcdirmid on Saturday February 29, 2020 @11:54PM (#22455200)
Or that companies that could do the job with lower pollution at greater cost domestically are outcompetes by companies that do not have to worry about pollution. For example, China’s cheaper but polluting processing of rare earths drove everyone else outside of China out of business.

Trade agreements will eventually have to capture externalities like pollution to ensure fairness. Otherwise, capitalism will simply not work when different companies get to play by different rules based on their location.

Re:NASA images show China pollution clear amid slowdown by t-writescode on Sunday March 01, 2020 @01:13AM (#22455420)
Well, capitalism will continue to work great at what it does. The problem is that pollution isn't really something capitalism tends to select for.
Re:NASA images show China pollution clear amid slowdown by yibg on Sunday March 01, 2020 @02:38AM (#22455685)
That’s not because the richer countries are being “clean” as in consuming less resources and polluting less. They are just doing it less in their boarders. They are exporting the dirty manufacturing and in many cases literally trash to poorer countries. If every country became like the US in terms of wealth and consumption tomorrow we are all screwed.
Re:NASA images show China pollution clear amid slowdown by byw on Sunday March 01, 2020 @01:19AM (#22455450)
>Notice how the richest countries have the cleanest environments

Per capita rich countries produce much higher CO2 though.