Why are people surprised that if something is free (pumping CO2 into air) demand for it is high?
You are telling me that doing a charge of let's say $10 - $100/ton of CO2 wouldn't have a DRAMATIC impact on emissions? Is $10 - $100/ton too little for a supposed climate emergency?
There is so much funding and lawmaking and finger pointing and shaming - but still - dumping CO2 into the atmosphere if free and dumping remains high and people pretend to be surprised.
On energy: CA curtails (turns off) solar (and wind) power because there is not enough demand. In 2019 CA had 921,000 MWhs of curtailment.
Let's start by charging something for CO2 emissions.
The tax that applies to every single business, every single product, every single process, everything. The one that causes every single vested interest to come out of the woodwork and join together to make it politically toxic.
We tried this in Australia. It has killed every government that even dared to discuss it. And politically it is utterly impossible to defend e.g. "Carbon tax that raises power prices for pensioners".
Our carbon tax worked at reducing emissions, and at being low economic impact. It was removed because we are a corrupt banana republic, not because it's unworkable.
"The Largest Public Statement of Economists in History": https://clcouncil.org/economists-statement/
For a while. But if the carbon tax works and society switches to clean energy, then there is no more emissions and no more dividends pay to the citizens.
Moreover, I think the same model can apply to other negative externalities (aka, Pigovian Tax [0]). But to the extent that the public will someday complain that their carbon dividend is going down: (a) I call that a good problem to have, and (b) because the collective action problem now points the other direction, there's no individual incentive to over-consume such that the dividend goes up again.
Two birds, one stone.
Opponents of carbon tax and similar measures need to decide which they like less... some lost profits, an escalating carbon tax, and reshuffling their investment portfolios -- or food riots, mass migration, the massive resurgence of left wing populism, and even civil war, once the effects of climate change become intense and obvious to the populace.
Not to mention the water supply of Calgary and many other western Canadian cities is glacier fed, and the Bow Glacier that provides to Calgary may not be able to meet demand within the next 30 years... a problem that will only get worse with climate change.
Yes, the great lakes region looks better than most. And it will look desirable to a lot of displaced people...
We need to think past that point: how will the world look like once civilization has collapsed? What will still exist? What will not?
IMHO, the first step is to migrate coal power plants to capture and storage. It is much easier to drop emissions than to pull from the air. I would like to see more tax pressure globally incentivizing carbon release reductions. Instead you get weird stuff like Japan's carbon tax where coal pays the lowest carbon tax of gasoline and diesel.
Then pull it out of political discussion! We don't have political discussion about "how to hang people of color Q better" anywhere in the world (mostly) anymore because we've wrote it in the text of our f laws that violence and racial discrimination are forbidden! Not on the political menu anymore.
Same needs to happen with lots of stuff concerning climate, ecology, sustainability etc. - we need to restrict the political menu to only the right choices.
And use the states' monopoly on violence to enforce these choices.
Yeah, sure, you can philosophise in the most general terms but that's not how you get people and companies stop doing wrong things. You get them when the people/entities who want to re-bring the despicable things back into discussion can be fined / closed / put-in-prison etc.
I don't argue for eco-fascism. But with some things we need to be ruthless, especially in order to be able to carry on our peaceful, understanding and democratic discussions concerning all the other things!
The most direct approach would be to levy the tax at the time buried carbon is taken out of its geological grave, but good luck enforcing that globally. The most realistic approach (still a total sci-fi fantasy, with plenty of room for a dystopian touch) would be a fundamental removal of resource extraction sovereignty, implemented through a combination of military force and buying out whoever is currently in charge of representing that sovereignty.
https://www.world-nuclear.org/information-library/current-an...
History will not look kindly on this epoch.
For a prospectus of what could happen, I point to the large-scale devastation of (ancient) civilization attributed to the Sea Peoples (https://www.history.com/news/who-were-the-sea-peoples). They're believed to have toppled the Hittite Empire and severely weakened the Egyptian one. "some historians believe they had been displaced from their homeland by famine or natural disasters." -- the parallels to the anticipated effects of climate change should be clear.
Large-scale political unrest, very possibly including a WW3, is something I feel justified in considering "an existential crisis." Your mileage may vary.
Do you have a reference to that prediction of it probably killing 100's of millions of people? On it's own, it doesn't really mean much because what time scale and what's the no-climate-change number to compare to?
Forests are not the only option. Imagine large installations with tanks of algae under a white canopy. I imagine the economies of scale are huge once this is ramped up to industrial levels.
The question is who will pay for it. Nobody wants to indirectly subsidize coal plants on another contintent.
Now look at the gigatons of coal we already dug out of the soil and burnt. That's a lot of forests you need to plant, cut down, and turn into charcoal. It might be doable, but it certainly won't be cheap or easy.
Nope. Tree sequestration is extremely effective on a global scale. That's why it's so important that we prevent deforestation.
"Intact forests and those re-growing after disturbance (like harvesting or windthrow) sequestered around 4 billion tonnes of carbon per year over the measurement period — equivalent to almost 60% of emissions from fossil fuel burning and cement production combined."
http://theconversation.com/explainer-how-much-carbon-can-the...
In summary: its not as bad as I thought when I wrote the previous reply, sure. But it is still far from feasible.
I looked this up and seems it's the opposite. I'd politely suggest you check your assumptions are correct.
https://www.quora.com/Is-there-less-carbon-dioxide-at-higher...
https://667-per-cm.net/2015/08/04/atmospheric-concentration-...
There's a reason energy based on organic matter has gotten a bad reputation. It's just not a very efficient way of getting energy from the sun compared to e.g. solar.
The calculation for carbon storage will be a bit different, but not by that much.
Large scale solutions that help mitigate the existing CO2 are going to require some significant capital and operational expenditure.
The cheapest large scale solution actually requires less money, and more legal / willpower. But I’d argue it’s also harder to measure concrete impact and “monetise” oceanic surface iron enrichment. It’s harder to convince people to pay for estimated results even ones based on measurement and science, than results containing physical outputs, like actual solid/liquid/gaseous CO2.
GREAT work.
Two (small) comments: - Perhaps the review of the re-forestation option could mention that this has a number of positive side effects (outside of carbon capture), for example on rainfall and wildlife.
- as there is a time constraint on co2 capture (e.g. 2050), and as the various co2 capture solutions are not all at the same stage of maturity, it could be useful to have a table/chart that summarizes which co2 capture options are deployable now vs. at some stage in the future
> Briefly: there are plant-based, mineral-based, and chemical options.
Where are cryocooling-based options?
You carefully compress incoming air. Separate water vapors (and liquids, and hopefully not solids) from it. Cool this air in thermal exchanger - at this point CO2 falls off. Then you pass that air through turbo detander, which returns you some energy, and get a pre-liquified air, which pass to the thermal exchanger. Clean air of normal temperature is released to atmosphere.
You have to compress the air - but you also cool air, so compression is easier, and you also get some energy from the turbine where you decrease the pressure. Subject to optimizations. How much energy will you need?
A lot.
Air compression is not cheap, energetically. Chilling is also energetically expensive. You'll need to do both. This would be pretty much the "brute force" method, like O(n!) in software engineering. The concept would be to bring half the planet's atmosphere down to near its liquid temperature. Currently in most US homes, Air Conditioning (air cooling) contributes the majority of each home's energy use. This would be much greater than that, it requires chilling air to -140 °C to get CO2 to "drop out".
In contrast, seeding the ocean with iron would be fairly close to O(1). However, potential side effects of this process concern some scientists greatly. Googling 'Russ George' may provide more insight.
Side note: The press material for sesinnovation also says the outlet stream is nearly 100% nitrogen...that means they're using a stream which already has oxygen removed from it (likely because the air was just used for combusting fuels). Air is roughly 21% oxygen so you can't take air, only remove CO2, and get 100% nitrogen out. Generally these "Carbon Capture" technologies only work on feed streams with high CO2. So hey're placed at industrial outlets, where fuel/coal is being burned. These streams can be > 10% CO2. Often they don't work as well, or at all, on diffuse streams like 0.04% atmospheric CO2. The technical reasons why this is the case deal with "partial pressures" as well as general entropy.
Not exactly.
The idea is that you don't just compress air - and let the heated compressed air cool to the atmosphere in order to then expand it so it would cool some more, and then just release whatever's left back to the atmosphere. No, you use those leftovers to cool the incoming air - so you need to compress air spending less energy - and you also get the expanding air to help you to compress incoming air.
The principal point where you have non-reversibility is that extra cooling - making compressed cold air to do the work - which you need to reach necessary temperature. And you only need that temperature to separate gases; after that you can use the cold products to help with compression.
So - without colorful metaphors - I'd like to figure out how much energy will you need.
I see the approach of SES with flue gases. I'm not sure how it will look like with regular air.
Aren't there plenty of places where energy is so plentiful that you don't need to care that much?
Sweden's tax covers 40% of emissions from that country. Finland covers 36%. Switzerland covers 33%.
British Columbia's tax is lower, but it covers 70% of carbon emissions - a very broad-based tax. It will be USD $38 in 2021.
Personally, I think it's better for governments to focus on total coverage rather than the price. The more broad-based the tax is, the more efficient it is in shaping the economic development of the region. You don't want carbon "leaking" into sectors where it's cheap to pollute - that's inefficient. Far better to have all sectors equally incentivized to decarbonize.
Why not to cool down air so that CO2 would fall off? Cooled air can be used for pre-cooling incoming "dirty" air stream?
I made some slightly more detailed posts elsewhere but this article addresses your point directly. Essentially, this is not a viable method for removing CO2 from the sky, because there's so little CO2 in the sky that it changes all the basic physics assumptions.
This is actually relatively basic undergraduate level napkin math from a chemical engineering perspective, but outside of that discipline most people understandably don't have experience with estimating physical states of mixed gases.
You would use cooled separated products to pre-cool incoming stream of "dirty" air. CO2, having low concentration, won't fall off at -79C (or we'd have that effect in Antarctica today), but if you go to ~-140C, you'll have some results.
Why cooling process will produce greenhouse gas? You'd use energy from "green" sources to compensate for required expenses.
This isn’t something you can just assert as if by magic.
By using this kind of technology, you increase the total power requirements of our civilization. That power has to come from somewhere. If you earmark green energy sources for it, something else will need to use a dirty energy source.
This remains true as long as green energy production falls short of planetary demand (modulo carbon taxes/credits/caps which change the math here a bit depending on specifics). The leftover slack will be met by burning fossil fuels.
You have to build these cleaning devices, and you'll need to build energy sources for them. We do have both power and increase in power supply with time; the question is specific numbers, which I'm trying to estimate.
Every kWh of clean energy produced is far more effective at addressing climate change when it replaces a kWh generated by fossil fuel than it is trying to remove the carbon from that fossil fuel after the fact.
True. However, here are two significant, in my opinion, notes.
1) We already have a lot of CO2 in the air. We'd better get it out, and sooner.
2) We're proving every day our limited abilities in organizing focused efforts in fighting climate crisis, particularly by a single specific way. So, if we could reduce organizational problems by choosing a solution which has less of them, we could win in practice.
It's rather obvious that it's better not to get CO2 into the air in the first place. Looks like we can't avoid doing that now. So other options become interesting.
For a fun take on some of this see https://wattsupwiththat.com/2009/06/13/results-lab-experimen...
The chart in the article by the link suggests -140C would work for pressure of 0,0004 atm.
How did you get that number - >10% ?
a) adding even a little bit more greatly affects the CO2 levels b) with a global ppm of ~400, it basically means that you need to filter 2500 molecules of air to get a single molecule of CO2, and that's assuming perfect binding and effectiveness. There is no magic powder we can mix that'll cause CO2 to precipitate out of the atmosphere and fall to the ground like snow; it's a grueling energy intensive process to filter that out of the air around us.