I made some slightly more detailed posts elsewhere but this article addresses your point directly. Essentially, this is not a viable method for removing CO2 from the sky, because there's so little CO2 in the sky that it changes all the basic physics assumptions.
This is actually relatively basic undergraduate level napkin math from a chemical engineering perspective, but outside of that discipline most people understandably don't have experience with estimating physical states of mixed gases.
You would use cooled separated products to pre-cool incoming stream of "dirty" air. CO2, having low concentration, won't fall off at -79C (or we'd have that effect in Antarctica today), but if you go to ~-140C, you'll have some results.
Why cooling process will produce greenhouse gas? You'd use energy from "green" sources to compensate for required expenses.
This isn’t something you can just assert as if by magic.
By using this kind of technology, you increase the total power requirements of our civilization. That power has to come from somewhere. If you earmark green energy sources for it, something else will need to use a dirty energy source.
This remains true as long as green energy production falls short of planetary demand (modulo carbon taxes/credits/caps which change the math here a bit depending on specifics). The leftover slack will be met by burning fossil fuels.
You have to build these cleaning devices, and you'll need to build energy sources for them. We do have both power and increase in power supply with time; the question is specific numbers, which I'm trying to estimate.
Every kWh of clean energy produced is far more effective at addressing climate change when it replaces a kWh generated by fossil fuel than it is trying to remove the carbon from that fossil fuel after the fact.
True. However, here are two significant, in my opinion, notes.
1) We already have a lot of CO2 in the air. We'd better get it out, and sooner.
2) We're proving every day our limited abilities in organizing focused efforts in fighting climate crisis, particularly by a single specific way. So, if we could reduce organizational problems by choosing a solution which has less of them, we could win in practice.
It's rather obvious that it's better not to get CO2 into the air in the first place. Looks like we can't avoid doing that now. So other options become interesting.
For a fun take on some of this see https://wattsupwiththat.com/2009/06/13/results-lab-experimen...
The chart in the article by the link suggests -140C would work for pressure of 0,0004 atm.
How did you get that number - >10% ?