News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What made the 1960s CDC6600 supercomputer fast? by interrealmedium on Saturday February 15, 2020 @05:52AM (#22334518)
>10 MHz

>1964

That's insane. What's even more insane is that a bit over 20 years later homecomputers reached that frequency. And in the next decade they reached over 100 MHz. - Pure lunacy.

Posted from my 5 GHz homecomputer.

Re:What made the 1960s CDC6600 supercomputer fast? by dwheeler on Saturday February 15, 2020 @10:34AM (#22335827)
> That's insane. What's even more insane is that a bit over 20 years later homecomputers reached that frequency. And in the next decade they reached over 100 MHz.

The CDCs still had a good run. This line was originally released in 1964. It started at 10MHz, but that was 60 bit words, and special floating-point systems. IIRC floating-point multiplies were only one clock cycle; if that's correct, it took 100 nanoseconds.

The Apple II came out in 1977, 1MHz, 8 bit CPU and no floating-point circuits. You had to use many cycles to do any floating point, and typically you only used 32-bit floating point (because it was painful enough there). A single 32-bit floating point multiply took 3-4 milliseconds according to: https://books.google.com/books?id=xJnfBwAAQBAJ&pg=PA26&lpg=P...

The original IBM PC came out in 1981. Its clock was 4.77 MHz. But again, that was misleading. Internally the 8086 was a 16-bit CPU but its memory I/O was only 8 bits wide. It didn't normally come with a floating-point processor. There was one, the 8087, and I think the original IBM PC had a socket for it, but it cost big $$$ and the 8087 wasn't actually available for purchase until ~6 months after the PC's release. That one could go 4-10MHz. If you bought a coprocessor, you were finally getting to somewhat similar speeds for numerical calculations... but that was 16+ years later.

Re:What made the 1960s CDC6600 supercomputer fast? by abbeyj on Saturday February 15, 2020 @12:21PM (#22336501)
> Internally the 8086 was a 16-bit CPU but its memory I/O was only 8 bits wide.

Did you mean 8088 here?

Re:What made the 1960s CDC6600 supercomputer fast? by dwheeler on Saturday February 15, 2020 @06:58PM (#22338890)
Yes, 8088. Thanks for the fix. The 8088 was a 16-bit CPU with an 8-bit bus. The 8086 was a 16-bit CPU with an actual 16-bit bus.
Re:What made the 1960s CDC6600 supercomputer fast? by Accujack on Monday February 17, 2020 @03:35PM (#22350475)
Interestingly, the original "sx" designation for Intel 386 chips (80386sx) meant the same sort of thing... the 386sx was a 32 bit chip with a 16 bit bus. The dx was 32/32.

A product generation later, Intel changed what this meant to indicate whether or not the CPU had an on-chip FPU.

Re:What made the 1960s CDC6600 supercomputer fast? by B1FF_PSUVM on Saturday February 15, 2020 @02:07PM (#22337205)
> If you bought a coprocessor,

Those were the days you looked at the TRW multipliers (packed in 64+ pin DIPs) advertised in trade magazines like auto buffs might at V8 engines ...

Intel sold their own 8087, until it was digested into the vast expanses of CPU chips opened by scaling.

Re:What made the 1960s CDC6600 supercomputer fast? by tpmx on Saturday February 15, 2020 @08:30AM (#22335169)
Seymour Cray had a number of fantastic early designs:

CDC-6600, 1964: 60-bit processor @ 10 MHz, 2 MIPS, 1 MFLOPS

CDC-7600, 1967: 60-bit processor @ 36 MHz, 15 MIPS, 36 MFLOPS

Cray-1, 1975: 64-bit processor @ 80 MHz, 80 MIPS, 160 MFLOPS

I think this means that if a corresponding development in video coprocessors had been taking place (there wasn't really a recognized need for them back then, as far as I can tell), the CDC-6600 could have been running Wolfenstein 3D decently well in 1964, 28 years before the launch in 1992.

And the CDC-7600 could have been running DOOM decently well in 1967, 26 years before the launch in 1993.

Re:What made the 1960s CDC6600 supercomputer fast? by kragen on Saturday February 15, 2020 @10:32AM (#22335815)
The first commercial GPU might have been the LDS-1 from Utah in 1969, which was indeed used for FPS gaming: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/LDS-1_(Line_Drawing_System-1...

But it built on the history of “display processors” already in use: http://www.cap-lore.com/Hardware/Wheel.html

I had thought that computers of the time didn't have enough RAM for a framebuffer, but evidently the CDC6600 did, with what we would call 982 kilobytes today.

Re:What made the 1960s CDC6600 supercomputer fast? by RantyDave on Saturday February 15, 2020 @05:28PM (#22338474)
Dedicated matrix multiply in 1969. Damn! people in the past, they were nuts.
Re:What made the 1960s CDC6600 supercomputer fast? by tpmx on Monday February 17, 2020 @12:48PM (#22349230)
I get this realization all of the time when reading about and exploring past innovations (it's one of my primary hobbies). The really smart people back then were just as smart as the really smart people today. It's just they had crappier tech and less knowledge to work with.

"On the shoulder of giants" is an old and very true statement.

Re:What made the 1960s CDC6600 supercomputer fast? by Accujack on Monday February 17, 2020 @03:37PM (#22350489)
It was originally meant as a dig at the height of some fellow scientists, really.
Re:What made the 1960s CDC6600 supercomputer fast? by tpmx on Saturday February 15, 2020 @02:00PM (#22337154)
Yeah, I guess bitmapped "GPUs" were considered an extreme luxuary/waste of money back then.
Re:What made the 1960s CDC6600 supercomputer fast? by kragen on Sunday February 16, 2020 @07:25PM (#22344639)
I suspect they were considered an inefficient use of memory. The TX-0 and PDP-1 had screens of about a million points. For uses like plotting data, playing video games, or drafting mechanical linkages, this resolution is highly desirable — I've done CAD on a 320×200 CGA screen, and the screen resolution was extremely limiting. (For those who haven't used one, this resolution is such that you can fit 25 lines of 40-column text on it before readability starts to suffer.)

You could imagine putting something like a 320×200 CGA on a CDC 6600, taking what we would now call 16000 bytes of memory, at a cost of around US$40 000 in 1965 (https://jcmit.net/memoryprice.htm says). But it seems like it would be hard to justify that as a good alternative to adding those 16000 bytes to the machine's main memory, supplying an extra 1.6% of its address space with storage and allowing it to tackle problems that were, say, 5% larger.

(There may also have been a question of memory speed. The memory cited above that cost US$2.50 a bit was core, and maybe it had a 300 ns cycle time; a 320×200 display at 50 Hz minimally requires a 312.5 ns dot clock, and probably quite a bit faster than that because of the blanking intervals, so you might have needed two to four memory banks just to satisfy the RAMDAC's hunger for pixels. Of course they wouldn't have called it a "RAMDAC" or "dot clock" at the time.)

Re:What made the 1960s CDC6600 supercomputer fast? by RantyDave on Saturday February 15, 2020 @05:26PM (#22338463)
There still are GPU's that work by rendering the entire display list for every line. Yes, ie thousands of times a second. https://www.ftdichip.com/EVE/EVEProducts.htm
Re:What made the 1960s CDC6600 supercomputer fast? by tpmx on Monday February 17, 2020 @01:01PM (#22349317)
That's fascinating! Can you tell us more about their typical use cases?

I mean.. I did see https://www.ftdichip.com/EVE/EVEApplications.htm .. but, in reality?

Are you based out of Taiwan?

Re:What made the 1960s CDC6600 supercomputer fast? by krallja on Saturday February 15, 2020 @12:54PM (#22336729)
Well, now I know what story is going to show up on HN next month

“Wolfenstein 3D on my basement CDC 6600”

Re:What made the 1960s CDC6600 supercomputer fast? by tomohawk on Saturday February 15, 2020 @03:46PM (#22337865)
The Cray's were hard 64 bit machines - smallest addressable unit was 64 bits. This had a lot of implications for software and computer languages that assumed you could easily access bytes.
Re:What made the 1960s CDC6600 supercomputer fast? by tpmx on Monday February 17, 2020 @12:51PM (#22349252)
Ahh..
Re:What made the 1960s CDC6600 supercomputer fast? by blattimwind on Saturday February 15, 2020 @07:35AM (#22334891)
ECL logic systems reached effective clock frequencies in excess of 500 MHz in the late 60s or so. It was extremely fast compared to contemporary RTL/TTL logic.
Re:What made the 1960s CDC6600 supercomputer fast? by ajross on Saturday February 15, 2020 @12:32PM (#22336581)
Exactly. It was MOS that lagged, not "transistors" or "computers", really. Transistorized microwave circuits (analog, not digital) in the GHz range were operating as early as the 1960's too.

MOS is just hard. It's hard to fabricate, it's hard to design (i.e. you need computers to make computers!), it's hard to scale. It required new chemistries be invented and new circuit design techniques to manage the (really tiny!) components. So for a long time you could have a big circuit in discrete bipolar components which ran fast or a tiny one in MOS which was slow.

But MOS was tiny and MOS was cheap. So by the early 90's it had caught up in speed with all but the fastest discrete technologies (GaAs was "right around the corner" for like two decades as it kept getting lapped by routine process shrinks -- now no one remembers it) and the market abandoned everything else.

Re:What made the 1960s CDC6600 supercomputer fast? by kken on Saturday February 15, 2020 @12:54PM (#22336723)
>MOS is just hard

I think the important point is that "MOS scales". All the bipolar technologies never had anything like Dennard scaling, which was the backbone of Moores Law.

Re:What made the 1960s CDC6600 supercomputer fast? by blattimwind on Monday February 17, 2020 @02:23PM (#22349915)
Case in point, you could get bipolar ECL RAM in the 80s with access times of around 1-2 ns (which is at least four times faster than the fastest DDR-SDRAM in 2020). Except those things would have a few kilobits at most and burn a Watt or two; an entire 16 GB stick of DDR4 doesn't require much more than that. (This is SRAM of course; you can't build good DRAM on a bipolar process, and MOS SRAM is much faster than DRAM as well. However, MOS SRAM in the 80s would have access times of 20-150 ns; it's typically the suffix of the part number, e.g. 62256-70)
Re:What made the 1960s CDC6600 supercomputer fast? by mark-r on Saturday February 15, 2020 @10:26AM (#22335791)
I worked at the company Jim Thornton founded after he left CDC, Network Systems. Each network adapter box had a custom processor implemented in ECL.
Re:What made the 1960s CDC6600 supercomputer fast? by cptnapalm on Saturday February 15, 2020 @09:00AM (#22335324)
I had not heard of ECL before. Thank you for popping in with this.
Re:What made the 1960s CDC6600 supercomputer fast? by bonzini on Saturday February 15, 2020 @10:15AM (#22335740)
These days ECL lives on as CML, which is similar and mostly used for signal transmission. It's very fast so HDMI uses it. Some crypto circuits use CML logic too, because it's less susceptible to side channel attacks.
Re:What made the 1960s CDC6600 supercomputer fast? by dfox on Saturday February 15, 2020 @11:24AM (#22336122)
Almost all modern fast serial interfaces are descended from ECL. Often with a twist that while receiver is ECL/CML-style long-tailed pair (which is the obvious implementation of comparator), the transmit side is normal CMOS totem-pole output stage coupled with some passive network to produce right voltage levels (and right output impedance).
Re:What made the 1960s CDC6600 supercomputer fast? by analognoise on Sunday February 16, 2020 @01:10AM (#22340092)
Wait, what? You can do a MOS long-tail pair just fine, can't you? Similarly for a totem pole with BJTs.

They're topological circuit constructions that work for either family - aren't they?