News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental probl... by emn13 on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @08:48AM (#22298402)
Also why anti-monopoly laws need to be reevaluated, and improved to ensure nothing counts as a market with fewer than 10 practical competitors at any given moment, and probably more like 100 for real competition (or some similar set of thresholds to ensure flexibility).

We've sacrificed meaningful constant progress at the altar of relatively speaking small economies of scale. That's a win... for the first few years; and a loss for the hundreds thereafter.

There's nothing necessarily wrong with a segment where there's essentially one one or two providers; some things may be natural monopolies. But if so - those suppliers are essentially governments of their fiefdoms, and deserve similar restrictions, including most particularly, no incentive-distorting profit motive.

Re:Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental probl... by magduf on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @10:37AM (#22299257)
You can't have 100 aerospace companies doing big projects; the economy just isn't that large.

For very mature industries, I believe studies have found that the optimal number of competitors is usually 3 large companies. For immature industries with a lot of change and innovation, that number is generally higher, but as the industry matures, players either die off or merge. A good example of this is the American auto industry.

Re:Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental probl... by wonderwonder on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @01:02PM (#22300743)
Generally I would say this is a good measure for companies that serve individuals. Person A shops around and buys a car that most meets their needs/budget. This goes out the window once you enter the world of government contracts, especially large scale ones. You currently have a few large companies; Boeing, Lockheed, Northrop, etc. that land all the major contracts. The landing of these contracts though is for the most part based on government lobbying, the assurance of a nice private sector job post government retirement and a large helping of 'this is the way we have always done it'. This has recently led to debacle after debacle where the end user (the US taxpayer) is left holding the bag for massive global corporations that continue to profit. When there is an incident large enough to cause people to sit up and take notice, the ceo of the company gets a massive golden parachute and the company says 'see we took care of it. wink wink'. Look at the F-35, Littoral Battleship, and the subject of this article.

If the government started bidding out smaller real hardware contracts to new companies, we would see a rise in new competitors and an accompanying rise in quality and roi. To do that though lobbying would have to be severely curtailed. Probably not going to happen.

Re:Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental probl... by magduf on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @10:09AM (#22309358)
Sorry to reply twice, but I think there's more here to address.

First, the thing about cars doesn't work even for individuals, because it's not comparable. Buying an all-new spacecraft or aircraft isn't anything like buying a car. Cars are engineered and designed for a market, and manufactured in quantities of tens to hundreds of thousands or more. This is more like getting an extremely custom house built for yourself (think something like a Frank Lloyd Wright house, not a subdivision house): you have to find someone who can architect it, and someone to build it. Neither of these is easy because the house is entirely unique and not even like other houses. It's not something you can just go pay someone to do and not think much about, like you can with a car: you have to be actively involved in the design and construction process.

>If the government started bidding out smaller real hardware contracts to new companies

What companies have these abilities? Would you have a super-custom mansion designed and built by some random guy you met on a street corner? Of course not. You have to find someone who can actually do the work, and you have to be careful because a bunch of people will claim they can do it, but they really can't, so you can't accept their bids, and that means you have to do a lot of work in verifying they're capable of delivering.

Building a new spacecraft or airplane isn't trivial, and isn't something some small company can just do, like you seem to believe. How is a new company going to start up that can actually do these things? The only reason SpaceX worked out is because a billionaire started it as a hobby project, and even there, it's been at it for well over a decade now. Same goes for Blue Origin: it wouldn't exist if it weren't for some billionaire who apparently had nothing better to do with his time. Even going back to the old days, this is what happened with TWA and Hughes aviation: Howard Hughes was a billionaire who inherited his fortune and got bored with oil drilling bits. You can't just award a hardware contract to some tiny company that has no ability to deliver on the contract in a reasonable timeframe.

Re:Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental probl... by magduf on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @01:30PM (#22301082)
>If the government started bidding out smaller real hardware contracts to new companies, we would see a rise in new competitors and an accompanying rise in quality and roi.

Do you have any evidence that this would actually work?

Small companies generally don't have the resources to do large project. How is a small company going to build a state-of-the-art fighter jet? It's pretty much impossible. Look at other countries to see how they do it with small companies: they don't. The European nations basically have only a few large companies, the Chinese are the same, and so are the Russians.

The reasons America had a lot more aerospace companies in decades past are 1) planes were a lot simpler, 2) they were wiling to accept higher risk back then (some test planes crashing and killing the pilot was OK), and 3) the defense budget was enormous because there was a Cold War and the US's economy was gigantic thanks to being the only industrial power left standing after WWII. #3 is probably the biggest factor, and isn't going to happen again.

As for the stuff about golden parachutes, that's endemic to US companies in general, not just contractors. I don't see how it really affects competition much since everyone does it, except that it adds costs to American companies that, for instance, Chinese companies do not have, so it's probably bad in the long term for American competitiveness, but that really doesn't affect this argument for competitiveness between US government contractors (since they don't compete with foreign companies anyway). The bit about "a nice private sector job post government retirement" is pretty much the same: it's bad for American competitiveness, but doesn't affect things much internally, except that it probably makes upstart companies more competitive as far as costs go, but since acquiring contracts is very political it actually probably hurts upstarts since they're not connected the way the incumbents are.

Also, I should add they government actually does farm out smaller contracts to smaller companies. They even have a policy I think which causes them to do this more than they probably should, in an effort to help small companies. They don't farm out fighter jets to small companies, of course, but there are a bunch of processes that cause them to farm out small things to small companies.

The other thing that's important to understand is that most small companies do NOT want government contracts, if they're not already in that business. It's not like there's small companies that would be happy to bid on these things but are being prevented. In reality, government contracting is a giant pain in the ass, so the companies that do it are ones that are interested in it, and are good at it: their processes are set up to handle that kind of business model. Bidding on contracts is a pretty arduous thing and requires a lot of specialized skill and knowledge and special staff, so companies that aren't in that sector just don't bother.

Re:Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental probl... by coliveira on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @12:35PM (#22300423)
> A good example of this is the American auto industry.

Your example shows exactly why this idea is flawed. Three competitors is what is called an oligopoly. There is nothing healthy about that.

Re:Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental probl... by nickik on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @05:08AM (#22307529)
I would disagree with that. For a market like that 3 competitors in one country is actually probebly close to maximal efficnecy. There is such a unification in basic car concepts that adding more providers really doesn't add much.

Specially if there is also tons of international competition as well.

When there was a real need for a new company, because of EV shift, a new one happened. If it was a real oligopoly such could not be done. In fact the Big 3 attempt at using their market power against Tesla have mostly been marketing oppertunites for Tesla.

Re:Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental probl... by magduf on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @09:53AM (#22309222)
Don't forget, there's a LOT more than 3 competitors in the auto market. There's 4 in America now (Ford, GM, Fiat/Chrysler, Tesla), but that doesn't count all the foreign automakers, many of whom have manufacturing plants right here in the US: Honda, Toyota, BMW, VW, etc. Just looking at cars on the road, the "American" automakers don't even appear to have a majority of sales.
Re:Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental probl... by nickik on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @10:03AM (#22309305)
That's why I wrote:

Specially if there is also tons of international competition as well.

And Fiat is European now I think.

Re:Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental probl... by dangerbird2 on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @12:33PM (#22310768)
Fac is based in London, but it’s two main subsidiaries, formerly fiat and Chrysler, are still based in Italy and Detroit respectively
Re:Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental probl... by deelowe on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @09:49PM (#22305279)
The counter argument to this is that the auto industry runs on razor thin margins and is littered with failed companies. Hell, the entire industry almost went belly up in the late 00s. Just look at how much cash had to be funneled into Tesla, which is a small market luxury brand.
Re:Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental probl... by tonyedgecombe on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @12:27PM (#22300341)
I've seen four mentioned several times and the fourth doesn't even need to be that big, a small scrappy competitor can have a big impact.
Re:Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental probl... by babesh on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @02:06PM (#22301513)
One specific example of antitrust that wasn't handled properly was the Bombardier C Series and Boeing petitioning it for dumping. It resulted in one fewer competitor in the market because it forced Bombardier to sell the plane to Airbus.

I think that there will/can be competitors that spring out from the lower end. The trick is to prevent the oligopolists/monopolists from squashing them through manipulation of the legal system or other underhanded tactics.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CSeries_dumping_petition_by_Bo...

Re:Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental probl... by redis_mlc on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @10:56PM (#22305592)
> One specific example of antitrust that wasn't handled properly was the Bombardier

Bombardier is a foreign company that is heavily subsidized by the Quebec Pension Fund.

They probably were dumping.

I don't see how anti-trust applies here.

The CSeries is a fascinating story with so many twists and turns - almost unbelievable if it was a fiction novel!

The CSeries probably did not have a viable marketing and support story against Boeing.

If you want to get wound up, then the Boeing/Embraer Civil lashup is truly anti-competitive.

Re:Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental probl... by babesh on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @10:53AM (#22309806)
Re:Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental probl... by cglace on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @09:10AM (#22298576)
Should the government prop up 10 competitors in every industry? Is there a geographical threshold? If there is one plumber in a small town should the government prop up more or punish the one guy who wants to serve that market? Does market size matter? What if I discovered a super niche market that no one serves should we assume this market needs 10-100 competitors?

Off the top of my head I have 100s of other questions and problems with your idea. I think picking a constant number to apply throughout the entire economy is going to be fraught with edge cases.

Re:Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental probl... by TheOtherHobbes on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @09:29AM (#22298712)
The government doesn't need to "prop up" competitors. It just needs to prevent mergers and takeovers that limit the number of market players to an unworkably small number.

Yes, market size matters and the problem only really applies to companies who provide strategic infrastructure and services and are large enough to dictate terms to government, to customers, and to competitors, in ways that distort and limit their market freedoms.

None of this is mysterious or hard to understand, and it's been the foundation of antitrust legislation since Standard Oil.

Re:Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental probl... by ksdale on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @09:49AM (#22298868)
That's easier said than done. Often times, refusing to allow a merger will mean that one of the competitors will just go out of business, and avoiding that will require propping up a competitor.
Re:Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental probl... by Swenrekcah on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @10:01AM (#22298961)
Then go out of business they must.
Re:Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental probl... by greedo on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @12:02PM (#22300036)
The result of that is a merger on the cheap. The surviving companies get to acquire talent, patents, trade secrets at a far cheaper rate. This would essentially kill off any company's chance of merging if it wasn't relatively healthy.
Re:Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental probl... by ksdale on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @12:03PM (#22300043)
Right, I was just responding to the parent's assertion that preventing a monopoly doesn't require propping up competitors. Sometimes it does require that, and we should be conscious of the trade off we'd make in that situation.
Re:Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental probl... by PaulHoule on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @10:01AM (#22298957)
In the 1960s you had several passenger airline companies based in the U.S. such as Boeing, Lockheed, and McDonald Douglas.

Europeans got seriously spooked because they were afraid that if Italian Airlines flew Italian planes and such, fragmented markets would prevent any European company from being a viable player in the long term.

So they collaborated on the Concorde, and then the Airbus A300, consolidating the European aerospace industry quite successfully.

It costs a lot of money to train a pilot to fly a new aircraft, and on top of that you have mechanics, ground handlers, air traffic controllers and many other skilled people whose operations revolve it.

Thus there is some public and industry benefit to consolidation, but at the moment the competitive landscape looks very different for widebody (B787, A350) airliners where new technology is making it to to the public as opposed to narrowbody (B737, A320) airliners where the youngest design is 35 years old.

(Some of that parallels the lack of competition in the U.S. airline market which is dominated by narrowbody airliners as opposed to international flights on which you are likely to ride on a widebody. If you're going to compress people in all three axes to get them in a 737, why bother thanking them for flying with you?)

Re:Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental probl... by cglace on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @11:40AM (#22299822)
Antitrust legislation used to block mergers of companies that were 1000x smaller than standard oil and controlled a much smaller share of the market. How antitrust is interpreted and enforced is very much a moving target.
Re:Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental probl... by Nasrudith on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:22PM (#22303009)
I wonder how much of that was locality vs shifting standards. I recall antitrust receiving a defacto softening of standards by going from business impact to consumer impact (there are some things to debate there since effectively any merger which makes them more competitive would technically count some).

Essentially locality means Exxon and Mobil can merge but not the only two gas stations in town. Speaking of which I remember a few gas station chain mergers resulting in closing of gas stations at an intersection not because they were redundant but laws against the same owner having separate gas stations within a certain distance.

Re:Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental probl... by nickik on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @05:17AM (#22307578)
You historical knowlage is just wrong here. In fact the 'foundation' of anti-trust has changed a lot since Standard Oil and the Progressive 'Trust Busters'.

We have since realized that Anti-Trust in the Progressive period basically was applied with very little oversight and it was not applied consistantly. It was basically a way for politicans to go after the competition of their funders. This part of Anti-Trust history is often ignored in the glorifited 'Progessives fight evil capitalists'-story that is now so popular with the modern progressives.

Under the new rules, that the judges (specifically Richard Posner) came up with you actually have to show consumers were harmed. And since then all Anti-Trust cases are judged according to that criteria. And unsurprisingly the amount of Anti-Trust conviction has gone to basically nothing.

Standard Oil being case and point, during Standard Oil the oil price consistantly went down and the quality improved. The people that ran amoke against it were not in fact the poor consumers but rather local oil companies that were getting their ass handed to them by Standard Oil. They simply could not compete with the price or the quality.

Re:Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental probl... by ncallaway on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @09:48AM (#22298858)
> Should the government prop up 10 competitors in every industry?

This questions seems answered by the comment it's replying to. The previous poster said:

> There's nothing necessarily wrong with a segment where there's essentially one one or two providers; some things may be natural monopolies.

So, that seems like an answer to your question: no. There are some segments where it doesn't make sense.

Re:Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental probl... by throwaway5752 on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @01:35PM (#22301157)
Bell/AT&T had an effective telephone monopoly during the time of Bell Labs. They invented the transistor, MOSFETs, Unix, C, lasers, information theory, photovoltaic cells, Shor's algorithm, CCDs (basis for CMOS)...

It's not in the sweet spot of this forum, but aerospace research is incredibly capital intensive and difficult. There are economies of scale of combined R&D departments. Those labs don't last forever, but I hope my example of Bell Labs shows how productive and important they can be. You would not achieve that with Boeing divided into 10 parts.

This doesn't even go into just how impractical that is for commercial aerospace. The overhead for flying multiple types of aircraft is huge. Simulators are very expensive to produce. Pilots need large numbers of hours on different planes. It would be a maintenance nightmare since parts are tested more than anything outside of medicine and similarly stringent supply chains. The market won't support 10 commercial aircraft companies.

Re:Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental probl... by magduf on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @01:43PM (#22301253)
The problem with this argument is that Boeing hasn't produced any innovation lately that I can see, while their much smaller competitor, SpaceX, is the one that came up with reusable rockets that can land themselves.

Things were really different back in the days of Bell Labs when those inventions were made (another example is Xerox and PARC). Companies like those invested heavily in R&D; long-term stability and profitability was more important than next-quarter returns. This just isn't the case in America any more.

Re:Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental probl... by travisporter on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @02:24PM (#22301700)
As a counterexample, what is your take on the current outcroppings of LEO launch providers? Surely they are also quite capital intensive.
Re:Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental probl... by Nasrudith on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:45PM (#22303242)
While capital certainly forms a barrier to entry benefits at scale has more of an effect on the equilibrium. Lets say that there is a rough quality/profitability function vs size called EOS. More money can help skip to the far end but if it doesn't give enough of an edge there isn't much point. A given field's capital requirements and EOS aren't independent but neither are they necessarily always driven by capital requirements.

Essentially capital intensive makes it harder to enter and reduces the rate of attempts while EOS affects how well they can actually compete when they get there. Take Microsoft establishing the XBox Console ve Bing. Both took large ammounts of capital to launch but one is a success while the other is generally regarded as a joke. Once they got large enough as a platform the Xbox was "on the map" and a significant segment here to stay. Bing meanwhile remains a "second best".

Other examples of EOS in action - while there are larger law firms they haven't consolidated, and most artists take commissions independently instead of forming a megaconglomerate. They don't get much of anything from it due to specialization and lack of shared demand.

One example of EOS shifting is the decline of music producers with digital music and the rise of independent artists - the higher scale lost the relative edge.

Re:Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental probl... by throwaway5752 on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:12PM (#22302909)
You mean SpaceX?

I don't think large R&D orgs have a monopoly on innovation. And they aren't guaranteed to produce good results. In context, though, the US put people on the moon 50 years ago at the cost in present dollars of $.5T. Easily that much or more has probably been invested in the defense side of rocket development. I think SpaceX was applying 50 years of incremental improvements to a technology that was relatively stagnant ("it just works" conservative approach/lower government funding/general risk aversion profile). This is not to slight them at all, just putting it in perspective.

But look at the payloads. Right now it's satellites/cargo. They still haven't done a manned mission. Commercial aircraft fly thousands of miles per day and carry hundreds of people. They do this while being repaired by different teams around the world.

It's not as glamorous, but incremental updates in adhesives, radar, rivets, and other safety and repairability are big deals and R&D into safety and reliability shouldn't be discounted. That's on top of the satellite division and Phantom Works (sustained and controlled hypersonic scramjet, wings that change shape). I am not a rocket scientist, so take it all with a grain of salt.

Re:Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental probl... by redis_mlc on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @10:52PM (#22305569)
> They still haven't done a manned mission.

Good. What a waste of resources.

> Commercial aircraft fly thousands of miles per day and carry hundreds of people.

Jet engines are more reliable than rocket engines, and will always be.

Re:Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental probl... by bumby on Friday February 21, 2020 @09:06AM (#22383145)
> What a waste of resources.

In your opinion, what should be the end goal worthy of resource allocation in the space sector?

Re:Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental probl... by travisporter on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @11:23AM (#22310112)
I was actually thinking of Rocketlab, Vector, etc, but I definitely agree with overall sentiment. Reality is new R&D happens slowly unfortunately.