News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental probl... by throwaway5752 on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @01:35PM (#22301157)
Bell/AT&T had an effective telephone monopoly during the time of Bell Labs. They invented the transistor, MOSFETs, Unix, C, lasers, information theory, photovoltaic cells, Shor's algorithm, CCDs (basis for CMOS)...

It's not in the sweet spot of this forum, but aerospace research is incredibly capital intensive and difficult. There are economies of scale of combined R&D departments. Those labs don't last forever, but I hope my example of Bell Labs shows how productive and important they can be. You would not achieve that with Boeing divided into 10 parts.

This doesn't even go into just how impractical that is for commercial aerospace. The overhead for flying multiple types of aircraft is huge. Simulators are very expensive to produce. Pilots need large numbers of hours on different planes. It would be a maintenance nightmare since parts are tested more than anything outside of medicine and similarly stringent supply chains. The market won't support 10 commercial aircraft companies.

Re:Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental probl... by magduf on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @01:43PM (#22301253)
The problem with this argument is that Boeing hasn't produced any innovation lately that I can see, while their much smaller competitor, SpaceX, is the one that came up with reusable rockets that can land themselves.

Things were really different back in the days of Bell Labs when those inventions were made (another example is Xerox and PARC). Companies like those invested heavily in R&D; long-term stability and profitability was more important than next-quarter returns. This just isn't the case in America any more.

Re:Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental probl... by travisporter on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @02:24PM (#22301700)
As a counterexample, what is your take on the current outcroppings of LEO launch providers? Surely they are also quite capital intensive.
Re:Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental probl... by Nasrudith on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:45PM (#22303242)
While capital certainly forms a barrier to entry benefits at scale has more of an effect on the equilibrium. Lets say that there is a rough quality/profitability function vs size called EOS. More money can help skip to the far end but if it doesn't give enough of an edge there isn't much point. A given field's capital requirements and EOS aren't independent but neither are they necessarily always driven by capital requirements.

Essentially capital intensive makes it harder to enter and reduces the rate of attempts while EOS affects how well they can actually compete when they get there. Take Microsoft establishing the XBox Console ve Bing. Both took large ammounts of capital to launch but one is a success while the other is generally regarded as a joke. Once they got large enough as a platform the Xbox was "on the map" and a significant segment here to stay. Bing meanwhile remains a "second best".

Other examples of EOS in action - while there are larger law firms they haven't consolidated, and most artists take commissions independently instead of forming a megaconglomerate. They don't get much of anything from it due to specialization and lack of shared demand.

One example of EOS shifting is the decline of music producers with digital music and the rise of independent artists - the higher scale lost the relative edge.

Re:Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental probl... by throwaway5752 on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:12PM (#22302909)
You mean SpaceX?

I don't think large R&D orgs have a monopoly on innovation. And they aren't guaranteed to produce good results. In context, though, the US put people on the moon 50 years ago at the cost in present dollars of $.5T. Easily that much or more has probably been invested in the defense side of rocket development. I think SpaceX was applying 50 years of incremental improvements to a technology that was relatively stagnant ("it just works" conservative approach/lower government funding/general risk aversion profile). This is not to slight them at all, just putting it in perspective.

But look at the payloads. Right now it's satellites/cargo. They still haven't done a manned mission. Commercial aircraft fly thousands of miles per day and carry hundreds of people. They do this while being repaired by different teams around the world.

It's not as glamorous, but incremental updates in adhesives, radar, rivets, and other safety and repairability are big deals and R&D into safety and reliability shouldn't be discounted. That's on top of the satellite division and Phantom Works (sustained and controlled hypersonic scramjet, wings that change shape). I am not a rocket scientist, so take it all with a grain of salt.

Re:Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental probl... by redis_mlc on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @10:52PM (#22305569)
> They still haven't done a manned mission.

Good. What a waste of resources.

> Commercial aircraft fly thousands of miles per day and carry hundreds of people.

Jet engines are more reliable than rocket engines, and will always be.

Re:Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental probl... by bumby on Friday February 21, 2020 @09:06AM (#22383145)
> What a waste of resources.

In your opinion, what should be the end goal worthy of resource allocation in the space sector?

Re:Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental probl... by travisporter on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @11:23AM (#22310112)
I was actually thinking of Rocketlab, Vector, etc, but I definitely agree with overall sentiment. Reality is new R&D happens slowly unfortunately.