Ask HN: I need advice. Major problems with my business & co-founder
First off, I'm a regular HN member with 4-figure karma (if it matters). I'm at a loss and need advice.
I am the technical co-founder of a 5 year old company with $2M in annual revenue and 5 F/T employees. Over the past 18 months, I've become increasingly at odds with my business partner. My partner already has a relative working for us, then last year brought in a "designer" who is a close, personal friend and gave this person free reign on redesigning all of our print and web properties. Problem is, this person is a traditional graphic designer with no web experience. My design skills aren't superb, but I know UI/UX basics, how to measure and test things, seo fundamentals, etc. My partner has basically given this friend an executive marketing position.
Our traffic has been flat for a year or more. Our sales are down slightly. Instead of hustling, working on SEO/SEM, learning analytics and a/b testing, good product and customer development–basically all the things a non-technical co-founder should do–my partner and collegue waste countless hours dicking around with pointless design aesthetics or useless networking events. Over the same period, my partner has had personal issues as well (left his wife).
Last year, after some conflicts between myself and this designer, I told my partner this person had to go. He agreed but never followed through. When I pressed this issue, he simply claimed this person is "too valuable". Since then, we argue constantly. Maybe I'm wrong, but as I see it, a year + is a long enough "experiment" ... this person is doing nothing to improve sales, there's a major conflict of interest, and should go. With my business partner, we might be past the point where the damage can be repaired. There is definitely no trust on my part.
We each own 50% of the company and are the only board members. In multiple meetings with an attorney, I discovered that our company has no deadlock provision for resolving major decisions. Even more interesting–I never signed the buy-sell agreement in our corporate papers (he did). So, technically, I could sell my stake to anyone at any time–but he can only sell his shares back to the company. Other than an outside company acquiring all or half of the company, the only other option would be for me to move to simply dissolve and split or sell the assets.
There is so much technical knowledge about the business in my head, that I'm fairly certain it couldn't function well without me (at least not without a solid transition period).
What to do? I have a family and the company has treated me well financially. But there are a lot of things I still want to do startup and entrepreneur-wise. Do I give an ultimatum? Can I shop my half of the company to others in the industry without alarming them?
Thanks HN. You're a constant source of insight and inspiration.
If that's too drastic, why not add another stakeholder? Two more options:
First: you can make a strategic hire, like VP/Sales, or a "rock star" VP/Eng. This doesn't change the ownership structure but, with buyin from your partner, does put pressure on the company to manage itself properly. If your partner likes the new VP/Sales, he'll listen when the VP/Sales says marketing sucks and the networking conferences aren't bringing in leads.
Or, you could go whole hog and bring a third partner in. The dynamics of 3-person teams are very different from two-person teams, because you can vote bad ideas off the island. With a business putting 1.2MM or so away every year, you probably have a pretty compelling pitch; all you need to do is find a gap between you and your partner that deserves a board-level answer. It doesn't need to be 33/33/33 for you to win; 45/45/10 still breaks the tie you're in right now.
It's a very long story, but one of the anecdotes is how a non-technical founder (who owned ~49%, and was painted as a great maverick hustler, but not so great in a larger operation) got booted by the technical founder, and a third guy who was there as a tie-breaker (and also was the manager for a while).
The books here: http://www.wordplace.com/ap/index.shtml
If you are having so many issues with your co-founder, the feeling is likely mutual. It seems as though he may be a control freak, so give him what he wants- total and absolute control.
Be honest. If you want to leave, bring it up with him privately; if he wants you to stay, he'll try to convince you to do so, but if he wants you out, he'll likely try to help you exit, either through LBO or through an outside investor. But, try to take the high road if possible. A current employee, client, or general peer may be your next business partner, so don't sneak off.
Don't go the legal loophole route if at all possible -- no one wins in the long term through method of exit, except the lawyer.
I'm not trying to be combatitive, but I'm not sure this "buy me out" or "I'll sell my share" stuff is very productive. Is there really a market for 50% of a 2MM company, sold by the 50% of the company most responsible for its technical operations? The way this guy phrased it (he doesn't think the company will survive long without him), it's hard to see how he could even do so ethically, if a market did exist. Which... I'm sure it does, just not a price he'll love.
It doesn't hurt to have any legal, financial or other documentation pertaining to the company and your part in it that you may want, or need, set aside before these discussions begin. If things do get ugly you might end up spending a lot of time and money getting them later.
I can't count the number of times I've heard an employee (sometimes myself) looking for a change of scene say "I'm doing this place a real favour, staying on".
To be honest, we started at just the right time in a growing niche and money was easy for a while. We have a lot of competitors now and technology has changed a lot.
Hope that answers your questions.
I see you saying that you're concerned the situation may be past the point of repair. But the only real concrete problem I see is that you disagree about a designer. That is not one of the all-time great reasons to dissolve a partnership.
† Not a criticism.
Lack of growth is not really the fault of a single person. And your partner has emotional reasons not to want to fire this guy. Either view the designer as a temporary cost of supporting your partner, or figure out a way to train the guy into greater competence in his role. At a minimum, it sounds like you'll have to be the bearer of bad news if you let him go. Do you have a way to do this and save your partner face?
Tip: deal with all conflict with your partner face-to-face instead of over email. That will avoid people reading passive aggressiveness and latent hostility into communications -- both you and him.
It would be rather simple to set up a list of skills this guy is going to be required to get versed in to actually execute his job rather than be a resource black hole. If this guy can't get versed then there's clear reasoning to let him go and save your partner face. It's not being cruel or unkind in anyway, it's simply requiring him to do the actual job he was wanted for.
You could always be exceptionally mean and just force this guy to quit, but he'd likely do a lot of collateral damage on the way out.
In hindsight, I should have just fired the designer. But I was trying to be a good partner and go to him with my issues first. He agreed and said he would take care of it.
I think I've downplayed how much power he's given this person. Not just design of marketing stuff, but actual product UI design. Plus a lot marketing/budgeting decisions, etc. Basically this person has become or directed the entire face of our company. For whatever reason, despite no sales growth, my partner hangs on and defends this person's every decision.
If it matters, I'll add that this person is a woman. My partner has assured me that they are not in a romantic relationship and have simply become extremely close friends. I believe him–but many people on the outside get the impression they are romantically involved.
* Hire another product lead to manage the front-end of the project.
* Convince your partner it's time to seek outside funding to scale the business.
* Hire a VP/Marketing, VP/Engineering, or VP/Sales to add a stakeholder who will be objective and put pressure on your team not to make dumb decisions.
* Convince your partner to add a minority partner, splitting the equity cost equally between the two of you, so that you can have another person who is fully focused on the business (and, don't say this to your partner, to break ties).
* Hire a mediator to hear you and your partner out and agree beforehand that you're going to abide by their decisions.
* Wait it out. For ~3 years or so your partner managed the business, kept things organized, got people paid, did sales at least as well as you did, and generally made up for all the gaps you (like everyone else) had. When things calm down with his personal life, maybe everything will be fine again.
And given the work dimension, people tend to deny such things, and rationalize denial as being an entirely private and separate matter (even when it isn't). So while I regret feeding such suspicions, they're evident in your own word choices, and could explain the otherwise perplexing loyalty you report.
But why bother? It's probably not. The guy's partner: not so great at hiring, and not so great at firing. Firing in particular is very hard to do, and if you already weren't managing the role you need to fire properly (his team wasn't), it's next to impossible. These weaknesses describe 60% of all entrepreneurs, including a small chunk of the successful ones. Work the problem.
Also, when he said his partner is getting divorced... hey, 20-somethings on HN? That's a big deal. Extremely stressful. I'm not saying, "cut the guy slack out of empathy". I'm saying not cutting him slack might be a dumb business move.
Arbitration, litigation, and ultimatums all have their place in business, but sometimes the best case scenario is to just get out (dissolve, sell, etc.) Often times, the partner is just as upset as you are, so start by seeing if s/he'll privately buy your half, and if not, see if s/he's interested in shopping the whole company to new owners.
I understand that walking away from or selling a company with 5 employees and $2m in revenue isn't a decision that's a.) easy or b.) happens overnight, but it seems as though you've thought it through and are ready to move on.
One way or another, thanks for sharing, and let us know how it turns out.
If you want to try and fix the situation, you will need a major shake, a shock therapy, something to make him stop and realize that things must really change. Simply making small changes (like getting rid of that designer friend) is pointless. If he does it, it will be to silence you and to go back to his comfort zone. You need a larger agenda, things will need to be different after dust settles or you and him will be back to bickering in no time.
If, on the other hand, you've already communicated specific problems and the importance of the problems and he hasn't shown a good faith effort in helping you resolve these concerns, then you may need to part ways or otherwise restructure the company.
In your shoes, I would tell your partner that you don't feel like you're being treated like an equal partner... If you don't have veto power on any hire in the company, that isn't right.
If you can't find consensus on strategic or tactical decisions, then I'd ask for a negotiated split. You could sell the whole entity, buy his half, sell him your half, or something more creative. If you can't come to an agreement, you could suggest a mediator. But I don't think you can do anything without his goodwill, so I'd work on getting that. The good news is that he's in the same spot. Hopefully he'll be reasonable... And hopefully next time you make sure to have rules in place for stuff like this. I've always liked http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shotgun_clause
Who knows? They say a change is as good as a holiday, and doing something different may also re-invigorate you to provide more energy back into the original business. I know I get better results when I have multiple jobs to think about than just one.
Working two jobs sounds too hard? Some people work three.
But I agree with the other commenter who said it sounds like mentally you've already 'checked out'. Go the whole hog for a while, and start treating it exactly like just a paycheck. You want to do other stuff? No one is stopping you, but you.
I think a restructuring is in order. You can either leave (dealing with your half of the company in whatever way is necessary), or restructure the company so that you (as the person who seems to understand and run the business) have all of the decision power. Of course your partner will need something in return for this, be it cash, or the threat of leaving. Another option is to mutually agree on a 3rd board member for dispute resolution. Make sure this person can remain objective and make decisions that are best for the company.
Unfortunately I can't give you any advice on how to deal with your personal friendship with this person. You probably know best the way to amicably approach the situation with him.
As an aside--you'd find "Managing Corporate Lifecycles" by Dr. Ichak Adizes a fascinating and relevant read. It talks through many of the concerns you express and offers solutions I've seen work wonders in practice. For instance, you express things like--"sales are down slightly" and "collegue waste[s] countless hours." I gather that you and your partner haven't delegated responsibility and authority in the area of sales. That is, who is _responsible_ for your sales? You? Your partner? And then, that person must get the authority to make decisions affecting sales.
In practice, you would both make weekly/monthly/quarterly updates for the areas you are responsible (given the responsibility and authority over). If Jan 1 you agreed to give your partner authority for sales, they would give you a measurable commitment say 5% month over month increase this quarter. You would track progress in the W/M/Q meetings, but would get no direct authority over their technique (if wasting time works for them...).
This doesn't mean you'd get no _say_ in things regarding sales. It means you'd only be an influencer, but have no decision-making authority.
Maybe you find after a quarter that you the numbers aren't getting met by your partner. Then you discuss remedies--which might include hiring a salesperson or you taking on the role.
Anyway--all of this is great if you are hitting organizational issues in your growth, but have a strong backbone of a relationship that first brought you together so strongly and has helped you build a successful business. If there are other systemic issues you'll have to address them too.
Congratulations on growing your business to this stage. These are some of the better problems you can have!
Anyway, I think the major problem here is that you think you can't say the exact same thing you typed here to your partner and then resolve the issue. You may be right about that, but from the post we can't draw any conclusions. If you feel this bad about the current state of affairs, you should be able to sit down with him and explain (without making accusations, because you are definitely also to blame for having letting it come this far) how you feel and how you think the problems can be resolved. If that is not possible, then the question is: why not?
So, I ended up stoping negotiations with the BAs and focusing on raising a personal loan to buy him his shares.
Finally I was able to buy him out and signed with the BAs (who were extremely supportive in the process because they saw me manage all of this professionally... and I didn't use their money for my battle).
So, if you really don't hit it off with him, my advice is only one: "the sooner the better".
so once you have that straight in your mind, just divide and conquer all the available options, i can't give you specifics because i don't understand the stakes, but obviously this marketing person/friend of co-founder must go or be relegated to a lower authority or else the culture and quite probably the business will flounder. perhaps finding a different role for this person would be beneficial. things cannot stay as they are, that's for sure.
good luck on this and don't let this suck your morale down, it really seems quite the downer, but you need to keep a positive view on things. ultimately, if you don't get the terms that you want then there are always other options, including starting another company.
Here's how you tackle the employee issue. Implement quarterly and yearly reviews and goals. If an employee is not performing they get a 1) verbal warning 2) written warning 3) termination. Make sure the employee understand where they stand at all times.
Good luck with the other issues.
How much is the designer making?
Take some fraction of that salary and go out, without the knowledge of your partner and get better work done. Then come back and say "look at this collateral and web marketing design I had done - it cost 10% of [designers] annual salary and the quality is [n] X better"