News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Can We Have Prosperity Without Growth? by weeksie on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @09:04AM (#22235579)
The one fundamental reason why growth is so important is that without growth, the economy becomes a zero sum game. In order for you to get more money you must take it from someone else since there is only a fixed amount. A low growth world is one where we plunder each others' wealth, not one were the incentives are aligned with building new industry.

That's why productivity increases are so important. Without them, if we want growth, we have to get it from positive sum games. I'm skeptical that will provide enough to stop people from reverting to a more Malthusian plunder mindset.

Any vision of a non-growth world needs to take that into account. Without growth we'd have to fundamentally rethink how we handle distribution without reverting to bloodsport.

Re:Can We Have Prosperity Without Growth? by Mvandenbergh on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @10:13AM (#22236391)
In fact, in the pre-modern world there were large spans of space and time where growth was so slow as to be invisible within a person's lifetime and people did think of wealth as being zero-sum. To a feudal lord, land = wealth and being wealthier was about having more land. Someone already had all the land, so the only way of getting more was taking someone else's.
Re:Can We Have Prosperity Without Growth? by pif on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @11:38AM (#22237601)
As bilekas was saying, the one fundamental reason why growth must not be so important is that it cannot continue ad infinitum, thus we will have to learn and cope with that.

While you state an important point, the issue of growth having to stop (sooner or later) cannot be ignored.

Re:Can We Have Prosperity Without Growth? by SkyMarshal on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @03:41PM (#22240714)
Growth may eventually stop if humans remain constrained to Earth, but if we can advance to a point where we can mine the Asteroid belt between Mars and Jupiter, the wealth influx from that will be enough to sustain growth in human society far into the future.
Re:Can We Have Prosperity Without Growth? by anchpop on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @01:25PM (#22239067)
Why can't it be ignored? I think we're very far away from the point where growth is impossible. We haven't even left Earth yet. Imagine the amount of wealth you could create with a moon-based space elevator.
Re:Can We Have Prosperity Without Growth? by Kaiyou on Wednesday February 05, 2020 @09:11AM (#22246789)
The universe is for all intends and purposes infinite. Why shouldn't infinite growth be possible?
Re:Can We Have Prosperity Without Growth? by jdkee on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @09:20AM (#22235770)
1. If you look at the productivity gains in the U.S. over the past 50 years, the vast majority of the gains have been captured by a very small subset of the population.

2. A zero sum game in terms of the distribution of money is not the same as a similar distribution of wealth.

Re:Can We Have Prosperity Without Growth? by baryphonic on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @09:56AM (#22236168)
Why does this matter? If we expand the timeline to the last 200 years, the gains in agricultural productivity have gone to a very small subset of the population (around 2%). This is in fact the major reason you're able to write comments on the Internet rather than having to plow your field. I'd rather live in a world where we can maximize the productivity gains of the entire population and let us have more leisure than one which we jam the gears of the machines because we're jealous that any given productivity gain has a power law distribution.

Your comment about "distribution of money" and "distribution of wealth" makes no sense, but let's assume that by "money" you mean "income." By definition, looking at the distribution of anything is zero-sum. The problem is, growth has nothing to do with distribution and everything to do with production. Production is not a fixed-sum game: you can have positive-, negative- or zero-sum production at any given time. The chief question of production is how do we produce more wealth using fewer resources, or more efficient combinations of existing resources? How we should distribute that wealth, income and control over the products made is an ethical and political question (though I am strongly opposed to any scheme that seeks to deprive a person from owning the product of her labor).

Re:Can We Have Prosperity Without Growth? by weeksie on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @09:34AM (#22235911)
Neither of those points are relevant to the larger one.
Re:Can We Have Prosperity Without Growth? by JMTQp8lwXL on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @09:51AM (#22236119)
The first point directly contradicts your main argument; that without growth, economics is zero-sum. We have growth, yet none of that growth is captured by middle income people. The growth (and wealth) is being plundered.
Re:Can We Have Prosperity Without Growth? by mech1234 on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @10:31AM (#22236642)
It's false that none of the growth is being captured by middle income people. It is being captured to a greater extent by the very top of the income distribution and by the global poor, but income is growing across the board.

Real median wages and household income in the U.S. are higher than they've ever been.

This is all despite the increased international competition typified by globalization trends and detailed by the Elephant Curve.

https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/LES1252881600Q

https://milescorak.com/2016/05/18/the-winners-and-losers-of-...

Re:Can We Have Prosperity Without Growth? by JMTQp8lwXL on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @10:51AM (#22236918)
Your second link proves that middle income people are getting virtually none of the growth; at best, scraps. The difference between "none" and "effectively none" isn't a mischaracterization on my part. I will clarify by "middle income" I meant the American middle class, and not the global median.
Re:Can We Have Prosperity Without Growth? by mech1234 on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @11:08AM (#22237171)
I think it is a mischaracterization.

Notably, the graph provided at the second link covers a time period ending in 2008, the depths of the great recession. Things are numerically a bit better than depicted there. The overall story is the same- the bottom and the top of the worldwide income distribution is where things are growing fastest, but the middle is growing slower. It is certainly growing though.

10% real median income growth since the 80's is nothing to sneeze at.

Re:Can We Have Prosperity Without Growth? by JMTQp8lwXL on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @11:24AM (#22237394)
That's 10% total --over 40 years-- not 10% annualized. In 1979, the median real weekly earnings was $335. Today, it is $362. The actual calculation, 362-335/335 = 8.05%. Over 40 years, 8.05% is 0.2% annualized growth.

Let's compare to the S&P 500 index. From Jan 1979 to Dec 2019, the S&P has returned 746% (2,401% including dividend reinvestment) -- both figures adjusted for inflation (as is the FRED data). Annualized, these figures are 5.35% and 8.16%. https://dqydj.com/sp-500-return-calculator/

For bonds, that's 262% and 3.19%, respectively. https://dqydj.com/treasury-return-calculator/

10% over 40 years is absolutely something to sneeze at. That cannot be characterized as meaningful growth.

Re:Can We Have Prosperity Without Growth? by mech1234 on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @11:48AM (#22237758)
Another well-regarded source is the congressional budget office. The data linked below from 2014 is even more optimistic than my previous data because it uses household income instead of individual income. (because the distribution of individual incomes is skewed and growing even more skewed, median household incomes grow faster than individual incomes). The CBO data shows 26.1% growth in the incomes of middle quintile households since 1979. This growth is larger if you look at the lowest quintile, include taxes and transfers, or do both. The data goes up to 2014 and would show larger growth still if it went all the way to 2019.

https://www.cbo.gov/publication/53597

Re:Can We Have Prosperity Without Growth? by viklove on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @01:31PM (#22239169)
Is that just because more people are opting to live with their parents because they can't afford their own rent?
Re:Can We Have Prosperity Without Growth? by mech1234 on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @02:39PM (#22240029)
No. Household sizes have been getting smaller, not larger, over time. It would be pretty far-fetched for the combinatorial effects of mixed-income households to boost the median in spite of this.
Re:Can We Have Prosperity Without Growth? by viklove on Thursday February 06, 2020 @07:35PM (#22262024)
Well, people are having less children now than ever before. That doesn't mean those children are moving out when they reach adulthood.
Re:Can We Have Prosperity Without Growth? by duxut_staglatz on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @02:47PM (#22240105)
This is especially at the world stage. In a zero-sum economy, either some countries are left in an awful state of poverty for ever (no growth, same distribution of income) or people from rich countries must significantly decrease their consumption (no growth, equalization of income).

For reference, the average world GDP is about US$17,300.

At the OECD tax-to-GDP average rate, about $6000 would be spent through public institutions (i.e. taxes and public services). So that leaves about $11500 for both consumption and maintaining the capital stock.

The consumption of fixed capital is about 15% of GDP per year, so that leaves about $9775 a year, or $815 per month to consume stuff.

Re:Can We Have Prosperity Without Growth? by xenocyon on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @01:10PM (#22238858)
Your argument establishes that a free lunch is desirable, not that a free lunch is feasible.

There is a very good essay I came across relating a discussion between a physicist and an economist on the question of neverending economic growth: https://dothemath.ucsd.edu/2012/04/economist-meets-physicist...

It's worth reading in its entirety regardless of which side one stands on.

Re:Can We Have Prosperity Without Growth? by bilekas on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @09:05AM (#22235608)
Does what you're saying imply that growth can be perpetual ?
Re:Can We Have Prosperity Without Growth? by thegabriele on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @11:52AM (#22237819)
It should last until we get to strong AI or fusion energy, both i believe will have too much an impact to be again in the hands of the fews (perhaps a global war will be in order before).

Then, the problem will be about literally physical space on earth.

Re:Can We Have Prosperity Without Growth? by baq on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @12:45PM (#22238533)
don't forget about waste heat, we'll get cooked alive in a few hundred years of 3% yoy growth in energy produced
Re:Can We Have Prosperity Without Growth? by dwaltrip on Thursday February 06, 2020 @12:13AM (#22253593)
Yeah. To achieve 3% growth per year for several hundred years we have to expand beyond Earth. Beyond a few hundred years, it starts getting more difficult. I wonder how much waste heat Mars or other large bodies could absorb. Or what is the largest possible radiator we could build in space...

Some fun facts I calculated while thinking about this:

* 3% growth for 100 years is 20x

* 3% growth for 300 years is 7,000x

* 3% growth for 1,000 years is 7,000,000,000,000x

Re:Can We Have Prosperity Without Growth? by thegabriele on Wednesday February 05, 2020 @03:28AM (#22244978)
Yep, the constraint here is not to wipe out ourself in the meantime!
Re:Can We Have Prosperity Without Growth? by tryptophan on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @11:53AM (#22237825)
It only needs to hold up for the next 100-500 years. No need to talk about perpetuity.
Re:Can We Have Prosperity Without Growth? by weeksie on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @09:07AM (#22235625)
You still need energy inputs, so I'm not sure it does.
Re:Can We Have Prosperity Without Growth? by cjfd on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @10:32AM (#22236655)
This is incorrect. If GDP is constant it means that every year the same amount of goods is produced. There can be a new industry in this case. It just means that another industry needs to get smaller. The workers in the other industry can move to the new one and no one is worse for the wear.

GDP is the derivative of the amount of goods and not the amount of goods.

Re:Can We Have Prosperity Without Growth? by duxut_staglatz on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @01:13PM (#22238907)
So if 1. the same amount of goods and services is produced and 2. you get more goods and/or services this year than last year, this means than 3. someone else must have less goods or services this year. I do not follow where this was incorrect.
Re:Can We Have Prosperity Without Growth? by cjfd on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @01:58PM (#22239538)
Well, this response sounds a bit more measured than what you originally wrote but it is still seems a bit weird. For one thing, sometimes people consume less just because they do not need as much in a particular year. E.g., a person might buy a new car every ten years. Is he poorer in the nine years that he did not buy a car than in the one year that he did? That the amount that a person consumes may fluctuate is not very important nor should anyone start panicking about it nor as a signal that it is necessary to go into some fierce kind of competition.
Re:Can We Have Prosperity Without Growth? by duxut_staglatz on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @02:03PM (#22239594)
Durable goods obfuscate the issue, but let's take your example.

Let's say I want to have both an all-terrain car for the weekend and my regular car on the weekdays. I now consume two new cars very ten years instead of one. The same number of car has been produced in those ten years (no growth). Where does my extra car come from?

Re:Can We Have Prosperity Without Growth? by cjfd on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @02:19PM (#22239790)
Let us tell a bit of a story. You bought your two cars because your all-terrain car hobby is very important to you. This was a bit of a financial squeeze and you could not go on holidays as often as you liked. But since the car hobby is more important to you, you think you made the right decision and are happy about it. There is another person who thinks going on holiday is the greatest thing ever. He went on holidays five times last year. This was a bit costly but he decided he did not need a car that badly and could use public transport instead. This was a bit less comfortable but he thought the great experience of going on holidays five times was well worth the inconvenience. So, where did your car come from? It did come from the other person who did not buy a car but went on holidays instead. But both of you were happy with your decisions. No crisis situation or fierce competition is needed in situations where not everybody gets what they want. In fact, both persons might choose to forego a promotion that was offered to them and which would have contributed to economic growth because it would leave the one person with too little time for his car hobby and the other with too little time for this travels.
Re:Can We Have Prosperity Without Growth? by duxut_staglatz on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @02:37PM (#22240010)
Ok, so you are agreeing with the comment you said you were disagreeing with (zero sum economy means if someone increases their amount of stuff, someone else must have less stuff, otherwise the amount of stuff would not stay constant).

You are making a different point, which is that more stuff does not equal happiness, so we should not care about it.

Re:Can We Have Prosperity Without Growth? by cjfd on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @03:32PM (#22240601)
Your original comment talked about this zero-sum game being a very grim circumstance. It talks about 'plunder' and the like. This is in part what I was commenting about, noting that it is not necessarily a grim thing. The other thing is that your talking about 'stuff' and zero-sum games still sounds a bit off. I am wondering if you are not using the term 'zero sum economy' in one meaning while at the same time evoking associations with another meaning of that same term. The 'zero sum economy' (the one with constant GDP) is still an economy where everybody is enjoying the benefits of trade and specialization. In that sense it is still a positive sum economy and if you start doing the 'plunder' that your first post talks about and lose the benefits of trade because you now have bad relationships between people and everybody will get poorer. Hence the 'zero sum economy' cannot be one of 'taking things' and 'plunder'. Also, the comments about 'stuff' still sound off. In fact in the 'zero sum economy' the amount of stuff gets increased every year by an amount that is exactly equal to GDP. That is the definition of GDP. There is also stuff that breaks down but it is not the case that other people take that stuff from you, just the forces of entropy. Maybe you mean to say things that are all correct but it just sounds a bit off to me. I can't shake the impression that you are confusing yourself by talking about one thing while thinking about another and/or evoking associations with it. For one thing, It is still quite unclear to me why you paint a very grim picture of the zero sum economy in your first post.
Re:Can We Have Prosperity Without Growth? by weeksie on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @06:16PM (#22242208)
Oh why not. Normally I don't get involved in these, but since you thought it was me replying to you all along I feel like I should at least reply :)

What I said is not theoretical. We have examples of zero sum economies, in fact that's how the world was everywhere right up until the industrial revolution.

I would urge you to re-read my original comment, since I address the very point you're making about cooperation inside a zero productivity growth environment. You can pay positive sum games! That's great! However any wealth generated by a positive sum game is, by definition, growth. I'm suspicious that it could be enough to matter. Productivity growth is a big deal.

In any case I am not convinced that zero productivity growth + positive sum games are a stable equilibrium.

Perhaps you could have a zero growth society where frequent jubilees reset everybody's wealth at regular intervals, but I'm not sure how that would work in practice and I'm also not sure it wouldn't be just as bloody as a zero sum land rush after the reset. You could do this with very high inflation levels, perhaps. Might make a fun science fiction short.

I'm hoping you give me a generous reading here, since I have neither the time nor inclination to deep-dive on a lot of my points, and I'm afraid I'd be boring as batshit if I did.

Re:Can We Have Prosperity Without Growth? by cjfd on Wednesday February 05, 2020 @12:55AM (#22244367)
This sounds like a legitimate fear that one could have. I can't really say I share it, tough. Also, at some point one does have to note that economic growth cannot go on indefinitely, although it is quite clear that it still can go on for quite a while, hopefully in a way that is more environmentally sustainable than the current way things are going.

Another thing to note is that current world GDP certainly is not enough because it leaves many people quite impoverished so we certainly still have some growing to do.