No idea how valuable or inovative any of these patents are, but I think its important to note when discussing: "They're never going to look like they're on the cutting edge of some space"
I've worked with former IBM people - all (or some it seems) of them have a plaque of whatever their first patent was. When they talk about it they admit it was a trivial invention that is too specific to be of much use outside the one project (thus there is no value in keeping it from competitors). IBM encourages patenting everything and has people looking for things to patent. Most other companies only patent things that are unique and worth the costs. (keeping from competitors, licensing to competitors, or keeping competitors from patenting it and stopping your use)
They spent 6 Billion Dollars on research that year (late 90s)
But Its true, IBM Values patents quite heavily. You can see some of them they printed as wall paper in the lobby (Along with mechanical calculators and models of some of daVinci's machines.)
But they also have "Trade Secrets" which are things they think they're competitors won't figure out and if you don't patent it you aren't telling the world how its done. I think some of the chip chemicals and processes for working with silicon wafers were to be classified as such.
They seemed always to be pushing the researchers to make something they could sell..
As an aside, IBM Yorktown is an oddly round building..
https://www.google.com/maps/place/IBM+Thomas+J.+Watson+Resea...
They sold off their chip foundries and all IP to GloFo a half decade ago (and since then GloFlo has stopped all non sustaining R&D).
The arc-shape building reminded me Apple Park in Cupertino, except TJ Watson center was built decades earlier.
I like that the hallway was on the outside and hallways radiated out (and everyone had offices with frosted glass). It was a pain running pipes though as standard bend didn't quite work for that radius.
https://picryl.com/media/ibm-thomas-j-watson-research-center...
https://picryl.com/media/ibm-thomas-j-watson-research-center...
The library was a trip too. It was like what they thought the future of furniture was in the the 1960s. It was all in excellent shape.
I just finished (a light) editing of an English (machine translated) version of a book for someone I have a lot of respect for who is a Japan-based mentor of mine - Hiroshi Maruyama had 26 years in IBM research, eventually as the director of IBM Tokyo Research Labs.
In one chapter of the book he provides a view across a possible way to fix the patent system which I found interesting. It referenced ideas from the following paper - https://www.ibm.com/ibm/files/S376023B46442F89/building_a_ne...
Some of the key points of the IP marketplace were - fees for the licensee fee would be set upfront; - the patentee would pay a % value to the government as a tax; - if the patentee wanted to use the patent exclusively, a high licensing fee could be set, but that would also result in a higher tax being due to be paid.
The approach was to dis-incentivize bad actors putting monopolies on products via patents. It would also encourage higher utility value from patents under this system.
Another interesting concept Maruyama's book covered was LOT networks used to fight against Trolls. - https://lotnet.com/
The idea with the Lot network was that if a patent did get rights to a patent from a member of the lot network, If any of the patents from members falls into the hands of a patent troll, all other members are automatically granted a free license of the patent.
The book covers themes on how to do research in corporate organizations (the audience focus remains with Japanese researchers/students) and has some interesting discussions.
I will provide a link to the book when it is available (if there is interest).
The book is an updated version of this Japanese book: https://www.amazon.co.jp/gp/product/4764903822/ref=dbs_a_def...
First 5 low fees. Next 5 (10%) increased fees, repeat.
This prevents one company from amassing too many.
Also there should be some additional value to people not just companies for the government to be granting legal monopolies, and it should also be restricted to things that are actually implementable not extremely vague system level diagrams.
"On June 19, 2014 the United States Supreme Court ruled in Alice Corp. v. CLS Bank International that 'merely requiring generic computer implementation fails to transform [an] abstract idea into a patent-eligible invention'"
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Software_patents_under_United_...
He had a 6' tall metal filing cabinet full of lucite plaques.
In the farthest corner of the garage. It was all binned later that day.
Top patenters of 2017:
IBM
Samsung
LG
Intel
Canon(!)
Alphabet
Qualcomm (!)
Toyota
Microsoft
Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing (fab for AMD and other chip designs)
Companies I've worked for have teams that facilitate employee patent submissions, and they will tell you why patenting is important to the company. They have had some kind of bonus structure so that you get rewarded if you submit a successful patent. But they pay well enough otherwise that, unless you're personally motivated to see your name attached to patents, it's just not worth the effort.
To put this another way: the patents you author as an employee of a company are probably not that valuable to you. But, because of the potential legal protections they offer, they are very valuable to your employer. I think the companies that are more successful in having high patent counts are doing more to align employee interest with corporate interest w/r/t patents.
In short, there's incentive as well as assistance in filling up patents, they don't seem to discriminate on basis of usability, feasibility or anything else. They do give bigger bonuses for patents that are in one of the fields considered strategic for the company.
Listening to it was somewhere between amusing to depressing:
https://kubernetespodcast.com/episode/086-invention-ibm-isti...
The 360 was innovative in pretty much every respect. In the 90s IBM was the only one of the big Unix vendors to bet on Linux and open source.
Sorry.
- "seems to have made" is important. A decade ago, Watson seemed to be a lot of progress in the AI world.
- Where's the revenue?
although qiskit is open source so literally anyone can look at the GitHub and get a pretty good idea of what's going on
Could be Watson all over again. Amazing technology demo, but no viable business plan behind it.
IBM wanted to prove that they employed smart people, so they hired some smart people and had them write a computer program to play Jeopardy. Did it matter that it had nothing to do with anything they were selling? Perhaps only IBM has those figures.
The problem is you have companies like Google, Microsoft, Amazon, Apple, Facebook, etc have problems that this tech solves. It's easier to come up with a product with a problem that you understand. I can ask Google Photos or Siri to show me pictures of my dog in the snow in 2015, and they do. So I give Google & Apple money to store my crap. Google and Facebook use AI with all of the data they hoover up to peddle products to me. My grandparents get ads for depends, I get ads for drones, Google and Facebook make $.
Now, companies like Amazon, Microsoft and Google can go to companies that were prospected by IBM with solutions. Microsoft is minting money with ATP, because enterprise security teams suck. Amazon is selling creepy facial recognition to people, because people see it on TV, have a Ring doorbell, and want the capability. Google is selling GIS solutions, etc based on work done on maps.
No, the problem was that Watson would be unable to help you learn anything new about enterprise data. IBM didn't even have a plausible, non-trivial proof of concept to trot out six years ago.
In general, what they did was not trivial, but it also wasn't revolutionary. Some of it was novel, but novel in the sense that it applied specifically to the problem they were trying to solve. It had little impact on the technology behind what IBM eventually tried to sell as Watson.
Anybody with a bucket of money could have built the same thing at the time. The impressive part was IBM figuring out that it would be worth spending a bucket of money on.
Note : I am aware that there are "Watson" products that claim to be this - but they aren't because they are MBA's ideas of what the best route to selling crap to the unwary. If IBM had appointed someone with a clue and given them 10x the R&D budget for the gameshow to deliver a decent product I reckon they'd have got (at least) 100x. But... oh no.. promise 30x for 1x and get f-all.x^2
It's an epic fail
The "This is Watson" special edition journal[1] taught me more about traditional NLP pipelines than just about anything I've read before or since.
[1] https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/6177724?reload=true
It was certainly a stye in the eye for Google (“organize the world's information and make it universally accessible and useful”), whether facbricated by marketing/advertising or not.
I don't follow big iron as closely as I'd like, but I was under the impression that IBM is considered pretty cutting edge when it comes to mainframes.
There are some things that mainframes are legitimately better at, and some things that POWER is better at than x86, and so on. AMD and Intel benefit from incredible economies of scale that IBM could never dream of, and that's mostly where IBM loses -- the price is a lot higher and the volume a lot lower on the IBM side.
Was the PS2 one of theirs as well?
IBM has been in video game hardware for a long time.
They outsource everything to sub contractors (they still apply to rfi and rfp though and win sometimes) but won't have the resources to do the job.
edit: sorry. I misunderstood you. Some projects are delivered with subcontractors, of course. But I can tell you from inside that we still have a healthy GBS, GTS and Cloud Services, delivering projects.
Go to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_mergers_and_acquisitio... and sort the table there by value, descending. "IBM" is a shorthand for more (un-dissolved!) subsidiaries at this point than GE or Samsung.
IBM itself is just a consulting "solution provider" company that provides "solutions" in terms of the products and services of its subsidiaries. They're never going to look like they're on the cutting edge of some space, unless that's what one of their (equally-stodgy) enterprise clients wants to pay them to do. (And even then, why build when you can buy? IMHO IBM would only ever build a new technology at this point if there was no existing company out there in the market, with that tech IP, that they could just acquire.)
Certainly, there's the Watson AI lab, though I don't think anyone's expecting much of it at this point; nor, importantly, was anyone inside IBM ever expecting much of it. Watson (the lab specifically, not the brand strategy of calling all their cloud OLAP SaaS products "Watson") is more a nod to their clients to say "of course we're looking into AI", and a pool of people competent enough that they could clone the existing ML approach of one of their competitors if one of their clients demanded it.
IBM could be a really innovative company if they rearranged their talent pool, certainly. But innovation—getting ahead of the market and so needing to educate the market on the problem their products solve—hasn't been IBM's business model since the 1950s. IBM makes money by listening to clients' "unique" needs, and then meeting them with "custom" solutions at low CapEx cost, by using an ever-larger flywheel of existing solutions pre-tuned to almost fit every possible business use-case.