News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Climate models are running red hot, and scientists don’t ... by rayiner on Monday February 03, 2020 @10:54AM (#22225241)
> Total War economy/society > quality of life improvements to our health and well being this kind of mobilization would bring would be astonishing.

The impact on quality of life and society would be "astonishing," but they won't be improvements. The Soviets and Chinese tried similar "mobilization[s]" for food production. The idea was to direct society's efforts to producing enough food for everybody. Tens of millions of people died of starvation as a result. It turns out that governments are bad at running economies.

I don't know why so many people think that the same mechanism (a command-and-control economy) will lead to a different result just because you change the goal from food or industrial production to climate change mitigation.

Re:Climate models are running red hot, and scientists don’t ... by nesyt on Monday February 03, 2020 @11:23AM (#22225595)
Thanks for the straw man. American WW2 mobilization didn't kill ten million people - that's not an intrinsic attribute of a country focusing on something.

Think also new deal / public works projects like the Hoover Dam (many died working on the Dam but not because it was a government mobilization project). Just the government spending a bunch of money on environmentally focused projects could happen and could be good.

Re:Climate models are running red hot, and scientists don’t ... by nate_meurer on Monday February 03, 2020 @03:38PM (#22228745)
It's not a straw man, and your examples are no more apt than Rayiner's.

America's WWII mobilization is really nothing like the Green New Deal. The total cost of the U.S. war effort is estimated at around $300 B (adjusted for 2009 dollars) [1]. The lowest realistic estimates for the cost of an effective Green New Deal are around double that amount every year, and lasting for decades [2].

It's true that WWII cost far more relative to GDP (over a third, versus 2% for the New Green Deal estimate above), but expressing the cost relative to GDP is not very useful in this context; in 1945 the U.S. was poised to enter a period of ten percent annual GDP growth at a time that military spending was plunging. The situation now is completely opposite; the U.S. will possibly never sustain greater than 2% GDP growth, and the Green New Deal proposes to pull money out of that for decades to come.

The character of WWII spending was also completely different. That money was largely spent on things that were pretty much guaranteed to help the war effort; materiel, industrial infrastructure, and troops. There was little risk of misallocation.

In contrast, the Green New Deal is fraught with misallocation risk. In that way, I suppose that a comparison to modern military spending is actually quite appropriate.

1 - https://eh.net/encyclopedia/the-american-economy-during-worl...

2 - https://newleftreview.org/issues/II112/articles/robert-polli...

Re:Climate models are running red hot, and scientists don’t ... by adrianN on Monday February 03, 2020 @01:07PM (#22227015)
At least it didn't kill ten million people unintentionally.
Re:Climate models are running red hot, and scientists don’t ... by harryh on Monday February 03, 2020 @01:07PM (#22227019)
American WW2 mobilization didn't kill ten million people

Um, sure it did? Killing a lot of people was, in a sense, the goal.

Re:Climate models are running red hot, and scientists don’t ... by viklove on Monday February 03, 2020 @11:28AM (#22225666)
> It turns out that governments are bad at running economies.

Extrapolating a general theory from just two examples seems like a mistake.

Re:Climate models are running red hot, and scientists don’t ... by gmueckl on Monday February 03, 2020 @11:33AM (#22225733)
Well, what other experimental data is there? If these incidents are the only data points, then that's the natural extrapolation, even though it is only weakly supported.
Re:Climate models are running red hot, and scientists don’t ... by claudeganon on Monday February 03, 2020 @12:01PM (#22226092)
As someone else pointed out, the New Deal, which gave us massive infrastructure projects that we still rely on and helped set the stage for postwar prosperity.
Re:Climate models are running red hot, and scientists don’t ... by rayiner on Monday February 03, 2020 @12:33PM (#22226524)
The impact of the New Deal on post-war prosperity is debatable, but I want to focus on two different points. First, the New Deal mobilization is small in comparison to what has been proposed in the context of the "Green New Deal." From 1930 to 1940, total government spending (at all levels), jumped from 12% to 18%. That's 6% of GDP, or about $1.17 trillion annually. It's unclear what folks who use the phrase "total war mobilization" mean. If you're talking about the Green New Deal's proposal of hitting 0 carbon emissions within a decade, that's not close to enough: https://www.factcheck.org/2019/03/how-much-will-the-green-ne...

> Pollin, however, strongly disagrees with the resolution’s aim of getting to net zero with just a decade of investment. “I think it’s completely unrealistic and it’s not worth costing out,” he said of the Green New Deal.

$1 trillion is the price tag of a much more conservative approach that puts a much longer timeline on carbon reduction:

> Edward Barbier, an economist at Colorado State University, agrees that a strict timeline isn’t realistic. He advocates jump-starting the transition by investing about 5 percent of GDP over five or so years. GDP was $20.5 trillion in 2018, according to the Bureau of Economic Analysis, so that’s a little over $1 trillion a year. “That would push us on a path to clean energy, and a path that permanently lowers carbon emissions,” he told us.

The second point I want to make is that we have much less headroom to do a "New Deal"-style project than we did in 1930. We are actually already far in excess of New Deal-era government involvement in the economy. (See my link above.) Today, government spending is at around 35% of GDP. We are in fact closer to the "total war mobilization" of World War II (where spending peaked at 45%) than to the New Deal era 18%.

Re:Climate models are running red hot, and scientists don’t ... by claudeganon on Monday February 03, 2020 @12:47PM (#22226723)
This demonstrates nothing other to me that the complexity of Capitalist economies and their industries grows over time in such a way that requires further state intervention and support to undergird them. This is true across most of the developed world and in regimes like China and likely will only expand in the future. Especially if Capitalism is to possibly survive the destructive consequences of its externalities.
Re:Climate models are running red hot, and scientists don’t ... by jschwartzi on Monday February 03, 2020 @02:00PM (#22227631)
You’re referencing The Great Leap forward right? Because if so you’re completely ignoring the details in an attempt to use it to bolster your point. The reason tons of people died in The Great Leap Forward has nothing to do with food production per se. Rather, the Chinese government declared several animals to be pests and commanded everyone to eradicate them to protect the harvest. Among those animals were sparrows. Sparrows are minor agricultural pests, but they are fantastic at eating bugs. And so, having hunted sparrows nearly to extinction the Chinese were unpleasantly surprised when a huge plague of Locusts descended on their fields and ate nearly all of the harvest.

So the real lesson is not that command economies are bad but rather that unforeseen circumstances should be avoided. If they hadn’t killed the sparrows we would not now be hearing about how many died.

Re:Climate models are running red hot, and scientists don’t ... by nate_meurer on Monday February 03, 2020 @03:52PM (#22228926)
> If they hadn’t killed the sparrows we would not now be hearing about how many died.

The Four Pests Campaign is a great example of humans suffering the unintended consequences of their own stupidity and hubris. However the Great Famine had many proximal causes, and there is no evidence that simply sparing the sparrows could have prevented it.