> Pollin, however, strongly disagrees with the resolution’s aim of getting to net zero with just a decade of investment. “I think it’s completely unrealistic and it’s not worth costing out,” he said of the Green New Deal.
$1 trillion is the price tag of a much more conservative approach that puts a much longer timeline on carbon reduction:
> Edward Barbier, an economist at Colorado State University, agrees that a strict timeline isn’t realistic. He advocates jump-starting the transition by investing about 5 percent of GDP over five or so years. GDP was $20.5 trillion in 2018, according to the Bureau of Economic Analysis, so that’s a little over $1 trillion a year. “That would push us on a path to clean energy, and a path that permanently lowers carbon emissions,” he told us.
The second point I want to make is that we have much less headroom to do a "New Deal"-style project than we did in 1930. We are actually already far in excess of New Deal-era government involvement in the economy. (See my link above.) Today, government spending is at around 35% of GDP. We are in fact closer to the "total war mobilization" of World War II (where spending peaked at 45%) than to the New Deal era 18%.
Extrapolating a general theory from just two examples seems like a mistake.