News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Much Does a Mile of Road Cost? by rahimnathwani on Monday January 27, 2020 @06:22PM (#22164933)
I was surprised to read this in the California DMV driver handbook:

"If you can choose among three lanes, pick the middle lane for the smoothest driving."

When I learned to drive (in the UK), the official guidance was to stay in the left-most lane except when overtaking. And then, after overtaking, to immediately return to the left lane.

Re:How Much Does a Mile of Road Cost? by dmurray on Monday January 27, 2020 @08:02PM (#22165455)
I've noticed while driving in the US that American highway exits seem to be designed differently than those in the UK. The rightmost lane of three-lane highways will often become the exit lane, so if you stick to the rightmost lane you'll frequently need to switch lanes to your left to stay on the road. In the UK, in contrast, the exit lane is usually the new lane, and you have to switch lanes to get into it.

So instead of constant lane switching, use the middle lane for going straight ahead, and the leftmost lane for passing.

Re:How Much Does a Mile of Road Cost? by wahern on Monday January 27, 2020 @10:20PM (#22166137)
That depends on the region and age of the road. In more rural areas where the freeways are newer things are much more consistent and usually just as you'd expect. In older areas like New York or California where many of the freeways predate the Federal Interstate system, and where lane expansions, lane extensions, and exits have grown far more organically, there are inconsistent designs (although often consistent within the time period) and even bizarre, one-off stuff.

California didn't even adhere to Federal Interstate guidelines for exit numbering until relatively recently (sometime in the early to mid 2000s, IIRC), decades after most other states. California's scheme predated the Federal Interstate system and they weren't keen on changing it.

Re:How Much Does a Mile of Road Cost? by cpitman on Monday January 27, 2020 @11:11PM (#22166374)
Only tangentially related, but New Jersey has a special case of this. It used to be all in on "jug-handles" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jughandle), where you would need to be in the rightmost lane in order to make a "left" turn. But they have also built intersections that have the standard left turn lane, on the left. You only know which one it is as you approach the intersection, then either need to get all the way to the left or right. Always a fun surprise!
Re:How Much Does a Mile of Road Cost? by THE_PUN_STOPS on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @12:12AM (#22166651)
>California's scheme predated the Federal Interstate system and they weren't keen on changing it.

Massachusetts is about to embark on a project to renumber all of their exits per federal mandate. The consensus is that the only way they can take "exit 17"[1] from us is by lasering it out of our brains. I know people who are planning a guerilla renumbering campaign for this sign after it is harmonized.

[1]: https://i.imgur.com/3X8gIOf.jpg

Re:How Much Does a Mile of Road Cost? by dsfyu404ed on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @07:06AM (#22168592)
Back when Connecticut re-numbered the highways they struck a deal where they'd re-number the highways as the signs were replaced to save money. Massachusetts being Massachusetts they'll inevitably find a way to replace all the signs three or four times to maximize the number of favors they can do for the well connected people in the relevant industries.
Re:How Much Does a Mile of Road Cost? by nitwit005 on Monday January 27, 2020 @09:40PM (#22165958)
California has a lower speed limit of 55 mph for trucks: https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySectio...

This means that they generally stay in the rightmost lane, as slower traffic is supposed to keep right.

Re:How Much Does a Mile of Road Cost? by shaftway on Monday January 27, 2020 @07:22PM (#22165235)
That feels pretty legit to me. I don't remember reading that, but when I drive a car and I've got more than 2 lanes to choose from, I usually end up in the middle. The right lane always has people merging, either to enter or exit, or trucks lumbering along at 45. The left lane always has someone wanting to do 90 in a 55. Middle is the smoothest, from a traffic flow perspective.

On a motorcycle it's all about riding between the left-most and its neighbor. More cars expect you there because most motorcycles ride there, so they make more room. The next lane-line is a death trap, from cars in the second lane moving over for a motorcyclist over there.

Re:How Much Does a Mile of Road Cost? by rahimnathwani on Monday January 27, 2020 @07:41PM (#22165347)
"The right lane always has people merging, either to enter or exit, or trucks lumbering along at 45."

Interesting perspective. I feel a little differently:

- cars meeting to enter shouldn't affect you, because it's their responsibility to get to the right speed and time their entry to a gap; an entering car should never cause you to need to change speed or direction

- an exiting car shouldn't affect you, because there's usually no reason for them to slow down before exit

- you can overtake the slow trucks when you encounter them: just change lanes to overtake, and then pull back into the right lane afterwards

Driving in the middle lane is optimal from each driver's own perspective but, globally, it reduces road capacity and increases journey times.

Re:How Much Does a Mile of Road Cost? by NoSorryCannot on Monday January 27, 2020 @08:24PM (#22165597)
This seems a little bit idealistic.

People merging onto the highway are supposed to reach highway speed before attempting to merge, but they very often do not do that.

And they're supposed to to find a gap, but there may not be one or other drivers may deliberately try to deny them one.

The merging lane may be very short.

The merging car may start to change lanes even if it's not safe to do so.

Congestion may require more deliberately courteous behavior.

The right lane often has many trucks clustered together and rote exercise of the keep-right rule will require an excessive amount of lane changing.

And on a limited access highway, lane changing is the most dangerous routine maneuver so one should be thoughtful of balancing lane changing with expediency.

And the idea that a driver has no responsibility to accommodate another merging driver, if applied strictly, also means that one cannot always leave the right lane at will, because driver in the left lane are not permitting. So you change speed a lot, which is rough on fuel efficiency and precludes cruise control if it's adaptive.

Being religious about keep-right is kind of miserable on a congested highway, especially one with a differential of speed speed limits depending on vehicle type. The people most steadfast about traffic laws get punished at the pleasure of people who flout them, which doesn't seem correct.

Re:How Much Does a Mile of Road Cost? by rahimnathwani on Monday January 27, 2020 @08:39PM (#22165671)
"The people most steadfast about traffic laws get punished at the pleasure of people who flout them, which doesn't seem correct."

Exactly. Each person acting in their own self-interest causes a reduction in road capacity and longer journey times. Those who try to stay in the right-most lane that's going their speed don't gain anything for themselves, as they only increase road capacity for people behind them.

Re:How Much Does a Mile of Road Cost? by NoSorryCannot on Monday January 27, 2020 @08:54PM (#22165727)
That's a bit of a cherry pick. I don't disagree with upholding the principle of the social good.

But two things.

Tragedy of the commons. You're arguing that some drivers should elect to have poor travel times to, frankly, accommodate those who are breaking the law. Maybe the law should be changed (different speed limits are bad) and more zealously enforced.

Second, your greatest responsibility on the road is safety and accident avoidance, not expediency. It is not defensible to change lanes or refuse to accommodate another driver when it may cause an accident that could have been avoided. Changing lanes or refusing to accommodate is least safe when there is a lot of congestion.

I don't know the best way to drive. I don't always obey the law and neither do I only do those things that give me individually an immediate. Mostly, I try to be safe and not instigate road rage.

But I don't think it's as simple as you're suggesting, either. You absolutely have to drive in a way that anticipates that others are acting selfishly. It's part of avoiding accidents.

Re:How Much Does a Mile of Road Cost? by rahimnathwani on Monday January 27, 2020 @09:13PM (#22165794)
You are right on all points, and just to clarify:

- I'm not saying that minimising your own journey time should be your only or main objective

- I'm not saying that minimising other people's journey time should be your only or main objective

My observation (no judgment) is that we'd each like less traffic in front of us, but it's most convenient for us to drive in a way that slightly increases traffic for those behind us.

Whether this is good or bad, I don't know. On the 280 and 101, it's common to see cars driving 80+, when the posted speed limit is 65. Perhaps better lane discipline would increase those speeds and make the roads less safe...

Re:How Much Does a Mile of Road Cost? by shaftway on Thursday January 30, 2020 @07:50PM (#22197809)
> cars meeting to enter shouldn't affect you

But they do, because when they don't it's potentially your life on the line.

> an exiting car shouldn't affect you

But they do, because there's always a reason.

> just change lanes to overtake, and then pull back into the right lane afterwards

I look at the act of driving on the freeway as gambling with my life. Every single action I take (or don't) has the potential to kill me. This is anecdotal, so I'm happy to take actual facts and change my opinion, but I see a much higher order of accidents (or near misses) caused by changing lanes than I see from people staying in their lane. My conclusion is that staying in a lane is inherently safer than drifting from lane to lane based on its occupancy level.

> Driving in the middle lane is optimal from each driver's own perspective

I generally stay in the middle lane when the load on the freeway is low to moderate. When the load is high it doesn't matter which lane you're in; they're all sub-optimal. But if there are so many people driving in the middle lane that journey times are increased, then people will start to pass more often and the lanes will even out. If they don't, then you're in high load.

> it reduces road capacity

It doesn't reduce road capacity. It could reduce road capacity utilization, but if you're hitting that point then the utilization has already taken a hit, and driver patterns change to utilize the road more fully (for better or worse).

Ultimately the lane choice of each driver doesn't matter, because drivers won't sit in bumper to bumper traffic with a wide open lane next to them.

In fact, changing lanes reduces road capacity utilization. For the duration of the lane change and for a short period before and after the car is effectively taking up two cars places (their place in the old lane and the new).

Re:How Much Does a Mile of Road Cost? by cortesoft on Monday January 27, 2020 @11:54PM (#22166577)
What is this ‘gap’ you speak of? We don’t have those here in LA.
Re:How Much Does a Mile of Road Cost? by rahimnathwani on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @12:26AM (#22166699)
You need a gap between cars to stop them colliding due to speed variation. I've heard that all cars on LA roads go at the same 0mph, so I guess you don't need a gap.
Re:How Much Does a Mile of Road Cost? by jibe on Monday January 27, 2020 @10:17PM (#22166118)
Wait a sec, you drive on the opposite side of the road in the UK, so the advice to stay in the left lane except for overtaking is the equivalent of the advice here to stay to the right, or out of the left lane except when passing.
Re:How Much Does a Mile of Road Cost? by rahimnathwani on Monday January 27, 2020 @10:28PM (#22166173)
"is the equivalent of the advice here to stay to the right"

Yeah, but the advice in the California DMV handbook is to stay in the middle, not the right.

The difference is that, in the UK, the middle lane is explicitly only for overtaking. If you're going the same speed as the cars in the left lane, you're not overtaking, so you shouldn't be in the middle lane. California's guidance is directly contrary to this.

Re:How Much Does a Mile of Road Cost? by hn_throwaway_99 on Monday January 27, 2020 @11:43PM (#22166526)
So wait, in a 3+ lane setup in the UK, both the middle lane and the rightmost are only for passing? That seems weird to me.

Reason for the CA rules is that, in the US, the rightmost lane is where all the entrance and exit ramps are, so you often have people speeding up or slowing down as they enter and exit. Rather than have to do a ton of lane changes to pass people as they merge on, the advice to stay in the middle lane if you just want to stay a constant speed is so you don't have to deal as much with people entering and exiting your lane.

Re:How Much Does a Mile of Road Cost? by rahimnathwani on Monday January 27, 2020 @11:53PM (#22166570)
Yes, the UK highway code rule 264 says:

"You should always drive in the left-hand lane when the road ahead is clear. If you are overtaking a number of slower-moving vehicles, you should return to the left-hand lane as soon as you are safely past."

When I learned to drive (many years ago), the guidance was more specific: the middle lane for overtaking a vehicle, and the right-most lane for overtaking multiple vehicles.

Re:How Much Does a Mile of Road Cost? by bartread on Monday January 27, 2020 @11:57PM (#22166589)
UK motorway junctions are all equipped with long sliproads. Generally you're supposed to do all your accelerating or braking on the sliproad when you join or leave the motorway, although traffic conditions can obviously prevent this.

With that said, in free-flowing traffic, it can be incredibly dangerous when people fail to follow this protocol, and I often wish there was more enforcement.

Re:How Much Does a Mile of Road Cost? by oblio on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @01:17AM (#22166900)
Everywhere in Europe it's the same as the UK. Exits add extra, temporary lanes 90% of the time, the right lane keeps going forward.
Re:How Much Does a Mile of Road Cost? by kevin_thibedeau on Monday January 27, 2020 @11:00PM (#22166328)
In the US there is no priority with 3+ lanes. You can legally plod along in the left lane without passing anyone. The middle is a safe option to avoid conflicts on either side. For two lanes you are supposed to leave the left/high-speed lane for passing only.
Re:How Much Does a Mile of Road Cost? by masonic on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @05:16AM (#22168011)

  In the US there is no priority with 3+ lanes

There is no monolithic Nationwide vehicle code. Laws can vary state to state.

  You can legally plod along in the left lane without passing anyone. 
Generally false. Definitely false in CA: Slower traffic keep right, notwithstanding speed limits.
Re:How Much Does a Mile of Road Cost? by nitrogen on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @12:23AM (#22166682)
That really depends on the state. In Utah, for example, the law requires left lane drivers to move over if they are being passed on the right. Some other states explicitly designate the left lane for passing only.
Re:How Much Does a Mile of Road Cost? by opportune on Monday January 27, 2020 @10:49PM (#22166276)
I stay in the middle lanes most of the time on the 101 because they are constantly adding/removing lanes or onramps with quickly disappearing lanes. Easier to stay in the middle than constantly deal with California drivers merging into your lane. I have had a lot of close calls where people behaved very irrationally merging onto the highway. Best to avoid it
Re:How Much Does a Mile of Road Cost? by Maultasche on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @05:10PM (#22174655)
That is indeed the rule in European countries I've driven in and (modified for which side of the road is being driven on) some US states (like Oregon) have similar rules.

California, on the other hand, allows people to drive in whatever lane they feel like for however long they feel like as long as they maintain sufficient speed. The slower traffic is supposed to stay to the right and the faster traffic is supposed to stay to the left. The police can intervene if they feel that someone is driving too slow in the wrong lane, but I've never seen that happen.

There are no rules in California to prevent overtaking on the right, so you can choose which lane you want to move into to overtake someone.

Re:How Much Does a Mile of Road Cost? by briffle on Monday January 27, 2020 @11:07PM (#22166354)
Oregon has a law that if you have 5 or more vehicles behind you, you must let them pass. It's more for the highways, not the freeway, but I haven't seen it enforced in many, many years
Re:How Much Does a Mile of Road Cost? by scarejunba on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @02:36AM (#22167221)
California has this:

> Vehicles proceeding at a speed less than the flow of traffic and moving on a two-lane highway where passing is unsafe, must turn off the roadway at the nearest place designated as a turnout or wherever sufficient area for a safe turnout exists, if a line of 5 or more vehicles forms behind them.

https://www.dmv.ca.gov/portal/dmv/detail/pubs/hdbk/driver_ha...

Re:How Much Does a Mile of Road Cost? by grifball on Monday January 27, 2020 @11:49PM (#22166557)
Do you have a link? All I could find is this:

https://www.oregonlaws.org/ors/811.425

Not doubting you, just wanna know.

Re:How Much Does a Mile of Road Cost? by skybrian on Monday January 27, 2020 @06:34PM (#22164989)
That's still mostly true in the US for the more rural areas. Interstate highways often have two lanes in each direction.

For denser areas with multilane highways that are entirely in use, the best you can say is that the people in the passing lane probably want to go faster. :-)