I think people advocating for CCS should be careful what they ask for. Reasonable things to do would be:
a) CCS should be confined to areas where no feasible technical alternative exists (e.g. cement) and to negative emissions.
b) No support for CCS as in Enhanced Oil Recovery. This is creating more emissions than it avoids.
Another industry where CO2 as a chemical byproduct is vented at a massive scale in the atmosphere is with the steel industry.
Both are good targets for carbon capture at the source.
Just to nitpick here, but I think this is crucial to understand: 8% is more plausibly a number for the total emissions of cement, including energy emissions. The chemical emissions are more in the range of 4%.
What type of cement are you talking about?
Reference: http://matse1.matse.illinois.edu/concrete/prin.html
There are 2 sources of CO2 during cement manufacture. One is from the decomposition of lime, the other is from the energy production needed to make the process work. The latter could be avoided by electrical heating, a solar furnace or other renewable heat sources. The decomposition part can be compensated by newer cement chemistries that reabsorb most of the CO2 during the curing process.
So there are alternatives, carbon capture is not the only solution.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sorel_cement https://www.solidiatech.com/solutions.html
Climate change must be addressed and I'm all for clean energy (as in a significant portion of my portfolio is in clean energy ETFs, and I'm actually shorting oil and natural gas producers for the moment) but let's not kill a potential golden goose on principle. Decades of cheap energy could help lead to a rebirth of the American manfacutring sector.
Energy is cheap in the USA (and has been for decades). Let’s not kid ourselves, energy costs aren’t the reason the USA exported ~all its manufacturing jobs.
(Remember to exclude subsidies in your comparisons, as that’s a matter of policy and, for example, the USA could choose to implement them today if it wanted.)
Germany figured it out, and their energy costs are roughly double ours.
Nah. We consider companies to be people in a legal sense and they should face justice in that same sense. Asset seizure, restorative justice, and incarceration all have suitable analogues that can be applied to these companies.
But back to the main point, that the two issues are often conflated by people? Also a reasonable position. Where has the profit been sought in extraction of non-renewables and release of CO2? Where should the capital for carbon re-capture and environmental restoration be drawn? The argument is that these two places are one and the same, and this idea has merit.
No, that's pretty much how the CCS debate has been going. Norway announced a big project to cleanup a gas plant with CCS used for an oil refinery. The plant was built, but without CCS.
When Germany built its last wave of new coal power plants a common argument was that "the CO2 emissions are no big problem, we'll add CCS later". Which never happened.
The promise of CCS as an excuse for continued fossil fuel use without actually buildling it is a recurring theme in the debate.
You can see a lot of examples where the planting is managed forestry that will be re-harvested. As long as it wasn’t recently a forested area, then it’s still a valid long-term carbon store for as long as the re-planting never stops or the final harvest is not taken. That’s a pretty big ‘if’ though, and the commercial interest that sits atop the arrangement is not aligned with a positive outcome. You’d also have to account for the output production of the felled wood to be sure of the benefit/cost to carbon capture. If a significant portion of the logged timber survives in some manufactured form for a long time that nudges the dial in a positive direction.
Also monoculture forests, characteristic of commercial interest, are a problem in terms of the multi-faceted nature of the climate change we’re attempting to halt/reverse. One of the big impacts of climate change is loss of biodiversity, but monoculture forestry does little to support nature and in many ways is akin to concreting over the area. Diverse native plantings that support wildlife and promote humus buildup is far more desirable to reclaim carbon AND provide much-needed refuge to threatened species.
Plus there's the political cost. Oil is in the ground. So wars are fought over it and rich nations exploit poor nations to their own advantage without considering the human toll. If alt energy makes nations more self-sufficient then that can only be a good thing.
Wind isn't going anywhere, the sun isn't going anywhere.
China and India have enormous populations. Their per-capita emissions are low.
Unless you’re arguing a position that some folks in the world are inherently more deserving of a better quality of their life beyond mere circumstance, it doesn’t make sense to raise the ‘per-nation’ measure of emissions over the per-person measure.
There is greatest scope for emissions reduction in nations where per-capita emissions are highest. American citizens need to be converned primarily about how to reduce America’s emissions. Chinese citizens need to be concerned primarily about how to reduce China’s emissions. Everyone is already best placed to exert political pressure and carry out grassroots change on their respective home turf.
Targets for nations have already been established in inter-governmental negotiations and re-litigating the basic figures in individual citizen discussion is pointless at best, actively distracting at worst.
“First, pluck the beam from your own eye”
Suppose a Chinese factory uses electricity supplied by coal to manufacture a product. The product is shipped to the United States aboard a Korean container ship before being shipped by diesel train to Seattle, where it is delivered to a retailer by truck, purchased, plugged into the wall and powered by a combination of hydroelectric and natural gas energy. In this scenario, many of the carbon emissions can be counted as Korean or Chinese even though the end consumer is American.
The flip side of this is that the United States can also directly affect Chinese carbon emissions by simply buying fewer Chinese products.
Edit: Also, since China is a totalitarian dictatorship, it’s not like Chinese people can pressure their government very much.
It works if everyone is honest, but when there’s financial incentive at local and global level to be dishonest, the outcome is predictable.
[0] https://ourworldindata.org/uploads/2019/10/Cumulative-CO2-tr...
CO2 is only useful for enhanced recovery in a few scenarios. It only works in non-water-wet reservoirs, which are fairly rare. You wouldn't use it in other cases even if someone was paying you to. (You'd lose vastly more money in lowered recovery factor compared to optimal methods for the reservoir than you'd get paid. Better to use the correct methods and inject C02 into something you're not producing from.)
Big oil companies are in favor of CCS because they're the ones who can do it most effectively and have invested the most R&D in carbon sequestration strategies.
Like it or not, big oil isn't some evil mustache twirling villain. Yes, Exxon has taken some dicey moves with lobbying, but most of the oil industry has been very aware of climate change for quite awhile now and has been heavily investing in ways of tackling it (or at least they were ten years ago when I worked in oil - I assume that's still the case). They're basically waiting on regulatory changes to make it profitable.
The technical challenge right now is efficient C02 capture. We've largely shown that long-term C02 sequestration should work. However, we still don't have a ton of ways to capture carbon at scale that don't involve significant energy expenditures. The whole system needs to be carbon negative to work, and the methods we currently have don't scale terribly well in that regard. (i.e. Carbon capture is most feasible right now during electricity generation and other industrial processes that produce high concentrations of C02. To have a global impact we need to get it to work at atmospheric concentrations.) That's something that actually is a fairly tractable problem, it just needs large scale focus. To get that in our current system, you need to make it economic to capture and sequester carbon.
We, as a society, are still dependent on hydrocarbons for lots of things. We really still can't easily replace them -- we're structured around cheap fuel with a very high energy density. Electric cars certainly help, but they can only replace some uses. We just don't have the technology to replace a large chunk of our current hydrocarbon uses. It's an energy density problem.
You want to change something, change the regulatory system. Regulate C02 as a pollutant, sure. You have to be careful how you implement that, though, or you'll most heavily impact the most venerable portion of the population with price increases. For that reason, cap and trade is also a good approach. So are many of the carbon market strategies. Yeah, some of those ideas come from the conservative side politically -- it doesn't make them ineffective.
Vilifying oil companies just demonstrates ignorance of both the problem and the solutions. Big oil is part of the solution as well.
Thank you for this interesting contribution ... I agree that the full-lifecycle accounting of CO2 and the requirement that the entire cycle come out carbon negative is the really challenging part.
I would go a step further: I am skeptical of carbon sequestration in gaseous form. Call me timid, but I wouldn't want to make high stakes bets on gas staying in the places where we put it. Instead, I would like to see a reaction that converts the CO2 to a solid form (chalk ?) that is stable in physical form.
I believe that weird seed-the-oceans-with-iron-dust proposal accomplishes, roughly, the same thing - carbon sequestered in a solid, stable form.
First off, even the simplest methods wind up with it dissolved in water. You basically can't just inject gaseous C02 into the ground and have it remain a gas. The rocks you're injecting it into are filled with water and it's highly soluble in water. Under certain conditions, you can inject liquid C02 and actually displace the water already there. However, that's mostly not what's being proposed.
Geologic carbon sequestration can take a handful of different approaches. The two you'll hear talked about the most are: 1) Inject it into a reservoir where you expect it to react with something and eventually form carbonate minerals (in-situ mineral sequestration, or mineral trapping). 2) Inject it into a very deep reservoir where it will dissolve into the brine already there and/or is unable to find a way back out again due to the geometry of the reservoir. (Solubility trapping and/or residual trapping)
The first method is preferable, but actually hard to guarantee in practice. The second may sound more risky, but we're actually pretty good at identifying regions that can store a buoyant phase over geologic time -- it's exactly what we do in hydrocarbon exploration. Both are being actively explored along with several others. There's a lot of geologic research being done on carbon sequestration right now (and has been for quite awhile, actually, though the government funded it well before industry started to).
The risk of the "seed the oceans" approaches (or the olivine beach proposals as well) are the environmental side effects. Altering ocean chemistry _will_ have significant effects. Similarly, putting olivine on beaches will result in a lot of heavy metal contamination (you can't get pure olivine -- you're going to have a lot of chromite and fun other odds and ends in ultramafic rocks).
I'd argue we're better off impacting the deep underground where more or less nothing lives than we are altering the oceans.
We could create more such sites at great expense after we run out of natural sites and abandoned mines.
Have to be also very careful to not break underground water reservoirs.
1. It makes extracting and burning oil not so bad - no need to make rules limiting oil extraction, we can simply start some CCS projects.
2. Injecting CO2 into deep oil wells actually helps get more oil out of them. Get the government to pay for CCS, while the oil company profits off increased yields.