I just got comcast installed in a new home, and the experience was completely different from what I've experienced in the past -- think "apple store", rather than "we're the phone company; we don't have to care". The customer service rep that helped me said they just finished six months of training, and even they were surprised that the system "just worked" when I went in to pick up the gear (my choice to pick it up two hours after calling them rather than waiting for delivery). I won't go into detail about all the other things that "went right" to avoid sounding like a marketing bird, but from what I heard it is a corporate initiative and not just for the fiber buildout.

My kid recently moved apartments from one served only by Comcast to one not served by Comcast. He filed the cancel request online and took his cable modem to a Comcast office in a nearby mall. The cancel process took about six minutes total; nobody called to beg for him to stay or stall him on the phone for over an hour.

My view is that the indication is how a company treats you when you leave versus when you arrive and, at least this once, Comcast did well on both.

My Comcast connection is rock solid. Except when it rains. And I live in Oregon.

FYI: I had that problem a decade ago, and the problem ended up being a nick in the coax sheathing on the run from the house to the neighborhood box. Water would get in and ruin the signal, but it was fine when it was dry.

It took 4 of Comcasts contractor technician visits to my house to fix a bad coax running to the building. The first tech identified the problem and said another would come to fix it, and no one did. The next two were completely useless beyond checking that the modem connected, and wasting my time.

Aside from that my 300Mbps service frequently tops out at 30Mbps, seemingly whenever I want to download something large. The upstream bandwidth they offer is also abysmal.