News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Philosophy of Ghost in the Shell (2012) by anotheryou on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @06:35AM (#21990485)
If you only watched the rather recent movie: know that they spun the story around 180°.

The original is more of a love letter to technology [SPOILER] and ends with the first merge of human and AI in to something new [/SPOILER] (it's not about technophobic humans policing the bad runaway machines).

Re:Philosophy of Ghost in the Shell (2012) by kerkeslager on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @07:55AM (#21990945)
Gosh that movie was awful.

American live action Death Note was the same: I was hopeful since they cast Willem Dafoe and he's usually in good stuff, but no, it was also pretty bad. It seems like American film companies are just trying to capitalize on the popularity of anime without grokking what made the best anime great.

Re:Philosophy of Ghost in the Shell (2012) by bitwize on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @08:21AM (#21991157)
The American Battle Angel was pretty damn good -- but it helps that they stayed faithful to the manga, only changing a few minor details. (Zalem is in South America rather than North, Alita is named for Ido's dead daughter rather than his cat.) I consider it a Hollywood take on a Japanese story -- done right.
Re:Philosophy of Ghost in the Shell (2012) by pbhjpbhj on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @08:12AM (#21991076)
Do you think they really don't grok it, or (as seems most likely to me) do those in control just not care about anything other than the monetary return?
Re:Philosophy of Ghost in the Shell (2012) by simonh on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @08:35AM (#21991257)
I think the problem is too many of them only care about how the film looks. The story is incidental, cobbled together using a lit crit course story construction kit formula.

J. J. Abrams is the living embodiment of this approach, which is why his Star Trek and Star Wars movies look gorgeous and individual scenes are awe inspiring, and the overarching story arcs are all fantastic on paper, but the world building and and actual in-world logic of the setting or character decisions in it just don't make any sense whatsoever. Zack Snyder is just as bad.

Re:Philosophy of Ghost in the Shell (2012) by jimbokun on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @09:43AM (#21991835)
Abrams approach to creating new content for existing universes seems to just remake a previous beloved movie from the canon except much worse than the original (Wrath of Khan > Into Darkness, Return of the Jedi > Rise of Skywalker).
Re:Philosophy of Ghost in the Shell (2012) by Loughla on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @09:20AM (#21991636)
Nailed it. This is why the most recent Star Trek movies don't count as actual Star Trek to me. We had the 'pretty' and 'explosiony' action sci-fi movies in the form of Star Wars. Star Trek was supposed to wrestle with just a little bit deeper themes.

But now they've devolved into beautiful looking action movies which exist just for the sake of action, with the story being secondary.

Re:Philosophy of Ghost in the Shell (2012) by MereInterest on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @10:09AM (#21992066)
The major thing that I miss in NuTrek is the optimism. We have enough shows that are gritty, dark, and depressing. My favorite part of Star Trek was how is showed that optimism about the future is not naive.
Re:Philosophy of Ghost in the Shell (2012) by kerkeslager on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @08:32AM (#21991225)
Well, obviously they only care about monetary return, but generally not alienating fans of the source material and not making terrible content are much better ways to make money.

Both films mentioned were commercial successes, but I think in the long run they burned audiences for this sort of film. I won't see any more American remakes of anime for some time.

Re:Philosophy of Ghost in the Shell (2012) by simonh on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @08:39AM (#21991282)
Battle Angel Alita. Cost $170m, Box Office $404m.

Don't bet on it. Also the live action Akira is currently on hold, but Taika still seems keen to do it.

Re:Philosophy of Ghost in the Shell (2012) by kerkeslager on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @09:27AM (#21991708)
I actually saw Battle Angel Alita. I thought it was okay, but I hadn't seen the original source material to compare. Other commenters here are saying it was more loyal to the source material.

The other American live-action remakes mentioned were profitable, but by much more narrow margins. If what people are saying about it being truer to the source material is true, then it seems that producing better remakes does in fact produce greater profits. We only have a narrow data set to look at for this, though.

I really don't know what a live action Akira would look like. The body horror scenes are going to have to be CGI, which could go really badly.

Re:Philosophy of Ghost in the Shell (2012) by Pigo on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @09:13AM (#21991568)
The original Ghost in the Shell has been one of my favorite films since the first time I seen it. To be honest, there's no other anime I've seen that I actually enjoyed apart from the Cowboy Bebop movie. So I don't consider myself a anime fan. The original GITS is a brilliant film that is beyond a specific genre.
Re:Philosophy of Ghost in the Shell (2012) by catalogia on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @10:07AM (#21992044)
You might like the Patlabor series/movies, directed by GITS's director Mamoru Oshii. Particularly the first two movies, which have a more serious tone than the rest of it. And imho the animation and aesthetics of the first two Patlabor movies is right up there with GITS.
Re:Philosophy of Ghost in the Shell (2012) by malvosenior on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @10:27AM (#21992202)
Honestly I wouldn’t recommend Patlabor to someone who only likes the GITS movie and Cowboy Bebop. It’s going to feel too slow and cheezy (in a way many anime fans including myself enjoy).

I’d probably suggest Rurouni Kenshin (Samurai X) or Gundam Zeta instead. They have interesting themes, are more adult and have amazing art.

Re:Philosophy of Ghost in the Shell (2012) by catalogia on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @10:43AM (#21992357)
I think the aesthetic/pacing/art of particularly the first two Patlabor movies would probably be appreciated by somebody who's a fan of the first GITS movie specifically. There is a common cyberpunk thread running through both those Patlabor movies and GITS. Patlabor 1 has a plot that easily could have been a GITS plot and spends a lot of time dwelling on the ways apparent progress leaves many people feeling abandoned and worthless.

The Patlabor TV show is definitely much lighter material, a lot more accessible to children.

Re:Philosophy of Ghost in the Shell (2012) by Pigo on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @10:59AM (#21992506)
Thanks for the suggestions, I'll definitely check them out. Maybe it's my age, but a lot of what I have seen like Deathnote or even the GITS SAC didn't click with me. Cowboy Bebop was just fun, and I forgot I was watching an anime.

I think maybe it's the high-concept, almost frightening, aspects of GITS that resonated with me. But I understand why it's not popular with most people.

Re:Philosophy of Ghost in the Shell (2012) by ihuman on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @11:07AM (#21992608)
There's also the Patlabor OVA series that came before the show and movies, and takes place in the same universe as the movies. I feel it's tone is in between the movies and TV show.

Obligatory Patlabor 2 opening title sequence: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IsMTpSDAGxM

Re:Philosophy of Ghost in the Shell (2012) by LiquidSky on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @12:28PM (#21993604)
>It’s going to feel too slow and cheezy

Patlabor is slow, sure, and purposefully so (it has and deserves the reputation as being the "boring" mecha show), but cheezy? I haven't seen the TV show which I hear is a lot more comic, but I wouldn't call the original OVA/first 2 movies cheezy.

Re:Philosophy of Ghost in the Shell (2012) by severine on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @04:20PM (#21995924)
I'd humbly recommend you Kon Sathoshi's "Paranoia Agent".

Wikipedia link (warning: spoilers ahoy): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paranoia_Agent

Re:Philosophy of Ghost in the Shell (2012) by spookybones on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @11:02AM (#21992548)
How about Akira or Neon Genesis Evangelion?
Re:Philosophy of Ghost in the Shell (2012) by armitron on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @11:17AM (#21992723)
Akira is not as iconoclastic in its philosophy as it was in its technical and artistic attributes at the time. It was also heavily influenced by and can be seen as a modern-day retelling/rewarning of the hiroshima/nagasaki incidents.

NGE can be philosophically heavy at times but is too diluted by its action sequences and fan service moments.

The first GITS movie is a philosophical tour de force and a piece of art that transcends time. A masterpiece.

Re:Philosophy of Ghost in the Shell (2012) by Pigo on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @11:31AM (#21992877)
Yeah, I'm definitely not trying to begrudge what other people like. Some people might not like a movie that is mostly cerebral. The art and action of GITS is almost secondary to the concept it's exploring. I've seen quite a lot of anime that looked fun and interesting, it just wasn't something I could get into.

It may also be that a lot of anime are series, and require a time investment.

Re:Philosophy of Ghost in the Shell (2012) by armitron on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @03:13PM (#21995263)
I agree with you. I've watched a lot of anime but the first Mamoru Oshii GITS movie is definitely a singularity. It doesn't even "feel" like anime.

The only other (comparable) anime that jumps to mind and something I can definitely recommend to you, is Serial Experiments Lain.

Re:Philosophy of Ghost in the Shell (2012) by hmschreck on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @04:32PM (#21996013)
It's less a retelling and more an expression of a culmination of factors in post-war Japan. Japanese media in that era really had a lot of fear about the post-war state, especially the loss of culture, baked in.