Re:Philosophy of Ghost in the Shell (2012)
by jimbokun on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @09:43AM
(#21991835)
Abrams approach to creating new content for existing universes seems to just remake a previous beloved movie from the canon except much worse than the original (Wrath of Khan > Into Darkness, Return of the Jedi > Rise of Skywalker).
Re:Philosophy of Ghost in the Shell (2012)
by Loughla on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @09:20AM
(#21991636)
Nailed it. This is why the most recent Star Trek movies don't count as actual Star Trek to me. We had the 'pretty' and 'explosiony' action sci-fi movies in the form of Star Wars. Star Trek was supposed to wrestle with just a little bit deeper themes.
But now they've devolved into beautiful looking action movies which exist just for the sake of action, with the story being secondary.
Re:Philosophy of Ghost in the Shell (2012)
by MereInterest on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @10:09AM
(#21992066)
The major thing that I miss in NuTrek is the optimism. We have enough shows that are gritty, dark, and depressing. My favorite part of Star Trek was how is showed that optimism about the future is not naive.
J. J. Abrams is the living embodiment of this approach, which is why his Star Trek and Star Wars movies look gorgeous and individual scenes are awe inspiring, and the overarching story arcs are all fantastic on paper, but the world building and and actual in-world logic of the setting or character decisions in it just don't make any sense whatsoever. Zack Snyder is just as bad.