News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Philosophy of Ghost in the Shell (2012) by pbhjpbhj on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @08:12AM (#21991076)
Do you think they really don't grok it, or (as seems most likely to me) do those in control just not care about anything other than the monetary return?
Re:Philosophy of Ghost in the Shell (2012) by simonh on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @08:35AM (#21991257)
I think the problem is too many of them only care about how the film looks. The story is incidental, cobbled together using a lit crit course story construction kit formula.

J. J. Abrams is the living embodiment of this approach, which is why his Star Trek and Star Wars movies look gorgeous and individual scenes are awe inspiring, and the overarching story arcs are all fantastic on paper, but the world building and and actual in-world logic of the setting or character decisions in it just don't make any sense whatsoever. Zack Snyder is just as bad.

Re:Philosophy of Ghost in the Shell (2012) by jimbokun on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @09:43AM (#21991835)
Abrams approach to creating new content for existing universes seems to just remake a previous beloved movie from the canon except much worse than the original (Wrath of Khan > Into Darkness, Return of the Jedi > Rise of Skywalker).
Re:Philosophy of Ghost in the Shell (2012) by Loughla on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @09:20AM (#21991636)
Nailed it. This is why the most recent Star Trek movies don't count as actual Star Trek to me. We had the 'pretty' and 'explosiony' action sci-fi movies in the form of Star Wars. Star Trek was supposed to wrestle with just a little bit deeper themes.

But now they've devolved into beautiful looking action movies which exist just for the sake of action, with the story being secondary.

Re:Philosophy of Ghost in the Shell (2012) by MereInterest on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @10:09AM (#21992066)
The major thing that I miss in NuTrek is the optimism. We have enough shows that are gritty, dark, and depressing. My favorite part of Star Trek was how is showed that optimism about the future is not naive.
Re:Philosophy of Ghost in the Shell (2012) by kerkeslager on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @08:32AM (#21991225)
Well, obviously they only care about monetary return, but generally not alienating fans of the source material and not making terrible content are much better ways to make money.

Both films mentioned were commercial successes, but I think in the long run they burned audiences for this sort of film. I won't see any more American remakes of anime for some time.

Re:Philosophy of Ghost in the Shell (2012) by simonh on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @08:39AM (#21991282)
Battle Angel Alita. Cost $170m, Box Office $404m.

Don't bet on it. Also the live action Akira is currently on hold, but Taika still seems keen to do it.

Re:Philosophy of Ghost in the Shell (2012) by kerkeslager on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @09:27AM (#21991708)
I actually saw Battle Angel Alita. I thought it was okay, but I hadn't seen the original source material to compare. Other commenters here are saying it was more loyal to the source material.

The other American live-action remakes mentioned were profitable, but by much more narrow margins. If what people are saying about it being truer to the source material is true, then it seems that producing better remakes does in fact produce greater profits. We only have a narrow data set to look at for this, though.

I really don't know what a live action Akira would look like. The body horror scenes are going to have to be CGI, which could go really badly.