News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by badrabbit on Friday January 03, 2020 @08:29AM (#21945632)
> And that's the price we pay for anyone being able to buy their own domain and run their own secure site.

No, that's the price we pay for using a name resolution system from the 80's (70's?) that was not built with trust validation in mind,decoupled from the infrastructure we use to establish domain ownership and authority. And also without user friendliness or of a layman's ability to independently validate authority in mind. e.g.: reverse order of hierarchy where in english you read left to right but dns has least authoritative/lowest level on the left and most authoritative on the right,why would I evaluate trust worthiness of site.com if 'secure' is evaluated first in secure.site.com (another example:google.com.site.info).

Cracked foundations make shaky buildings.

Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by acvny on Friday January 03, 2020 @08:39AM (#21945689)
yes, very wrong conclusion. the author blames cheap domains and easy to get https. You could as well blame cheap computers, cheap internet access, cheap electricity.

Since that looked like an SMS, I would report it to your mobile provider, let them track who sent the message.

Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by LinuxBender on Friday January 03, 2020 @01:06PM (#21948548)
The messages are spoofed. The attacker has access to a SS7 signalling link and you can set the source number to anything you want. Telco's share some blame in facilitating this. I tried to stop of of this in the 90's and was told to help the scammers send messages faster. I wanted to terminate their SS7 links but I would have been fired for doing so. To clarrify, the individual scammer may not even know what a SS7 link is. It's usually a tiered system, where one shady person has access to a link, then sells access via bitcoin to other shady people via some tor web interface.

As for the domain name, that problem isn't going away. If anything, it will only get worse, as people are lazy and push UX designers to show less and less information. And the UX devs are right, the users won't know what to do with the extra info most of the time anyway.

And then there are payment processors, who also teach people BAD habits, by sending HTML messages, clickable links, etc. And that isn't going to change because it would increase customer support cases which costs them money. Banks won't implement secure authentication beyond phone MFA for the most part. I can think of a dozen ways to make this more secure, but all the ideas would be rejected as adding too much friction.

All that is left is educating the masses and that fails as well. Most people learn by making mistakes. About 40% of people will click on the scammers links. About 10% of people will enter their credentials.

Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by belorn on Friday January 03, 2020 @02:35PM (#21949483)
> All that is left is educating the masses and that fails as well.

That is not always true. You can have regulations which force banks to change. Banks don't like it but politicians don't like an unstable banking sector, especially if it causes sharp changes in the stock market.

As an example, the recent money laundering scandals in Sweden has caused some changes in credit card security. Politicians want to reassure the public and increase trust in Swedish banks, so the last years has seen several notable banking regulations. I would guess that they actually want noticeable friction in order to reassure the public that they have things under control.

Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by LinuxBender on Friday January 03, 2020 @04:05PM (#21950362)
That is excellent. I would love to see this pattern spread around the world.
Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by NickNameNick on Friday January 03, 2020 @09:15PM (#21952327)
I don't get why the phone companies don't implement something akin to bogon filtering on their interconnect points.

If the incoming call or txt has an internal source number, but is coming from an external network, reject it. If its an outgoing session with an external source, drop it and follow up with the account holder.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bogon_filtering

Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by LinuxBender on Monday January 06, 2020 @09:58AM (#21969560)
A similar concept applies in the SS7 [1] network, B-number [2] analysis, but is not used that way, as telco's have no way to properly manage which switches may originate which numbers as they are portable. They just do routing and trust the sender is allowed to have the number presented in the SS7 packet.

[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Signalling_System_No._7

[2] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Called_party

Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by tgsovlerkhgsel on Friday January 03, 2020 @10:25PM (#21952660)
This would be problematic e.g. in the case of ported numbers, or if a customer is using a third party to send their SMS for a fraction of the cost. Implementing such blocks without covering these use cases would likely (rightfully) result in antitrust issues.
Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by edent on Friday January 03, 2020 @08:43AM (#21945722)
I'm the author. I'm not blaming cheap domains. I'm saying that spam like this is a consequence of cheap domains.

The blame lies at the feet of the spammers.

And, I've worked for a couple of mobile providers. This spam was likely sent from a disposable pre-paid SIM. There's no realistic way to check who sent it.

Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by danShumway on Friday January 03, 2020 @10:04AM (#21946430)
> I'm saying that spam like this is a consequence of cheap domains.

Technically correct, but the thing is, spam like this is a consequence of a lot of things. Why draw attention to that specific cause out of everything else?

You could just as accurately say that spam like this is a consequence of human-readable domains. If humans weren't visually validating URLs, it would be impossible for a scammer to use unicode tricks to make a URL look legitimate.

A lack of gatekeepers means we'll have more scammers, yes. But, gatekeepers almost universally don't scale well in any system as large as the Internet, and they come with so many additional problems that they're not worth paying special attention to or prioritizing as a solution to any problem on this scale.

Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by thefounder on Friday January 03, 2020 @09:15AM (#21945990)
Chances are the scammers didn't even pay the domain name or the SMS. Maybe the real issue is the state of payment services. You provide some random numbers in an unknown form....and this is since forever. How stupid is that? Things like Apple Pay seem to go a bit in the right direction but at the root you still use that random card number as identity/authentication.
Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by bostik on Friday January 03, 2020 @08:50AM (#21945780)
So the phone/device IMEI is not recorded for the session?

Not that it would tell who sent it, but would allow to track if the same devices were used as part of ongoing campaign.

Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by edent on Friday January 03, 2020 @08:54AM (#21945806)
The sending network may have a record of the IMEI, but I don't think the receiving one gets it.

But SMS sending devices are cheap and disposable. Sure, it's illegal to alter your IMEI in the UK - but if they're already committing one crime, I don't think that'll stop them.

Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by prox on Friday January 03, 2020 @04:37PM (#21950650)
If you watch kitboga (youtube / twitch) and in the odd chance kitboga gets to talk about why they do it the spammers fall into a couple of categories:

1) The angry/evil spammer. Doesn’t give a shit and wants make his dollars. Usually someone higher up. 2) The worker. Just his bills paid. Usually rather uncaring what they are doing, although they acknowledge its wrong 3) Playing oblivious, just ignoring and avoiding any sense of blame or justice

It’s lucrative and as long as we keep falling for it, it will stay. Making domains more expensive will make the barrier of entry higher, but the top players will likely just consolidate more resources vs little scammers.

If a domain is like an address then maybe we could or should enforce some more legitimacy, but such a thing would be hard to implement in the countries where spam usually originates from.

Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by ryanlol on Friday January 03, 2020 @09:07AM (#21945920)
Sending bulk sms costs waaaay more than any domain. This theory doesn’t really make any sense.
Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by edent on Friday January 03, 2020 @09:15AM (#21945984)
Bulk SMS costs around 1p/message - if you're sending from the UK. If you're sending from overseas it can be significantly cheaper.

So, sending a couple of hundred messages is about the same price as a domain.

Of course, if you've stolen a SIM or hacked peoples' phone in order to send the messages, it's even cheaper.

Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by ryanlol on Friday January 03, 2020 @09:18AM (#21946017)
IME good providers tend to charge at least 2p/message. You also need to get decent leads from somewhere or your conversion rates will suck.

Then there’s also a significant time investment in setting up accounts with those SMS services that’ll constantly be banning you.

Couple of hundred messages isn’t going to get you very many hits unless you’re collecting low value information.

Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by badrabbit on Friday January 03, 2020 @09:01AM (#21945863)
And who sent it shouldn't be recorded. Your problem is not the spammers but the reason users fall for the phish. Why are prepaid pins special and free email is not?
Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by acomjean on Friday January 03, 2020 @08:49AM (#21945772)
The fact that we were trained to look for https as a sign of legitimacy..

it kinda bugs me that letsencrypt which is a fantastic public service is being abused by scammers in this way.

Anonymity all the way down the stack...

Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by toohotatopic on Friday January 03, 2020 @08:56AM (#21945818)
It's legitimacy for the connection, not for the domain. Who trains people to trust every domain?
Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by Operyl on Friday January 03, 2020 @09:31AM (#21946138)
The reality is a lot of _us_ did, because we were trying to train the older generations some sensible internet habits. At the time, it was just easier to say “look for the green, and the bank company name next to it.” When we started killing the EV UI stuff (due to lack of UI space or what have you), people just kept looking for the padlock.
Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by saagarjha on Friday January 03, 2020 @01:13PM (#21948623)
It’s easy to phish people with EV certificate name collisions.
Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by Operyl on Friday January 03, 2020 @01:26PM (#21948762)
At the time nobody was thinking about that though. Times change, we get smarter, new flaws are exposed, etc.
Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by wongarsu on Friday January 03, 2020 @09:06AM (#21945907)
An EV certificate is still a decent proxy for legitimacy: it's somewhat expensive to get and allows you to track down a legal entity. Both points deter scammers and other evil-doers, even if they don't completely prevent them.

Sadly there's no way to judge from just the URL if a site has an EV cert or just a cheap/free https cert, and by the time you opened it in the browser it might be too late.

Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by SAI_Peregrinus on Friday January 03, 2020 @10:15AM (#21946539)
Not really. "Legal Entity" doesn't mean much, it's cheap to register a company and the name doesn't have to be unique. One guy registered a company called "Stripe" and got an EV cert for his site.[1] Modern web browsers don't show anything different for EV certs (try it). They stopped last year, mostly because EV certs were ineffective.

[1] https://stripe.ian.sh/

Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by PeterisP on Friday January 03, 2020 @09:57AM (#21946355)
A lack of EV certificate is not a decent proxy for legitimacy, because most of legitimate important sites don't have an EV certificate - so people can't be trained to think that they should think twice if an EV certificate is absent.
Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by SAI_Peregrinus on Friday January 03, 2020 @10:32AM (#21946699)
They also don't show up any differently in browsers any more. There's no difference a user can see unless they go through the menus to view the cert itself.
Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by SmellyGeekBoy on Friday January 03, 2020 @10:06AM (#21946451)
EV certificates are a scam anyway.
Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by wongarsu on Friday January 03, 2020 @10:20AM (#21946590)
I sure would do a double take if I noticed a bank website using a non-EV cert or an EV cert issued to somebody other than the bank. But that's probably one of the few industries where you can expect it.
Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by Deukhoofd on Friday January 03, 2020 @09:04AM (#21945890)
Banks did for a while, many banks told you to look for the green padlock to ensure it was the right site.
Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by tonetheman on Friday January 03, 2020 @09:41AM (#21946223)
Yes.

I am not sure it really says anything about legit-ness either. It really only guarantees you and the next person you are talking to in the chain have an encrypted connection.

Hard to explain that to anyone really.

Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by joe_the_user on Friday January 03, 2020 @04:12PM (#21950432)
Oh, we have a doubly problematic system.

The Internet became the standard for global networking in the 1990s by being an informal trust based system where the competition was things like Al Gore's Information Superhighway - these other hypothetical systems were centralized extension of something like a cable TV network and essentially had all the bad things we decry in today's Internet and none of the good.

Which to say, the lack of centralization in DNS or whatever aspects on might name in the Internet (IP addresses, etc) allows bad actors from below to do their terrible things.

But the lack of centralization also prevents bad actors from above from doing their terrible things. Centralized DNS is already a target - cable companies were complaining to congress about firefox from enabling secure DNS and keeping them from MTM traffic.

Which is worse? I couldn't say.

Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by tinus_hn on Friday January 03, 2020 @10:47AM (#21946862)
No, it’s the price you pay for trusting concepts that are not intended to be trustworthy. No matter what you come up with, as long as you train people to do things wrong there will always be a way to fool them.

No company should send messages containing a url that requires login, payment data or the like. People should go to these places by typing the url or by using their own bookmarks.

Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by thinkloop on Friday January 03, 2020 @04:21PM (#21950514)
> No company should send messages containing a url that requires login, payment data or the like. People should go to these places by typing the url or by using their own bookmarks.

Maybe they don't? This wouldn't help here, that's not the company sending the message. For that to work, people have to deeply know and trust the policies and resolve of each of their service providers not to do that - might as well just teach them how links work.

Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by tinus_hn on Saturday January 04, 2020 @05:23AM (#21954085)
No, because that’s impossible. Are you going to teach them to distinguish between l and I in sans serif fonts? Or one of the look alike Unicode symbols? That roads leads nowhere but blaming someone else for a problem you brought yourself. You can’t trust links by visually inspecting them.
Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by thepete2 on Friday January 03, 2020 @08:55AM (#21945813)
I think it's time stuff like domains and basic internet things like that need to become part of the school curriculum. Education is the only way to combat these things.
Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by O_H_E on Friday January 03, 2020 @10:46AM (#21946848)
Yes, agree.

A few weeks ago I had an argument with a few engineering students is one of the 30 top schools in the world, whether you can send an email form Gmail to Outlook or not!!

They thought it was like Messenger and WhatsApp not being able to talk to each other.

The concept of Open protocols and clients have to be taught in school.

Oh, how puzzled the looked when I showed them my Outlook email on my phone's Gmail app.

I was agitated.

Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by potatoz2 on Friday January 03, 2020 @03:10PM (#21949817)
I'm not convinced knowing about how this works is the solution. Plenty of software engineers that understand TLS/DNS/etc. get phished because it only takes a few minutes of distraction. The same principle applies in medicine or aviation: without systems in place, even the most educated person will predictably fail at least some of the time.
Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by zamadatix on Friday January 03, 2020 @11:39AM (#21947494)
The price we pay (scammers registering date based domain names) is due to the name resolution system being decoupled from the infrastructure we use to establish domain ownership and authority? How is looking up the domain supposed to give you more validation than the domain being assigned in the first place?

Right now that infrastructure is the only thing in the stack that actually does any validation (you get your cert because you have the name). There isn't any other validation infrastructure to couple it to for it to be "decoupled".

Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by ljm on Friday January 03, 2020 @04:32PM (#21950604)
For some time I've wondered what the internet would look like if we used reverse domain notation (like with software package identifiers), which I think would mitigate this issue.

`com.01-01-2020-billing.secure.hsbc` or whatever looks a hell of a lot more dodgy. But I presume it comes with a whole lot of issues of its own.

Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by rjsw on Friday January 03, 2020 @04:10PM (#21950407)
It didn't have to be that order for DNS, JANET NRS [1] had the most authoritative part on the left.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/JANET_NRS

Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by xyz20200102 on Friday January 03, 2020 @05:09PM (#21950911)
According to Paul Mockapetris who designed the DNS, domain names are little-endian to make autocompletion easier and to allow unqualified "local" names (e.g. "bilbo" instead of "bilbo.cs.college.edu").
Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by snarf21 on Friday January 03, 2020 @10:41AM (#21946793)
This is probably unpopular but I think domains should just cost more. We don't all need our own name as a domain. Make them cost $500 or $1000 a year. [This money goes to ICANN, W3C, etc.] That is nothing for a business but would make scammers and link farms (more) unprofitable. You could still make .org free but it requires sending 501c3 (or similar) documentation to the registrar.

If you want a phone line you have certain fees for 911 and other regulations to help pay for the infrastructure and this is very similar in terms of a naming and communication service.

Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by badrabbit on Friday January 03, 2020 @10:59AM (#21946998)
That opinion is unpopular for good reason. A financial barier to prevent crime implies lack of petty money is the cause of the crime. You can make 10x what you said with the simplest scam targeting a few million valid recipients within a week.

Even if your solution would solve the problem, it would destroy the purpose of the system. Throwing the proverbial baby with the bath water.

If I want a phone line it costs me $10 to get a sim card from walmart. Most reputable TLDa cost a ton more.

I mean what is it with this lazy way of solving real problems. What's next, tax domain registrations? Require a government ID? How ridiculous, this is what happens when humans give up their basic freedoms to goverenments and ruling classes. By what authority are you even regulating my free speech here? If I put up a website, I am not engaging in commerce unless I sell or buy something using that site. It is the equivalent of me calling myself a name and making a speech in public and you want to charge me £1000 for the right to call myself a name or to label the soap box I stand on a name so others can distiguish me. The fact that scammers also stand in soap boxes and make false claims for profit does not magically give you, your ruling class or the goverenmen t authority to regulate soap box labels and tax speech.

Even if this has popular support, free speech is a natural right. You can police harmful/false speech retroactively but you can't inhibit speech proactively to deter a possible crime unless you can guarantee your measure affects only law breakers.

Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by snarf21 on Friday January 03, 2020 @11:34AM (#21947443)
You are welcome to disagree but I guess I am missing your point.

Having a website doesn't require a domain. DNS is a vanity layer on top to make it more user friendly and provide an abstraction layer. Domain registration costs money today. According to your argument that should be free or it is limiting your speech. I never said anything about speech or what you use the domains for. If it is yours, do whatever you want with it. Ethos bought .org for $1B. Why should a private equity company be able to own DNS suffixes? Are you okay with that?

The issue at hand is that these domains are being created specifically to deceive. This is an issue of consumer protection and greater good. The US just passed bigger fines for robo-callers. Everyone seems fine with not getting scam phone calls from their own phone number. Is this a restriction of free speech? Everyone isn't allowed to run their own tv or radio station, it is regulated. Is that limiting your free speech? You can't make up your own phone number. If you want a special 800 number that is more memorable, you have to pay the phone company lots of extra money for it. I'm merely suggesting similar.

Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by imtringued on Friday January 03, 2020 @09:04PM (#21952256)
>Having a website doesn't require a domain.

Are you even listening to yourself? Your idea was to make domain names hard to obtain so scammers can't have them. The only way that idea will be effective is if people only go to sites that are part of the validated domain name system. This means that if you don't have a domain, nobody will go on your site (this is already true today). So why on earth are you saying those legitimate websites should look like scams?

Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by saagarjha on Friday January 03, 2020 @01:40PM (#21948903)
Domains are fundamentally different from phone numbers, because you interact with people you don’t necessarily “know” all the time while you only infrequently call people who aren’t in your contact list. Clicking on links would work, of course, but trying to remember the address of “that one dude who writes about maps” gets quite a bit harder.
Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by dane-pgp on Friday January 03, 2020 @10:45PM (#21952743)
I actually like this idea, and I wonder how low the cost could be while still deterring the spammers. From what I've read, the cost of domains is a factor that spammers are sensitive to, especially if they are abandoning them after 24 hours, so increasing the cost by just an order of magnitude could be enough to make many campaigns unprofitable.

This article somewhat supports my assertion:

https://krebsonsecurity.com/2018/06/bad-men-at-work-please-d...

saying "domains in the remaining five [out of ten] Top Bad TLDs can be had for between 48 cents and a dollar each." so I would suggest a one-off $100 fee rather than $500 or $1000 a year.

A more interesting approach would be to make the fee act as a bond, which is returned to the registrant after a year of good behaviour. Unfortunately, determining "good behaviour" is almost as hard as determining "bad behaviour", but perhaps a domain could opt in to having anonymous metrics recorded of how many users visit their site or send emails to that domain. That would put a substantial amount of trust into the hands of whichever organisations were responsible for recording these metrics, but the only harm they could do to a registrant is forcing them to pay their $100 bond to charity.

Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by FDSGSG on Friday January 03, 2020 @11:00PM (#21952801)
Phishing is so lucrative that a $100 fee on domain registrations would do literally nothing to combat it.

20-30 victims can easily earn the phisher $1000

Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by dane-pgp on Friday January 03, 2020 @11:08PM (#21952821)
That's an important number to note, thank you. Do you have an estimate for how many victims a single domain is likely to trick (before it gets blacklisted by Google Safe Browsing or similar)?
Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by FDSGSG on Saturday January 04, 2020 @04:51AM (#21953951)
Depends on who's being spammed and what kind of techniques the phishing site employs to resist safebrowsing. Single-use links and various browser fingerprinting techniques are common and fairly effective.

Beyond that it comes down to who's being spammed, with the right demographics your link could last very long without being reported by anyone.

I hack phishing sites for fun, anything between 0-500 hits seems common for the type of phishing seen in the OP (mostly depending on the quality of the leads).

Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by wolco on Friday January 03, 2020 @08:55PM (#21952220)
A lot of these domains are rented rather than purchased where someone can use them for 45 days and return them.
Re:Scammers registering date-based domain names by imtringued on Friday January 03, 2020 @09:06PM (#21952274)
I've seen a lot of sites give you offer for registering a domain name for the first time. Sometimes it's an absurd price like 1€ for the first year.