News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:On Privacy versus Freedom by blindgeek on Thursday January 02, 2020 @10:41PM (#21942905)
My biggest problem with messaging applications as a whole is that I need so many of them. I have a few contacts who are reachable with Signal, a few more who are reachable on Hangouts or whatever Google is calling its latest thing, and a few more who are reachable with Skype. That's three programs, to communicate with three different subsets of people. I'm sure if I used Facebook Messenger and Whatsapp, I'd have two more subsets of people who are only reachable through those.

XMPP was supposed to solve all those problems when it came out in the early 2000s. But then all the big tech companies who build "ecosystems" decided to push their own applications, all incompatible with one another. So here we are again with this proliferation of programs that really only do one thing: communication. It's like the 90s / early 2000s with the proliferation of instant messengers: ICQ, AIM, Yahoo, MSN, and on and on and on. The players are different, but the game is still the same. I suspect that twenty years from now, when the players have all changed yet again, there will still be one reliable method of reaching me: IRC.

If the Googles and Whatsapps and Facebooks of the world had been around in the early 90s, you'd have one email client from Facebook for mailing Joe and Fred, an email client from Google for mailing Mary and Jane, and an email client from Whatsapp for mailing Alice and Bob. Thankfully, email became entrenched before that could happen.

I want messaging to be like email, where I use one and exactly one program to communicate with all of my contacts, regardless of what server they use. People say that federation is more complicated than centralization. I'm sure that's true for developers, but in fact, federation can be vastly simplifying for an end user. I'm a fundamentally lazy person. Having to learn all these different messaging tools is frankly a waste of my time. All I want is a federated protocol and an open system, be it Matrix, XMPP, or something else.

As a final aside, you know what else that bugs me? The word "ecosystem". I worked for a big tech company for a while, and the only people I ever heard use that word were people out to build a walled garden.

Re:On Privacy versus Freedom by progval on Friday January 03, 2020 @01:33AM (#21943786)
> XMPP was supposed to solve all those problems when it came out

That's also what Matrix said it would solve when it started. Except now it's yet another protocol with its own chatrooms that are not reachable from any other protocol by default (even rooms on matrix.org); and bridges are at best in "beta" (except the Telegram bridge, which is "late beta"): https://matrix.org/bridges/

Re:On Privacy versus Freedom by Arathorn on Friday January 03, 2020 @03:30AM (#21944228)
We tend to be pretty conservative on maturity estimates on Matrix (and bad at keeping the website updated).

IRC, Slack, Gitter bridges are all considered stable these days.

XMPP, Discord, Telegram, WhatsApp work usably too.

The UX for managing them is not always great or consistent (we’re working on that currently), but “yet another protocol with its own chatrooms” is untrue. You can certainly access the entirety of Matrix via Bifrost (the XMPP bridge) if you so desire, for instance.

Re:On Privacy versus Freedom by Meldane on Sunday January 05, 2020 @05:56PM (#21964802)
Hi, I am trying to write an article in French to introduce Matrix to a wider public. Especially non tech people.

So I'd like to describe the possibilities accurately. Bridges are a very interesting feature, but how do you implement them ?

I went to the #whatsapp:maunium.net room and only saw guys wondering the same thing with no answer given to them.

I went to https://github.com/tulir/mautrix-whatsapp/wiki/Bridge-setup and understood they have to be implemented from the server itself ? Is that right ? So as a basic user I can't really make any adjustment on my side to join a Whatsapp group from Matrix, right ?

Re:On Privacy versus Freedom by Arathorn on Saturday January 11, 2020 @07:55AM (#22019625)
https://github.com/matrix-org/matrix-appservice-bridge/blob/... explains how to write them.

For adding them to a chat as a user, you need to use an integration manager (eg t2bot.io) or to run one yourself.

Re:On Privacy versus Freedom by progval on Friday January 03, 2020 @06:40AM (#21945054)
I only have experience with the IRC one, which is ok, but I think it deserves to still be considered Beta (see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21944035 )

Regarding Bifrost, it's the first time I hear about it. I'm glad it exists.

Is there an hosted instance that allows me to access Matrix rooms without installing anything other than an XMPP client? I can't find any info about it other than the code repo.

Re:On Privacy versus Freedom by Arathorn on Friday January 03, 2020 @07:30AM (#21945330)
The IRC bridge shouldn’t restart that frequently (and we’re in the process of decoupling the irc connectors from the bridge itself so we can fix bugs in the bridge without bouncing all its connections). Membership should categorically be synced correctly - if you ban a Matrix user on IRC their Matrix side should be kicked out too. If not, it’s a bug and we need to know the details asap. The only scenario I can think of here is if the matrix server was lagging on handling traffic, but that shouldn’t cause a desync like this either.

For bifrost; we used to run one on matrix.org but temporarily stopped due to lack of ops bandwidth. There’s a community one somewhere though - come ask in #bridges:matrix.org about it

Re:On Privacy versus Freedom by Arathorn on Friday January 03, 2020 @03:37PM (#21950061)
#matrix#[email protected] is the community one (and would take you to matrix from xmpp)
Re:On Privacy versus Freedom by blindgeek on Friday January 03, 2020 @03:06AM (#21944125)
I have lots of warm and fuzzy feelings toward Matrix, but my take is that XMPP solved my basic problem over 15 years ago. The problem being: I want to talk to Alice, Bob, Mary, Jane, Fred, and Joe without having to install ICQ, AIM, and Yahoo Messenger. Or should I say Facebook, Whatsapp, and Signal? I don't know what Matrix buys me over XMPP, but at this point, I don't care. I'll gladly drink the Matrix kool-aid, as long as it solves my problem and somehow ends up being the clear winner among federated protocols.

I don't think XMPP "lost" because it was bad technology. AFAIK the big players are still using it in various places under the hood. It lost because big players want to build "ecosystems".

Re:On Privacy versus Freedom by rakoo on Saturday January 04, 2020 @11:58AM (#21955918)
XMPP lost because there was no big player behind it willing to push it as far as possible under its public name. Only a community of enthusiasts and a steering committee that only cares about what is going in the next spec.

Matrix at least has a company pushing for it, so there's a better chance it'll have more success than XMPP; unfortunately we'll have to wait a few more years to see the difference.

Re:On Privacy versus Freedom by Arathorn on Saturday January 11, 2020 @07:52AM (#22019620)
tbf there was a big player (Jabber Inc), and they sold out to Cisco. Hopefully the difference is already visible for Matrix, or if it isn’t it should be visible this year.
Re:On Privacy versus Freedom by Leer10 on Friday January 03, 2020 @02:02AM (#21943892)
In practice those bridges function very well. It's common to find channels in the Matrix ecosystem that have IRC and Discord users that aren't even aware that there's Matrix participants.
Re:On Privacy versus Freedom by progval on Friday January 03, 2020 @02:38AM (#21944035)
The IRC bridge between matrix.org and freenode disconnects almost every week, showing sometimes hundreds of clients disconnecting, then reconnecting a few hours later.

I didn't check it personally, but I heard they (understandably) have issues enforcing bans: if one of their users is banned but another one is in the channel, the banned user can still read messages.

Re:On Privacy versus Freedom by zaarn on Friday January 03, 2020 @04:17AM (#21944432)
Matrix is general lacks support for community tools to handle stuff like that (unless you're running a channel with loose rules that doesn't get raided by 4chan on a weekly basis).
Re:On Privacy versus Freedom by progval on Friday January 03, 2020 @06:36AM (#21945036)
Yes and it's perfectly acceptable for a Beta service. It's just too bad they don't have a single bridge that's of release quality yet, while it was their main promise.
Re:On Privacy versus Freedom by zaarn on Sunday January 05, 2020 @06:37AM (#21960822)
I don't believe this is really fixable, on various occasions when I ask for the community tools I need, I get blown off and told that such features won't be implemented in Matrix or will depend on client support (which is unacceptable).
Re:On Privacy versus Freedom by Arathorn on Saturday January 11, 2020 @07:51AM (#22019616)
better late than never: i don’t know what community moderation tools you’re talking about here. we certainly haven’t closed the door on any moderation features in Matrix, and certainly wouldn’t make them client specific. my guess is you are conflating random feedback from randoms in matrix rooms with input from the actual matrix core team. https://matrix.org/docs/guides/moderation/ is the official moderation guide, which is evolving fairly constantly, and we have a tonne of work on communities & moderation coming up in Feb/Mar.
Re:On Privacy versus Freedom by stiray on Friday January 03, 2020 @01:45AM (#21943835)
And those are the reasons I use phone calls, sms and email. It is more than enough to keep contacts and to arange where you will meet in-person. For distant relations I prefer email, I always loved a well formed letter where sender has actually put some thought into it.

Yeah, I dont have 999 friends but those 10 good friends is all I need. And they DO call, sms, email me. For everyone else I dont care.

Re:On Privacy versus Freedom by balladeer on Friday January 03, 2020 @03:19AM (#21944174)
Personal emails also help with the urge to reply "right then" and there are no single, double, blue, grey ticks.
Re:On Privacy versus Freedom by Vinnl on Friday January 03, 2020 @05:48AM (#21944819)
> I want messaging to be like email

I'm not sure if I want that. Most of my communication over email can be read by Google, regardless of myself using Google. Moreover, there's the risk of things like AMP for email unilaterally changing the protocol in ways that as a user I might not like, but that I can't really influence through my choice of client.

I don't believe matrix.org will become such a thing, but if Matrix becomes as successful as email, I fear it's practically inevitable for a Google, Facebook or whatever to arise and become the dominant player, whereas that is practically impossible with, say, Signal.

I do see the value of the world that's made possible by technologies like Matrix, but I'm not so sure if they're possible with social processes evolving the way they do. I feel like Signal may be the best we can get.

(Though I'm certainly happy that Matrix is trying to prove that wrong.)

Re:On Privacy versus Freedom by m-p-3 on Sunday January 05, 2020 @08:12AM (#21961104)
> XMPP was supposed to solve all those problems when it came out in the early 2000s. But then all the big tech companies who build "ecosystems" decided to push their own applications, all incompatible with one another.

Facebook Messenger and Google Talk actually used XMPP back then, I'm sad it's no longer the case.

Re:On Privacy versus Freedom by kitd on Friday January 03, 2020 @06:00AM (#21944875)
A 'chat' client in the style of eg WhatsApp, but based on S/MIME over SMTP/IMAP, seems perfectly doable, and appropriate for most people's needs, with the obvious advantage of being supported by traditional email clients as a fallback.

Additionally, message threading is the feature I most appreciate in a messaging system, but which is painfully lacking in most products (and no, Slack doesn't cut it). SMTP has built-in support for it.

Re:On Privacy versus Freedom by marcus_holmes on Friday January 03, 2020 @07:22AM (#21945288)
I'm old enough to remember when this was exactly how email was used. (but using a normal email client).

It was acceptable to send one-word email replies, and there were email chains of hundreds of emails (I was the guy who tended to "snip" them after 20 or replies).

Now email seems to have taken over from where snail mail was: bills, newsletters, and formal communication. Chat is now the norm.

Though I do notice a generational divide: one of my co-founders is in his 60's, and will phone randomly (which is now considered rude), another is a bit younger and prefers email to messaging, but will message to ask if it's OK to call. My younger colleagues send formal email replies, and use Whatsapp/Keybase for all other communication. I vetoed using Slack in the organisation completely ;)

I wonder if in another 30 years, chat apps will be the formal channel, and something else will have taken over for just chatting.

Re:On Privacy versus Freedom by zelphirkalt on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @10:57AM (#21981130)
Yep: Direct thought transfer protocol, and people will just assume, that you are OK with them dumping their brain load full of irrelevancies and distractions into yours, unable to form a coherent thought and making an appointment, "because everyone is on TTP" (they wont know what TTP stands for though), so you are supposed to be too! And we will be "outdated", for using chat applications. "It's soooo slow!"
Re:On Privacy versus Freedom by jddj on Friday January 03, 2020 @06:50AM (#21945125)
There's an open source (GPL) client app (last updated last week) on F-Droid called Dib2Qm for exactly this, and it's apparently e2e as well.

I haven't used it, I just happened across it yesterday out of sheer coincidence.

Link: https://f-droid.org/en/packages/net.sourceforge.dibdib.andro...

Re:On Privacy versus Freedom by lazylizard on Friday January 03, 2020 @08:20AM (#21945579)
Re:On Privacy versus Freedom by kitd on Friday January 03, 2020 @10:02AM (#21946398)
Hmm, interesting. I might have a play.
Re:On Privacy versus Freedom by mirz23 on Saturday January 04, 2020 @04:25AM (#21953877)
Check out deltachat, it uses autocrypt and pgp for e2ee, smtp for transport and has a UI based on signal. It is compatible with autocrypt-supporting e-mail clients like thunderbird
Re:On Privacy versus Freedom by nirui on Friday January 03, 2020 @05:18AM (#21944700)
I guess most of the people that you mentioned can be reached through Email?

Email is a very good system, completely decentralized and yet still agile. It is sad that the protocol (SMTP, POP and IMAP etc) is stopped advancing into today's world.

If somebody from IETF is watching, maybe consider renewing the email protocol standards to make it more modern (like what you guys did in HTTP/2: Binary protocol, multiplex, better security etc)?

Re:On Privacy versus Freedom by brnt on Friday January 03, 2020 @11:30AM (#21947368)
I was using multi-protocol clients such as Trillian/Miranda/Pidgin for most of the 00's. It did not matter much what client/protocol somebody was using, in all likelyhood it was supported by such multi-protocol clients.

At some point, reverse engineering/implementing protocols must have lost the interest of that part of the community.

Re:On Privacy versus Freedom by Pete_D on Friday January 03, 2020 @01:34PM (#21948837)
> XMPP was supposed to solve all those problems when it came out in the early 2000s.

The really frustrating thing is that it almost did. I swear I remember at some point in the mid-2000s being able to send a message from Google Chat to Facebook. I think the option was hidden behind some account flags to enable external messages, but it was there.