#3 is really important. Do not shy away from sharing your stories with your potential new employer. It helps them better understand who you are. If they care about you and the investment they are making in you, then they will want to hire someone who is strong enough to stand up for something they believe.
Just keep your dirty laundry private would be my advice.
so, i struggle to see how hiding it is better from a game theory perspective. i do acknowledge that if your resume is strong enough as to "speak for itself", then not mentioning it is a reasonable enough gamble-- if they don't bring it up, and reject you anyway, then they are clearly idiots you don't want to work for anyway.
well, i guess I talked myself into a bit of a circle, but i guess i retain the claim that the prior of "hiding your baggage in all circumstances" is a bit more conservative than i think one needs to be.
We hired someone who came within a hair of (deservedly) being charged with a felony by the FBI. He basically said he did something stupid 10 years ago, had learned a lesson, made amends, etc. Had he not addressed it during the interview, we would definitely have not hired him when it later came up during a formal background check.
Was it a work-related alleged offense? If not, sounds a little extreme to not hire someone because of an allegation that happened 10 years ago that they weren't even charged with.
I think it's a tossup whether it should be mentioned in interviews because it can easily be misinterpreted/misread even by good employers to mean there's an issue with this applicant.
It's always said not to mention negative situations with past employers. I've been through some shit along these lines in the past, but at times wish to be honest about what I seek in a place of employment to give comparing perspectives. How did you go about explaining this?
* Don't put your negative experiences on the fore front.
* But don't hide them either, because:
1. if you do hide them, they might always bite you in the neck later (personally, or professionally);
2. there's a lot to learn here as well, and that's what you need to take the focus on: what you learned from it.
If you can show that you confronted the negative experience, and solved/learned something out of it, you demonstrate a very valuable strengh to your potential employer: humility, courage, resolution.
Plus, that you prefer to bring potential bad news yourself.
That's worth mentioning.
As a hiring manager myself I really hate it when candidates slag off their current/former employeer. It's a real put off. However if you can turn a negative experience into a positive then it shows that you're not just bitter and/or a bad team player but rather that you use all experiences to help enhance your capabilities as a productive employee.
What's wrong with being bitter when you are wronged by your manager or employer?
"and/or bad team player"
Sounds like blaming a victim to me.
Seriously, imagine you got robbed, beaten and humiliated how would you feel listening to someone telling you that being bitter about that is bad and it's your own fault?
Being bitter about past employers is a sure fire way to fail an interview (from my personal experience) because a mopey employee is a poor performer, but it's also a lame way to go through life regardless.
Then maybe it shouldn't ask questions like 'why have you quit your previous job?' and focus on applicant's skills?
What I don't like is presumption that a conflict at previous job is an employee's fault.
Quite a long time ago, when I used to work for a local company, I did some hiring as a team lead and tried hard to avoid prejudice.
As a hiring type, I absolutely want to know why, in your words, you left. I also want to see how that lines up with what your references and what former HR people say, and possibly even compare that to something like Glassdoor reviews (if you're a strong candidate, mind you).
It is important. I want to see how they describe the situation they're leaving/left because it allows me to evaluate their ability to comprehend and communicate social/political/team dynamics. Statistically you're not staying with us longer than five (5) years, which means at some point you're going to have to explain why you left me -- and I don't feel like dealing with a shit talker.
Plus an honest, direct answer is different from being blunt. I need workers who are willing to tell me direct, honest truths sometimes.
I.E. "I never really clicked with the team, and found I was struggling personally and professionally to keep up with their changing demands,"
vs.
"They were elitist assholes who changed things on a whim because they thought they were fucking geniuses".
What I don't like is presumption that an applicant who gives the first kind of answer, is a bad team player and if he doesn't put the blame on himself he is 'bitter' (which is bad).
In a interview you’re trying to paint the best possible picture of yourself, anything that detracts from that is wasted effort. Why would y’all talk about your shitty previous employer when we can talk about something else that is interesting.
In the setting you've described I agree with you.
Example: "my last employer screwed me and it was an awful place to work." vs "my last job taught me a lot about the pros and cons of workplace culture, which is why I'm interested in your company now". They are both true statements, but one indicates the prospective employee is upset and holds grudges, while the other shows they are ready to move on to a better job.
Over time they can probably share more about why they left, but with the limited time in an interview it is best to show what they are focused on. Focus on old employer and anger doesn't sit well, while focus on a new potential job and lessons learned is very impressive.
The first answer in your example is honest, the second one, while technically true, triggers my bullshit detector.
But a job interview is probably not the time or place.
Furthermore, there are often two sides to a story. It's entirely possible that I'll read your complaints as reflecting more about you than your current/former company.
More generally, raising gripes about teams/managers/work mostly don't use your interview time to raise positive aspects about yourself and your work even if they aren't necessarily negatives.
It can actually be a good filter, prospect-wise: a company that does gossip about/blame an ex-employee for some of their failures is advertising their own lack of agency.
If they were smart, they wouldn't gossip, and not even let the gossip go. That's very bad strategy, both internally and externally.
If they're not, well, I can't tell you what to do.
What happened to me:
1. first I spent several horrible months expecting my whole career to be over;
2. until I realized my ex-employer and its own reputation in the field was totally irrelevant and could not harm much my reputation (or better yet, act as a useful filter);
3. when looking for employment, when relevant, I explicitly mentioned this experience and what came with it, and what I was then looking for in a new company/position/team, so that I was the first to pitch what did happen and how I reacted to it.
It served me well. Those that listened to my story and took the time to understand it turned out to be great teams to work with. Those that dismissed me on the spot, well... I can't say really - but what I heard of afterwise from ex-employees was kind of reminiscent. :)