News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:"You've angered the hive" by JonnieCache on Monday February 07, 2011 @01:51PM (#2190124)
"So why can't you sell this information to the FBI like you intended? Because we're going to give it to them for free."

As ill advised as messing with the FBI may be, this is a masterstroke. Hats off.

Re:"You've angered the hive" by jayzee on Monday February 07, 2011 @02:31PM (#2190279)
You can't buy stolen stuff. If the FBI wants to use the stuff they may still have to pay for it.

Besides deals at that level are all political and given to their buddies. The person who gave the deal to HBGary is going to still fork over the money since what is a few $M between friends esp when they are not your $M.

Re:"You've angered the hive" by jessriedel on Monday February 07, 2011 @02:55PM (#2190374)
Your second paragraph is true, but the first paragraph only applies to physical property and, trivially, to legally protected intellectual property. ("Trivially" because in the case of intellectual property, the only value is in the legal protection itself, whereas for physical property it's possible to illegally transfer stolen goods even though the new possessor will not have a legal claim to them.) However, private-eye type intelligence has no legal protection as property as far as I know. It is only "sold" in the sense that the person who has it reveals the info in exchange for compensation.
Re:"You've angered the hive" by anamax on Monday February 07, 2011 @08:32PM (#2191544)
> However, private-eye type intelligence has no legal protection as property as far as I know.

Why do you assume that it isn't "born copyrighted" like almost everything else? (The big exception is pure data, such as the phone book.) The expression of observations is clearly copyrightable.

And then there's trade secret protection. The fact that they got hacked doesn't necessary void that.

Re:"You've angered the hive" by pyre on Monday February 07, 2011 @03:50PM (#2190666)
It depends on whether the information in question is the raw source information, or the actual intelligence report created by the private-eye.
Re:"You've angered the hive" by jessriedel on Monday February 07, 2011 @04:33PM (#2190879)
Only if the buyer intended to publish the report, in which case it would be the protected intellectual property I mentioned. But if the report were leaked before the private-eye was able to sell it, there is nothing he could do legally to prevent the potential buyer from acting on that information (which is usually why people hire detectives). In particular, the FBI would legally be able to investigate and prosecute people using HBGary's info without paying HBGary. Professional courtesy and/or conflicts of interest might prompt them to pay for it anyway, of course.
Re:"You've angered the hive" by ZachPruckowski on Monday February 07, 2011 @08:04PM (#2191485)
What about chain of evidence? Who's to say that the hacker didn't change details of the report between downloading it and publishing it? "This is a report from a security expert" sounds quite a bit better in court than "This is a report that another hacker claims is an unaltered copy he nicked from a security expert".
Re:"You've angered the hive" by pyre on Monday February 07, 2011 @05:23PM (#2191034)
I was assuming there would be some sort of copyright issues with the information. I think that HBGray owns copyright on the report itself since they likely have some sort of analysis in addition to the raw information organized in an understandable fashion, though I guess there might not be any 'fruit of the poisoned tree'-type issues with the FBI using that information in their investigation.
Re:"You've angered the hive" by rthomas6 on Monday February 07, 2011 @02:37PM (#2190307)
Is it really stolen if people just tell the FBI the information, and it just so happens to be the same information that the security group was going to give?
Re:"You've angered the hive" by HeyLaughingBoy on Monday February 07, 2011 @02:47PM (#2190347)
Say you and I know this really cute girl. Let's call her Susie. I just won the lottery and I bought a new Mercedes (or whatever the devil it is these kids are driving nowadays...) that I want to give to Susie for Valentine's day.

But on Feb 13, I leave the keys in the ignition when the car's in my driveway and you take it and give it to Susie as a present from you to her. You get the love, I get screwed.

Is it really stolen if you just give the car to her and it just so happens to be the same car that I was going to give?

Re:"You've angered the hive" by ecuzzillo on Monday February 07, 2011 @02:59PM (#2190393)
No, that's an example of stealing an object. Stealing an object is fundamentally not the same as telling someone something, even if it's something you didn't want them to say. This is why your example induces an obvious ethical reaction, whereas the original example induces a much more complicated one.

The better example is, you found out where her long-lost cousin lived, some guy eavesdropped, and HE told her where said cousin lived, and she jumped into HIS arms and drove off into the sunset. You are not now without an object that you formerly owned; you just planned to exploit a scarcity of information that no longer exists, and you're mad about it.

You also feel cheated because you were the one that did all the work to find her cousin, and he got all the benefit. That doesn't make it the same as stealing a car.

But in this case, the information was actually of little value, but because there was a scarcity of information in the first place, the FBI would have been none the wiser.

The ethics of spreading information are complicated. Oversimplifying them by comparing them to the ethics of stealing physical objects is wrong and bad.

Re:"You've angered the hive" by gphilip on Monday February 07, 2011 @11:42PM (#2191963)
"The better example is, you found out where her long-lost cousin lived, some guy eavesdropped, and HE told her where said cousin lived, and she jumped into HIS arms and drove off into the sunset. You are not now without an object that you formerly owned; you just planned to exploit a scarcity of information that no longer exists, and you're mad about it.

You also feel cheated because you were the one that did all the work to find her cousin, and he got all the benefit. That doesn't make it the same as stealing a car."

There's Something About Mary

Re:"You've angered the hive" by Jach on Monday February 07, 2011 @02:58PM (#2190390)
Please, let's stop equating information with property.

Say you're a guy in a pub and you overhear some private company contractors talking about just learning that a group of terrorists is plotting to blow up the Empire State Building, and mentioning some things in detail. You decide to tell the FBI about the terrorists, while they might refuse to give up their information if the price isn't right.

Re:"You've angered the hive" by ddagradi on Monday February 07, 2011 @02:55PM (#2190377)
You wouldn't download a car.
Re:"You've angered the hive" by pyre on Monday February 07, 2011 @03:54PM (#2190686)
Obligatory piracy warning from The IT Crowd: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ALZZx1xmAzg
Re:"You've angered the hive" by bloodnok on Monday February 07, 2011 @03:33PM (#2190572)
Fuck you I would.
Re:"You've angered the hive" by gcb on Monday February 07, 2011 @05:24PM (#2191041)
this is the reference (contains same language as parent post)

http://www.google.com/imgres?imgurl=http://www.thevrabec.com...

Re:"You've angered the hive" by Unseelie on Monday February 07, 2011 @04:05PM (#2190737)
I actually have downloaded blueprints for every patent filed...well, did in 2005. I'm just waiting for my printer.
Re:"You've angered the hive" by vacri on Monday February 07, 2011 @09:50PM (#2191718)
Of course not, it'd block the tubes!
Re:"You've angered the hive" by rhizome on Monday February 07, 2011 @04:25PM (#2190845)
I recommend familiarizing yourself with the concept of rivalrous goods.
Re:"You've angered the hive" by derleth on Tuesday February 08, 2011 @12:28AM (#2192074)
I recommend familiarizing yourself with the concept of making people think that treating nonrivalrous goods as rivalrous is a moral imperative.

After all, you wouldn't download happiness.

Re:"You've angered the hive" by rhizome on Tuesday February 08, 2011 @01:22AM (#2192184)
Ah, but you can steal a kiss.
Re:"You've angered the hive" by knowledgesale on Monday February 07, 2011 @11:15PM (#2191893)
Please, don't downvote opinions you don't agree with. Even though the opinion may look ridiculous to you in general(it does to me), it is clearly stated and has its inner logic and has the right to be expressed. Downvoting is for irrelevant or emotion-driven comments.

(see http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html )

Re:"You've angered the hive" by wtallis on Tuesday February 08, 2011 @12:31AM (#2192079)
Not all opinions are equally valid and worthwhile. In particular, opinions derived from from oversimplifications do not help the conversation and should be downvoted regardless of the stance.
Re:"You've angered the hive" by dools on Monday February 07, 2011 @10:06PM (#2191758)
This is a thoughtful enough contribution to the discussion. Should you really be downvoting something to oblivion because you disagree with the sentiment or find the content erroneous/apocraphyl?
Re:"You've angered the hive" by jharrison on Tuesday February 08, 2011 @12:07AM (#2192024)
Wouldn't the FBI want to get HBGary's copy anyway? Why wouldn't they expect the torrent to be tainted or incomplete?
Re:"You've angered the hive" by adn37 on Monday February 07, 2011 @04:21PM (#2190827)
The most astonishing info here is that this is HBGary that is involved.

Come on, we are talking about the rootkit.com guys. Not taking side is one thing, taking the opposite side is a completely different one.

Pretty much everything I learned for fun about rootkits, I learned it thanks to these guys.

I am speechless.

Re:"You've angered the hive" by getsat on Monday February 07, 2011 @04:25PM (#2190850)
Expertise with Win32 internals doesn't make you a competent sysadmin or web application developer. rootkit.com runs one of the worst custom web apps I've ever seen.

If you can't even get GET/POST/cookie escaping correct in PHP after years, you should probably not be building web apps.

It's a shame that their site is so bad when their book is so awesome.

Re:"You've angered the hive" by adn37 on Monday February 07, 2011 @04:54PM (#2190940)
Indeed.

I am speechless because they (started?) monetize going after the 'bad guys', while they have been publishing grey/black hat stuff on Rootkit.com for many years.

The trust is gone.

Re:"You've angered the hive" by hysterix on Monday February 07, 2011 @05:34PM (#2191073)
Yes to everything you said. The book is amazing, yet their web site is awful. It sucks seeing as how I'm in that list too.

p.s. - if anybody can crack my password, I'll be impressed.

Re:"You've angered the hive" by krschultz on Monday February 07, 2011 @04:05PM (#2190739)
Regardless of whether or not the information is handed over by Anonymous to the FBI, the company will get paid. There is a contract between the government and the contractor, and it will be upheld. It is embarrasing for the company but really this move won't change anything financially for either party.
Re:"You've angered the hive" by GBond on Monday February 07, 2011 @04:11PM (#2190776)
> It is embarrasing for the company but really this move won't change anything financially for either party.

I beg to differ.

National news about a security firm being hacked for its confidential IP can't be good for future business.

Re:"You've angered the hive" by krschultz on Monday February 07, 2011 @04:18PM (#2190814)
That's very true. But the conjecture that the FBI "won't pay [the firm]" becuase "[anonymous] will give it to them for free" is pure bullshit. Trust me, the company will still get paid.

If necessary, they will change their name.

Re:"You've angered the hive" by wisty on Tuesday February 08, 2011 @07:14AM (#2192634)
They will also probably do some security audit.

Believe me, there will be a lot of boxes that will need ticking, meetings, powerpoint shows, and sentences written in the passive voice.

Re:"You've angered the hive" by tomrod on Monday February 07, 2011 @10:09PM (#2191761)
I call BS on your BS call. Releasing something like this puts it into the public domain. Unless the FBI has a contract already in place, payment is not ensured.
Re:"You've angered the hive" by bmelton on Monday February 07, 2011 @10:35PM (#2191820)
Given the nature of how the government provisions work to contractors, they almost certainly do. Not being privvy to the task at hand, they likely had one of the following scenarios at play:

1) The Federal Government (hereby, "Fed") wanted the data. Fed puts out a request for proposal to qualified federal contractors to solicit work bids. Qualified federal contractors respond with work proposals, detailing the level of effort, the likely strategy to obtain the information, and establishing a cost and payment terms. Cost structure is either Time & Materials (T&M) or firm fixed. If it's T&M, they'll be paid for the time, effort and overhead required to have performed the task. If it's firm fixed, they'll be paid a set cost as established in the proposal.

2) HBGary had an existing contract for work with Fed. This contract may cover intelligence gathering, cyber intel, whatever. Fed creates a new task order for HBGary on the existing contract. Contract is either amended (if firm fixed, after the effort is quoted) or falls under existing task orders. HBGary is paid according to the terms of the existing contract.

To cut to the chase, there are other likely scenarios, but they all look similar to the above, and all involve HBGary being paid under the terms of the contract. Whether they're paid a flat fee or based on the effort involved depends on the terms of the contract. When they get paid depends on the terms of the contract. How much they get paid depends on the terms of the contract.

It sometimes happens that the government opts out of paying for things like this, and someone decides to buck the red-tape-brigade, but those matters usually end up in court as a contract dispute. Generally speaking, I think it's fairly safe to assume that HBGary is getting paid.

What I suspect a lot of people are overlooking here is that generally, if the government has contracted to buy something, EVEN IF somebody completely different comes up with the same good (tangible or intangible) for zero or significantly reduced cost, the government is not allowed to purchase unless there are provisions in their existing contract that allow for this.

The rules governing this process are the "Federal Acquisition Regulations", are set in stone, and are established so that both sides 'play fair'. The terms of the contract are always upheld unless there are exceedingly dramatic reasons not to, or failures of performance. If I contract to buy 10 servers for the government for $1,000 each, and somebody else then offers 10 identical servers to the government for $0 each, I will still be paid.

Since the cost of technology generally goes down over time, this prevents Fed from buying cheaper after the original contract was penned, and is allotted to protect contractors from the Fed, as well as the other way 'round.

It's complicated as sin, and yeah, there are loopholes out the wazoo (most of which relate to winning work,) but it's also defined, repeatable and ends up in HBGary getting paid.

Re:"You've angered the hive" by tomrod on Tuesday February 08, 2011 @12:35AM (#2192086)
Getting government rents must be very nice.
Re:"You've angered the hive" by bmelton on Tuesday February 08, 2011 @11:16AM (#2193378)
It's actually quite a hard way to earn a living. GETTING the contracts is next to impossible, as despite having the FAR in place, they generally are wired for a particular company. Most government work is, of course, only eligible to companies who have 'past qualifications' of doing similar work for government agencies, meaning that new companies have an even harder time breaking into the network of opportunities and that even if you've built a 100 'websites & cms systems' for government agencies, you're not qualified to build a system categorized as 'web portal' unless some of the work you've previously done was labelled as such in the contracts.

After you've gotten the contract, it's difficult to work with the government's red tape and still live up to the terms of the contract. If you've ever worked on a project with a prolonged or contracted management life-cycle, you have _some_ idea of what it's like, in a very small sense.

Changes requested are shot down by government lifers on little basis. "I vote no, until we've thoroughly thought about the security implications," was a valid rejection on a project I was running that involved, at least partly, replacing plain-text passwords stored in configuration files with Kerberos Keytab certificates. Infuriating, at best.

Meanwhile, slips to the project schedule don't affect your project's contractually obligated deadline. The government is generally happy to trod along at a tortoise pace while contractors run sprints in spurts -- weeks waiting on an approval for a change, then sprinting until it's done.

Add to that the required overhead of having somebody able to meet incessantly about every single line item in every single invoice.

Add to that the fact that in most government agencies, their IT staff is comprised by a heterogenous mix of slow government employees and other contractors that would love to see you fail (as they likely also bid on the work you won, and would love the opportunity to see it rebid in the event that you fail).

Add to that having to get approval on every single change in any product, no matter how trivial, by a committee of stakeholders -- the size of which shrinks and grows as the project moves on, and knowing that no change, however firmly approved, is ever REALLY approved until ship date (aside, months after development on a renovation had begun on a portal's backend infrastructure, senior government personnel were still arguing over the look and feel of a mockup that had been approved and finalized prior to the beginning of development.)

Again, red tape, red tape, red tape.

Re:"You've angered the hive" by tomsaffell on Monday February 07, 2011 @04:06PM (#2190745)
..until they come to negotiate their next contract.
Re:"You've angered the hive" by krschultz on Monday February 07, 2011 @04:16PM (#2190799)
And what then? The FBI uses the Bittorrent archive instead of paying the company? Please.

100% of my work is government contracting, thats not how this works. The only question is whether the FBI will ever use this company again, if the FBI thinks they are incompetent then HBGary is out of work. But if the FBI still believes they are competent then they will get another contract to find more information even if some of that information is already in the public domain. The FBI won't punish them for a criminal action. At my job, just because something leaked through Wikileaks doesn't mean its unclassified. We still abide by all the rules and you can get in a lot of hot water for talking about something off of Wikileaks that you do not have need-to-know on. It's as if leaks don't exist to the government.

You or I, and many companies would take advantage of the situation and just use the publically available information and not pay the PI firm. But this is the government. They operate in a whole different ballgame with a different set of rules. Anyone pointing their finger and laughing hasn't been through the requisition process, the government has thrown good money after bad in much fouler situations than this.

Re:"You've angered the hive" by rhizome on Monday February 07, 2011 @04:23PM (#2190836)
At my job, just because something leaked through Wikileaks doesn't mean its unclassified.

...as long as you're clear that this is merely company policy and is not actually a point of law.

Re:"You've angered the hive" by cpenner461 on Monday February 07, 2011 @09:38PM (#2191691)
I'm pretty sure this _is_ actually a point of law. Being released via Wikileaks (or similar) does not change the classification of the information released.
Re:"You've angered the hive" by rhizome on Tuesday February 08, 2011 @01:22AM (#2192183)
Correct, but classification does not cover regular citizens. The only people who can be prosecuted for revealing classified information are those who have sworn to protect it, i.e. people who have previously agreed to respect the secrecy. It's a covenant.
Re:"You've angered the hive" by lucasjung on Tuesday February 08, 2011 @09:38AM (#2192951)
Not true. Classified documents have cover pages explaining that they are classified and warning that you can be prosecuted for distributing classified information even if you haven't made the normal agreements associated with a security clearance. People who do have access, and who have signed the corresponding agreements are open to additional charges as well as pre-emptive extra-legal action for purposes of preventing or investigating security leaks (background investigations, polygraphs, etc.).

Actual prosecutions for people without clearance revealing classified information are generally rare because it's usually done as a form of journalism, which brings first ammendment issues into play. That's probably why wikileaks has made such an effort lately to re-cast themselves as a journalistic organization instead of just a clearinghouse for "whistle blowers."

Re:"You've angered the hive" by rhizome on Tuesday February 08, 2011 @02:29PM (#2194398)
Prosecuting the possession of information without clearance is done so rarely because a conviction on any of the points that touch the act is impossible.

The scenario you describe simply doesn't exist, it has nothing to do with journalism, and the onus is on those advocating for the validity of these kinds of prosecutions to distinguish acts from those which AIPAC members had charges dropped in the Franklin case just a few years ago.

I'd be interested in hearing about any successful prosecutions, so consider me eager to be proven wrong.

Re:"You've angered the hive" by lucasjung on Tuesday February 08, 2011 @06:09PM (#2195336)
I didn't say anything about possession: I said distribution. Huge difference.

I also didn't describe any scenario for prosecution, so I'm not sure what you're referring to when you say that the scenario I describe simply doesn't exist. The only scenario I described was the kind where prosecution doesn't happen.

My overall point was that your statement regarding the illegality was wrong: the illegality of distributing classified materials is not based on covenant, it is based on statute. The covenant part gives prosecutors a few extra charges to pile on for people who have clearances, but it's not the main piece. Whether or not such laws are enforceable in a practical sense does not change the fact that distributing classified material is, under current law, illegal regardless of who you are.

Re:"You've angered the hive" by rhizome on Thursday February 10, 2011 @12:31PM (#2202770)
The US does not have a state secrets law the way the UK and others do. If I find a piece of paper on the street, post a scan of it on the chans, then find out it was classified, what law have I broken? If you're going to say The Espionage Act, I don't agree. My understanding is that the prohibition on distribution covers only people who have previously agreed to respect classification.
Re:"You've angered the hive" by lucasjung on Friday February 11, 2011 @08:58AM (#2206318)
If you had no idea it was classified before you distributed it, you probably wouldn't have broken any laws. Given the way classified documents are labeled, that's an incredibly unlikely scenario: classified documents are marked with the classification level on every page and paragraph (individual paragraphs may be classified at a lower level than the overall document), and have cover sheets explaining exactly what the classification level means, which includes a statement warning the reader that anyone can be prosecuted for unauthorized distribution, not just people who have agreed to protect it. So your understanding is wrong: the prohibition extends to everyone. There are also directions for what to do with it if you aren't supposed to have it (e.g. "Return to nearest office of [appropriate federal department or agency].")

If the hypothetical piece of paper on the street were a single page marked with a classification level, but without the cover sheet and its explanation, you might be able to argue that you didn't think that you were legally prohibited from distributing that information. Then again, "I didn't know that was illegal, your honor," generally doesn't play well in the courts. IANAL, so I can't tell you what would happen in this situation, but I can tell you that even if you were to avoid conviction the overall experience would probably be time consuming, expensive, and generally unpleasant.

Re:"You've angered the hive" by rhizome on Saturday February 12, 2011 @02:24PM (#2210856)
Please cite the laws under which you propose that people without clearance be prosecuted for viewing Wikileaks releases.
Re:"You've angered the hive" by lucasjung on Saturday February 12, 2011 @04:47PM (#2211213)
Enough with the strawmen: I never said anything about viewing. I keep saying "distribute" and you keep substituting other words like "possess" or "view." Please stop.

For that matter, I honestly couldn't tell you which statutes provide for prosecution of non-cleared persons who distribute classified materials. All I can tell you is that every classified document has a cover sheet, and that at least some of those cover sheets specifically state that you can be prosecuted for distributing the contents to unauthorized people, even if you haven't agreed to protect it. It's been a long time since I've seen one, so I don't remember the exact wording but the warnings were stern enough that I remember them being there. Maybe the cover sheets cite a statute, maybe they don't specify. Maybe the whole bit about prosecution is a bluff, but I somehow doubt that an anal-retentive government bureaucracy would print official documents with a bluff that audacious.

Re:"You've angered the hive" by robryan on Monday February 07, 2011 @07:02PM (#2191320)
It's interesting government adopt this approach, seems weird that a government on the other side of the world could be discussing american diplomatic affairs while members of the government in america would be bared unless they are cleared under a classification system that has failed in this case.
Re:"You've angered the hive" by gcb on Monday February 07, 2011 @08:53PM (#2191588)
They clearly stated it was public before they leaked the documents to begin with.
Re:"You've angered the hive" by moe on Monday February 07, 2011 @06:11PM (#2191192)
But if the FBI still believes they are competent

Excuse me?

The FBI can't be that dense, can it?

Re:"You've angered the hive" by Confusion on Tuesday February 08, 2011 @12:57AM (#2192139)
The competence of the firms intelligence gathering ability is unrelated to the security of their computer systems. Whether the intelligence gathering was any good is hard to say, unless you take the released documents at face value. Taking something released by Anonymous at face value does not seem like a good strategy.
Re:"You've angered the hive" by incomethax on Monday February 07, 2011 @10:35PM (#2191822)
It isn't about HBGary being competent or not, its about whether or not they were able to fulfill the letter of their contracted terms.

If the FBI believes that the company can still fulfill its contract terms, and in a lot of situations that comes down to providing the requisite documentation showing sufficient protocols in place, then the FBI will continue to work with HBGary.

Much greater incompetence has been rewarded by the government bureaucracy than poorly picked passwords.

Re:"You've angered the hive" by thomasz on Tuesday February 08, 2011 @03:48AM (#2192412)
> At my job, just because something leaked through Wikileaks doesn't mean its unclassified. We still abide by all the rules and you can get in a lot of hot water for talking about something off of Wikileaks that you do not have need-to-know on.

Isn't that a little bit kafkaesque?

Re:"You've angered the hive" by flashgordon on Monday February 07, 2011 @06:02PM (#2191172)
Touche about governments throwing good money after bad money ( or just bad money after bad money for that matter)...

Virtual Case File anybody? - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virtual_Case_File

Re:"You've angered the hive" by maayank on Tuesday February 08, 2011 @09:55AM (#2193014)
I'm pretty sure it doesn't work that way and not because of "HBGary are friends with the FBI" as the other posters seems to think... HBGary probably have a contract with the FBI where the FBI pays either anyway or based on the results (probably the latter). Notice however that based on the results here is based on the results of HBGary only, unless there is false data in the results. Think of it this way - if the FBI contracted HBGary and HBGary did all the work and gave it to the FBI only to find out that the FBI contracted a second group at half the price and now refuses to give money to HBGary - would it seemed fair/probable that such a contract have been signed?