News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Downsides to working at a tech giant by senordevnyc on Monday December 23, 2019 @12:49PM (#21865410)
This is such a weird post. Big fan of Garry, but I don't agree with most of this.

1. Just because it turned out that you would have made $200mm doesn't make it a mistake. If anything, that outsized return proves just how rare this kind of outcome is. If you look at the YC startups graduating every year, maybe 1 will ever generate $20mm for an early employee, let alone $200mm. Joining a new startup for that kind of outcome is stupid, even (especially?) if the founder is a big personality.

2. What is the bizarre pie chart in the middle of this post supposed to show? I'm very skeptical that it's actually based on data of any kind.

3. What is the line about it being hard to believe that any company other than Google is going to make money? Apple and Microsoft both earn more than Google, don't they?

Bottom line, if you care about comp, you should know that no early stage startup of any kind offers an expected outcome remotely close to the big tech companies. Yeah, you might make a few million after working your ass off for many years. But realistically, you won't. But you would make close to that (or more) if you worked for the big tech companies for those same number of years, at a much lower risk.

If you want to do the startup thing, do it as a founder, not an employee. Start with 30-100% of the equity, not 1% or 2%.

Again, I'm a fan of Garry's, but I'm very skeptical of these posts by VCs trying to convince you it's a good idea to work at an early stage startup. Startups are great for them since they have a whole portfolio of companies to spread their risk across, but it's a shit deal for employees if you care much about comp. I don't envy the hassle of trying to hire at a startup when big tech companies literally pay 2-3x as more, but that's where we are.

EDIT: apparently the graph I referenced in #2 is showing that the top 5 companies in the S&P500 (as of sometime back in 2018) are equal in market cap to the bottom 282: https://www.newworldadvisors.com/post/the-role-of-private-ma...

Interesting, I guess, but pretty useless stat for the topic of this post. It also ignores about 200 companies in the middle that have huge market caps as well. Like Visa or Walmart or Disney. More here: https://disfold.com/top-us-companies-sp500/

Re:Downsides to working at a tech giant by freddie_mercury on Monday December 23, 2019 @08:55PM (#21869221)
> If you look at the YC startups graduating every year, maybe 1 will ever generate $20mm for an early employee

YCombinator -- like all other VCs -- has the data trivially available to show actual compensation of early employees across entire classes of startups and not just cherry-picked best cases. After all, they have the cap tables and the exit dollar figures and how long it took to reach those exits and how many never exited. They probably show that stuff under NDAs to their LPs.

Just not to engineers.

Since YC, like every other VC, has never bothered to publish that kind of data I have to assume it doesn't support their boosterism case for working for a startup.

Re:Downsides to working at a tech giant by techslave on Wednesday December 25, 2019 @04:54PM (#21880684)
> They probably show that stuff under NDAs to their LPs.

Probably not. I can’t imagine why LPs would care. it’s not their problem.

Re:Downsides to working at a tech giant by 55555 on Tuesday December 24, 2019 @04:30AM (#21870900)
Very interesting point.
Re:Downsides to working at a tech giant by garry on Monday December 23, 2019 @01:38PM (#21865902)
Thanks for the note! I appreciate the feedback.

These things are crazy rare. I didn't do a good job of explaining then how weird this experience was. In the moment it felt like any other startup. Peter was great and well known but not outrageously famous the way he is today.

I also didn't do a good job of doing an intro on this idea that tech startups are taking over all of the economy. There are some things that I just take for granted— I guess in abstraction now there are trillions of dollars of market cap in just tech firms, and this fits with my overall view that software is eating every part of GDP. We see this every day, but it's not well explained in my video/post.

I was making a joke about Google eating all of the world's revenue, but it didn't land. Sorry about that.

Really appreciate the feedback here. You're totally right that it's more directly lucrative and lower risk to work at a big tech co. I just still think people should consider making things for themselves though.

Re:Downsides to working at a tech giant by jonny_eh on Monday December 23, 2019 @02:57PM (#21866748)
> I just still think people should consider making things for themselves though.

I've worked for startups and big companies. In both cases you're making something for someone else. Even then, at least at a "Big Company" you can sometimes choose to work on a product that you personally use.

Re:Downsides to working at a tech giant by senordevnyc on Monday December 23, 2019 @01:42PM (#21865952)
Yeah, I hope none of the criticism was too harsh. I'm a big fan, we've actually met in person, and I almost got into YC while you were a partner. Oh well :)

Agreed on most of your points here, especially about software eating the world. There's a good post here, just not sure this is it yet!

Re:Downsides to working at a tech giant by garry on Monday December 23, 2019 @01:48PM (#21866016)
Just trying to get better. Not too harsh at all. Thanks again.
Re:Downsides to working at a tech giant by akhilcacharya on Monday December 23, 2019 @06:24PM (#21868429)
> I was making a joke about Google eating all of the world's revenue, but it didn't land. Sorry about that.

Honestly, I found it slightly offensive.

Re:Downsides to working at a tech giant by garry on Monday December 23, 2019 @07:05PM (#21868668)
Sorry about that. Lots of other companies are going to make money, and that's a good thing.

It's certainly a bad thing for large tech firms to take out increasingly large portions of global profits. It also might be a secular trend without end.

Re:Downsides to working at a tech giant by commandlinefan on Monday December 23, 2019 @02:25PM (#21866435)
Yeah, the moral of the story, as far as I can tell, is: 1) make sure to know the kind of person who can write you a $72,000 check as if he was leaving a tip at Starbucks, 2) impress him enough that he’s willing to offer you $200 million when you’re 23.

I see now where I went wrong in my youth.

Re:Downsides to working at a tech giant by akhilcacharya on Monday December 23, 2019 @06:26PM (#21868438)
> 2) impress him enough that he’s willing to offer you $200 million when you’re 23

I think the answer to that is "Go to Stanford". For literally 99.999% of people that is never possible.

Re:Downsides to working at a tech giant by desert_boi on Monday December 23, 2019 @08:22PM (#21869081)
I think you're not giving the meritocracy at MIT enough credit. I went to a state university.
Re:Downsides to working at a tech giant by akhilcacharya on Monday December 23, 2019 @09:08PM (#21869276)
I'm not sure if this is sarcasm? I went to an unranked state university myself - I'd love to experience even a fraction of the respect these folks get.
Re:Downsides to working at a tech giant by desert_boi on Monday December 23, 2019 @11:03PM (#21869755)
It is not sarcasm. Stanford does indeed have the most alumni who founded unicorns. But Harvard, UC, and MIT round things out nicely, for American schools at least.

https://www.theatlas.com/charts/HJSgAUdPx

Re:Downsides to working at a tech giant by akhilcacharya on Tuesday December 24, 2019 @12:01AM (#21869996)
That's...effectively the same idea.

I'd argue that all meritocracy has completely failed people like me so I can't take that seriously at all.

I'd also argue for a replacement, but I guess I'm not credentialed enough to propose one.

Re:Downsides to working at a tech giant by sneak on Monday December 23, 2019 @03:56PM (#21867291)
Surprisingly, these sorts of people are both not that rare and relatively straightforward to connect with.

A year of low level engineer’s salary is, relatively speaking, not a lot of money in our industry/society, regardless of what that figure ultimately works out to as an integer.

Re:Downsides to working at a tech giant by TheCoelacanth on Monday December 23, 2019 @10:42PM (#21869662)
There are 607 billionaires in the US out of 320 million people. You need to meet over half a million people to average one person with Peter Thiel's level of wealth.
Re:Downsides to working at a tech giant by vjktyu on Tuesday December 24, 2019 @01:04AM (#21870203)
My personal controversial opinion is that life doesn't work like that half million people math. In reality, one either can meet a billionaire with very little effort, or won't meet one regardless of effort. Another controversial opinion: that ability to get the desired results with little effort is something that needs to be earned, it's not a casino.
Re:Downsides to working at a tech giant by sneak on Tuesday December 24, 2019 @02:57AM (#21870601)
You don’t need to be a billionaire to be able to write a check for $100k like it ain’t no thing.
Re:Downsides to working at a tech giant by S_A_P on Monday December 23, 2019 @01:06PM (#21865575)
Agreed. On the surface Im like, oh ok yeah that is good advice. But as I pondered the situation and remembered what I was doing at that age. If someone waved my annual salary in my face to join a startup there is no doubt I would take it. But how many of us hob knob with hundred millionaires or billionaires and get approached to leave their job? maybe .01% of the folks who frequent HN. It feels a bit humble braggy.
Re:Downsides to working at a tech giant by garry on Monday December 23, 2019 @01:29PM (#21865818)
I guess what I wanted to say was that if you are capable of building great software, you should join the .01%, because that was my experience.

I started as a reader of Hacker News just out of college, and it taught me a lot. Many of the founders we back came through Y Combinator and learned about startups here.

Re:Downsides to working at a tech giant by mikewhy on Monday December 23, 2019 @03:44PM (#21867203)
I have a hard time not reading this as a "pull yourself up by your bootstraps".
Re:Downsides to working at a tech giant by garry on Monday December 23, 2019 @05:09PM (#21867915)
I grew up poor as the child of refugee immigrants. I was food insecure. My dad was an alcoholic. Being obsessed with computers was literally the thing that changed my life.

That's just my experience, YMMV.

Re:Downsides to working at a tech giant by akhilcacharya on Monday December 23, 2019 @06:30PM (#21868456)
> That's just my experience, YMMV.

The vast majority of people like that aren't (and don't) getting into Stanford, period, because impressive-to-admissions-committee folks are usually children of other impressive people (not always, usually). I don't think it's possible to interpret this as anything but "pulling yourself up by your bootstraps".

Re:Downsides to working at a tech giant by garry on Monday December 23, 2019 @07:06PM (#21868675)
I guess I was one of those middle class scholarship kids. There were lots of them around and they were my friends. The private school kids honestly tended to keep to themselves. It's a part of my Stanford experience I found most jarring.
Re:Downsides to working at a tech giant by akhilcacharya on Tuesday December 24, 2019 @12:03AM (#21870004)
I know several "middle class" kids who went to Stanford. All of their parents were professors (or at least PhDs). The rest had parents who were doctors.

So, maybe things are different now.

Re:Downsides to working at a tech giant by alecbenzer on Monday December 23, 2019 @01:14PM (#21865650)
I hope that eventually as more and more people realize how much more they could make at big tech (IME a lot of people just straight up don't know, esp. when a lot of the comp comes as equity grants), startups will have to start paying more/offering bigger slices of equity. But seems we're not there yet.

I also wonder how much of this is driven by software engineers who couldn't (or, probably more realistically, don't think they could) get a job at Big Tech?

Re:Downsides to working at a tech giant by garry on Monday December 23, 2019 @01:30PM (#21865825)
Oh I agree— big tech is fantastically lucrative! I wouldn't dissuade people from spending some time there.

Separately I also agree that there's a big problem of credentialism in software engineering. We meet lots of amazing software engineers who didn't go to the right schools— that's a big reason why I funded Triplebyte.

Re:Downsides to working at a tech giant by opportune on Monday December 23, 2019 @01:36PM (#21865885)
The other big thing messing up startup comp right now are super-high valuations for mid stage companies. When you’re getting options based off an inflated evaluation your upside is low, and the probability your options become worth $0 even if the startup does moderately well (eg if it raises a round at $4b right before you start and goes public for $3b). Doesn’t matter how many options you got, they were pegged to an inflated evaluation
Re:Downsides to working at a tech giant by senordevnyc on Monday December 23, 2019 @01:46PM (#21865996)
Agreed. People are madly in love with working at companies like Stripe and Airbnb right now, but I'm not convinced the risk is worth it. They're giving out equity as if it's liquid, but it's not. So if I can get $200k per year in equity from Stripe or $200k per year in equity from Google, why exactly would I choose Stripe or Airbnb? Just in the hopes that the $200k will end up worth $400k or $800k? I mean, maybe it will, but that feels pretty speculative. Put another way, if you already worked at Google and had the opportunity to invest cash into those companies, would you put all your equity comp in Stripe or Airbnb?
Re:Downsides to working at a tech giant by rsanek on Monday December 23, 2019 @03:11PM (#21866902)
In the example where you have equivalent equity packages available at Google and Stripe/Airbnb, I think you're right -- it's hard to see how equity that has an uncertain liquidity horizon is equal in value to Google's, which you will definitely be able to sell in a year. However, I've found that offers from these companies compensate for that -- Stripe/Airbnb will offer more in equity than Google precisely because of the liquidity premium. Then it comes down to, how much of a liquidity premium do you demand as an investor?
Re:Downsides to working at a tech giant by CydeWeys on Monday December 23, 2019 @09:58PM (#21869496)
Google at least is insanely profitable. Are Stripe and Airbnb?

Seems to me that there's less risk in the Google stock than the others, because the others need a lot of potential future upside to justify their high valuations absent major profits, and if that upside fails to materialize the valuations will tank (as we're seeing with, e.g., Lyft).

Re:Downsides to working at a tech giant by bradleyjg on Monday December 23, 2019 @01:53PM (#21866067)
RSUs are the solution to this problem. With a double trigger a pre-public company can offer them without employees suffering a tax liability on illiquid equity.
Re:Downsides to working at a tech giant by throwaway1777 on Monday December 23, 2019 @04:17PM (#21867477)
RSU will make you pay tax at the marginal rate though instead of long term cap gains on options.
Re:Downsides to working at a tech giant by bradleyjg on Monday December 23, 2019 @05:56PM (#21868235)
NQSOs have the same issue and ISOs are increasingly difficult to issue as startups get to mid and late stages.
Re:Downsides to working at a tech giant by throwaway1777 on Monday December 23, 2019 @10:32PM (#21869635)
Valid points
Re:Downsides to working at a tech giant by fossuser on Monday December 23, 2019 @03:29PM (#21867077)
I understand the general skepticism, but if Peter Thiel writes you a check for your current annual salary as a signing bonus and asks you to join his new company - you’d be stupid to turn that down now.

Worst case you can just go back to Microsoft on failure without too much lost.

Today the salaries are higher, but they’re often pretty high at VC funded startups too.

Re:Downsides to working at a tech giant by DaniloDias on Monday December 23, 2019 @01:01PM (#21865532)
Could you recommend good reading from this guy? That article doesn’t reflect well on his judgment- the story, the decision to post this story- the idea that Peter Thiel literally told him to quit his job (after he answered the question of his current salary?!?)- none of it makes any sense to me.
Re:Downsides to working at a tech giant by garry on Monday December 23, 2019 @01:31PM (#21865833)
It's pretty bewildering to me too. The point is I said no, and it was the wrong decision. I ended up starting a company and later becoming a VC.
Re:Downsides to working at a tech giant by gregd on Monday December 23, 2019 @01:47PM (#21866005)
What I got out of the post is that the value you bring to a company, doesn't at all align with what you're actually paid, which is typical of our society.
Re:Downsides to working at a tech giant by senordevnyc on Monday December 23, 2019 @01:50PM (#21866042)
I think the truth is more complicated than that. The synergistic existence of the company itself is what allows each person to be able to create millions of dollars in value. And there was a risky bet made with capital to create that company in the first place, and those investors / owners / etc. making a solid risk-adjusted return on their investment hardly seems like a travesty to me.

I wish we did have more employee-owned cooperatives though. I think that's a better way to fix the inherent tension of owners vs employees.

Re:Downsides to working at a tech giant by Pfhreak on Tuesday December 24, 2019 @02:24AM (#21870486)
Yup. It's almost axiomatic that you are being paid less than you are worth to your company. This is a foundational piece of the capitalist mode of production.

I wish there were more software cooperatives, or worker owned businesses out there.

Re:Downsides to working at a tech giant by thatsenough on Monday December 23, 2019 @01:54PM (#21866077)
A cynical reading is this: he missed out by not buying a $200M lottery ticket, so the next generation of engineers and designers should buy lottery tickets.

Conveniently, the author is now in the business of selling lottery tickets.

(Then again, if he’d stayed at Microsoft he probably wouldn’t be in a position to sell lottery tickets).