News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How tracking pixels work by Rainymood on Thursday December 19, 2019 @03:09AM (#21832956)
>Safari and Firefox both block many third-party cookies by default (which is why I had to change Firefox’s privacy settings to get this experiment to work), and as of today Chrome doesn’t (presumably because Chrome is owned by an ad company).

Wow. I am very strongly considering switching to Firefox now, just from this paragraph.

Re:How tracking pixels work by colourgarden on Thursday December 19, 2019 @07:39AM (#21834341)
My immediate reaction to your comment was "How do you not know that?!" (I'm sorry.)

However, if people frequenting a tech forum are not aware of the privacy benefits that Firefox has been pushing for a long time now, we as "tech folk" have a responsibility to push out the message.

So you can find out more about Firefox tracking here - https://blog.mozilla.org/blog/2019/09/03/todays-firefox-bloc...

And the Firefox Facebook Container may also be of interest - https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/facebookcontainer/

Hopefully, you're now reading replies to your initial comment in Firefox!

Re:How tracking pixels work by CoolGuySteve on Thursday December 19, 2019 @08:11AM (#21834557)
I knew Firefox was working when within about 6 weeks of switching over on my computer and phone (along with using DuckDuckGo and the Facebook container feature), I started getting ads telling me to practice law in Pennsylvania and to fix my weird sideways penis.

Both of which were thankfully completely off target. Apparently those two categories are the birdshot of advertising.

Re:How tracking pixels work by tmaly on Thursday December 19, 2019 @11:45AM (#21836511)
I use firefox focus on mobile to erase my history everytime I close the browser.

So I am in a similar position as you in terms of getting the ad companies to just throw random guesses at me.

But here is what gets me. There is this new push by YouTube that let's you clearly label your videos just for kids.

If I am on YouTube and I am playing a video that clearly is made for only kids, why does YouTube show advertising that is targeted for adults?

Re:How tracking pixels work by vanadium on Thursday December 19, 2019 @12:39PM (#21837174)
I use Focus for ephemeral browsing (about 70-80% of what I do), and Firefox Mobile proper on iOS for anything I need to hold history or state within. Hope more people recognize the value of Focus for that reason alone.

Perfect mobile duo for me.

Re:How tracking pixels work by maroonblazer on Thursday December 19, 2019 @09:20AM (#21835088)
Genuine question: why do you prefer ads for things that are irrelevant to your interests over ads that aren't?
Re:How tracking pixels work by _jal on Thursday December 19, 2019 @09:29AM (#21835168)
From context, the OP likes it because it provides evidence that surveillance efforts against them are failing.

For me, a second reason to prefer them is that ads are noise. If the semantic content of that noise stays irrelevant, it is easier to ignore.

People can have a ton of other reasons, like avoiding temptation.

My turn - genuine question: did you honestly not know people feel this way?

Re:How tracking pixels work by maroonblazer on Thursday December 19, 2019 @11:05AM (#21836092)
As evidenced by your and the other comments, there's more than one answer to the question. The parent's explanation for knowing if their defensive measures were working were novel to me, so I was curious as to the motivation.
Re:How tracking pixels work by jasonlotito on Thursday December 19, 2019 @11:11AM (#21836156)
I know for myself, I always find it curious how people are against targeted advertising in certain areas, but completely willing to accept it in others, sometimes without realizing it. It's always amusing to me reading this on HN where targeted advertising takes place and no one bats and eye.
Re:How tracking pixels work by DataWorker on Thursday December 19, 2019 @11:47AM (#21836544)
Are you a targeted ad by your own definition then? If everything is targeted advertising then nothing is, which seems to be your thesis.
Re:How tracking pixels work by jasonlotito on Friday December 20, 2019 @10:59AM (#21845062)
> Are you a targeted ad by your own definition then?

How am I a targeted ad? I didn't say everyone on HN is a targeted ad. However, HN does show targeted ads.

> which seems to be your thesis.

Not even close. You should reread my comment for what it says, not what you want it to say so you can try to reply with a witless comment.

Re:How tracking pixels work by DataWorker on Sunday December 22, 2019 @10:01AM (#21857431)
Sorry I thought you were saying something worth commenting on, but you were saying something else. Can you point me to some examples of targeted advertising here? I mostly see comments and submissions and if those can count as ads then that’s not a useful definition of ads to me. Maybe you mean something else though.
Re:How tracking pixels work by andykx on Thursday December 19, 2019 @09:35AM (#21835204)
I am not totally against targeted advertising when I am being targeted based on my activity on that site, but I find it really creepy when ads are targeted based on things I've done outside of the internet, or conversations I've had. I don't like the idea that my activity unrelated to a specific site is being stored somewhere and sold to companies that could theoretically use it for whatever they want.

I don't mind supporting companies by not blocking ads on a page, but I do mind being "followed" by them around the internet and IRL.

Re:How tracking pixels work by randompi on Friday December 20, 2019 @04:42AM (#21842828)
I don't mind being targeted as well and if they push me cheaper and better promo all the better. It's despicable however if they start to skew the prices in their favor due to your interest in the item.
Re:How tracking pixels work by lightbyte on Thursday December 19, 2019 @09:37AM (#21835222)
My perspective - I do not want to see ads relevant to my interests. If I want to buy something that I care about I'll do my own due diligence for what a good product is. I don't want to be lied to and distracted by junk marketing trying to convince me I should buy something.
Re:How tracking pixels work by athenot on Thursday December 19, 2019 @10:43AM (#21835829)
Irrelevant ads are way easier to ignore. It's so off-target that your mind doesn't even loose a cycle trying to make sense of it. Then you get so used to not paying attention that the occasional relevant ad gets ignored too.

In short, this allows me to strengthen my focus. Even though this all happens semi-unconsciously, it makes me more immersed in the content I'm actively trying to pay attention to.

Re:How tracking pixels work by mdiesel on Thursday December 19, 2019 @02:08PM (#21838133)
And then there are irrelevant video popups...
Re:How tracking pixels work by reportgunner on Thursday December 19, 2019 @12:03PM (#21836738)
Simply because things I'm not interested in don't look interesting and therefore don't distract me.

Let's say I like cars and I don't care for travelling.

If both sides of the page are background image of a car, I will check what car it is because I like cars. If it's a huge picture of a beach I won't even notice because I don't care for beaches.

Re:How tracking pixels work by pelliphant on Thursday December 19, 2019 @12:33PM (#21837101)
Not op but I'll answer:

Advertising works, on everyone, including on me.

No matter how hard I try to not be affected by advertising, I can't stop it from working.

Now, with that said, if I have the option to be exposed to an advertisement for a category of products that I am likely to purchase anywhay, or a category that I will never purchase: Isn't it obvious that my behaviour is more likely to be influenced by the relevant add than the irrelevant one?

Some people might think that the word "brainwashing" is too strong to be used for describing advertising, and maybe it is, but is it really that strange that I would prefer a tiny amount of "brainwashing" over a small amount?

Re:How tracking pixels work by nerdponx on Thursday December 19, 2019 @09:28AM (#21835159)
I can't speak for the person you're replying to, but for me it's a sign that the advertising brokers/sellers don't know enough about me to advertise intelligently. Therefore they have less of my data (or less specific/identifying/informative data), which is a good thing for several reasons that have been discussed many times on this forum.

Worse advertising is a sacrifice I'm willing to make (as much as I do really like ads for things that are on sale when I happen to need them).

Re:How tracking pixels work by mr__y on Thursday December 19, 2019 @12:23PM (#21836977)
The ads can be made relevant relative to website's content, not my previous activity. If I'm reading a tutorial on how to fix something there may be ads for tools that are required for that. This is very relevant to me and at the same time does not need any information about my previous browsing history or other activities.

On the other hand, when I'm later visiting pornhub I'm unlikely to consider purchase of those tools even though they may appear relevant to my interests based on my previous browsing history. On the other hand, I am more likely to be interested in meeting hot moms from my area then - which is again solely context based.

Re:How tracking pixels work by bryanmgreen on Thursday December 19, 2019 @12:01PM (#21836717)
It's not only about the relevancy of advertisements.

I'm sure they'd prefer or even like advertisements that are relevant from page content NOT invasive personal tracking or profiling.

IE: You go to a bathtub website and see an ad for rubber ducks and soap because those products make sense with bathtubs, not with the users browsing history.

Sadly, sacrificing relevancy is currently the only move to speak out about tracking, as a consumer.

Re:How tracking pixels work by ksec on Thursday December 19, 2019 @03:27PM (#21838891)
I want sensible target advertising. As both a consumer and once shop owner I find the advert to be very powerful. The problem is I think current was of Digital Data Gathering and target advertising is going way off track.

I dont have a solution, as often it is with all these questions, but I hope there is a better way going forward.

Re:How tracking pixels work by ryukafalz on Thursday December 19, 2019 @09:36AM (#21835209)
Not GP, but: for me it’s never been about the ads. Poorly targeted ads are a sign that the advertising companies don’t have that much data on me, which is what I really care about.
Re:How tracking pixels work by sixothree on Thursday December 19, 2019 @10:10AM (#21835493)
Neither of those things you described are useful to me in any way. I would prefer the one that has respect for my privacy.
Re:How tracking pixels work by dorgo on Thursday December 19, 2019 @09:05AM (#21834951)
> if people frequenting a tech forum are not aware of the privacy benefits that Firefox has been pushing for a long time now

Maybe it's because this is a tech forum. I take care of cookies and third party (and even first party) resources myself - so I don't know and don't care what Firefox does by default. Defaults are good for the other 99% of the people (who usually don't visit tech forums).

Re:How tracking pixels work by Jallal on Thursday December 19, 2019 @03:46AM (#21833134)
Actually, this has been a strong focus of Mozilla foundation for years. The good news is that Mozilla has done a lot of refactoring / rewriting of its FIrefox codebase during the last year, and Firefox is now on par with Chrome regarding the technical aspects.
Re:How tracking pixels work by acolumb on Thursday December 19, 2019 @10:02AM (#21835429)
I use Firefox and what is ironic is the integration with Pocket - an on-by-default service that has tracking pixels [1]

[1] https://getpocket.com/privacy#passive

Re:How tracking pixels work by mirimir on Thursday December 19, 2019 @11:51AM (#21836592)
Huh. I didn't know that.

But I've always disabled it, on general principles.

Re:How tracking pixels work by lordnacho on Thursday December 19, 2019 @04:33AM (#21833349)
FF also makes it easy to run tabs in their own containers. They've thought a lot about privacy.

Plus they fixed their issues with performance, so it works just as well as the other browsers on my mbp.

Re:How tracking pixels work by the_real_sparky on Thursday December 19, 2019 @05:21AM (#21833561)
I was highly amused just a few days ago when a 1080p60 YouTube video was not playing correctly in Chrome (dropping frames), but played perfectly fine in Firefox. Resource utilization was not the problem on that machine. I tried restarting chrome, disabling extensions, etc but it seemed to just be some weird bug.

I will also take a moment to rant about the fact that YouTube allows you to select from a bevy of lower resolutions, but doesn’t allow you to select a lower frame rate. Many times I would rather watch a 1080p30 video on slower hardware instead of the 720p60 I am forced into selecting.

Re:How tracking pixels work by mojomark on Thursday December 19, 2019 @06:53AM (#21834069)
> I will also take a moment to rant about the fact that YouTube allows you to select from a bevy of lower resolutions, but doesn’t allow you to select a lower frame rate. Many times I would rather watch a 1080p30 video on slower hardware instead of the 720p60 I am forced into selecting.

I've thought about this too. I'm not certain, but I suspect this has to do with streaming video compression, specifically the fact that most video compression schemes I know of are temporal (i.e. they can eliminate the need to transmit a lot of data based on unchanged or productively changing pixels between consecutive frames). With a lower frame rate, the probability that pixels in consecutive frames being related decreases. That's my guess anyway.

Re:How tracking pixels work by leni536 on Thursday December 19, 2019 @08:26AM (#21834659)
In these cases 1080p30 is typically available. AFAIK there is a setting, only available to logged in users. If you are not logged in then youtube-dl is also an option. I also used a browser extension before to reenable the lower framerate options, but it stopped working.
Re:How tracking pixels work by prox on Thursday December 19, 2019 @05:45AM (#21833712)
Firefox even has its own Facebook container these days.

I recently went to a website which had 250 (!) tracking cookies for marketing purposes... As you might suspect it was ridden with ads.

Re:How tracking pixels work by hollander on Thursday December 19, 2019 @08:05AM (#21834528)
I don't understand why they don't have the same for Google. The FB container does not only force the facebook and instagram sites into that container, but keep the rest out, and disable buttons on websites that open in other tabs. Google is such an obvious candidate for this, but maybe their relationship with Google comes into play here?
Re:How tracking pixels work by Monory on Thursday December 19, 2019 @08:17AM (#21834586)
Re:How tracking pixels work by Spivak on Thursday December 19, 2019 @09:05AM (#21834948)
The Google container is less useful than just manually putting your Google session into a container because I would assume you don't want all your searches to go through your logged on session.
Re:How tracking pixels work by onreact on Friday December 20, 2019 @08:50AM (#21844074)
250? Geek Tyrant injects 400 just for marketing and 500+ in total!

I stopped recommending them.

Re:How tracking pixels work by kalev on Thursday December 19, 2019 @09:56AM (#21835384)
That paragraph alone just made me decide to switch to Firefox. In only 30 minutes, it blocked 120 (!) tracking cookies.
Re:How tracking pixels work by cj on Thursday December 19, 2019 @08:40AM (#21834770)
Doesn't Chrome have a "Block third-party cookies" setting (disabled by default) that you can enable in Settings > Site Settings > Cookies and site data > "Block third-party cookies"?

I'm under the impression that Safari and Firefox have this enabled by default. Is the only difference that it's disabled by default in Chrome?

Re:How tracking pixels work by ishitatsuyuki on Thursday December 19, 2019 @08:54AM (#21834867)
Safari and Firefox both have a blacklist of known trackers in addition to cookie blocking. Not only that, these browsers also fight against other means of fingerprinting.
Re:How tracking pixels work by saagarjha on Thursday December 19, 2019 @12:46PM (#21837257)
Safari does not have a blacklist of known trackers; it generates one dynamically based on tracker-like behavior it sees as you browse.
Re:How tracking pixels work by vanadium on Thursday December 19, 2019 @12:53PM (#21837331)
It feels telling that Firefox puts their Enhanced Tracking Protection settings pretty close to upfront as possible, and Chrome’s “Block Third Party Cookie” setting is for all intents and purposes to a non-technical user, both buried and off by default.
Re:How tracking pixels work by randlet on Thursday December 19, 2019 @09:14AM (#21835027)
Even if it's true it's a huge difference. Very few people are going to a) think about this issue and b) know the right terms to google for a solution and/or c) dig around in their browser settings to find the setting.
Re:How tracking pixels work by jefftk on Thursday December 19, 2019 @06:48AM (#21834046)
If you block third party cookies without having built out fingerprinting prevention, trackers switch from cookies to fingerprinting, which on balance is probably worse. And if you prevent that, sites need to serve ads without any information about the user they're serving them to, and make about half as much money.

Chrome is working on fingerprinting resistance and developing privacy preserving APIs that can replace third party cookies: https://www.chromium.org/Home/chromium-privacy/privacy-sandb... https://blog.chromium.org/2019/08/potential-uses-for-privacy... https://www.blog.google/products/chrome/building-a-more-priv...

(Disclosure: I work on ads at Google, speaking only for myself)

Re:How tracking pixels work by mherrmann on Thursday December 19, 2019 @06:56AM (#21834084)
I would assume that trackers always do what's in their best interest. Your claim that fingerprinting is both just a fallback and probably worse for the user thus does not add up to me. Wouldn't they always use fingerprinting if that is more powerful?

> Chrome is working on fingerprinting resistance and developing privacy preserving APIs that can replace third party cookies

And what will their (business and thus vital) interest in doing this probably be? Probably not what's in my, the user's interest. But what's in their customers' interest - advertisers.

> I work on ads at Google

Well...

(Thank you for the disclosure though.)

Re:How tracking pixels work by jefftk on Thursday December 19, 2019 @08:27AM (#21834667)
> Wouldn't they always use fingerprinting if that is more powerful?

Fingerprinting is less reliable and more difficult to use, but it's powerful enough that multiple companies will have a clear picture of your browsing history whether your browser blocks third party cookies or not.

Fingerprinting is worse for users because you don't have control over it. If you open a private browsing window, close it, and open another one you're a different user from a cookie perspective but the same user from a fingerprinting perspective.

> what will their (business and thus vital) interest in doing this probably be?

My understanding from what Chrome has said publicly is that they're trying to get both (a) websites can make similar money from ads as they do now, keeping browsing free and (b) users have much more privacy than they do now, keeping third parties from being able to compile browsing histories for users.

Users benefit from (a) because they value these sites and from (b) because they don't want their browsing histories leaked.

Re:How tracking pixels work by lopis on Thursday December 19, 2019 @07:39AM (#21834348)
Chrome doesn't need fingerprinting at all. If you are using that browser, you are already being tracked at all times. So by implementing fingerprinting resistance in the most popular browser, Google can thus hurt the competition while merrily continue their tracking business as usual.
Re:How tracking pixels work by jefftk on Thursday December 19, 2019 @08:30AM (#21834678)
If you read the links I posted above, Chrome's plan is not "implement fingerprinting resistance while leaving third party cookies alone". It's "implement fingerprinting resistance, add new APIs that give privacy preserving ways of doing some of the things third party cookies are used for today, and remove third party cookies".
Re:How tracking pixels work by blackearl on Thursday December 19, 2019 @08:58AM (#21834899)
The problem is Google tracking, not just third parties.
Re:How tracking pixels work by jefftk on Thursday December 19, 2019 @09:01AM (#21834922)
Google ads don't have any special access in Chrome. They use regular cookies.
Re:How tracking pixels work by OnlineGladiator on Thursday December 19, 2019 @12:34PM (#21837106)
Why would Google even need to use cookies inside of its own browser which is linked to your personal identity? It's like saying Facebook uses regular cookies on its own website to figure out which pages you visit. I guess they could, but they already have your page view history so it's kind of pointless. If anything it sounds like a red herring argument.
Re:How tracking pixels work by jefftk on Thursday December 19, 2019 @12:48PM (#21837275)
Facebook does use cookies to handle identity on their website; that's how they know you're you.

Google's ad networks do use cookies for ad targeting, even in Chrome.

Re:How tracking pixels work by OnlineGladiator on Thursday December 19, 2019 @12:56PM (#21837367)
I'm not saying they don't. I'm saying they have a litany of other tools (I've spoken at length with engineers at Facebook about how they do this) that really make those unnecessary. Obviously you know more about how Google does it, and admittedly ads is not my wheelhouse at all. But from what I understand: it's overkill.

If you can point me towards a source that discusses the technical details of how Google tracks its users, I'd be interested in reading it.

Re:How tracking pixels work by jefftk on Thursday December 19, 2019 @01:04PM (#21837455)
> I'm saying they have a litany of other tools (I've spoken at length with engineers at Facebook about how they do this) that really make those unnecessary.

That's not how identity works on the web. Cookies are how every site tracks logged-in identity, including Facebook. To test this, clear your facebook.com cookies and observe that you're logged out.

Re:How tracking pixels work by OnlineGladiator on Thursday December 19, 2019 @01:10PM (#21837514)
I think we're talking about different things. I'm saying they don't need cookies to identify you, not that they don't use cookies for anything. Saying Facebook can fingerprint its users without cookies isn't even a controversial statement. Otherwise how would they track users without accounts?
Re:How tracking pixels work by jefftk on Thursday December 19, 2019 @01:55PM (#21837956)
FB can track users without accounts via cookies; you don't have to have a login to use cookies.

But they may also be fingerprinting; I don't know how they do things.

The key thing from my perspective, though, is that Google ads don't have any sort of special treatment in Chrome.

Re:How tracking pixels work by Consultant32452 on Thursday December 19, 2019 @08:24AM (#21834638)
Yep, on the occasion I need to use chrome it's very upset by the fact I'm not logged into my Google account. I'm sure most users log in. So Google really, really knows who you are.
Re:How tracking pixels work by blackearl on Thursday December 19, 2019 @08:59AM (#21834909)
The profile will connect to Chrome if you use any Google products with a login. changing this is opt-out
Re:How tracking pixels work by Consultant32452 on Thursday December 19, 2019 @11:09PM (#21841656)
Is it possible to get Chrome to never nag me to create and log into a profile? When I open Chrome right now it asks me to authenticate or "Browse as Guest."

Honestly it's kind of a rhetorical question because by having the nag screen the damage is already done to Google's reputation and it makes me feel really icky. Opting out of the nag screen just hides the grossness, and I would rather be reminded that using Chrome, and by extension all Google products, is just a bad idea.

Re:How tracking pixels work by oneeyedpigeon on Thursday December 19, 2019 @09:12AM (#21835000)
A site could make a lot more money by selling its users' passwords to the highest bidder — that doesn't mean we shouldn't try to deny them that income. Without sharing personal data, ads can still be relevant to the scope of the site itself (less so for incredibly 'broad' sites such as facebook, of course, but they get compensated by having a much larger audience). A site can also gather whatever personal data it wants, and serve its own ads.
Re:How tracking pixels work by jefftk on Thursday December 19, 2019 @10:02AM (#21835428)
Chrome's Privacy Sandbox proposal [1] is about (a) having interest-based ads without (b) letting third parties track users across sites. Have a look at it, especially FLoC [2] and PIGIN [3].

[1] https://www.chromium.org/Home/chromium-privacy/privacy-sandb...

[2] https://github.com/jkarlin/floc

[3] https://github.com/michaelkleber/pigin

[dead]
Re:How tracking pixels work by zo1 on Thursday December 19, 2019 @08:26AM (#21834657)
At this point, they're not that great at either ads or search. They just have a huge amount of market share momentum behind them. They're then able to then use this to influence and mold the web in the direction that suits/grows their business. E.g. AMP, HTTPS, google-play lock-in, no-root access on devices, and a host of things that all synergize with each other to make it next to impossible to fight back as a consumer (even a skilled/informed one).

Regarding them not being that great at search. It's non-trivial to see how blog-spam and fake generated websites are pummeling google's results. We've all encountered it, and have learned to kinda skim/ignore it to get to what we really want, but it's there, and it's dragging us all down.

Not only that, but here we are more than 2 decades since they started, and being one of the largest data companies in the world with untold amounts of potential training data, and they can barely do basic search inference. They practically guess the most likely "thing" you are actually searching for and don't bother to go further. Checking whether the content of the site speaks to the "thing" or "noun" that you want instead of just having it as text inside of it? Forget it. Maybe if I append certain things it means I want the thing I'm searching for to be somehow related to this additional term?

Call me crazy, but I would have imagined that at this point we would be living in an actual digital super age instead of what we have now. I am no longer going to say that we have "all of humanity's combined knowledge" at the tips of our fingers. We simply don't. We have basic facts and a whole host of brain-vomit content that I have to read/watch in order to extract the information I need, without even being able to tell how authoritative it is.

Re:How tracking pixels work by jefftk on Thursday December 19, 2019 @08:40AM (#21834767)
> So the reason why Facebook (that I rarely use and block using the Facebook container extension) serves me better ads than Google (that has known me since before I left school) is because Google is clueless?

While Google has a lot of information, most of it is not eligible to be used for ad targeting. For example, Gmail data can't be used at all, and Search data can only be used in cases where information about what you were searching about won't be leaked.