Fingerprinting is less reliable and more difficult to use, but it's powerful enough that multiple companies will have a clear picture of your browsing history whether your browser blocks third party cookies or not.
Fingerprinting is worse for users because you don't have control over it. If you open a private browsing window, close it, and open another one you're a different user from a cookie perspective but the same user from a fingerprinting perspective.
> what will their (business and thus vital) interest in doing this probably be?
My understanding from what Chrome has said publicly is that they're trying to get both (a) websites can make similar money from ads as they do now, keeping browsing free and (b) users have much more privacy than they do now, keeping third parties from being able to compile browsing histories for users.
Users benefit from (a) because they value these sites and from (b) because they don't want their browsing histories leaked.
Google's ad networks do use cookies for ad targeting, even in Chrome.
If you can point me towards a source that discusses the technical details of how Google tracks its users, I'd be interested in reading it.
That's not how identity works on the web. Cookies are how every site tracks logged-in identity, including Facebook. To test this, clear your facebook.com cookies and observe that you're logged out.
But they may also be fingerprinting; I don't know how they do things.
The key thing from my perspective, though, is that Google ads don't have any sort of special treatment in Chrome.
Honestly it's kind of a rhetorical question because by having the nag screen the damage is already done to Google's reputation and it makes me feel really icky. Opting out of the nag screen just hides the grossness, and I would rather be reminded that using Chrome, and by extension all Google products, is just a bad idea.
> Chrome is working on fingerprinting resistance and developing privacy preserving APIs that can replace third party cookies
And what will their (business and thus vital) interest in doing this probably be? Probably not what's in my, the user's interest. But what's in their customers' interest - advertisers.
> I work on ads at Google
Well...
(Thank you for the disclosure though.)