"First Premise: Suffering and death from lack of food, shelter and medical care are bad.
Second Premise: If it is in your power to prevent something bad from happening, without sacrificing anything nearly as important, it is wrong not to do so.
Third Premise: By donating to aid agencies, you can prevent suffering and death from lack of food, shelter and medical care, without sacrificing anything nearly as important.
Conclusion: Therefore, if you do not donate to aid agencies, you are doing something wrong."
[1] https://www.thelifeyoucansave.org/the-book/
They bought back the publishing rights, so it is freely downloadable.
How can I join this learning ?
https://books.google.it/books?id=vhmZCgAAQBAJ&redir_esc=y
"A passionate and convincing case for the sophistication of nonhuman minds." —Alison Gopnik, The Atlantic
https://www.psychologytoday.com/gb/blog/animal-emotions/2017...
The point of the exercise is humility — to think about how people in the future might think your ethics are wrong and evil — not arrogance.
It's not at all arrogant to think future people will share my ethics, just like abolitionists were not arrogant to hope for a world without slavery. Arrogance would be believing they'd share all of your ethics, and just as well I'm sure most abolitionists were still very racist, sexist, homophobic, ...
Everyone from Caesar to the crusaders to Martin Luther to the American revolutionaries to the KKK to the Amish to the imperial Japanese to the 1960s hippies to the Taliban to the IRA is on the right side of the shift as they see/saw it.
We can't all be right, some people have to be wrong. Some people will be right on some things and wrong on others. Some people will be so right or wrong on particular things that it will overshadow how right/wrong they were on others.
I'm not even sure that clean meat relies on genetic modifications, but even if, so what? There is no reason to believe that targeted changes are more harmfull than random mutations.
Circumcision aka male genital mutilation is the first thing that comes to mind.
Wikipedia link: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jordan_Anderson#Letter
Since public education became a thing for all the states, conservative Christians have been opposed to it. They will moderate their message depending on the audience, but when discussed among themselves they talk about abolishing it. The really ridiculous thing is how schools are funded. I won't go into it here, but it guarantees that poor people will have a bad education.
It is for many things but education (not indoctrination or brainwashing) is not one if them. Thankfully I realized this very early.
Some amount of education does occur, but it's incidental to social indoctrination, keeping parents' wages high by forcing kids out of the job market, etc.
That's America's choice to have a failing system, not a universal property of schooling.
Both public and private schools can be places where people experience violence, but many more people experience violence at home first.
Rein it in, minuteman.
What more could you ask for in a prison?
I hope you never see a real prison. I'm serious about this. They are horrifying.
By the way, what do you call a well-treated slave?
It does happen, and if I did meet someone that was forced into slavery, I would hope that I could find help?
If anything I was defending public school? What the hell are you talking about?
It's easier to agree with if you widen your concept of slavery, beyond the specific institution of African slavery in the US... during the later years. That system was so brutal and unethical by slavery standards. So, it's hard to compare to.
Before, during & after chattel slavery, the Americas had other systems of "slavery." Most were not that* brutal, but still slavery.
Indentured service was huge, at a certain point. Share croppers. These people probably outnumbered free employees in many times and places.
Serfs were not free to go. Monks were arguably enslaved by abbots. Artisans sometimes bought apprentices as children.
In western Europe, the "tenant" concept that replaced serfdom was often similar to sharecropping.. arguably also a system of slavery.
We know of ancient examples: Greek, Roman, Jewish, Persian, Babylonian... Ancient law codes (including the bible) dedicated a lot of ink to slavery laws. Slaver rights, slave rights, manumission, and such. A Greek slave could be wealthy, and that should help broaden the concept.
Marxism sees slavery in class terms. Ie it's just a name to describe the lowest class, and wage labour is a descendant of slavery.
There are even many modern-economy examples where employers have a say in an employee's marriage or reproductive choices. That arguably is slavery-like.
Anyway... once you widen the concept of slavery with multiple examples that you easily accept as "obviously slavery*, drawing analogies to other institutions is easy.
Indenture, for example, exists, today, in practice, widely... in many forms. Invariably, the "slavers" think it's ethically sound.
I don't know that the former master was genuinely hurt as much as he was trying to get some more free labor.
I became vegan after asking myself that same question.
Here we go again, everyone posts their pet not-actually-barbaric thing under the moral authority of people from the future.
Very few problems are as unambiguous as slavery. A lot of our problems are much more nuanced.
The most barbaric things we do now are probably closely guarded by people as legitimate traditions or rights.
Besides, frequency of an event isn't a defense against charges of barbarism. Lobotomies, the Tuskegee Experiment, and eugenic sterilization weren't all that common, but they were barbaric.
If we are being honest, open heart surgery is barbaric. They cut people open and then break all their ribs.
It's not assault or murder, for a variety of reasons that I'm not going to go into.
Further, experience tells me that granting good faith in these arguments is usually a bad idea. I oppose the right-wing on every issue. Abortion is particularly important in this context because it normalizes state based oppression against women.
So the poster shouldn't have an opinion?
"Further, experience tells me that granting good faith in these arguments is usually a bad idea."
Isn't granting good faith to others' arguments one of the cherished ideals on HN?
People have been using free speech absolutism over the last couple of years to popularize poisonous ideas. Should we keep letting that happen?
EDIT: Maybe they have an opinion, but frankly that lot don't spin this as an opinion. It's barbarism. It's murder. It's evil. Don't act like their isn't a larger context to all of this.
I understand the desire to group that opinion along with PizzaGate or some other toxic nonsense. That's exactly the sort of cognitive dissonance I'm talking about.
I am actually sympathetic to and support single mothers in all sorts of ways, not that people should have to qualify philosophical opinions with virtue signalling.
https://www.humanesociety.org/resources/pets-numbers
It's very sad but legal.
Yes. All of them.
I've never had to do so with a flat-earther simply because I've never met one.
But the others? Sure, I treat them like human beings.
Marginalizing people for their beliefs will not change their minds but it WILL fracture society. I think some people will side with the "opposing view" simply because they are indignant when they see how the sanctimonious mob treats them.
Somehow I'm being sanctimonious because I'm not going to pretend that there is no historical context to all of this.
That's what they have been doing this whole time. The far-right pushes against the bounds of decency and then the center-right says that you aren't being civil when someone brings it up.
I'm not marginalizing anyone. I'm just not going to pretend that there is no larger context.
Of course, but if you say which ones they are they'll be censored on all the consensus based websites like this one, since people won't agree.
I remember a (googleable) exchange of letters between the former owner and an ex-slave. The former was genuinely hurt by slave's betrayal and urged them to go back.
There were people for whom owning other people was so normalized that they were actually angry at their former slaves. I wonder if any of our current practices will be viewed as barbaric. Or maybe we'll go back and the future generations will laugh at our idealistic concept of "human rights", while sipping drinks served by their slaves.