News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Abe’s New Word Order by ginko on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @03:14AM (#21822866)
Isn't this essentially telling other languages how they're supposed to work?
Re:Abe’s New Word Order by gumby on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @03:45AM (#21823014)
Well it's liker the German government saying that they will always write München even in English; that doesn't say anything about how English speakers (or German private citizens speaking English) might choose to refer to Munich. In Malaysia "Datuk" is used as a combined honorific with a name when speaking otherwise completely idiomatic English rather than being translated into "Sir So-and-so"

It's not really different from the Maharashtran givernment deciding to write Bombay as "Mumbai" in English (which is how my grandfather pronounced it even when speaking English).

Unaddressed in the essay is how the construct SURNAME given_name (e.g. BREL Jaques) is quite common in countries like France -- not used in social conversation but in all official contexts including work and school. And let's not forget "Bond, James Bond."

The "communitarian/individualist" split and even more so its onomastic implication is overrated IMHO as you can see from my French example above.

Re:Abe’s New Word Order by roenxi on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @05:23AM (#21823542)
> Well it's liker the German government saying that they will always write München even in English; that doesn't say anything about how English speakers (or German private citizens speaking English) might choose to refer to Munich.

I suppose this sort of thing instantly confuses me - why aren't we already calling the city München if that is what the Germans are doing?

Re:Abe’s New Word Order by twic on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @08:07AM (#21824398)
Exonymy. Here's a lightweight survey of it in Europe:

https://www.citymetric.com/horizons/which-european-cities-ha...

One fun fact in there: there's a town in Bulgaria called Plovdiv, but the Italians call it Philipoppoli - and they've been calling it that since long, long before it was called Plovdiv!

Re:Abe’s New Word Order by 205guy on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @04:22PM (#21829629)
Lightweight indeed. That article seemed so promising, and then it was just arbitrarily limited by its data (as the author admits but doesn't do anything to fix).

That topic has so much missed potential. He admits he left off Venice, but what about Aachen/Aix-la-Chapelle, a historical town if there ever was one. Most of his examples are just different languages changing spelling to fit their conventions (eg Italian names ending in -o). But it totally overlooks pronunciation (Paris is totally different in French and English). It would be much more interesting to understand why cities sound different in different languages, for example London in English and Londres in French--why did they add they add the r sound to that word?

Re:Abe’s New Word Order by posterboy on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @07:34PM (#21830972)
I didn't know Londres.

I heard about Durres, Albania, for the first time today, too.

I had wondered about a connection between door, Germanic \dorz, Latin forum* and port, porta, portal before (Latin f frequently corresponds to English d, e.g. inferior, En under).

Suppose -dres for Londres once meant port, which is always a good guess for any bigger city's name. I can't confirm it though.

Durres derives from Dorian Greek Durrhakhion, but Greek has thura for "door"; so if I'm correct, they would have loaned the form with d. Ironically, Albanian dere "door" has a homophone "bitter; difficult, tiresome" (from a different root if akin to Greek due "misery") and one traditional explanation of Albanias means difficult coast (although there was a historical kingdom Albania far off from the coast).

By the way: It's Londer in Albanian, too, and Londres in many Romance languages.

tl;dr: nobody really knows, and the first address for French etymology doesn't explain Londres either

Re:Abe’s New Word Order by thaumasiotes on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @09:06AM (#21824910)
> but the Italians call it Philipoppoli

Judging by Italian wikipedia, Filippopoli, which makes much more etymological sense.

I wonder what the Italians think of this:

> The city has historically developed on seven syenite hills, some of which are 250 metres (820 feet) high. Because of these hills, Plovdiv is often referred to in Bulgaria as "The City of the Seven Hills".

Re:Abe’s New Word Order by posterboy on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @06:14PM (#21830469)
Eh? Siebenbergen is in Czech I thought, or Tschechien as we call it.
Re:Abe’s New Word Order by thaumasiotes on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @06:26PM (#21830555)
There might be another one, but I was thinking of the more famous city built on seven hills, Rome.
Re:Abe’s New Word Order by peshooo on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @01:02PM (#21827467)
Well, that was the ancient name of the city.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philippopolis_(Thrace)

Re:Abe’s New Word Order by TazeTSchnitzel on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @06:01AM (#21823727)
For the same reason German speakers say Wasser but English speakers say water. Words diverge over time.
Re:Abe’s New Word Order by chownie on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @07:50AM (#21824282)
Part of it is that language diverged, but it's also because if you're in country X talking about country Y and you have a long enough history you'll have a word in language X for country Y.

I recall a story but I'm not sure of its authenticity, it described western traders asking portuguese translators to give them the pronunciation of 日本 (Nihon/Nippon the native word for Japan). The PT translators interpreted the characters through Mandarin and come out with "Jipangu" which would be the root etymology for our english term "Japan".

Re:Abe’s New Word Order by yorwba on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @09:58AM (#21825452)
The reconstructed Middle Chinese pronunciation for 日本 is /ȵiɪt̚ puən/. In some languages, such as Japanese, the ȵ became an n. In others, such as Mandarin, it denasalized to a fricative like ʐ̩ instead. The etymology for English "Japan" /dʒəˈpæn/ is apparently Portuguese "Japão" /ʒɐ.ˈpɐ̃w̃/ via Malay "Jepun" /d͡ʒəpon/, via Min Nan 日本 (Ji̍t-pún) /ʑit̚⁴⁻³² pun⁴¹/ which itself is probably a loan (using Min readings of the characters), since the Min languages split off the Chinese branch before 日本 came to be used for Japan.

https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/%E6%97%A5%E6%9C%AC#Pronunciat...

Re:Abe’s New Word Order by 9nGQluzmnq3M on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @09:37AM (#21825219)
Not Mandarin, but some unspecified southern dialect (probably Fujianese/Hokkien, where it's Jitpun).

If Mandarin had been involved, we'd call Japan something like Arben (Riben) in English.

Re:Abe’s New Word Order by gurkendoktor on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @05:30PM (#21830154)
> why aren't we already calling the city München if that is what the Germans are doing?

You mean, what the Deutsche are doing :) Why stop at the city level?

Re:Abe’s New Word Order by majewsky on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @05:47PM (#21830276)
While we're on it, I demand that people stop saying Dresden. Over here, we call it more like Dräsdn, or somethings Dresdne.

(I just now notice that a sincere implementation of this effort would require adding some diacritics to the German writing system to accomodate the Saxonian dialect.)

Re:Abe’s New Word Order by layoutIfNeeded on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @06:00AM (#21823718)
From Wikipedia:

The name of the city is derived from the Old/Middle High German term Munichen, meaning "by the monks".

Re:Abe’s New Word Order by frabert on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @06:12AM (#21823773)
The Italian name for München/Munich is Monaco (literally "monk"), which makes a lot of sense now :)
Re:Abe’s New Word Order by desdiv on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @07:13AM (#21824062)
Which brings up the question, what is the Principality of Monaco called in Italian? To save you a guys a trip to Wikipedia:

The city state of Monaco is also called Monaco in Italian. Both the English and the Italian names are derived from the Greek word Monoikos, meaning "single house".

The German city of München is called Monaco in Italian and Monacum/Monachium in Latin. The Italian name derives from the Latin name, which in turn is derives from the Latin word for monk.

To avoid confusion, the German city is more commonly referred to as "Monaco di Baviera" (Monaco of Bavaria) to better differentiate it from the microstate.

Re:Abe’s New Word Order by GuiA on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @11:25AM (#21826441)
> Unaddressed in the essay is how the construct SURNAME given_name (e.g. BREL Jaques) is quite common in countries like France -- not used in social conversation but in all official contexts including work and school

Pointing that it’s common in other cultures weakens the article’s argument that “East Asians put their family name first because family affiliation was traditionally the most important information about a person, the individual identity coming second.”

Re:Abe’s New Word Order by Baeocystin on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @03:48AM (#21823031)
Frankly I don't care one way or another regarding the ordering, but as a method to unambiguously specify which name is which, regardless of order, I'm all for it.
Re:Abe’s New Word Order by oddeyed on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @03:35AM (#21822955)
I don't really think so - I think it's more about asserting that the name ordering does hold meaningful and legitimate significance for people who are native Japanese.

For comparison, consider the loan word in English, "Sushi". No one in English would consider calling it by the name "Raw Fish and Rice" because the term "Sushi" implies a specific cultural context and carries the connection to Japan, Japanese culture and history etc. Trying to take the word "Sushi" away from the concept of "Sushi" would be almost rude, as it is de-valuing the social context that it is connected with.

By comparison, at the moment, East Asian people typically re-order their names to fit Western norms in Western contexts, which by the the opposite token implies that the name ordering isn't that important, and doesn't carry any significance to the person who wears the name. Deciding to use the traditional ordering isn't about telling other languages how they're supposed to work, it's about asking other people to acknowledge your cultural context as legitimate and equal to their own.

The decision to do this now may well, in this case, be steeped in nationalist sentiment as the article implies.

Re:Abe’s New Word Order by baddox on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @03:54AM (#21823056)
But the optimistic view is that the name order normalization is motivated primarily by the desire to minimize confusion among speakers of the language in question (in this case, English). Using the Western name order for Japanese names in English could simply be a straightforward way to translate names without requiring a lot of additional explanation to English speakers. That’s the same reason we almost always transliterate the Japanese names in English, and I don’t see much argument to stop doing that.

To me it seems like a better idea is to promulgate the convention of uppercasing the English family name in contexts where different name orders are likely to appear. I believe I have seen that convention on TV broadcasts of the Olympics, and it seems like a good idea.

Re:Abe’s New Word Order by thaumasiotes on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @09:32AM (#21825179)
> By comparison, at the moment, East Asian people typically re-order their names to fit Western norms in Western contexts, which by the the opposite token implies that the name ordering isn't that important, and doesn't carry any significance to the person who wears the name.

As mentioned in the article, only the Japanese do this. (Well, Hungarians do too, but they're not even West Asian.) East Asians except for the Japanese do not reorder their names. Normal practice for a Chinese person would be to use an English name in English contexts.

Re:Abe’s New Word Order by baddox on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @02:39PM (#21828485)
That’s definitely true, and I suspect many English speakers are unaware of this. How many American basketball fans know that Yao is the family name of Yao Ming?
Re:Abe’s New Word Order by thaumasiotes on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @05:17PM (#21830057)
Heck, I was unaware. But the thing that surprised me was that Japanese names are presented backwards in English media, not that Chinese names aren't.
Re:Abe’s New Word Order by fiblye on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @04:39AM (#21823279)
It isn't. Spoken English uses the expressions "first name" and "last name", but in official documentation, everyone pretty much asks for your family name/surname and given name. Those aren't determined by order.
Re:Abe’s New Word Order by tus88 on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @03:54AM (#21823064)
No, it's when Japan writes in English, not when we do.