I'll never forget the day in lab meeting when it came out that I was a US citizen. I thought my accent and appearance would have made it obvious, but evidently my coworkers had assumed otherwise, and the response was an astonished "Then what the hell are you still doing in academia?" followed by looks of pity when I admitted to loving research. This was a biomedical lab at Carnegie Mellon about a decade ago and I was the only one doing ML work, so their astonishment was in part due to an underestimation of the market value of my degree, but on the other hand their intuition was likely accurate with regard to the STEM PhD market outside of AI.
Those PhDs are worth $pittance + green card, but not worth $pittance.
I trippled my compensation by deciding to work in industry.
And not only that, but the push for STEM imo has more to do with lowering wages and getting more software engineers (especially for S and M, I don’t think there is any real critical lack of PhDs. In fact a very large amount of physics and math phds just go into data science or software engineering). It’s entirely an economic problem, if it’s even a problem at all.
I was an undergrad in the late 90s, and even then there was no point. It made sense if you wanted to pursue an academic career (barely) and it made sense for immigration purposes. Personally, I’m an advocate for very open immigration, instead of creating weird niche paths to citizenship.
Probably because they import so much cheap labor it's a lot easier and more sane/lucrative to do something else.
>Or, in other words: there were as many American citizens getting CS/EE grad degrees in 2016 as there were in 1990.
The push for STEM has been incessant for extremely real concerns. Our population is just. not. entering. the STEM graduate courses. Yes, this needs to change, but it's a cultural problem, not an availability problem.