News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by closetohome on Monday December 16, 2019 @08:37PM (#21809648)
The search for an ongoing revenue stream is one of the most destructive forces in the tech industry. It leads to some very customer-hostile experiences.
Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by asdff on Monday December 16, 2019 @10:47PM (#21810332)
That along with buying an entire new product for a minor gain. So what if the new car is super green? You are replacing one multiton hunk of metal and hazardous waste with a brand new multiton hunk of metal and hazardous waste, doubling your footprint of extraction of resources from the earth but netting the same utility. Or people who replace their perfectly functioning phone with a completely brand new phone to continuing to use the same exact trio of apps on a screen with darker blacks.

The most frustrating part of tech is how disposable it is by design. It's degenerate and seemingly inescapable.

Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by ClumsyPilot on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @01:42AM (#21811247)
As annoying as replacing a phone is, I don't think the argument works for ecological dimension. The car produces many times larger carbon footprint in the course of being used, than comes from its manufacturing.

Plus you are not destroying your old car, they are sold onwards and used for decades by someone anyways. You are probably enabling someone to replace a rusbucket two or three steps down the line, possibly in a condition so bad, it does not pass road worthiness tests.

Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by AngryData on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @06:34PM (#21830624)
Well, unless you implement the Cash for Clunkers program that just smashes up a bunch of cars for a quick buck, then they don't get used. So many good and valuable cars, and especially car parts, that were all lost. People think "But it was a $500 car! They can't be good!" Except ive fixed and driven many $500 cars for the same amount in parts and put another 100K+ miles on them. $1000 for 28 MPG and 100K miles is a pretty damn good deal if you are poor as shit.

But now those cars mostly don't exist because we smashed them all up and weren't allowed to part them out either. Instead of spending $20 for $150 worth of parts, now I gotta buy all new Chinese manufacturer replacements for 10X as much.

Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by lbotos on Monday December 16, 2019 @10:33PM (#21810273)
My fave is "subscription headphones": https://www.nuraphone.com/products/nuranow
Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by Izkata on Monday December 16, 2019 @11:42PM (#21810658)
> Please note: NuraNow is not a rent-to-own program — as long as your subscription stays active, the Nuraphone stays active too.

...isn't that straight worse than rent-to-own...?

Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by blaser-waffle on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @03:46PM (#21829253)
Rent-to-Never-Own
Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by spectramax on Monday December 16, 2019 @11:44PM (#21810669)
I had to double take on this to make sure it wasn't on the Onion. Wow, just wow.
Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by closetohome on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @03:41PM (#21818563)
For anyone wondering, these are also sold outright (though not on their site I guess?) for $400. They are essentially a generic pair of bluetooth headphones that don't even have ANC, and use some kind of proprietary charging cable.
Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by coupdejarnac on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @03:15AM (#21811666)
Interesting, I've been looking for case studies like this. I'm curious if there has been anything similar that managed to turn a long term profit.
Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by efreak on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @12:17AM (#21810853)
At least you get a free cable with it. With $20 RRP, I sure hope the entire cable is gold plated, not just the connectors.
Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by logfromblammo on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @11:21AM (#21815077)
Completely unsellable to anyone with a time preference extending beyond next month.

But the remaining market is probably big enough.

Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by cosmodisk on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @02:14AM (#21811391)
Well,now I've seen everything.
Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by suzzer99 on Monday December 16, 2019 @10:18PM (#21810202)
You mean you don't want a mattress subscription?
Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by raxxorrax on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @04:04AM (#21811912)
Especially in agriculture custom firmware is getting more and more prevalent. I think for many people wanting to be productive products like iCrap and consorts are generally not worth it.

I think John Deere tractors were especially restrictive for any form of unauthorized rapairs. Restricting access for selected partners is a very customer hostile behavior. It is like printer ink all over again.

Still there are high technically hurdles that can indeed be compared with the smartphone market that still supplies crappy software on otherwise decent phones.

Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by daemin on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @05:11AM (#21812224)
I think software broke economics in a way, since that was one of the only products which you could produce once and sell infinitely. No other thing on the planet you could do that with. All other things you need to transform something physical or spend time doing which results in a linear mapping between input and output.

Digital goods (such as music, games, etc) do not count as independent things since they are implemented as software. Also previously things like music you had to perform or distribute physically.

Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by bregma on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @09:30AM (#21813730)
I'd like to introduce you to some songwriter friends of mine.
Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by logfromblammo on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @11:44AM (#21815362)
Before computing divorced the idea of the file from the physicality of the storage medium, music was sold as live performance, printed paper, plastic discs, or magnetic tape.

Those all have a non-trivial cost of reproduction.

Now that music is just files, the marginal cost of sending a file down the network wire is proportional to its compressed file size, which is insignificant in relation to the cost of the human labor of creating a master recording.

Also, now that music is encoded digitally, all copies are (usually) perfect reproductions of the original.

Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by bregma on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @02:45PM (#21817864)
Long before the invention of paper, plastic, magnetic tape, piano rolls, or metal drums with pins, songs and stories and other kinds of "intellectual property" could be conveyed from mind to mind verbally. Such ideas were expensive and difficult to create the original copy (ever write a song or derive Pythagoras' theorem from first principles?), but the marginal cost of each reproduction was minimal and close enough to zero. It it weren't, whoever wrote those earworms I get would be fabulously rich by now.

Centuries, nay millennia, ago there were starving artists who created great works, only to have the economics of zero marginal cost of production take the food from their mouths. The appearance of and democratization of high-bandwidth telecommunication (enabled by computers, but not a property of computers) did not create that situation, it's only multiplied the zero marginal cost by a large constant. An if you've been paying attention, zero multiplied by anything is still zero.

Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by logfromblammo on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @05:38PM (#21819726)
I think you're discounting the cost of pre-network human communication a bit too much.

Before computers, it was nearly impossible to copy a musical song from one person to another faster than the time it took to perform it. And to go that fast, you needed someone trained to perform it well enough (cheap, but not free) and someone trained to memorize it by ear in one take (expensive). To do it more slowly, with more repetitions, you still needed someone that could perform what they had learned, which was cheap, but not free.

The cost of connecting the teacher with the learner was likewise not free. They had to be in the same place, physically. They might meet up, learn each other's repertoire, then split up again, so as to not compete with each other by working the same territory. The invention of written musical notation was a huge leap forward, in that it enabled the profession of composer/lyricist to be separated from that of the musical performer.

Millennia ago, great works were lost completely, because they were not copied enough to survive the deaths of everyone who knew how to reproduce them. That is not a thing that happens when copies are cheap. Even things that were written down have been lost, because copying written materials was not cheap enough until the printing press.

If making a copy takes a specialist four hours, and consumes paper and ink, that is nowhere near "close enough to zero".

Now, you can copy music in a millisecond, using a device that nearly everyone carries in their pocket, to anyone in the world who likewise carries a similar device. The cost is still not zero. It is just now too small to think about, unless you are making millions of copies per second.

Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by m463 on Monday December 16, 2019 @09:50PM (#21810067)
That and control of how the product is "mis"-used and data gathering.
Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by W__S on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @11:48AM (#21815402)
I may get tarred and feathered (well, more likely simply digitally snuffed out or whisked away to the digital concentration camp of shadow banning and/or digital gassing) for saying this here, but I think you are talking about two different motivations.

One is the VC/investor trap, where the primary unrealized motivation is actually just finding VCs that will fund some scheme to be the "next {insert hopes and dreams of boundless riches}", where far more often than not the winners are the cunning founders (Adam Neumann anyone?) and the VCs, with everyone else left holding the bag (Hello, WeWork starry eyed people that believed the predictions of alien visitation) if the effort can't be pawned off on someone else, or some "exit" to a corp in a kind of reverse defensive blackmail auction to snuff out or keep a competitive advantage from a competitor.

The other thing goin on here is that very predatory and pernicious and rent seeking nature you are directly referring to that seeks to constantly corral and rope in as many consumers as possible as the whole tech industry is rapacious in its lust to generate "ongoing revenue streams" through dependency or even (what used to be illegal) what amounts to predatory pricing and snuffing out alternatives by reaping havoc on the target industry and society. None of these tech companies should have been allowed to use this predatory pricing model to utterly decimate our economy as they have … Amazon, Uber, WeWork, etc. are just a few examples. At the very least it should not be allowed for public money (pensions, etc.) to be invested in companies that are unprofitable at certain ratios, e.g., over 1/4 of their existence.

One clear example comes to mind in Uber/Lyft and their wake of both immoral and illegal actions that have led to the utter collapse of the taxi industry through unfair competition, predatory pricing, and illegality. What we are now left with is a for-hire transportation sector that is now a far less competitive environment (Uber/Lyft compared to roughly 5-20+ taxi companies per city (Ignore the flaws of the industry that are irrelevant to the anti-competitive issue), but we are now also facing a collapse of competition on a far larger scale, essentially Uber/Lyft instead of literally tens of thousands of taxi companies just alone in the USA.

So what happens when the Taxis cannot keep up under the Uber/Lyft onslaught? Well, we know what happens, they use regulatory capture to limit and prevent competition and they start raising rates as they have and are doing.

Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by Semiapies on Monday December 16, 2019 @09:04PM (#21809782)
The problem is that not having a revenue stream is one of the most destructive forces to tech (or other) companies, and people like to keep their jobs.
Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by NeedMoreTea on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @02:07AM (#21811356)
Hardly. There are countless firms who built their reputation on and survived quite happily making durable products. You might find pages of their early products filling eBay and the like, still going strong. A few are still adhering to those built to last attributes, most have transitioned into "as cheap as we can get away with, but with our valuable brand and logo" as has most of the whole world, including those offering coffee pod and headphone (ffs!) subscriptions.

The steady progression of new people - some created every day, new homeowners and what have you was enough to give a vibrant business, and ongoing sales.

What changed was the deal.

Pre 1980s most companies tried to balance the needs of all - staff, customers, local area, and shareholders. Post 1980s only the shareholders count, all else is secondary. Products and offerings are made and subscribed accordingly. The few folk still making stuff to last seem to have an anachronistic worldview to go with it. Perhaps still care about craftsmanship, repairability, and reputation, rather than built in obsolescence, subscriptions and DRM'd parts. Now they can sell you the thing 15 times, perhaps 12 of those without good cause apart from greed.

Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by Semiapies on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @09:10PM (#21821119)
"Pre 1980s most companies tried to balance the needs of all - staff, customers, local area, and shareholders."

I think you have a very strong set of rose-tinted glasses. Planned obsolescence was a strategy long before 1980.

Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by NeedMoreTea on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @03:33AM (#21822942)
More that I remember the companies I dealt with back then, and the products they made which I bought. Many of which would remain static far longer, with readily available spares available in stores, alongside the new sales. There was some decent effort to use common spares across multiple models, often for decades unless something transformative required a major change.

I could compare and contrast in just about every sector I can think of. Sure there were some abuses, notably some of the car makers come to mind. The needs of the customers -- beyond making the initial sale -- were far higher up the priority list than today.

Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by andrey-g on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @11:33AM (#21815230)
Could you give some examples of such products?
Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by NeedMoreTea on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @03:42AM (#21822989)
Kenwood and Dualit kitchen equipment and Linn hi-fi. Still support products they made in the sixties and seventies, and have provided upgrade routes and repairs for later improvements. In each case those flagship products still exist, are still being made, perhaps with vastly better materials and technology almost incomparable with the original, and spare and repairs are still readily available.

Not too different with Hoover vacuums in the era of the Hoover Senior and Junior -- they stuck around, being repaired and reconditioned easily for decades. Had Hoover or Dyson not gone with cheap throwaway plastic for everything when cyclones meant capability improved in post 1980/1990 models we might have those lasting 30+ years easily too. As is they self destruct in a decade or less as more and more bits break. The (cheap plastic) spares that are available are priced such that you're heavily incentivised to replace. One or two commercial brands still make products that might last a while...

Most of the current kitchen appliance brands are mainly now just worthless logos, usually owned en masse in a larger group, probably after a leveraged hostile buyout. Now made in the same single factory and generate churn with new models every year - for the sake of difference not because there is any improvement, just deliberately changed from the previous. Spare parts might be just filter, lamp or element, often deliberately unique to model, and will be available at vastly inflated price for limited time only.

No end of other examples from hand tools, garage equipment, and home goods through to the most complex products.

Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by criddell on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @12:00PM (#21815570)
High end mechanical watches like Rolex and Omega. They keep parts going back decades. If a part isn't in inventory, there are watchmakers that can create just about any part from scratch.
Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by Semiapies on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @09:09PM (#21821113)
Note that these are products that conspicuous consumers may in fact buy several of, including new models as they come out.

Not exactly "farm tractors that last forever".

Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by suzzer99 on Monday December 16, 2019 @10:20PM (#21810210)
As I type this I'm looking at the Onkyo stereo and Polk speakers I bought in college. I'm 50 years old.

I can't help but think they regret making these things that durable.

Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by Red_Leaves_Flyy on Monday December 16, 2019 @11:03PM (#21810426)
UBI, more research spending, a flatter wealth distribution, and separating necessities from investment portfolios would help to allow developers to develop without living like stereotypical artists.
Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by cletus on Monday December 16, 2019 @09:36PM (#21809993)
You make a thing. You sell your thing. You sell it for more than it cost to make it. That's your revenue stream. But that's not enough (apparently) hence locking down repairs and other anti-end user behaviour.
Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by OldManAndTheCpp on Monday December 16, 2019 @09:43PM (#21810029)
Now you've shipped your thing that lasts forever. If it's a mechanical object, maybe you can get continuing revenue from spare parts, but those will bring in less than the original purchase. Worst case, someone brings up a factory copying your part design (without doing any engineering work on them, just copies them exactly), and undercuts you.

If you sell software, do you let the old stuff atrophy and become insecure? If not, you are spending salaries on maintenance without any associated revenue. As time goes on, the maintenance costs increase without bringing in another cent.

Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by cletus on Monday December 16, 2019 @09:55PM (#21810085)
On the software front, this is why I, personally, am a fan of the subscription model... if done right. And almost no one does it right.

The shining example for actually doing it right is Jetbrains. There is a schedule for new releases they keep to. You get loyalty discounts for long term subscriptions and ending a subscription entitles you to a version that is ~1 year old in perpetuity.

Plus the prices are (IMHO) entirely reasonable.

Almost no one else does this. Other companies will, say, take the MSRP of the software package, divide it by 12 and give you that as the monthly price with a minimum contract period of 12 months. They'll also restrict you to choose platform when you purchase and may limit the number of installs rather than concurrent users.

Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by pixelface on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @02:09AM (#21811366)
Another company using this model very effectively is Derivative, makers of Touchdesigner. Licenses are sold at an initial price that includes a year of updates. Once that year expires, the newest version (old versions are kept available on the site) within your update period will continue to be usable with your license - which is freely transferable between machines. They offer a couple license tiers, custom work, and paid support hours. They even provide a free non-commercial license that is minimally limited and great for learning. The other great thing is that they are highly responsive to user feedback and bug reports. I've had a situation before where we found a bug in the course of a project and they fixed it in a matter of days, had a build sent over in time for my deadline, and then the fix was pushed for everyone in the following update. I frequently point them out as a model for the best way to offer a software product to both a professional and amateur market. It's essentially all the benefits of perpetual licensing while still providing a revenue stream for the company and ongoing support for professional users.

No direct affiliation, but I've shared drinks with the devs and am a very pleased user.

Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by crc32 on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @05:18AM (#21812255)
> Now you've shipped your thing that lasts forever. If it's a mechanical object, maybe you can get continuing revenue from spare parts, but those will bring in less than the original purchase.

This might be bad for a tractor manufacturer; but an everlasting tractor would be great for society, right?

The incentive now is to innovate in order to create a better more efficient product. E.g.; a more fuel efficient tractor which increases productivity - then you'll get another sale.

Deliberately hobbling your product so that it needs repair or replacement disincentives innovation and is a form of rent-seeking https://www.investopedia.com/terms/r/rentseeking.asp and as such should be treated as a market failure. (I.e., legislated against)

Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by closetohome on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @03:35PM (#21818499)
Exactly - it's a perverse incentive against the interests of society.