News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by mmastrac on Sunday December 15, 2019 @02:46PM (#21798480)
Every time I see these guys pop up, I'm reminded of the time a decade ago where they literally copied my .NET profiler (nprof) into their "brand new" .NET profiling product at the time and just shipped it.

No apologies, no compensation for building a commercial product on something I had spent a decent amount of time on. Very disappointing of them.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by mshafirov on Monday December 16, 2019 @07:11AM (#21802483)
JetBrains CEO here

At the time, we had a student working on the project and they used a couple of classes from NProf code for loading the profiler under IIS. This was done incorrectly as it was not in compliance with the GPL license. This was brought to our attention on March 18th 2005, and after careful examination we responded on March 21st 2005, following up by removing said code and rewriting it. We indicated this resolution to you and you were satisfied and showed support for JetBrains. We do have reference to the aforementioned interchange between yourself and JetBrains. Should you require a copy, please let us know. We'd like to apologise for this mishap which was a complete oversight, and was remedied as soon as it was brought to our attention.

Feel free to reach me out if you have any further questions

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by mmastrac on Monday December 16, 2019 @10:58AM (#21803991)
Thanks for the (second) apology. It looks like some details got fuzzy over 15 years.

Apologies on my end for mis-remembering that I already received an apology from the VP of product development at the time.

That would be great - I no longer have the email in question as I lost access to that account and virtually all email records from the early 2000s ([email protected], I'm assuming). If you could forward that to [email protected] I can have that for my records so I don't forget the details again.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by swyx on Monday December 16, 2019 @10:26AM (#21803676)
that is a fantastic response. no coming back from that one. F.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by sah2ed on Sunday December 15, 2019 @03:06PM (#21798626)
> No apologies, no compensation for building a commercial product on something I had spent a decent amount of time on.

I think the important question here is did they do this in violation of the open source license you had adopted as at the time the alleged infraction took place?

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by kevingadd on Sunday December 15, 2019 @03:11PM (#21798658)
Something can be legal and still be incredibly tasteless. If you keep lifting major open source tooling as the basis of your product without contributing, you're eventually going to exhaust the patience and free time of the people working on it.

Think about it this way: When Linus started working on Linux and decided to release it under the GPL, was it because he wanted companies to use it as the basis of billion-dollar revenues without sponsoring development or compensating him for his work? Lots of people start contributing to open source at a smaller scale, where it's just individuals and small businesses and non-profit orgs sharing with each other, but it becomes kind of a different matter when a company has dozens or hundreds of millions to throw around and doesn't share back. At least in the case of Linux it is well-funded now but there are other cases where core infra has still suffered - you can find recent stories about how the maintainer of NTP struggled to pay rent even though massive companies rely on it.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by manigandham on Sunday December 15, 2019 @04:30PM (#21799130)
Taste has nothing to do with it. You can't give people an explicit ability to use your code and then be upset that they did.

If you want money then ask for it. Offer a product or service. There are dozens of licenses to choose from.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by sah2ed on Sunday December 15, 2019 @03:32PM (#21798786)
If you think doing so is tasteless, you are clearly approaching this with a social lens and I don’t necessarily disagree with your conclusions.

I chose to approach this with an economic lens, hence the question of whether the original license was permissive, which is the green-light that allows all commercial exploitations to not appear illegal in the eyes of the law.

Open source is one of those activities where developers, who are no less human than non-developers, interleave social norms with market norms.

As far as humans go, social & market/economic norms don’t mix very well [0], so an unfortunate side effect of a lot of open source projects is that our expectations as humans get routinely violated due to the unnatural mix, as your example of the open source NTP developer in near penury clearly illustrates.

[0] https://www.aglobalreach.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/04/Soci...

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by kevingadd on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @06:12AM (#21812494)
I think a fundamental root of this problem is that many foundational parts of the open source/free software model are social and not economic in nature. People are encouraged to view this as a commons, where everyone is helping each other and lifting each other up. In practice, if you put something on github, you're funding some tech company's products, you just don't know it yet.

In my case I built and maintained my software for 3 years and when I chose my license I knew the license meant that someone could repackage it and sell it. That was a decision I made, and maybe my decision was wrong, but in the end the economic factors meant I could no longer pay rent by doing it anymore, so I stopped. Those actors lost the foundation of their product as a result, so the economic factors didn't end up working out in their favor either.

I could perhaps have prevented their actions by using the GPL, but it wouldn't have suddenly made them pay me - they would have just lifted someone else's inferior permissively-licensed solution, because there were multiple options and mine was just the best. I did previously have corporate sponsorship, but that never lasts forever.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by acollins1331 on Sunday December 15, 2019 @10:30PM (#21800608)
Woah the tech tips guy wrote Linux
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by fabiensanglard on Sunday December 15, 2019 @02:53PM (#21798521)
What do you claim they copied? The GUI, the features?
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by mmastrac on Sunday December 15, 2019 @02:58PM (#21798555)
Code from the open-source nprof project made up a good chunk of dotTrace (confirmed via decompilation at the time).
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by wldlyinaccurate on Sunday December 15, 2019 @03:03PM (#21798595)
Which licence did you distribute the code with? Surely there's solid grounds for a legal case if the licence didn't permit commercial use?
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by mmastrac on Sunday December 15, 2019 @03:18PM (#21798697)
I wasn't really clear on licensing back then and it looks like I had a few GPL headers in the source.

EDIT: it was clearer than I thought - v0.4 [1] has an explicit GPL 2.0 COPYING.txt in the root.

[1] https://sourceforge.net/projects/nprof/files/OldFiles/nprof-...

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by ncmncm on Sunday December 15, 2019 @03:26PM (#21798750)
GPL is GPL. If their thing isn't, they are in violation. They now have deep pockets.

For anything that had no license spelled out, they had and have no license to use it at all.

To be clear: they appear to have no license to distribute your code today, and owe you damages for all the distribution they have done thus far that was not licensed.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by dannyw on Monday December 16, 2019 @01:15AM (#21801128)
To add, if they are still selling it today then it may reset any statue of limitations. I would recommend that you talk to a lawyer, and get them to draft Jetbrains a letter.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by ncmncm on Monday December 16, 2019 @02:00AM (#21801276)
There is no statute of limitations for copyright violation, to my knowledge. I gather Germany imposes some pretty draconian time limits for initiating enforcement, but have not heard of others.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by zenhack on Sunday December 15, 2019 @06:29PM (#21799702)
As others have pointed out, if they weren't distributing source and passing on the license, this is a blatant copyright violation, and what they were (still are?) doing is illegal.

If you're at all interested in doing anything about it, copyleft.org has a bunch of useful resources.

[dead]
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by ncallaway on Sunday December 15, 2019 @04:58PM (#21799264)
This seems wrong.

It turned out that they specified GPL, and so the redistributor is violating the license.

However, if they hadn't specified a license, then the product would be unlicensed. Which would make the redistributor directly violating their copyright.

If source code doesn't come with a license, that doesn't make it fair game. That makes it unusable by any third-parties.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by chris_wot on Sunday December 15, 2019 @03:04PM (#21798605)
That sucks. Are you just looking for an apology?
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by mmastrac on Sunday December 15, 2019 @03:13PM (#21798670)
Given that it's 15 years later, I'm sure that would be fine. It was really just disappointing for a me in his mid-20s.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by xnyan on Sunday December 15, 2019 @03:49PM (#21798884)
If they've done it to you, it's very possible they've done/do it to others. You should post your story. JetBrains is not a little operation and should to be held to account if they've done what you've said.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by ncmncm on Sunday December 15, 2019 @03:29PM (#21798768)
No. Contempt should be accountable.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by kevingadd on Sunday December 15, 2019 @03:04PM (#21798604)
Pretty standard in the .NET ecosystem, unfortunately. I had a similar experience with multiple tools vendors repackaging my stuff for free as the foundation of their product. The only time I ever got a sponsorship offer or even bug fix contributions was a while after I had stopped doing their work for them for free.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by mmastrac on Sunday December 15, 2019 @03:19PM (#21798702)
Yeah. That soured me on the .NET ecosystem a lot. I was a fan of VS.NET/Resharper at the time (pretty groundbreaking). I moved on to Java/Linux over the next couple years.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by manigandham on Sunday December 15, 2019 @09:09PM (#21800328)
This doesn't have anything to do with .NET specifically. It can and does happen everywhere.