News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is there dark matter at the center of the Milky Way which... by knzhou on Friday December 13, 2019 @04:26AM (#21780256)
This is a good article because it gives insight into how the scientific process works: nobody is "for" or "against" various dark matter hypotheses, an analysis that definitively supports either direction can be very interesting, and people who think a lot about dark matter often publish papers showing that various effects can't be due to it.

Actually, this is the default situation in our field, and it's a good one. The only issue is that typically only the "hottest" stuff get popular exposure, which usually means the most blaring declarations of discovery, like the hundreds of fifth force articles we just got hit with.

(My one minor complaint is that the headline by itself is misleading. The question is whether there is dark matter at the center of the Milky Way which also decays, leading to the signals mentioned in the article.)

Re:Is there dark matter at the center of the Milky Way which... by dang on Friday December 13, 2019 @02:57PM (#21784801)
Ok, we've added that decaying bit to the title above. Thanks!
Re:Is there dark matter at the center of the Milky Way which... by raxxorrax on Friday December 13, 2019 @06:39AM (#21780760)
Isn't it basically just matter that isn't detectable but has to exist because the known laws of nature told us it does? Instead some mystery goo that hides from our sight?

Yes, I am sure the mystery goo theories would get much more exposure. The pitfalls of pop-sci probably. I mean wich kid will get out of bed for a boring pulsar these days?

> "I was pretty excited, because I knew the implications were very big—it meant that the dark matter explanation was back on the table"

I don't understand this. Isn't this basically feeding? Doesn't this just say we know less than we thought? Were we in danger of knowing everything?

Re:Is there dark matter at the center of the Milky Way which... by noselasd on Friday December 13, 2019 @07:52AM (#21781101)
>Isn't it basically just matter that isn't detectable but has to exist because the known laws of nature told us it does?

> Instead some mystery goo that hides from our sight?

Maybe. We assume "dark matter" has to exists because it interacts with/creates gravity. The only thing we know that can do so is matter.

However this besides detecting gravity interactions with normal matter, this dark matter cannot be seen, not in any wavelenghts, nor does it block any light or radiation from normal matter that's behind it.

It's not like it's just a bunch of normal matter that hides in a corner we cannot see by normal means.

Re:Is there dark matter at the center of the Milky Way which... by amluto on Friday December 13, 2019 @12:40PM (#21783606)
> Maybe. We assume "dark matter" has to exists because it interacts with/creates gravity. The only thing we know that can do so is matter.

This isn’t really accurate. Everything interacts via gravity, notably radiation and gravitational waves. (The latter hasn’t been directly experimentally tested AFAIK.)

A major reason to think of dark matter as matter is its equation of state, i.e. how it behaves when stretched or diluted. If you put 10g of light in one box (this is possible in principle — it’s a lot of light, and you need a box with impossibly shiny walls) and put 10g of cool gas in another, they gravitate identically. But, if you expand the boxes the same amount, the light gets diluted far more than the gas. That is, if you double the box’s volume by moving one of the walls, you still have about 10g of gas but much less than 10g of light. If you had a third box full of 10g of dark energy and you double the box’s volume, you end up with 20g of dark energy. Yes, this is really weird.

Re:Is there dark matter at the center of the Milky Way which... by david-gpu on Friday December 13, 2019 @01:09PM (#21783873)
Wow, really? Isn't energy conserved? I would expect that expanding the volume of the box would have a negligible effect on the mass of the contents, whether they are light or matter.

And I say negligible only because my understanding is that even vacuum has a tiny amount of energy in it due to Heisenberg's uncertainty principle, so a box twice as large would contain a tiny bit more energy even if it was equally empty in both cases.

What's the name of the phenomenon you describe? I'd like to learn more.

Re:Is there dark matter at the center of the Milky Way which... by amluto on Friday December 13, 2019 @02:24PM (#21784512)
Energy is indeed conserved [0], but you have to take pressure into account. Suppose you build a cylinder with a piston, just like in a car engine or a bike pump. Start with the piston in a position that puts the interior of the cylinder at half its maximum volume. For simplicity, imagine that the outside of the cylinder is in a vacuum [1].

Now put some gas, light, or dark energy in the cylinder and then pull the piston out to its full extension. You've doubled the volume, but you're also done some work by pulling out the piston. If the cylinder is full of gas or light, the pressure is positive, so you did negative work (received energy) by pulling out the piston, and the energy in the cylinder decreases. For dark energy, the pressure is negative (crazy, I know), and you had to pull hard to extend the piston, so you put energy into the cylinder and, in fact, doubled the total energy in the cylinder.

[0] In general relativity, on large scales, conservation of energy is complicated.

[1] With a real bike pump or car engine, nothing fundamental changes if you have air outside the cylinder, but when you're talking about cosmology, you start considering that the whole universe is full of more or less the same stuff and it gets a bit more complicated. It all works out in the end, though.

Re:Is there dark matter at the center of the Milky Way which... by donmatito on Friday December 13, 2019 @04:42AM (#21780326)
This looks like a very healthy process, of people questionning their own results ! The scientific method, as it should be. beautiful
Re:Is there dark matter at the center of the Milky Way which... by acqq on Friday December 13, 2019 @04:08AM (#21780179)
It really seems to be very interesting and relevant work:

One of the authors vas a coauthor of the 2015 paper that was now disproven about its “it can’t be dank matter” claim:

"My hope was that this would be just the first of many studies of the galactic center region using similar techniques. But by 2018, the main cross-checks of the method were still the ones we'd done in 2015, which made me pretty nervous that we might have missed something."

And the whole article about this new paper is informative.

Re:Is there dark matter at the center of the Milky Way which... by tsukurimashou on Friday December 13, 2019 @06:49AM (#21780803)
> dank matter
Re:Is there dark matter at the center of the Milky Way which... by AnimalMuppet on Friday December 13, 2019 @12:12PM (#21783364)
Well, if the dark matter is also damp...
Re:Is there dark matter at the center of the Milky Way which... by raverbashing on Friday December 13, 2019 @04:12AM (#21780194)
It's an interesting approach.

More "debunking the debunking" studies like this are needed.

It seems there is a bias and "debunking with a weak method" is much more likely to be accepted than "proving with a moderate method". Ok, the null hypothesis might be more likely, but some methods are just inappropriate.

Re:Is there dark matter at the center of the Milky Way which... by mnw21cam on Friday December 13, 2019 @09:12AM (#21781643)
Re:Is there dark matter at the center of the Milky Way which... by girishso on Friday December 13, 2019 @06:32AM (#21780743)
Slightly tangential. One thing I always wonder about, is there no dark matter around us, I mean here on earth?
Re:Is there dark matter at the center of the Milky Way which... by maxnoe on Friday December 13, 2019 @08:45AM (#21781423)
There should be and we are looking for it. Several experiments are looking for WIMPs or other proposed particles on Earth or in the solar system.

But the amount us tiny, current estimates of the dark matter density in the Milky Way result in roughly 700 grams of DM in the Earths volume

Re:Is there dark matter at the center of the Milky Way which... by DougWebb on Friday December 13, 2019 @02:45PM (#21784703)
I've read (elsewhere, I guess) that some 95% of the Milky Way's mass is estimated to be dark matter. If there are only 700g of it nearby, it can't be distributed the same way normal matter is. How can that be, since it interacts with normal matter gravitationally? Does the solar wind blow it away, or something like that?

I've also seen an article not long ago showing 'visualizations' of dark matter around a spiral galaxy, and it was mostly in teardrop-shaped lobes above and below the galaxy's center and aligned on the axis, rather than distributed through the disk. I didn't think of it at the time but now that I do, it seems like that distribution also indicates that light from the stars is pushing the dark matter away.

Re:Is there dark matter at the center of the Milky Way which... by cdumler on Saturday December 14, 2019 @01:49AM (#21788193)
The reason why normal matter forms disks is because of electromagnetic repulsion: electromagnetic atoms naturally resist being in the same place as another atom. There becomes a tension between the repulsion to not stack up and gravity to compress things together. Since angular momentum is conserved, the matter will spin and flatten out: ie, a galaxy.

If dark mater is a particle, it rarely interacts with anything, including itself; so, it cannot collapse. Most of the particles will be in a constant state of free fall throughout the galaxy. Only if the particle just happens to have a nearly matching velocity would it get trapped in a star or planet. Even then, it would still be wobbling around with nothing to touch.

Re:Is there dark matter at the center of the Milky Way which... by adrianN on Friday December 13, 2019 @09:16AM (#21781699)
Do we have estimates on how heavy individual dark matter "particles" are? Could the 700g all be in one blob?
Re:Is there dark matter at the center of the Milky Way which... by wiz21c on Friday December 13, 2019 @12:20PM (#21783446)
do you mean that 700g of that stuff can actually interact with earth's gravity in meaningful way ?

If so, (I'm no scientist at all), that sounds like a very powerful matter indeed :-)

Re:Is there dark matter at the center of the Milky Way which... by maxnoe on Friday December 13, 2019 @12:41PM (#21783612)
700g are 700g. So no, the dark matter inside Earth has basically 0 effect on Earth.
Re:Is there dark matter at the center of the Milky Way which... by d0mine on Friday December 13, 2019 @01:40PM (#21784153)
For comparison Earth mass is 5.9722×10^27 g.

So yeah, the effect is basically zero.

Re:Is there dark matter at the center of the Milky Way which... by girishso on Friday December 13, 2019 @01:11PM (#21783887)
WIMPs?
Re:Is there dark matter at the center of the Milky Way which... by maxnoe on Friday December 13, 2019 @08:46AM (#21781437)
See https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/XENON

Article about a Dark Matter research detector using Xenon, not the element itself.

Re:Is there dark matter at the center of the Milky Way which... by SiempreViernes on Friday December 13, 2019 @07:41AM (#21781033)
There should be some, but dark matter is inherently very hard to detect, so we don't know how much there is.
Re:Is there dark matter at the center of the Milky Way which... by contravariant on Friday December 13, 2019 @07:44AM (#21781053)
Although if the 'small rogue black hole' theory still has some merit then we can at least pretty conclusively rule out that there are no such black holes.
Re:Is there dark matter at the center of the Milky Way which... by jansan on Friday December 13, 2019 @06:49AM (#21780801)
Give me a dark matter detector and I will tell you.
Re:Is there dark matter at the center of the Milky Way which... by ianamartin on Friday December 13, 2019 @10:35AM (#21782445)
It's kind of impressive to me how much of modern science is really just people misapplying statistical models they don't understand to data that doesn't fit assumptions.

Snark aside, what's really interesting is the way that different fields respond to it when the model errors are discovered. Physics and Chemistry seem to be fairly (or at least comparatively) professional and receptive when they find out about mistakes. But mention a model error or data mismatch to someone in Neuroscience or Climatology? You're suddenly an anti-science heretic and probably murder kittens for fun.

Re:Is there dark matter at the center of the Milky Way which... by blotter_paper on Friday December 13, 2019 @12:35PM (#21783549)
I feel like this has to do with supervenience. Higher order fields have more noise, which means that more hypotheses seem valid to different people and that it's easier to make incorrect arguments against valid hypotheses.
Re:Is there dark matter at the center of the Milky Way which... by Tagbert on Friday December 13, 2019 @02:25PM (#21784517)
For Climatology, there are a lot of crazy or disingenuous people who try to weigh in on topics. That makes everyone gun-shy and likely to lash out at criticism because they are so used to getting attacked by unsupported arguments.
Re:Is there dark matter at the center of the Milky Way which... by ianamartin on Friday December 13, 2019 @06:13PM (#21786496)
This is excellent. Thank you.
Re:Is there dark matter at the center of the Milky Way which... by ianamartin on Friday December 13, 2019 @06:12PM (#21786483)
I love that this comment is generating downvotes. Thanks for making my point!