News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:United orders 50 new Airbus long-range jets to replace Bo... by davidhyde on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @10:26AM (#21702920)
What is keeping Boeing's share price so stable in the wake of such catastrophic news for the company this year?
Re:United orders 50 new Airbus long-range jets to replace Bo... by snowwrestler on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @10:41AM (#21703080)
I'm sure Boeing would have loved to have those orders, but 50 planes is not catastrophic.

In terms of the aircraft group, Boeing has steadily growing 787 orders and deliveries, with about 500 orders yet to deliver.

In terms of their space program, they are close to testing their manned capsule and just got a light touch program review, while SpaceX got put through the ringer.

And there are other aspects to Boeing that I'm not familiar with, but I'm sure don't relate directly to the 737 MAX.

As for Airbus, they have had to kill their A380 program, seemingly prematurely, in the face of declining interesting and cancelled orders. So, it's not all roses on the other side of the pond either.

Re:United orders 50 new Airbus long-range jets to replace Bo... by Xixi on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @02:58PM (#21706274)
787 orders and deliveries are very nice, but the bread and butter of Boeing and Airbus remains the 737 and A320 families. As you say Boeing has 500 orders for 787 yet to deliver, but they most importantly have 4,500 of the 737 remaining to deliver. Same for Airbus, they have about 600 orders for the A350 yet to deliver, but they most importantly have over 6,000 A320 in the pipeline.

The biggest issue for Boeing is that the MAX sold about 5,000 frames vs 7,000 for the A320NEO, going from a 50%/50% market shares (737NG vs A320) down to 40%/60% market shares (737MAX vs A320NEO). On the other hand the A320 is practically sold out for the next decade (Airbus is aiming at a production of 750/year, and that's quite a challenge), so the ratio is unlikely to move much.

Re:United orders 50 new Airbus long-range jets to replace Bo... by snowwrestler on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @04:46PM (#21707480)
Thanks, interesting. Do you think this dynamic has already been priced into Boeing's stock now, which is why it did not move much on this 50 plane order?
Re:United orders 50 new Airbus long-range jets to replace Bo... by Xixi on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @06:59PM (#21708498)
Yes, I think it is, none of what I wrote should come as a surprise to anyone even casually reading news about Boeing/Airbus. Certainly not an analyst crunching numbers.
Re:United orders 50 new Airbus long-range jets to replace Bo... by rrss on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @11:03AM (#21703306)
> just got a light touch program review, while SpaceX got put through the ringer.

Is this a reference to the Organizational Safety Assessments NASA announced in response to Elon Musk smoking pot on a livestream online?

I don't think that's a program review - more of a "are spacex employees smoking pot at work review."

If not, could you link to some info on the reviews you are referencing?

Re:United orders 50 new Airbus long-range jets to replace Bo... by stallmanite on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @02:05PM (#21705753)
Got any further reading on SpaceX getting a tougher review due to the pot thing? It seems kind of silly, if a CEO is seen having a glass of wine outside of work is there generally a presumption that the company / it’s employees are drunk during business hours?
Re:United orders 50 new Airbus long-range jets to replace Bo... by snowwrestler on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @04:48PM (#21707506)
Re:United orders 50 new Airbus long-range jets to replace Bo... by SmellyGeekBoy on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @10:51AM (#21703179)
> In terms of their space program, they are close to testing their manned capsule and just got a light touch program review, while SpaceX got put through the ringer.

I'm sure this will end well for them...

Re:United orders 50 new Airbus long-range jets to replace Bo... by snowwrestler on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @10:54AM (#21703217)
Ha! Yeah, the light touch worked so well for the 737 MAX. Well at least the first flight of their capsule will be unmanned...
Re:United orders 50 new Airbus long-range jets to replace Bo... by dnautics on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @11:13AM (#21703406)
Oh no kidding. I'm putting puts on BA ahead of their upcoming capsule failure in two weeks.
Re:United orders 50 new Airbus long-range jets to replace Bo... by CamperBob2 on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @03:10PM (#21706391)
Except the whole point of this subthread is that Boeing's stock price never faces any actual consequences, regardless of how badly the company screws up.

Boeing will not be allowed to fail, even if it personally bankrupts every taxpayer in the United States. And they know it.

Re:United orders 50 new Airbus long-range jets to replace Bo... by dnautics on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @04:18PM (#21707119)
Puts are short term, not long term. I agree that boeing will not be allowed to fail. Let's assume that it gets that bad. At what valuation will the company in the immediate wake of a bailout? 125% of current value? Or 75% of its current value?
Re:United orders 50 new Airbus long-range jets to replace Bo... by rsynnott on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @10:32AM (#21702974)
I think partly it’s the nature of the business. Even if every airline wants to drop the 737 and order all A32xes from now on, they can’t; Airbus simply doesn’t have the pipeline. Boeing will sell either a patched up MAX or a less ambition re-engine (a MEDIUM?) Probably for less money, but it’ll sell; the airlines really have very little choice.
Re:United orders 50 new Airbus long-range jets to replace Bo... by luch on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @11:07AM (#21703349)
it's worse than that : airplane pilots are certified for a particular set of aircraft (and that's why the 737 max came to existence). Even if a company wanted to boycott Boeing, on top of refresh its current fleet it would have to re-train and re-certified all its employees.

Weirdly enough, most of Air France & KLM fleet are comprised of Boeing planes

Re:United orders 50 new Airbus long-range jets to replace Bo... by alexis_fr on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @05:48PM (#21708027)
> Most of Air France & KLM fleet are comprised of Boeing planes

Are you sure about that? On WP I see 79 Boeing out of 223 planes for Airbus, but I’m not expert. Is there any wider fleet to consider? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_France

KLM has 13 Airbus out of 123 airframes, that part is correct. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/KLM

HOP is mostly Bombardier/Embraer, etc.

Re:United orders 50 new Airbus long-range jets to replace Bo... by divbyzer0 on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @11:21AM (#21703481)
$20 billion in Share buybacks. They effectively support their own share price, but this cannot go on for ever.

They increased their dividend which will also support a higher share prices, but again this can only continue for a finte period.

And as another poster mentioned: Military contracts.

Re:United orders 50 new Airbus long-range jets to replace Bo... by swampthinker on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @10:27AM (#21702928)
Military contracts
Re:United orders 50 new Airbus long-range jets to replace Bo... by jandrese on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @10:28AM (#21702941)
That and the implicit guarantee from the government that Boeing is too big to fail.
Re:United orders 50 new Airbus long-range jets to replace Bo... by whatshisface on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @10:32AM (#21702976)
The USG is already putting tariffs on foreign planes. We have all the downsides of nationalization without any of the benefits of collective ownership (except for the fact that Boeing is in people's retirement accounts, which is a little collective ownership). Capitalism and socialism on their own both have provisions for taking care of the elite and taking care of the average person. What we have now with these pseudonational industries is a combination of both that takes the elite-benefiting parts of capitalism and combines them with the elite-benefiting parts of socialism.
Re:United orders 50 new Airbus long-range jets to replace Bo... by magduf on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @10:42AM (#21703093)
>The USG is already putting tariffs on foreign planes.

How so? They can't put tariffs on foreign planes purchased by foreign airlines, and most of the airlines in the world are not American.

Re:United orders 50 new Airbus long-range jets to replace Bo... by whatshisface on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @10:45AM (#21703116)
They are putting tariffs on foreign planes purchased by airlines in America. It's mentioned in the last paragraph of the linked article.
Re:United orders 50 new Airbus long-range jets to replace Bo... by briandear on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @12:28PM (#21704390)
Airbus gets EU subsidies that works as an effective tariff against Boeing.
Re:United orders 50 new Airbus long-range jets to replace Bo... by Gwypaas on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @02:46PM (#21706147)
And Boeing gets US subsidies.

"The World Trade Organization said on Thursday the United States had ignored its request to halt a subsidized tax break for Boeing Co in its main plane-making state of Washington as a 15-year-old transatlantic trade row edges towards tit-for-tat sanctions."

https://www.reuters.com/article/us-eu-usa-aircraft-wto/wto-s...

Re:United orders 50 new Airbus long-range jets to replace Bo... by magduf on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @03:18PM (#21706466)
It's funny how the US complains about China propping up or even owning (usually partially) big corporations there, but they do the same with Boeing and many other companies.

At least in China, the government is the one that has the final say on everything, and the state-owned corporations have to do what the government wants. Here, the corporations get to do what they want, but they still get subsidies from the government but without being required to operate in the interests of the government or the nation at large.

Re:United orders 50 new Airbus long-range jets to replace Bo... by onepointsixC on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @11:10AM (#21703373)
Defense contracts account for a fraction of their civilian revenues.
Re:United orders 50 new Airbus long-range jets to replace Bo... by vonmoltke on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @01:21PM (#21705165)
I assume "a small fraction" is what you meant.

According to their most recent 10-K, the Defense, Space, and Security business unit represents about 23% of Boeing's revenue and 13% of their profit. Some portion of the Global Services revenue comes from government contracts as well, though, so the true contribution is higher.

https://www.sec.gov/cgi-bin/viewer?action=view&cik=12927&acc...

Re:United orders 50 new Airbus long-range jets to replace Bo... by dboreham on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @11:56AM (#21703909)
In analyzing a stock price you need to look at what other people perceive about it, which is not the same as objective facts. So in this case it tells us that other people don't think the company's sales will be hurt much. I believe they are wrong (and sold most of my Boeing stock right after the second crash) but only time will tell.
Re:United orders 50 new Airbus long-range jets to replace Bo... by johngalt on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @01:38PM (#21705393)
1. The market correctly understands that Boeing is backstopped by the US government. Removing any large downside risk.

2. Even including the problems with the 737 max, Boeing has an exceptionally good safety record.

3. Regulatory capture of the FAA by Boeing is bad news for consumers, but not necessarily for shareholders.

4. Investing in aircraft manufacturers during a growing economy is reasonable and Boeing is one of only two airplane manufacturers positioned to take advantage of the trend.

Re:United orders 50 new Airbus long-range jets to replace Bo... by TwoHeadedBeast on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @03:03PM (#21706322)
On your fourth point, a downturn is widely anticipated and aircraft manufacturers would be particularly affected.
Re:United orders 50 new Airbus long-range jets to replace Bo... by baq on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @11:07AM (#21703344)
Pension plans and pension funds.
Re:United orders 50 new Airbus long-range jets to replace Bo... by PedroBatista on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @11:17AM (#21703438)
Old money, national pride and insurance from the tax payer.
Re:United orders 50 new Airbus long-range jets to replace Bo... by avocado4 on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @10:31AM (#21702965)
The fact that these news are not catastrophic, but rather wishful politically-motivated thinking. Boeing is here to stay, until maybe a viable competitor in China springs up.