In what way do multirotors / drones differ?
Average multicopter designs would seem to be incapable of autorotation for aerodynamic and technical reasons. The technical reason being that the BLDC motors used are typically permanent magnet synchronous machines, which develop significant holding torque in most (driver) failure modes and there is no clutch to disconnect the motor from the propeller.
*There are some exceptions: https://www.droneguru.net/collective-pitch-drones/
A multirotor on the other had doesn't have the ability to glide, like a fixed wing or a helicopter. Any safety will have to be engineered in by making sure that a single rotor failure (or even multiple) can be coped with correctly and reliably.
Some helicopters with very heavy blades with lots of angular momentum have been built, but it makes the blades heavy which requires a more powerful engine which makes the whole craft heavier which means you need even more angular momentum...you get the idea. It's an engineering nightmare so it's atypical.
Can anyone with more knowledge chime in?
I’m off to bed, otherwise I’d try looking in to it.
Multirotors I believe require active control of every individual rotor instead of straightforward big angular momentum. Which I believe is part of why they are seen on drones.
Most motors on multirotors are BLDC motors that require active control to make them spin. Voltage gets applied to the motor phases sequentially to make it spin. However, when they're completely open-circuit, they actually spin quite freely! I've seen the ones I had (26" prop) windmill quite well in a mild breeze. The trick, though is that you're probably not going to get much descent-arrest out of open-circuit BLDCs. Another possibility is short-circuited BLDCs; in that condition, the rotos are quite tough to turn. My speculation is that the props wouldn't spin much at all in a short-circuit condition. Buuuuut... if ESCs were able to modulate the open/short-circuit condition (even without power to actively spin the motors), I suspect you might be able to get some kind of arrested descent situation.
I've been thinking of building an ESC from scratch this winter... this might be a useful feature to experiement with!
The FAA generally requires certified helicopters to have a 30 minute fuel reserve in order to allow a safe diversion to an alternate landing site. With lithium battery power, once you subtract out the reserve time there's hardly any range left. (It might be possible to obtain some exemptions to the reserve regulations in limited circumstances.)
https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/14/91.151
Experimentals don’t get to waive fuel reserve requirements (which are Part 91 flight requirements [pilot responsibility to comply], not Part 23/25 type design requirements [designer responsibility]).
(Even if the range and safety issues can be resolved it's not clear that the target market even exists, but that's a separate problem.)
The absolute bottom line offering of any small aircraft has to be that its safe (or at least, the failure rate is acceptable - which means at least comparable to modern helicopters). That's the innovation that anyone entering the market needs to bring.
Making a new type of aircraft that is significantly more dangerous and requires significantly less training (so it is unrealistic to expect the consumer to understand the risk) is just valuing profits over human lives - full stop.
Are you still okay with unsafe flying machines when they start falling out of the sky and killing people on the ground? As mentioned previously, these aren't even supposed to require a pilot's license, so you can't expect the customer to be trained like a pilot.
The FAA rules are written in blood. If people want to experiment with new types of aircraft responsibly, that's fine! There is even a specific process for that, it's called an experimental certification.
https://www.faa.gov/aircraft/air_cert/airworthiness_certific...
But selling these things to untrained consumers is just completely, utterly, reprehensibly irresponsible. That's probably why Kitty Hawk returned deposits - they realized the machines just weren't safe enough to sell to people.
Safe + not working eventually leads to bankruptcy too, but people don't die in that case.
Not to say that advancing aerospace engineering should be totally without risk. But these folks are not building space vehicle or fighter planes, they're building commercial aircraft. In that sector, tolerance for risk is far lower, as it should be.
I'm sure they've started from zero several times with entirely new designs. There's no point worrying overly much about safety if you only plan to fly something once.
Having worked in other hardware startups though, I'm guessing what actually happened was a few years of reinventing the wheel and learning on the job. Safe systems don't look any different to non safe systems to an outsider, so unless there's a real buy in from management it's very hard to build them.